South Africa

ANALYSIS

If Ace Magashule’s arrest story was to test the waters, they look chilly for him

If Ace Magashule’s arrest story was to test the waters, they look chilly for him
African National Congress Secretary-General Ace Magashule. (Photo: Gallo Images / Sunday Times / Alon Skuy)

When the online arm of Independent Media falsely reported on Tuesday night that ANC Secretary-General Ace Magashule had been served with a warrant of arrest, it might have been an innocent mistake. But the speed with which Magashule-affiliated groups expressed concern suggested a more coordinated campaign afoot.

On Wednesday, the SABC News Online website was inadvertently summing up the mess.

Under its “most viewed” stories tab, the top article was: “Ace Magashule issued with a warrant of arrest.

The second most viewed story: “ ‘There is no arrest warrant issued for ANC SG #AceMagashule,’ says Hawks spokesperson.

The report that ANC Secretary-General Ace Magashule was to be arrested first entered the public domain on Tuesday night via a tweet from the Independent Online, or IOL News.

“BREAKING NEWS: A warrant of arrest has been issued for ANC Secretary General Ace Magashule,” it read. “Story to follow on IOL.co.za.”

The tweet was retweeted almost 8,000 times.

The promised story was published shortly thereafter, under the headline: “ANC secretary general Ace Magashule confirms warrant has been issued for his arrest”.  

It stated not only that the arrest warrant had been issued – “Independent Media reliably learnt” – but also that Magashule had confirmed knowledge of it: “I’m aware. I’m aware. It’s going to be a Hollywood-style type thing.”

It did not take long for the Hawks to categorically deny the arrest, but not before SABC news had also reported that “reliable sources” had informed them that Magashule’s arrest warrant had been issued.

Even before the Hawks’ denial was issued, however, there were two aspects around the IOL report that smelt fishy. One was the fact that the website reported that the charge on which Magashule was to be arrested was “his alleged failure to exercise oversight relating to the Vrede Dairy Farm investigation”.

But a failure to exercise oversight is not a criminal offence, or else practically the entire Parliament would be behind bars by now. In other words, IOL made up a clearly absurd charge, framing the story as allowing Magashule to claim the role of innocent victim of drummed-up charges in advance.

The other malodorous aspect of the report was the speed with which Magashule-aligned groups pumped out press statements in support of the secretary-general thereafter.

Barely had the IOL story been published than the ANC Youth League (ANCYL) in Magashule’s home province of the Free State had issued 450 thunderous words denouncing the “well-orchestrated usage of state organs to fight internal ANC factional battles”.

The youngsters explicitly spelt out what Magashule has not yet: that any charges against him amount to a political witch-hunt reminiscent of the “similar approach… used against the then deputy president of the ANC, Cde Jacob Zuma”.

Allegations would be concocted against Magashule, the ANCYL predicted, in order to “ensure that the real stumbling block against the white monopoly capital cartel is sidelined”.

These are lines straight out of the Zuma playbook.

When it comes to the ANCYL, the body can hardly be regarded as a significant grouping: in national terms, it is kaput in all but name. And even the branch in Magashule’s personal fiefdom of the Free State, whose support he allegedly courted assiduously with gifts, has since revealed itself to be split on the matter.

Hot on its heels came the incoherent fulminations of the ANCYL Vhembe region (Limpopo).

“It is quite shocking to see how far and to what extremes some leaders are prepared to [go to] settle political scores and settle their failed commitments by arresting fellow comrades,” the young lions frothed.

While the Hawks “categorically distanced” itself from the IOL report, terming it evidence of “malicious intent to undermine the integrity of the organisation”, Magashule continued to whisper the opposite into the ears of IOL journalists.

About three hours after the original report, Magashule seemed determined to give the rumours a longer shelf life, this time telling IOL that law enforcement agencies “shouldn’t spin it now”. Curiously, however, in this second report Magashule’s arrest warrant had been downgraded without explanation, to his name appearing “on a list of people allegedly earmarked for arrest by the NPA”.

The most plausible conclusion to draw from this mess is that word of Magashule’s arrest was deliberately spread by the secretary-general himself, with his ANCYL supporters tipped off to start raising hell as soon as possible.

But if the ultimate aim of this clumsy piece of political theatre was to test the level of political support for Magashule, the results can only have been disappointing for him. The only voices audibly heard for his defence in response to the news were a handful of ANCYL branches, a bunch of Twitter unknowns and assorted old faithfuls from the Radical Economic Transformation (RET) camp, like Carl Niehaus.

When it comes to the ANCYL, the body can hardly be regarded as a significant grouping: in national terms, it is kaput in all but name. And even the branch in Magashule’s personal fiefdom of the Free State, whose support he allegedly courted assiduously with gifts, has since revealed itself to be split on the matter.

In a highly memorable statement, the ANCYL Free State provincial task team – as distinct from the faction that issued Tuesday’s statement in support of Magashule – distanced itself from the secretary-general’s cheerleaders.

“There is no amount of ideological farting and twerking of eldership [that] can convince us that state institutions of law enforcement are used against ‘RET forces’,” the rival group wrote.

“Ace Magashule has led no ‘Economic Struggle’ in the Free State as a former Premier and provincial chairperson of the ANC, except for destroying comrades and wrecking marriages.”

The ANC Women’s League, which has in the past reliably defended male RET champions, has been silent on the issue thus far.

And the ANC itself put out no official statement on the matter, with spokesperson Pule Mabe merely telling journalists that Magashule is “establishing the factual basis” of the matter.

There is little doubt that Magashule’s arrest is indeed forthcoming at some point. But on the basis of the deflating response to the test run of the news, the secretary-general may want to look for an alternative cover story than “political conspiracy”.

Indeed, the only thing that seems to have been confirmed by this saga is the degree to which Independent Media is practising embedded journalism from within the Magashule camp. DM

Gallery

Comments - Please in order to comment.

  • Andrew McWalter says:

    Great insight Rebecca. What do you think his “Plan B“😉 will be?

  • Gerrit Marais says:

    Why is that we are still at the mercy (not that they know the term) of a bunch of criminals?

  • District Six says:

    Carl who?

    • David A says:

      Google him. The laughs you’ll get from the stories you’ll find are worth the time spent! I think he’s currently the MKMVA spokesperson and works in the office of the ANC SG. No surprises then that he’d jump to the defence of his Lord and Keeper.

  • Mike Abelheim says:

    So who ACED it. There is no doubt a large audience is watching this game of cards.

  • Roger Saner says:

    > But a failure to exercise oversight is not a criminal offence, or else practically the entire Parliament would be behind bars by now.

    Bravo!!! I laughed. I cried. Sigh.

  • Helen Swingler says:

    Smelt a rat as soon as I saw IOL.

  • Geoff Young says:

    Very good analysis, thank you Rebecca. We all know Ace is guilty as the alternative is plainly absurd. The Ramaphosa faction simply does not have the ability (or need) to concoct and maintain such a complex and Machiavellian conspiracy against an innocent man. Even if they could, it would unravel and backfire horribly. So the only real question is whether the NPA can actually gather the evidence needed to convict Magashule and present it coherently in court. So far, so good?

  • Johan Anton says:

    Magasule your demise is approaching and there is NOTHING you can do about it !

  • Peter Dexter says:

    As soon as you see IOL you know it’s a scam. The question I would like Ace to answer is why he hasn’t instituted a defamation suit against Pieter-Louis Myburgh for the allegations he makes in Gangster State? If there is no substance to the allegations have them tested in court. Strange

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted

X

This article is free to read.

Sign up for free or sign in to continue reading.

Unlike our competitors, we don’t force you to pay to read the news but we do need your email address to make your experience better.


Nearly there! Create a password to finish signing up with us:

Please enter your password or get a sign in link if you’ve forgotten

Open Sesame! Thanks for signing up.

We would like our readers to start paying for Daily Maverick...

…but we are not going to force you to. Over 10 million users come to us each month for the news. We have not put it behind a paywall because the truth should not be a luxury.

Instead we ask our readers who can afford to contribute, even a small amount each month, to do so.

If you appreciate it and want to see us keep going then please consider contributing whatever you can.

Support Daily Maverick→
Payment options