Maverick Citizen


Nelson Mandela Bay walks tightrope of a wing and a prayer – and then finally … rain

Nelson Mandela Bay walks tightrope of a wing and a prayer – and then finally … rain
The Kromme Dam (old Churchill Dam), Eastern Cape, in 2022 (left) and on 28 September 2023.(Photo: Deon Ferreira)

There was a long-standing joke in Nelson Mandela Bay that you’d never hear local weatherman Garth Sampson say, ‘Good rains fell in the catchment area.’ Then, after more than seven years of drought, at around noon on Thursday, when combined dam levels reached 65%, Sampson finally said: ‘The drought has been broken.’

For the past few years, local weatherman Garth Sampson had only dismal predictions for rain in Nelson Mandela Bay.

DA councillor Retief Odendaal, whose term as mayor saw some of the most critical days of drought, recounted: “Garth would come in for our drought meetings and every time he had a picture on his presentation of an angel of death.”

“He said he was the prophet of doom,” Odendaal laughed. 

While Odendaal was mayor for less than a year, he led the city when there were fears it would run out of water altogether, and, along with Sampson, he became one of the most trusted sources on Nelson Mandela Bay’s response to the drought.

This week, the SA Weather Service’s Sampson had better news. 

“We are out of the meteorological drought, yes! But the hydrological drought will be for the Department of Water and Sanitation to decide. 

“They will consider it when the combined dam levels reach 65%. We should hit that by the weekend. If I was them, though, I would wait until it is considerably higher than 65%. 

“I would not lift restrictions as we are moving into our traditionally dry period with a forecast of below-normal rain.

“Personally, I would never scrap restrictions, just ease them to varying degrees. We are a water-scarce nation and with exponential population growth and climate change, we must flatten that curve,” he said.

On Friday, Odendaal and his former mayoral committee member for water and infrastructure, Dries van der Westhuyzen, as well as residents, plan to trek up to the Kouga Dam early in the morning to watch the sluice gates being opened. 

By 2pm on Thursday, the dam was at 90% capacity. 

The local farm stall and restaurant, Padlangs, has invited everyone for a celebratory glass of sparkling wine.

There was a moment in June 2022 when the city was about to be cut off from its supply dams when Kouga was at 3% and the largest supply dam to the metro, Impofu, had been decommissioned, while authorities battled to save the Churchill Dam. Two days of heavy rain saved the city but the war with the drought continued.

Read more in Daily Maverick: Dam in Nelson Mandela Bay is at its lowest level yet

The Kouga Dam on Thursday, 28 September, as dam levels exceeded 90%. (Photo: Gamtoos Irrigation Board)

Residents of Nelson Mandela Bay hold a service to pray for rain on 30 January 2023. (Photo: Deon Ferreira)

Zane Bosch (left) and Lehan van Niekerk (right) playing in the water at Park Rugby Club in Gqeberha, Nelson Mandela Bay, after heavy rains over the long weekend. (Photo: Deon Ferreira)

“We knew that if we reached Day Zero it would have been something terrible,” Odendaal said on Thursday.

With its large manufacturing industry, Nelson Mandela Bay is home to more than 1.2 million people and Odendaal said that at one stage they had faced almost certain water armageddon.

The city gets about 40% of its daily water from the Nooitgedacht Scheme, bringing water from the Gariep Dam, but not all reservoirs are connected to this source.

“I think a lot of credit must go to the officials from the water and sanitation department, Joseph Tsatsire and Barry Martin, who got us through this,” said Odendaal.

“There was a time when Joe wanted to move to Cape Town and I actually felt quite teary about it … I just said ‘sometimes sacrifice is called for. Don’t leave us now.’” 

Read more in Daily Maverick: Daily outages likely as Nelson Mandela Bay starts water throttling during crisis

Odendaal’s first encounter with what was to become a near-disastrous drought was in 2016 when the Democratic Alliance (DA) was in charge of the city. 

“We managed to reduce water consumption to 250 megalitres per day and we started putting money away for drought control measures and water augmentation projects. 

“If I think back now, we paid too much for some of these projects. Coega Kop [a plant filtering iron and manganese from borehole water] was very expensive at R350-million and still only produced eight or nine megalitres per day. It was supposed to provide us with 20ml per day.” 

Odendaal said he often thought back to the Eastern Cape’s 2011 response to climate change that was drawn up before COP17, at a time when former deputy minister of finance, Mcebisi Jonas, was the MEC for Finance in the province. 

“Already then it was forecast that the western side of the province [where Nelson Mandela Bay is] will have more intense and longer cycles of drought. But very little was done.”

Read more in Daily Maverick: Drought-hit Nelson Mandela Bay on tenterhooks as weather models predict heavy rain

Since 2016 the Karoo municipalities and towns like Graaff-Reinet were in the grip of an unrelenting drought. Kouga Local Municipality, which includes popular holiday towns like Jeffreys Bay and St Francis, were on their knees. 

After the 2021 local government elections, an ANC-led coalition took over control of the metro. 

“We knew they were allowing over-extraction from the dams,” Odendaal said. The ANC-led coalition admitted this was the case. 

In September 2022, a DA-led coalition took over.

“I asked that the over-extraction be stopped. We were at the point where water authorities wanted to decommission the Churchill Dam. I still believe the rain that fell that day was a miracle,” he said. 

“Until this day, I don’t think residents know how close we came to disaster,” he said.

Read more in Daily Maverick: Tough restrictions push back Nelson Mandela Bay’s Day Zero, but trouble still lies ahead

At the time, given the severe political instability in the metro, the trust in local politicians had hit an all-time low. 

“I knew we had to overcome this,” Odendaal said. So he began writing social media posts. “I started pleading, then cautioning, and eventually threatening.”

Read more in Daily Maverick: Residents in drought-hit Nelson Mandela Bay warned — save water now or mayor will come knocking

“The metro’s relationship with the Department of Water and Sanitation was so bad and they were so angry with us by then that they threatened to reduce our quotas. But I had to stand my ground and say that we were entitled to 30ml a day from the dam, and I promised that we would stick to it. We had to rebuild trust really fast.

“It was a very, very difficult time for us. Residents struggled. Suburbs often had no water. But there were no major protests. I think playing open cards about how dire our situation was worked.”

Read more in Daily Maverick: Daily Outages likely as Nelson Mandela Bay starts water throttling during crisis

Odendaal recalled that the urgency of the situation meant that documents would often not be sent to his office through the normal channels. Joseph would instead deliver them himself.

Eventually, through a series of critical decisions, the city managed to avoid Day Zero.

Read more in Daily Maverick: Boil before drinking warning issued for Nelson Mandela Bay

“There are a few things I think must be done differently. I would suggest an entity like the Gamtoos Irrigation Board should be put in control of our bulk water. They have done an incredible job steering their dam through this crisis.”

“We must also continue to fix existing infrastructure. I said often that this was a man-made crisis. We would not have stumbled from crisis to crisis if it wasn’t for our bad infrastructure. 

“With the Nooitgedacht Scheme [bringing water from the Gariep Dam], this metro should be water secure. It is immoral that 45% of our water remains unaccounted for. We know there will be another drought.”

Read more in Daily Maverick: It’s raining at last in Nelson Mandela Bay, but dam supply will be cut as emergency water plan kicks in

“Now is the time for us to learn our lessons. People must change their water lifestyle. You can no longer fill a swimming pool and water a garden with municipal water,” he said.

“Like the people of Cape Town [who suffered a severe drought in 2018], we must not forget.”

Odendaal added: “I want to pay tribute to Garth Sampson. He did more for awareness than anybody else during this drought. When the metro failed, he stood up and informed people in a very straightforward way. He doesn’t beat around the bush.”

Read the series Countdown to Catastrophe here, here and here.

Over the Heritage Day weekend, the catchment area for the supply dams to Nelson Mandela Bay received 75mm and 134mm of rain. 

Read more in Daily Maverick: Heavens finally open over Nelson Mandela Bay

Reinette Colesky from the Gamtoos Irrigation Board said they were excited to see the Kouga Dam overflowing.

“It seems like Churchill started to overflow last night,” she said. 

“We expect Kouga will start overflowing sometime on Friday. We are going to be there to see it,” she said. 

The Kouga Dam was built in 1971 and has overflown 33 times. The last time the sluices were opened was in 2015. 

By Thursday afternoon, 70,000 litres were running into the dam every second. 

“Over the past five hours, 5 million cubic metres of water ran into Kouga. That is nearly twice the volume of Loerie Dam,” the Gamtoos Irrigation Board said in a Facebook post on Wednesday.

The current executive mayor, Gary van Nierkerk, said the metro’s infrastructure remained in a dire state. 

“I would like to see dam levels increase to 70% before restrictions are lifted,” Van Niekerk said. 

The Groendal Dam near Uitenhage is 100% full, but its main line to the Kabah water treatment works had broken and, due to flooding, engineers were struggling to repair it. 

“I am still encouraging people to use 50 litres of water per person per day. We must still conserve water,” said Van Niekerk. DM


Comments - Please in order to comment.

  • Richard Cowling says:

    The NMB metro must assist Gamtoos Irrigation Board in controlling invasive alien trees that drastically reduce river flow in times of drought. It is well known that this intervention is extremely cost effective for enhancing water security. The City of Cape Town invests in managing the mountain catchment that provide the city’s water and we all know it is by far the best managed metro in the country.

  • Heinrich Heiriss says:

    NMB lost a gem when Retief Odendaal got voted out as mayor. I hope that he gets a second chance at the dig soon – NMB is a metro with almost unrivalled potential in South Africa.

  • Megalitres should be abbreviated as caps (ML) or else it looks like you’re talking about millilitres (which is clearly not the case).

  • dlwkrueger says:

    Yes, we can all give a sigh of relief and a prayer of thanks, especially for Counselor Retief’s efforts, whose meetings were always constructive and supportive .
    But I agree with the comment made that using water very sparingly must become a permanent lifestyle for all South Africans.

    Our family has met the 50 lpd target for the past year without much hardship, and will continue to do so.

    My only criticism of the Metro would be that the water pricing tariff has not, and does not, reflect a water scarce area. Water wasters will only reduce consumption when it starts hurting their pockets.

  • Denise Smit says:

    We in the Western Cape have suffered with the Eastern Cape during the seven year drought after we had our nearly day zero in 2016/17. We know how it is to live without rain and pounding sunshine with al your plants dying. So thankfull this has now ended for you.

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted


This article is free to read.

Sign up for free or sign in to continue reading.

Unlike our competitors, we don’t force you to pay to read the news but we do need your email address to make your experience better.

Nearly there! Create a password to finish signing up with us:

Please enter your password or get a sign in link if you’ve forgotten

Open Sesame! Thanks for signing up.

A South African Hero: You

There’s a 99.8% chance that this isn’t for you. Only 0.2% of our readers have responded to this call for action.

Those 0.2% of our readers are our hidden heroes, who are fuelling our work and impacting the lives of every South African in doing so. They’re the people who contribute to keep Daily Maverick free for all, including you.

The equation is quite simple: the more members we have, the more reporting and investigations we can do, and the greater the impact on the country.

Be part of that 0.2%. Be a Maverick. Be a Maverick Insider.

Support Daily Maverick→
Payment options