POLITICAL REFLECTION

The week the circus of pain came to town – senior ANC members took a drubbing of note all round

By Marianne Thamm 26 May 2021

From left: Former South African Revenue Service commissioner Tom Moyane. (Photo: Gallo Images / The Times / Esa Alexander) | Suspended ANC Secretary-General Ace Magashule. (Photo: Gallo Images / Sunday Times / Alon Skuy) | Former minister of finance Malusi Gigaba. (Photo: Moeletsi Mabe / Sunday Times) | Former president Jacob Zuma. (Photo: Gallo Images / Darren Stewart) | Former South African Airways chairperson Dudu Myeni. (Photo: Gallo Images / Phill Magakoe) | Minister of Health Zweli Mkhize. (Photo: Gallo Images / Sharon Seretlo)

The tone for the country’s political week was set by the testimony of investigator Paul Holden to the commission on Monday, 24 May – an endless recital of figures with astounding amounts of zeros, millions and millions of taxpayers’ money laundered through the Gupta washing machines.

Marianne Thamm

Dawn broke on Wednesday, 26 May 2021, with the announcement of an urgent press conference by the Minister of Health, Zweli Mkhize, followed swiftly by former president Jacob Zuma finally being asked to plead to corruption charges, an event which coincided with former SARS boss Tom Moyane’s turn at the Zondo Commission.

And that was before noon on just one day.

Mkhize’s early morning presser announcement was to acknowledge that the Digital Vibes contract, exposed by Daily Maverick’s Scorpio investigative team member Pieter-Louis Myburgh, was indeed irregular and corrupt. This after the Department of Health (DoH) had asked “for a few days to think about the matter”.

Department of Health’s irregular R150m Digital Vibes deal: Daily Maverick’s investigative work so far in one bundle

In the face of irrefutable evidence, Mkhize acted swiftly, saying he was no friend of Tahera Mather (his former PA) and Naadhira Mitha, who received R150-million from the DoH to do their work for them.

The tone for the political week in the country was set by the testimony of investigator Paul Holden to the commission on Monday, 24 May – an endless recital of figures with astounding amounts of zeros, millions and millions of taxpayers’ money laundered through the Gupta washing machines. 

By midweek, the ANC – the governing party – had become the butt of jokes, memes and Tik Tok  (our favourite was @ZethuZethu, of course) postings across South African social media platforms.

Former SAA board chair, Dudu Myeni, made an early evening appearance before the Zondo Commision on Tuesday after attempting to duck it earlier in the day. Had to rush to an alleged family event in Richards Bay apparently. Short notice and what what.

Deputy Chief Justice Raymond Zondo would have none of it and Myeni was instructed to get her arse to her lawyer’s office in Pietermaritzburg tout de suite.

When Myeni, who Zondo kept waiting for about an hour, later stated she would be replying to her cross-examination in isiZulu, someone in the peanut gallery over on YouTube, which tunes in daily to watch Zondo proceedings, responded “but she was stealing in English”.

On Wednesday, after Mkhize’s admission earlier in the day and which was broadcast live on several platforms, a Soweto motorist called into SAfm shouting “look, I don’t care about the protests and the road blockade. People are going to vote for the same party again and again. I just want Rob Byrne to tell me what routes and traffic jams to avoid.”

It all began when Holden, Zooming from London, read each amount that made up the money flow to Gupta entities from South African SOEs to Zondo like a roll call of the nameless dead in a war. 

The final estimated total (without tip) the country gifted to the Gupta brothers is R49,157,323,233.68 Holden calculated.

On Tuesday, ENS Forensics specialist Steven Powell laid bare former ANC spokesperson and current Deputy Minister of State Security Zizi Kodwa’s fattening of his personal bank account to the amount of R2-million by tech giant EOH.

Powell told the commission that a subpoena of Kodwa’s bank accounts had revealed multiple transfers from EOH’s Jehan Mackay between May 2015 and February 2016. On one such occasion, in February 2016, Mackay deposited R30,000 in Kodwa’s account to take it out of arrears.

Kodwa’s stay in the ultra luxury Villa Barbados in Camps Bay was also sponsored by sugar daddies EOH. Powell said the deputy minister was one of a number of “influencers, middlemen, intermediaries” used by EOH between 2015 and 2017 to help it win lucrative state tenders. 

In total, EOH made payments of more than R15-million to the ANC and suppliers, seemingly for the same purpose.

Kodwa and his ANC colleagues are accused of intervening in support of EOH in at least three procurement processes: a Home Affairs Department tender, an Eastern Cape document management tender, and a Sassa (South African Social Security Agency) ICT tender worth about R90-million.

On the same day everyone got all up in Kodwa’s business, acting ANC secretary-general, Jessie Duarte, announced the party’s national working committee decision to consider disciplinary action against Ace Magashule, Tony Yengeni and Carl Niehaus for their delinquent behaviour at former president’s Zuma’s appearance at the Pietermaritzburg court.

The party is going to give them a bonus 60 days to continue behaving badly before instituting “disciplinary action” which will be guided by a “national presenter”. The as-yet-unnamed presenter will table a report to the party’s national executive committee, who will in turn refer the matter to the national disciplinary committee.

The party was also challenging Magashule’s South Gauteng High Court application to have his suspension declared invalid, said Duarte. The matter will proceed on 1 June.

Also on Tuesday, global consulting firm, McKinsey announced that it would be repaying R1-billion to the state, the proceeds the company unlawfully received from Eskom and Transnet deals.

As Scorpio’s Pauli van Wyk wrote in our Insider Newsletter this week, “In 2017, as part of the #GuptaLeaks, Susan Comrie from amaBhungane and I, on behalf of Daily Maverick’s investigative unit Scorpio, delved deep into what became known as the The McKinsey Dossier and the crimes perpetrated against the South African people.”

Four years later McKinsey has paid back the money thanks to the relentless work by journalists, and not the country’s law enforcement agencies.

On Wednesday, former president Jacob Zuma was finally asked the question “how do you plead” when charges of corruption, fraud and racketeering related to the Arms Deal were finally put to him. 

He pleaded not guilty, of course, and maintained his defence that the prosecution all stemmed from actions by foreign agencies, the CIA in particular, to target him politically.

More or less the same time Zuma was slipping into the dock, former SARS Commissioner Tom Moyane continued to bleat that all accusations against him were part of a plot.

Nonetheless, evidence leader advocate Alistair Franklin grilled Moyane on his relationship with Bain & Co, which has been found by the Nugent Commission to have conspired with Moyane to weaken SARS.

The company itself issued a statement to the Nugent Commission saying “it has become painfully evident that the firm’s involvement with the South African Revenue Service (SARS) was a serious failure, for South Africa and SARS, and clearly for Bain too”.

The Commission and Nugent’s finding, said Bain, “have laid bare the disarray in which SARS now finds itself, with both morale and performance severely damaged. Contributing to that outcome was not the intent of the Bain project and we clearly made significant errors of judgement in taking on this work.”

Moyane insisted that SARS had done superlative work under his watch and that his demise could be blamed on Pravin Gordhan.

The dust from the circus of ANC rogues was kicked up the week of 20 May when Norma Mngoma, estranged wife of former minister Malusi Gigaba, revealed the depth of her husband’s indebtedness to the Gupta brothers and how he did their bidding.

So much so they literally gave him headaches as he bent over backwards to accommodate them.

Ms Mngoma, as she preferred to be referred to, spoke of long shopping trips, lunches and facials with her husband in Sandton, revealed her husband had over 200 fancy suits, that he had secreted out in a leather bag, loads of cash from the Guptas’ Saxonwold vault and that her husband had often called on Guptas to help out his family members including his sister and father.

The couple paid for nothing, the country heard, apart from a DStv subscription. She also indignantly told Zondo that her spending limit was around R100,000 and that her husband had given her a credit card with a R3,000 limit.

“I can do nothing with R3,000,” she told the commission.

As the Commission of Inquiry into State Capture rushes to finish its work and as the ANC which Jacob Zuma grew during his decade-long ruinous tenure unravels in full public view, the ANC that is left behind is, for now, a national laughing stock, the butt of jokes and ditties as the nation comes to terms with the trauma that it has visited on country. DM

Gallery

Comments - share your knowledge and experience

Please note you must be a Maverick Insider to comment. Sign up here or sign in if you are already an Insider.

Everybody has an opinion but not everyone has the knowledge and the experience to contribute meaningfully to a discussion. That’s what we want from our members. Help us learn with your expertise and insights on articles that we publish. We encourage different, respectful viewpoints to further our understanding of the world. View our comments policy here.

All Comments 20

  • With barely many comrades of the ANC left untouched by corruption I wonder who the presenter could be – Gordhan
    CORRECTION -Norma objected to having being given a DEBIT card with a limit of R3000 because she wanted to flash a CREDIT Card with a limit of R100k whence she swipes R40k for a handbag.

  • Unfortunately, “The ANC… is… a laughing stock, etc.” amongst anyone with a modicum of sense and understanding. They will, however, be re-elected, which I fail to understand other than the massive election “machine”the ANC operates, together with free T-shirts,

    • Keep them uneducated, keep them poor, blame it on others, and take the votes. The ANC should be charged for crimes against humanity for what it’s done to the poorest in our country, ironically the voting “fodder” they rely on. It’s really sickening.

  • A thorough drubbing is the nearest we’ll see to any justice, so keep the drubbing coming Maverick. Drubbing is good therapy for everyone. Who knows the electorate could awake and some of those drubbed could be drubbed back into the holes. One can still dream. ANC reform? Not!

  • Unfortunately, coming up to the next election, our rulers will bask in their “successes” (vaccinations, the forthcoming utopia of NHI) and, with the help of food parcels and tee shirts, the sheep will be herded in to the abattoirs , sorry, ballot stations. Then four years/commissions later…….!

    • “Nur die dümmsten Kälber wählen ihre Schlächter selber “ (Berthold Brecht) loosely translated: only the dumbest cattle vote for their butchers. ANC ensured that indeed the vast majority is so poorly educated that they fail to see that they are being defrauded on a daily basis since 27 years.

  • Corruption in SA has a sad and sobering side to it. The more proof, the more support corrupt leaders and organisations get. Scumbags become martyrs. The collapse of a country becomes an excuse to destroy even more. All in the name of the Struggle. Democracy has failed. What kind of country is this?

  • The ANC might have become a laughing stock but it is nevertheless a very dangerous laughing stock given the education of the majority of the voters. I don’t think that even Mandela believed that democracy could work here but his cohort was so hungry for power that they convinced themselves it would.

  • The voting public will keep the ANC in power. They deliberately choose poverty and that is their democratic right. Unfortunately they will blame the minorities for their misery.

    • So do your thing and encourage all and sundry to vote the democratic opposition in. We can only try. And try. And try.

  • Tragically millions will still vote for this disastrous political circus which has destroyed so much of our promise as a country.

  • I suspect it might be a bit early to call what happened a drubbing. I also suspect that, in must of these cases, drubbings will not be forthcoming.

  • We need to understand that the masses vote for the ANC, not because they support the policy and behaviour of the ANC, but because ANC successfully uses the old apartheid rule and continually uses apartheid and race as the factor the black majority should fear more than the ANC’s elite looting of SA.

  • The ANC represents an existential threat to South Africa. Sadly, as SimonD has pointed out below, the voting “fodder” doesn’t see it that way.

  • Like their Russian counterparts and role models, this grudge of no-hope former chairpersons and their political masters are not only innocent of all charges, but in fact hard at work, running a country, and eliminating their exposers and persecutors by any means possible, and suing anything that moves in the meantime. Will we ever see the end of it? Only when another party wins an election. Will that ever happen? Not in my lifetime…

  • MASS SURVEILLANCE: PART TWO

    Vumacam’s ‘hundreds of thousands of cameras’ will be watching you

    By Heidi Swart