Defend Truth

GROUNDUP

Elections 2024 — Where SA’s major political parties stand on state of basic education system

Elections 2024 — Where SA’s major political parties stand on state of basic education system
Various webinars and events on housing, water crisis, and education activism are scheduled for the week ahead. (Illustration: Lisa Nelson) South Africa’s education system is in a poor way. We asked political parties what they would do to fix it.

We sent questions to the ANC, DA, EFF, IFP, FF Plus, ActionSA, PA, MK Party and Rise Mzansi

Today’s questions to the major political parties deal with basic education.

We asked the ANC, DA, EFF, IFP, FF Plus, ActionSA, PA, MK Party, and Rise Mzansi on 13 March and sent follow-up queries to those who did not respond. Some have still not responded.

Answers are very lightly edited for grammar and typos.

What steps would your party take to ensure that a greater percentage of South African children can read, write and do arithmetic at an age-appropriate standard?

ANC: The ANC did not respond to our questions.

DA: The DA will improve the reading, writing and arithmetic abilities of our learners by:

  • Devoting the first two hours of each school day in the Foundation Phase (Grade R to 3) to developing reading and writing skills.
  • Devoting one hour each day in the Foundation Phase to numeracy skills.
  • Introducing a national literacy and numeracy test at the end of the Foundation Phase, under independent invigilation, to assess whether learners have acquired these foundational skills, release these results to parents and intervene appropriately in schools with a high failure rate to identify the causes and take appropriate rectification steps.

EFF: The EFF intends to implement Early Childhood Learning from the age of three years old, free of charge to all South African children. This will include in-depth curriculae that encourage age-appropriate learning through play, as well as build on literacy from an early age.

IFP: Prioritise Early Childhood Development (ECD) programmes for a strong foundation in these areas of learning.

FF Plus: Mother tongue education is key to improving the literacy rate and the arithmetic standard. We will ensure that all official languages are developed so that children can complete schooling and go to university in their mother tongue. Community-based education is also crucial.

ActionSA: To improve basic educational outcomes, ActionSA will establish a presidential task team of independent experts to implement the National Reading Plan.

We will allocate a sufficient budget for reading interventions and resources in Foundation Phase classrooms. We will ensure that Foundation Phase teachers receive training on teaching children how to read meaningfully at least once every quarter.

ActionSA will provide access to parental reading training initiatives to empower parents to help their children read for meaning and create a culture of reading by launching community reading programmes.

ActionSA will introduce training to improve the ability of existing Foundation Phase teachers to teach numeracy at age-appropriate levels, and we will implement evidence-based teaching methods for numerical skills development.

PA: Subjecting teachers to competency tests (something Sadtu vehemently opposes) would be a very good start. We also believe that a school depends heavily on the leadership of its principal. School heads should be hired independently of the unions and held to the highest standards.

MK Party: The MK Party did not respond to our questions.

Rise Mzansi: Rise Mzansi believes our basic education system is broken and requires comprehensive reform. First, education requires a new Minister of Basic Education with the vision and fortitude to lead systemic reform.

Second, we need to improve how we train teachers, support them in the classroom and hold them accountable for student performance.

Third, we need to provide higher-quality, timeous data — including through better and more regular standardised testing — on student performance to education system leaders, principals and parents. Finally, we need to address the capture of education administration — and associated corruption and patronage — by political parties and teachers’ unions.

Read more in Daily Maverick: Desperate times call for desperate measures — and our schooling is in dire straits

The implementation of the norms and standards policy for school infrastructure — including the provision of toilets, libraries and proper classrooms — is many years delayed. How would you speed up implementation?

ANC: The ANC did not respond to our questions.

DA: The DA will speed up the realisation of the norms and standards policy for school infrastructure by:

  • Encouraging efficient use of government and community facilities to increase education facility access (such as libraries, laboratories, and sports facilities).
  • Diversifying sources of funding available for school infrastructure. This can be done through research to identify ways in which strong private sector participation and funding can be included within the school infrastructure maintenance network.
  • Enhancing the protection of existing school infrastructure. In line with the Human Rights Commission Report, the DA will establish a National School Protection Response Team. This response team would include relevant departments such as SAPS, DBE, and other relevant stakeholders. This task team will be replicated at provincial and local levels.
  • Conducting a feasibility study for the potential nationwide expansion of online schooling.
  • Expanding the availability of mobile classrooms in under-resourced schools.
  • Increasing the supply of teachers.
  • Acknowledging that independent schools relieve the burden on the public schooling system. This would be done by simplifying legal requirements for independent schools to register, requiring amendments to the South African Schools Act.

We will enhance accountability in school infrastructure projects by ensuring improved accountability mechanisms by the DBE. The DA will:

  • make public school infrastructure progress information on the Education Facilities Management System;
  • ensure that information from the system is collated and published in a report annually; and
  • implement a culture of 10-year post-project evaluations and reviews to assess the quality of the project.

EFF: The EFF recognises the crucial need for speedy implementation of the norms and standards policy for school infrastructure, as education is one of the areas we have consistently been vocal on. Here’s how we plan to accelerate this process:

Prioritisation and Phasing

We will prioritise urgent needs like toilets, libraries, and proper classrooms.

A clear, phased approach will be implemented, focusing on the most critical areas first.

Resource Mobilisation

We will explore innovative funding mechanisms like Public-Private Partnerships (PPPs) and redirecting wasteful government spending towards education infrastructure. Local businesses and farmers will also be prioritised for school meal programmes and construction projects, boosting the local economy.

Streamlining Bureaucracy

We will cut unnecessary red tape and establish a dedicated task force to fast-track approvals for infrastructure projects, while empowering local communities through participatory budgeting to ensure projects address their specific needs.

Utilising Existing Programmes

We will leverage existing initiatives like the Expanded Public Works Programme to create jobs and expedite construction. Furthermore, existing teacher training programmes will be revamped to equip them with skills for technology integration and inclusive education.

Transparency and Accountability

We will establish clear timelines and performance indicators for all infrastructure projects. Regular progress reports will be made public, fostering transparency and holding ourselves accountable.

Capacitate Teachers and Educational Resources

Furthermore, we will increase teacher training through the creation of high-tech teacher training colleges to equip educators to utilise new technology in upgraded classrooms. Additional learning materials will be provided to enhance education in improved facilities, while we will build accessible school libraries which will create lifelong learners in surrounding communities.

IFP: We will address underfunding by restructuring the education budget to improve infrastructure and resources in schools.

FF Plus: Corruption and the inflation of prices related to school infrastructure projects have led to severe delays and shortages. Resources should be spent efficiently and the best value for money should be the only criterion used in the award of tenders for these projects.

PA: There is no real will from the government to do this. When Gayton McKenzie was the mayor of Central Karoo, he showed that it was possible to eradicate the bucket toilet system in the entire district without needing enormous amounts of money, and not needing more than a few months. We have an incapable state.

Contractors are hired using procurement processes that are prone to corruption. We should instead go back to creating government departments that can deliver and employ people to do the work. For the enormous amounts of money that get blown on hiring consultants, experts, contractors and every manner of professional firm, you could give so many qualified people jobs in the public sector to get these same jobs done. Instead, we are hiring more and more “managers” into the public sector who only farm the work out to private companies who may or may not get anything done. Often, they just steal the money, run away and start new companies to do it all over again.

ActionSA: Fixing South Africa’s education system, particularly with reference to the need to expand access, requires that we couple an increase in infrastructure investment with system-wide reforms, ranging from education administration and bureaucracy.

It is also critical that we implement strict performance and consequence management practices in supply chain and procurement processes that hold underperforming and non-performing service providers accountable, especially as it concerns infrastructure projects.

MK Party: The MK Party did not respond to our questions.

Rise Mzansi: Dilapidated, unsafe schools are unacceptable. It is vital that schools are safe spaces for children. Rise Mzansi would complete an audit of the schools with the greatest infrastructure challenges, calculate the funds required to achieve minimum standards of safety, and lobby to fully fund this through the Budget. Rise Mzansi would establish national and provincial delivery units to drive implementation, according to a clear timetable, with monthly progress updates reported to the public until completion. DM

First published by GroundUp.

Gallery

Comments - Please in order to comment.

  • Johan Buys says:

    It would have been interesting to ask SADTU what their Education solutions are.

    Answer 1 : scrap qualification requirements – everybody can be a teacher. Employ more teachers, pay teachers more and reduce working hours. Give us 50% bonuses for increasing the basic literacy and numeracy test of age 9 kids from 20% to 40%. You still win eleventy percent better outcome.

    Answer 2 : Norms and standards are a western colonial concept designed to force teachers to work harder. They must go. So must standardized tests that don’t focus on herding and fetching water as a basic skill.

    • Alan Paterson says:

      Greatly enjoyed this but at same time depressed. That the ANC (and its ugly sister MK) did not respond is appropriate. Its all about reading for meaning after all. As for the EFF we can only assume that the private school promised for Alexandra by Julius five years ago is about ready to go, Or not. Whomsoever amongst the good, bad and plain ugly that triumph in this election are faced with at least another generation of catch up after the monumental failure by the ANC dating back thirty years, Starting with Bengu collapsing the training colleges and unionizing the “teachers” to the current sock puppet wheeled out annually as praise singer and then returned to the drawer. It is a disaster and possibly deliberate to buy the support of the T-shirt and KFC masses come May.

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted

X

This article is free to read.

Sign up for free or sign in to continue reading.

Unlike our competitors, we don’t force you to pay to read the news but we do need your email address to make your experience better.


Nearly there! Create a password to finish signing up with us:

Please enter your password or get a sign in link if you’ve forgotten

Open Sesame! Thanks for signing up.

A South African Hero: You

There’s a 99.7% chance that this isn’t for you. Only 0.3% of our readers have responded to this call for action.

Those 0.3% of our readers are our hidden heroes, who are fuelling our work and impacting the lives of every South African in doing so. They’re the people who contribute to keep Daily Maverick free for all, including you.

The equation is quite simple: the more members we have, the more reporting and investigations we can do, and the greater the impact on the country.

Be part of that 0.3%. Be a Maverick. Be a Maverick Insider.

Support Daily Maverick→
Payment options

MavericKids vol 3

How can a child learn to read if they don't have a book?

81% of South African children aged 10 can't read for meaning. You can help by pre-ordering a copy of MavericKids.

For every copy sold we will donate a copy to Gift of The Givers for children in need of reading support.