Dailymaverick logo

South Africa

This article is more than a year old

DAILY MAVERICK WEBINAR

Young people have been seriously let down — nobody chooses a life where you have to ask for a handout, says Minister Gwarube

In a country where more than 45% of youth are unemployed, Basic Education Minister Siviwe Gwarube and mobiliser strategist Nape Senong argue that instead of being sidelined to youth leagues, young people and women should storm the political bastions and fix the systemic mess that’s left them jobless and frustrated—because if the future is young, why are the leaders old enough to be their grandparents?
Young people have been seriously let down — nobody chooses a life where you have to ask for a handout, says Minister Gwarube Daily Maverick journalist Suné Payne. (Photo: Leila Dougan) | Minister of Basic Education Siviwe Gwarube. (Photo: Gallo Images / Brenton Geach) | Mobiliser strategist, Youth Capital, Nape Senong. (Photo: Supplied)

South Africa faces a daunting challenge with more than 45%  of its youth unemployed. Basic Education Minister Siviwe Gwarube and Nape Senong, a mobiliser strategist with Youth Capital empowering youth and women to address the country’s pressing needs, as well as support to address underrepresentation, with only 12 MPs aged 20-29 out of 400.

They were speaking on a webinar hosted by Daily Maverick journalist Suné Payne.

The discussion focused on young people in the country and the power of working together — looking into the number of young people in Parliament and ongoing youth unemployment.

Empowering women and youth

With South Africa’s alarming youth unemployment rate of 45.5%  among young individuals aged 15-34, compared with the national average of 32.9%, Gwarube shared the importance of empowering young people and women, especially in politics.

However, she said that she did not share the view that young people in political positions should be confined to youth leagues and youth desks. 

width="830" height="415" frameborder="0" allowfullscreen="allowfullscreen">

“I think that young people should contest political power inside their political parties. I think the same thing about women, I think women should not be confined to women’s desks and women’s leagues.

“While I think there’s a role for those organisations to play, when it comes to contesting political power young people and women should contest the main political power, they should be the ones who are starting the debate… and they must occupy positions of power,” Gwarube said.

Read more: South Africa’s youngest Cabinet minister, Siviwe Gwarube, to tackle myriad challenges

Reflecting on her own experience, Gwarube, 35, said: “Being a young MP in South Africa is something that should have been happening a long time ago. The African continent has one of the youngest populations in the world, and it is a weird and strange phenomenon to me that as young as the population of the African continent is, the leaders on the African continent remain almost double or triple the age of the people they lead.’’

Roots of Unemployment

With statistics indicating that the majority of South Africa’s population of 60.6 million is comprised of youth, Gwarube attributed South Africa’s longstanding unemployment to historical and systemic factors. 

“For historical reasons, black South Africans mostly were not able to obtain good quality education, which is part of the reason we need to undo that. The South African economy has not grown over one percent in the past decade; you can’t have young people in work if you’re not growing the economy.

“The energy crisis, companies not investing due to poor service delivery, rampant corruption — all these factors combine to make South Africa an unviable place for young people to start businesses. There’s also excessive red tape for young entrepreneurs. People will tell you the statistics show that small businesses are unlikely to survive the first five years,” Gwarube said.

Since the youth comprise the largest percentage of the population and face the highest unemployment rates, Nape advised that “solving young people’s problems is like solving the country’s problems”.

In a card game organised by Youth Capital, Gwarube was asked the question: “How do you feel when people say young people are lazy and waiting for handouts?”

In the webinar, Gwarube responded that the question made her very angry because “young people have been let down seriously in our country and I think nobody chooses a life of indignity… nobody chooses a life where you have to ask for a handout”.

Youth Empowerment

Gwarube challenged the notion that placing youth in positions of power automatically addressed their issues. Instead, she argued that quality education and youth unemployment were national concerns that those in power should tackle because of the instability that otherwise resulted.

Read more: #FeesMustFall: Political failure triggers ticking time bomb

Nape echoed this sentiment as he reflected on the 2015 Fees Must Fall protests, noting that although various political parties took many young people from the protest to Parliament, their presence didn’t truly prioritise youth concerns there.

Youth Unemployment Solutions

To address unemployment, Gwarube stressed the importance of growing the economy and enhancing the quality of education for young people.

Similarly, Nape highlighted the importance of engaging with young people through approachable government and technology, stating: “We have to meet young people where they are, whether it’s on TikTok, social media,  going into their communities to engage with them because a lot of government and other engagements are always centred around going to where the government is, going to town for public consultations… the consultations are always far and then means the consultations aren’t meaningful… Those in power should be going to where young people are.”

Nape also stressed the importance of collaborations and youth involvement in various organisations, highlighting the need for young people to be treated as “partners rather than just beneficiaries”. DM

Comments (10)

jbest6787@gmail.com Oct 4, 2024, 06:55 PM

I think the only solution is for young people to be active in political action to take the country from older generation. I believe that new ideas can therefore guide our democracy to a higher level of economic and political evolution. Old people are not guiding the country in a modern style.......

Trenton Carr Oct 4, 2024, 07:39 PM

The ANC had more than a generation to make a positive change for the youth, they failed them. More than 50% of the youth are unemployable. This is their failure, they own it. Other societies with far worse initial conditions have been able to build a future for their youth, the anc have not.

Roger Sheppard Oct 7, 2024, 03:23 PM

...and include Israel and New Zealand in your last sentence please.

Fanie Rajesh Ngabiso Oct 4, 2024, 09:39 PM

Everything is balance. Both young and old have a part to play and a contribution to make.

Arnold O Managra Oct 5, 2024, 05:24 AM

It's a bizarre idea that the youth can solve systemic problems like unemployment (by given leadership positions for example). They literally do not have the experience or even emotional maturity to do so. Khmer Rouge and Great Step Forward again? Horrible suffering.

andilegwijane1988 Oct 5, 2024, 06:30 AM

who are they , another DA experiment?

Jennifer D Oct 5, 2024, 07:08 AM

“Solving young people’s problems” is not a solution to anything. Young people must get up and solve their own problems. The problem with South Africa’s youth is that they are entitled and think they are owed a job. They are not. Africa will only be great when people solve their own problems.

Helen Swingler Oct 5, 2024, 11:24 AM

Yes. But they do not operate in a vacuum. Nothing grows if basic conditions are not met for nurturing new life/energy/vision. What can govt, civil society, elders, etc do to enable this. It's a partnership of all facets of government, business, education, society.

David McCormick Oct 5, 2024, 04:03 PM

Young people in our office do not have an entitled presence, and are grateful to have a steady job where skills are transferred. Challenges include communication in Engish, and transitioning from village/township to "city" life. The quality of village/township "formal" education can be poor.

Peter Oosthuizen Oct 6, 2024, 12:26 PM

A very sweeping statement - every day I meet well spoken, well educated young South Africans doing jobs with a smile and cheerfulness that shows no attitude of entitlement at all. Remember every time one points a finger three fingers are pointing straight back!

Michele Rivarola Oct 5, 2024, 07:37 AM

Current jobs require more and more STEM proficiency so what does SA’s government do? Make the pass mark/proficiency level 30% to fudge the stats so they look good but when it comes to finding jobs reality bites.

Barrie Lewis Oct 5, 2024, 07:47 AM

Such a complexity with many interacting factors but one often forgotten is that South Africa's children, and their mums one might add, are so poorly fed that nearly 50% in rural villages are permanently mentally and/or physically stunted by the age of 5. And we are surprised they are unemployable?!

Indeed Jhb Oct 5, 2024, 10:21 AM

The constant 'improvement' to the schooling system to make learning more practical to ready learners for employment is a 30 year failure. Instead of uplifting the level of education it is pulled down. Added to that very poor quality teachers - a grim situation. Outcomes based, we now have it.

Rob Wilson Oct 5, 2024, 12:59 PM

It starts with quality of education. I recently employed someone to paint my house and he asked if he could bring his recently matriculated son along for some experience. The poor lad didn't know one half from one third. Could not use a tape measure. I cannot employ that.