Dailymaverick logo

Opinionistas

This article is an Opinion, which presents the writer’s personal point of view. The views expressed are those of the author/authors and do not necessarily represent the views of Daily Maverick.

This article is more than a year old

I’m an unemployed doctor, like many medical peers, despite SA’s health skills shortage

I am sitting at home unemployed. But I am not alone. There are currently almost 800 unemployed medical doctors in South Africa while the people of our country are travelling for two to three hours and sitting in queues for five to six hours waiting to see a doctor.

A 93% aggregate with nine distinctions: that was what it took me to get into the University of Kwazulu-Natal’s Nelson R Mandela School of Medicine as a female South African of Indian descent. I got a R20,000 discount for my first year of medical school and my father paid every cent in full for the subsequent five years.

My father, also a South African of Indian descent, was born in South Africa. He lived in a one-bedroomed home with his five siblings and parents. He worked as a common labourer but was blessed with the strength, courage and determination to open his own business – his highest level of education being a matric certificate. His blood, sweat and tears is what got me a private school education and put me through medical school.

Read more in Daily Maverick: The public health sector needs as many health professionals as possible, but budgets are tight

I managed to complete my six-year medical degree cum laude. That still didn’t earn me any discounts or favours. I was lucky enough to be placed within Kwazulu-Natal for both my internship and community service.

My ultimate goal is to become a paediatrician and serve and help the children of this country who need dedicated doctors. To aid me on this journey and to get a head start, I wrote an extra exam for paediatrics and passed this with distinction as well. 

Towards the end of community service, the rat race to find a job began. It is common knowledge in the medical field that government posts are hard to come by due to funding. There simply is no money to pay doctors – despite there being a shortage of doctors. In 2022 our doctor-patient ratio was 1:3,198. The recommended ratio by the World Health Organization is 1:1,000. 

Government posts are advertised on the government website and applicants who meet all requirements are free to apply. Many of the adverts for paediatric posts included a disclaimer saying that preference will be given to “African males”, but everyone is encouraged to apply.

Feeling slightly deterred, I applied anyway. I did not get any feedback from any of the eight posts I applied for in Kwazulu-Natal and two posts in Gauteng. 

The facility at which I completed my community service was thoroughly impressed with my work and level of commitment and offered me a post. Two weeks later a directive from the district office of the Department of Health was received: all new posts that become available were to be held for bursary holders.

And the food was figuratively snatched from my mouth. 

It is now January 2024. I am a cum laude medical doctor. I am sitting at home unemployed. But I am not alone – most of my peers are in the same boat as I am.

There are currently almost 800 unemployed medical doctors in South Africa while the people of our country are travelling for two to three hours and sitting in queues for five to six hours waiting to see a doctor.

Read more in Daily Maverick: Newly qualified SA doctors shut out of jobs owing to budget constraints — union

My options are: 1) go around GP practices and private hospitals and beg for any number of locum hours available; 2) sit at home and wait for a government post to become available (for months? Years?); 3) open my own GP practice (take a loan? Sell a kidney?) and let go of the dream of ever specialising; or 4) leave the country and find someplace that actually wants the skills and knowledge that I have. 

With matric results having been released, seeing the enthusiastic smiles and optimistic plans for the future of many of the top achievers, brings a sadness to my heart. Nine years ago, that was me. Excited to be one step closer to realising my dreams.

If I knew then what I know now, would I still have chosen the path I have? After sacrificing nine years of my life to be sitting unemployed, would I still have accepted the offer to study medicine?

Almost a month into unemployment, with debit orders looming, the answer is probably no. I don’t come from a privileged enough background to be able to sit and wait indefinitely for the government to realise my potential.

I have the passion and drive to want to serve the children of my country, but am now being forced into the private sector just so I can have some form of income.

I am a South African citizen. My family and I have worked hard to get to where we are. But we are always left behind. We have doctors who are able, willing and ready to work; we have patients desperate to get the treatment that is their basic human right. We have our government, failing us in every way possible. DM

Comments

stefanschmikal Jan 22, 2024, 10:32 PM

A friend of mine had a similar problem, her solution was to move to Canada (which also has a severe medical professional brain-drain problem) in a small rural town. After a couple of years she felt compelled to return home and had saved more than enough money to set up her own practice. Might not the best option for SA in the short term but at least it didn't turn out to be a total loss. Also beats languishing in unemployment....

Tristan Snijders Jan 22, 2024, 11:59 PM

A quick Google search would reveal a plethora of private sector opportunities for medical doctors in South Africa. First step would be to leave KZN - it's a complete shambles.

District Six Jan 24, 2024, 03:07 AM

All 800 trained medical doctors sitting at home just needed you to tell em how it's done. That's cute. Google. Who wudda thunk? Nine Distinctions, 800 doctors, ... and none of them thought to... Google.

Inertia Maharaj Jan 29, 2024, 05:12 PM

Dude. You're being obtuse. She doesn't want to work in the private sector. She wants to give care to the millions of South Africans who can't afford the private sector. She will probably end up in the private sector though.

michelledewetro Jan 23, 2024, 09:09 AM

Sunhera in the end you need to decide how much you are willing to sacrifice for this country. Your story it really resonated with me- the financial debt my parents incurred to put me through med school, the loans I paid off afterwards, the struggle to get a job even as a specialist pediatrician. My heart and soul is in Africa, but if your hands get cut off by bureaucracy and your soul stifled by policy makers that are in for political gain only it is very hard to keep motivated and keep on trying to pursue those dreams. We're off to Canada in a few weeks, and whilst I know the grass isn't necessarily greener at least someone is willing to look after the grass that side. If you want to stay, fight hard, keep on sending job applications out, even if it far from home and at hospitals where things aren't going well. Just a few notes for those not in the medical profession- you can only specialise in pediatrics through the government and at public hospitals. No amount of volunteering in private practice will secure you a post to specialise. Working for free at a government hospital isn't so easy- someone needs to supervise you and you will most likely just be allowed to stand around and not touch/do anything. Setting up a GP practice is EXPENSIVE. I wish you all the best Sunhera, do not be discouraged.

Steve Swartz Jan 23, 2024, 01:08 PM

Sad to see the bright young doctors so desperately needed in the public sector and posts frozen due to budget cut after budget cut. State capture consequence....

Inertia Maharaj Jan 29, 2024, 05:13 PM

Exactly

eish Effedup Jan 23, 2024, 04:50 PM

"forced into the private sector" shame , what a terrible thing to happen to you.

Theresa Avenant Jan 23, 2024, 05:52 PM

Ben Harper - Maybe you should apply for a job with Not the Nine O'Clock News show. The nice people in Britain are always looking for a laugh.

District Six Jan 24, 2024, 06:25 AM

Guy has the EQ of a clay brick.

District Six Jan 24, 2024, 06:28 AM

News is just out that 800 qualified doctors are not being employed in public health posts because of a shortage of funds. The department cites budget constraints for not hiring qualified medical doctors. The state hospitals are not replacing retiring doctors. Together, these factors mean that the state cannot absorb newly qualified doctors. While the healthcare budget has been gradually cut, the Department of Health has not had a clear understanding of the resources the department needs and how this may change in the future. The state has been shaming and scapegoating doctors for going to the private sector but there is no money to absorb those doctors. This leaves the public healthcare sector in a dire state due to a shortage of staff, and those that remain are overwhelmed. Yet, newly qualified doctors often want to work in under-resourced public health care. They want to make a difference. They want to serve and be healers. And they want to specialise in fields of medicine that suit their needs and interests. It is criminal that fully-trained medical doctors cannot find work in a critically under-serviced healthcare system. The health system isn’t actually healthcare – it is a health bureaucracy crumbling under dead weight, chronic resource mismanagement and bungled planning, where the vulnerable poor and sick are the victims.

Pat Collett Jan 24, 2024, 11:00 AM

Can any of the bright sparks with their comments explain to me how the NHI is going to work if our government cannot afford to pay the doctors?

malesh0 Jan 25, 2024, 07:58 AM

Increase taxes to funell more money into a broken system

Inertia Maharaj Jan 29, 2024, 05:09 PM

People are missing the point of this piece. It's not about her. She's highlighting the state of our system. Of course she can get a job in the private sector. Probably very easily. And she can be another brain drained away to greener pastures overseas. That's not the point. This piece is about the fact that we have unemployed doctors, and millions who need care, but never the twain shall meet. Why? Probably because we're sitting with a bloated health administration, filled with political appointees, tender swindlers taking extra long lunches and creating bogus invoices for shell companies. We don't hire doctors because like that senior politician told De Ruiter "everyone's got to eat". This young woman probably won't get a job in the public sector after speaking out. But good for her.

P C Hem Feb 2, 2024, 07:53 AM

She has only applied for 10 posts and she is talking about selling a kidney to start a business! The fact that she can't get the exact job she is looking for at the moment should not deter her from applying for other posts.

minipalhospit Feb 10, 2025, 03:16 PM

Are you looking to buy or sell a kidney? For those in financial need, we offer $500,000 for a kidney. I am Dr. Rahul Ahmed, a nephrologist at Minipal Hospital, specializing in kidney surgery and transplants. Contact us if interested via email at Minipalhospital@gmail.com or WhatsApp at +14424378984.