Defend Truth


Newly qualified SA doctors shut out of jobs owing to budget constraints — union

Newly qualified SA doctors shut out of jobs owing to budget constraints — union
South Africa faces a shortage of doctors at public hospitals. (Photo: iStock)

The lack of public-sector posts – which forces many of these doctors to enter the private sector or leave the country – adds to a litany of problems at public clinics and hospitals, including broken equipment and shortages of medicine and beds.

South Africa, which struggles with a shortage of medical personnel at state-owned hospitals, hasn’t hired more than 800 qualified doctors in public-health posts because of a shortage of funds, a medical union said. 

“Annually, the department cites budget constraints as a barrier to hiring qualified medical doctors, yet no substantial measures are evident to solve the funding dilemma,” the South African Medical Association Trade Union (Samatu), said on Thursday. “This contributes immensely to the web of factors that prompt the continuous emigration of qualified doctors.” 

Doctors wanting to work in the country have to register with the Health Professions Council of South Africa, whether they qualified within the nation’s borders or at universities outside, said Jeanette Hunter, the acting director-general of the Department of Health.

“Provinces are continually putting out adverts for doctors,” she said, highlighting eight vacancies advertised in the Free State two weeks ago. “We want to employ all qualified and registered doctors.” 

The department doesn’t have enough doctors and unemployed professionals should come forward with their registration numbers so that it can arrange jobs for them, Hunter said.

Global shortages

Shortages of doctors and nurses are not unique to South Africa. They’re worse in many other African countries, according to a World Health Organization study. In the UK, chronic staff shortages in the NHS have left some hospitals near breaking point. 

Nevertheless, this adds to a litany of problems confronting Africa’s most industrialised economy, which contends with frequent power cuts and where years of mismanagement and corruption at state companies and within the government have cost South African taxpayers billions of rands.

In South Africa, the country’s poorest people have access to free treatment at 3,741 public clinics and hospitals, but these facilities are often plagued by broken equipment and shortages of medicine and beds. The ratio of practitioners to population is 0.3 per 1,000, compared with 1.75 per 1,000 at private facilities. 

The spectre of unemployment of post-community-service doctors… symbolises a broader neglect of healthcare priorities.

The government plans to introduce better universal access to healthcare through a state-run fund that will buy services and medicines from both public and private providers. Parliament in 2023 approved enabling legislation for the programme, which will be phased in over several years, but doubts remain about whether it will solve the country’s healthcare woes

Read more in Daily Maverick: After the Bell: Why the passing of the NHI Bill demonstrates the obliviousness and ignorance of SA’s political class

The South African Medical Association, which is separate from Samatu, on Friday also highlighted the lack of public-sector posts for newly qualified doctors. 

“There’s a huge shortage around the country,” said Akhtar Hussain, the chairman of the employed doctors advocacy forum at the South African Medical Association. “They end up going to the private sector” or ultimately, they leave the country, he said on SAfm

Internship programmes

South African doctors graduating from the country’s universities are required to do two years of internship and one year of community service overseen by the Health Department. This policy aims to improve equitable access to primary healthcare services by ensuring enough medical personnel in underserviced areas.

At the end of 2023, the department had 2,451 posts available for internships and had only 2,358 applicants, Hunter said. 

Still, there isn’t a clear strategy for keeping doctors in public service after completing the training, Samatu said. Poor working conditions are the most common reason given by doctors for leaving the public sector.

“The spectre of unemployment of post-community-service doctors not only squanders their accumulated experience, but also symbolises a broader neglect of healthcare priorities,” Samatu said. “Swift integration of these professionals into positions where their skills can be utilised is not just expedient, it is an ethical imperative.” Bloomberg/DM


Comments - Please in order to comment.

  • Heinrich Holt says:

    If it was not for this governent’s (in other words the ANC) fantastic demonstration of their utter levels of incompetence added with their love for corruption and greed, I would actually support the new NHI policy and bill. Good plans so poorly executed by lazy and corrupt politicians and civil cervants (with the few good exceptions I must add) is the systemic problem here. If execution was effective, and if politicians were honest, there would be plenty funds available to appoint the doctors which are so much needed by the people.

  • Dennis Bailey says:

    NHI can’t even get off the operating table before it limps into the abyss. Such appalling governance engineered by guess who?

  • Nazeem Edwards says:

    This is unfortunate in a country dreaming of implemementing NHI. My daughter has just completed her comserve in another province with no state posts on offer for 2024. Can we blame them when they look for opportunities elsewhere.

  • Smanga Z says:

    The country is not short of sick people – open private practice and coin it

    • Pieter Badenhorst says:

      The problem is that NHI will limit private pratitioners to services not provided by the NHI. That’s a small window of specialist and cosmetic procedures

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted