Defend Truth

Opinionista

Cyril Ramaphosa’s Zimbabwe blind spot will come back to bite him in devastating fashion

mm

Jonathan Moakes and Emily Osborne conduct political research, campaign and communications consultancy as well as political analysis for SABI Strategy Group, a communications and campaigning firm based in London and Johannesburg.

Despite travelling over 9,000km in an attempt to intervene in the war in Ukraine, President Cyril Ramaphosa is unwilling to condemn political violence and repression on his own doorstep.

In the months after his “victory” in Zimbabwe’s shamelessly rigged elections in August, President Emmerson Mnangagwa has continued to ride roughshod over the country’s remaining political freedoms.

Since election day, opposition MPs and activists have been abducted and murdered, wrongfully imprisoned, and recalled under false pretences. Zimbabweans are living in desperate conditions within a violent and repressive regime.

As Zimbabwe’s opposition and civil society are crushed north of the Limpopo River, South Africa’s President Cyril Ramaphosa remains silent. He regards Mnangagwa as an ally and was one of the few African leaders to attend his inauguration.

By endorsing Mnangagwa’s brutal regime, Ramaphosa proves to South Africans (and the world at large) just how low he values commitment to democracy, human rights, and basic humanity.

A pattern of political repression

Zimbabwe’s ruling Zanu-PF is determined, by any means necessary, to reclaim the two-thirds majority in the National Assembly it lost in this winter’s elections. How fortuitous, then, that a man calling himself the “Interim Secretary General of the Citizens Coalition for Change (CCC)” has written to the Speaker of Zimbabwe’s Parliament recalling 28 of the party’s MPs and multiple senators and councillors.

It did not seem to matter to the Speaker that CCC officials vehemently refuted this and denied any knowledge of the man and his supposed role in the party; the MPs were stripped of their seats and by-elections are now scheduled for 9 December.

Opposition candidates for these seats are campaigning in an increasingly dangerous environment. CCC activist and cleric Tapfumaneyi Masaya was abducted while canvassing for his candidate in a constituency just outside of Harare. His body was later found dumped on the outskirts of the city.

Read more in Daily Maverick: Zimbabwe opposition party says activist found dead after abduction

Tragically, this was one in a series of increasingly violent crimes carried out against CCC MPs and supporters. Party activist Jeffrey Kalosi was kidnapped with Masaya, although he survived the ordeal. Two opposition MPs, James Chidhakwa and Takudzwa Ngadziore, were also abducted and tortured in recent weeks.

Read more in Daily Maverick: Technology exposes involvement of intelligence agents in abduction and torture of Zimbabwe’s youngest MP

These tactics are grotesque, although sadly quite common in the Zanu-PF playbook, particularly around an election period. They have naturally prompted deep condemnation of Mnangagwa’s regime by concerned onlookers including Amnesty International, Human Rights Watch, the Inter-Parliamentary Union, and the US government.

History, however, teaches that these complaints will have little bearing on Mnangagwa’s behaviour. Especially when regional partners, like South Africa, continue to look the other way.  

Ramaphosa’s silent support

In the face of these egregious and well-documented human rights violations, Ramaphosa continues to back his ally in Harare, tacitly condoning the attacks against opposition leaders with his silence.

At the United Nations General Assembly in September, Ramaphosa called Mnangagwa “my brother” and stood shoulder-to-shoulder with the Zimbabwean president after SADC and AU election observers had decried his election as deeply flawed.

Ramaphosa’s silence on Zimbabwe is also deeply hypocritical, given how vocally he claims to defend civil liberties elsewhere in the world. On Israel, he has referred the country’s government to the International Criminal Court for its military operation in Gaza, backed a motion to sever diplomatic ties with Tel Aviv, and promised unwavering support to the Palestinian people. 

In Ukraine too, the President has sought to style himself as a statesman: leading a delegation of six African heads of state to Moscow and Kyiv in June in a vainglorious attempt to broker a peace agreement. Yet despite travelling over 9,000km to intervene in a European war, he is unwilling to condemn political violence and repression on his own doorstep.

Chickens coming home to roost

Ramaphosa’s tacit support for Mnangagwa is fostering an incredibly unstable situation in Zimbabwe. This will only spell bad news for the South African president, whose party is currently polling below 50% in the lead-up to next year’s elections. He would do well to remember that his stance on Zimbabwe may be consequential for many voters.

As long as Mnangagwa’s regime is allowed to continue unchecked by South African intervention, Zimbabweans will continue to migrate in large numbers to South Africa. They are fleeing from the political repression and economic turmoil, many crossing the border at Beit Bridge into South Africa in search of a more stable, prosperous, and hopeful future.

Figures vary, but there are estimated to be more than one million people in the Zimbabwean diaspora currently residing in South Africa. The issue of migration into the country is a key concern for many voters heading into 2024, many of whom would like to see numbers reduced to free up employment opportunities. As a result, anti-Zimbabwean xenophobia is on the rise, a situation populist opposition politicians are already exploiting.

Ramaphosa’s silence is also fundamentally not a good look for him or South Africa, both at home and on the global stage. It completely undermines any effort by South Africa to present itself as an international peacemaker, and Ramaphosa as a crusader for civil liberties.

It is not too late, however, for Ramaphosa to change course. Nearly 30 years ago, Nelson Mandela notoriously opted for “quiet diplomacy” in his dealings with Nigeria’s General Sani Abacha, refraining from publicly speaking out against his increasingly brutal regime. However, as the atrocities of Abacha’s military rule mounted — culminating in the execution of Ken Saro-Wiwa, an environmental activist and government critic — Mandela reversed his earlier stance. He called for sanctions on Nigeria and its suspension from the Commonwealth.  

In 1994, Mandela and the ANC swept to victory with the promise of a better life for all. As we approach the 30th anniversary of democracy in South Africa, and the 10th anniversary of Madiba’s passing, Ramaphosa has the chance to embody the teachings of his former mentor by championing political freedoms and human rights in our region.

If he cannot do this for the people of Zimbabwe, perhaps he can do it for his own re-election campaign. DM

Disclosure: SABI Strategy Group (which the authors work for) conducted work for the Citizens Coalition for Change during the Zimbabwe 2023 elections. 

Gallery

Comments - Please in order to comment.

  • M D Fraser says:

    The ANC farce continues unabated. Good article, good questions – but sadly we all already know the answers. ANC is determined to shoot itself in the foot and take the country down with it . Won’t bother the wealthy ANC elite, they will simply move on and live elsewhere, on their ill-gotten gains.

  • Beyond Fedup says:

    Cyril the spineless and useless is nothing but a huge a fraud. He has zero morals, integrity, ethics, honesty and common decency. Whenever I see or hear the word Cyril Ramaphosa, the first thing that comes to mind and stays permanently there is a despicable and sleazy all-consuming hypocrite, one so false and revolting that even Zuma pales into significance. At least with the latter, one knew exactly what you are dealing with. How this odious and poor excuse of a man/leader can look himself in the mirror and sleep well at night is beyond comprehension. Cyril – you are a total disgrace to the nation and besides being a horrendous hypocrite, you are treasonous, treacherous, self-serving to you and your party, duplicitous and dishonest to the core!

  • Rae Earl says:

    Ramaphosa couldn’t care less about the rapidly escalating negativity of his image. He sits on the ANC benches, in parliament and wallows in the sick attendance of fools and clowns like Cele and Mbalula. These buddies will make ongoing idiotic decisions and nonsensical statements until they have achieved the downfall of the country. Then they’ll retire with bank accounts full of money looted from SA citizens and go off to the pub for a drink with buddy Mnangagwa to joke about how they have the last laugh on two devastated countries which are no longer their concern.

  • Change is good sa says:

    Why do we only blame Ramaphosa. The top 10 of the ANC government are silent on this issue as well.
    They are all complicit in the suffering of Zimbabwe’s citizens, but then looting state coffers is all the ANC top 10 and Zane-PF are interested in. SA citizens still have the power to change this in 2024, let’s do it for us and Zimbabwe’s citizens, let’s get rid of these big man bully politicians and try something new.

  • Edward Burke says:

    I’m afraid if you think Ramaphosa or anyone in his party has even a passing interest in either the morality of government, or indeed governing anything at all, you have not been paying attention for the last thirty years.

  • Penny Philip says:

    A lot of the top ANC have joint interests in mining operations in Zimbabwe, as well as in the DRC.

    • Kenneth FAKUDE says:

      He couldn’t care less he has so much coming back to bite him, I guess we are all disappointed because he was the only person who could have fixed this country with a majority support from all parties due to his role and interactions Pre 1994, and as someone instrumental in drawing the constitution upholding it should have been a walk in park and his pride, dollars under the mattresses later he now has to look behind his back for knives, he cannot step on toes now yes he is in a difficult position inside his corrupt party

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted

Daily Maverick The Gathering 2024 banner

Daily Maverick has secured an esteemed speaker line-up...

to help make sense of Elections 2024.

Trevor Manuel, Prof Thuli Madonsela and Minister Ronald Lamola are among the latest panellists confirmed for Daily Maverick The Gathering Twenty Twenty-Four.

Join us, on Thurs 14 March 2024 at CTICC Cape Town or online wherever you are, for an event that will put the election in perspective.

Otsile Nkadimeng - photo by Thom Pierce

A new community Actionist every week.

Meet the South Africans making a difference. Get Maverick Citizen in your inbox.