First Thing, Daily Maverick's flagship newsletter

Join the 230 000 South Africans who read First Thing newsletter.

UK bans Bain from state contracts for 3 years over Stat...

South Africa

AGE OF ACCOUNTABILITY

Bain banned from receiving UK government contracts for three years over State Capture work in South Africa

Lord Peter Hain and Bain whistle-blower Athol Williams outside the House of Lords after meeting Cabinet Office Minister Jacob Rees-Mogg. (Photo: Supplied)

British cabinet minister Jacob Rees-Mogg has acted against Bain on the urging of anti-apartheid campaigner Peter Hain.

The British government has banned Bain & Co, the US-based global management consultancy, from tendering for UK government contracts for three years because of its “grave professional misconduct” in State Capture in South Africa.

UK cabinet office minister Jacob Rees-Mogg issued the ban to Bain & Co under pressure from Lord Peter Hain, the former anti-apartheid campaigner who has vowed now to ensure that the US government does the same.

“I’m pleased the UK government has agreed to suspend Bain from public contracts at my urging,” Hain, a Labour Party member of the House of Lords, told Daily Maverick.

Former British MP and anti-apartheid activist, Lord Peter Hain. (Photo: Cate Gillon/Getty Images)

“Global corporates like them have to feel the pain for the consequences of their corrupt and unlawful behaviour in South Africa’s State Capture and corruption scandal under former president (Jacob) Zuma. Otherwise other corporates will be tempted to do the same.”

He added that he was now turning his attention to the US to impose a similar ban. “I have already pressed the US ambassador to the UK.”

Read more in Daily Maverick: “Peter Hain proposes UK ban on Bain and other global consultancies implicated in SA State Capture

Britain’s Financial Times first reported the UK ban on Wednesday, saying Rees-Mogg had written to Bain’s UK managing partner, James Hadley, to say the three-year ban would apply retrospectively from 4 January 2022. 

‘Mainly reputational’ damage

The paper said he had told Hadley that the company would be banned from cabinet office contracts under 2015 legislation on the basis that “Bain & Co is guilty of grave professional misconduct which renders its integrity questionable”.

Rees-Mogg would advise all government departments to apply the same three-year ban. Hain told Daily Maverick that while individual cabinet ministers would theoretically have discretion, the ban would effectively apply across the board. 

According to the Financial Times, Bain has been awarded UK public sector contracts worth up to £63-million since 2018, including £40-million worth of Brexit consulting work for the cabinet office.

But it added that the damage to the company “will be mainly reputational”.

The paper quoted Bain as saying it was “disappointed and surprised” by Rees-Mogg’s decision and that it would respond to express its concerns about the process, address “inaccuracies” in the minister’s letter and then, if necessary, consider other options for a review of the decision. 

Read more in Daily Maverick: “Bain & Company — the rot at the heart of State Capture

Hain is also campaigning for legislation to empower the government to also bar other companies like Bain which have been implicated in unlawful or unethical conduct in any country, from tendering for UK government contracts.

Last month he told the House of Lords that “Bain purposefully assisted former president Jacob Zuma to organise his decade of barefaced looting and corruption, the company earning fees estimated at £100-million (R2-billion) from state institutions”. 

He noted that the Zondo Commission – before which he had testified – had “condemned Bain’s deliberate immobilising of the South African Revenue Service (Sars) as ‘unlawful’”.

The commission found that Bain’s work on restructuring Sars was “a clear example of how the private sector colluded” with the breakdown of public institutions.

Read more in Daily Maverick: “Peter Hain meets Minister Jacob Rees-Mogg in quest to ban Bain & Co from doing business with UK

Hain told parliament the commission had recommended that law enforcement authorities examine every public sector contract Bain had won with a view to possible prosecution. 

Hain said Bain should have used its financial expertise to help Sars to collect tax and deal with tax evaders, but in fact had helped Zuma instead to disable the revenue service from doing that. 

Read more in Daily Maverick: “Bain & Co planned to work with Zuma to ‘reshape SA economy’, says former partner Athol Williams

“Yet this is the very company that works across our government and across our economy, influencing our public institutions and impacting millions of British lives.”

Referring to Bain’s earlier acknowledgement of some failings in its South African office and its repayment of some fees, Hain said: “Bain would have us believe that what happened in South Africa was the work of one rotten apple. But its South African office’s work was endorsed by leaders here in London and its US headquarters in Boston, and many senior people currently working for Bain in London were in the South African business during the corrupt Zuma era.”

Bain whistleblower, Atholl Williams welcomed the decision.

“I commend Lord Peter Hain for leading a sustained and carefully crafted campaign. The UK government has acted to protect its public sector from Bain’s destructive behaviour and also acted in solidarity with the SA people. When will the SA government do the same for our people?

“Bain & Co claim they’ve merely made ‘mistakes’. In contrast, the Zondo Commission concluded Bain acted ‘unlawfully’ and ‘colluded in the clearest example of state capture.’ On 2 August 2022, the UK government further discredited and dismissed Bain’s denials, stating that it is ‘guilty of grave professional misconduct’ relating to their involvement in state capture in SA, banning them from government contracts for 3 years. I now call on the SA government, particularly National Treasury, and companies like Sasol (who have hired Bain) to do the same,” Williams said in a statement.

In July, Williams was invited to present facts around Bains involvement in state capture to Rees-Mogg which he says “proved pivotal in the UK Government’s decision to ban Bain”.DM


Visit Daily Maverick’s home page for more news, analysis and investigations


 

Gallery

Comments - share your knowledge and experience

Please note you must be a Maverick Insider to comment. Sign up here or sign in if you are already an Insider.

Everybody has an opinion but not everyone has the knowledge and the experience to contribute meaningfully to a discussion. That’s what we want from our members. Help us learn with your expertise and insights on articles that we publish. We encourage different, respectful viewpoints to further our understanding of the world. View our comments policy here.

All Comments 11

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted