Our Burning Planet


All three Karpowership ‘emergency plans’ back on the table for late approval

All three Karpowership ‘emergency plans’ back on the table for late approval
The MV Karadeniz Powership Fatmagül Sultan floating power plant moored off the shore of the Lebanese town of Zouk Mosbeh, north of Beirut, Lebanon, 19 September 2018. (Photo: EPA-EFE / Nabil Mounzer)

All three of the 20-year Karpowership ‘emergency power’ plans have come bubbling back to the surface for belated government approval — despite perceptions that they may be on the point of sinking.

Last month, the national Department of Environmental Affairs issued a series of incremental announcements which gave the impression that the controversial proposals for floating gas-power plants in three South African harbours had struck the rocks.

The department said at the time that environmental approval for the Coega harbour power ship plan had been refused in toto because of opposition from the Transnet harbour authority, which had competing plans for the harbour space proposed by the Turkish-based Karadeniz group.

Approval for the power ship plan for Saldanha Bay was also in jeopardy after The Green Connection environmental group lodged complaints alleging that Karpowership’s environmental consultants, Triplo4, deliberately sought to “mislead” the Department of Forestry, Fisheries and the Environment (DFFE) during the environmental approval process.

The third proposal, in Richards Bay harbour, was also in doubt after Triplo4 withdrew from the approval process, citing an “administrative error” during the submission of its environmental authorisation application.

Now it has emerged that all three plans are potentially back on the table for final approval following last-minute legal appeals or requests for extra time by the Turkish-controlled consortium.

The DFFE confirmed on Thursday that it had rejected objections from The Green Connection and was now considering a request for extra time from Karpowership to lodge a new application for environmental approval.


Karpowership Power of Friendship. (Image: Supplied)

If this request for extra time was refused, Karpowership would have to lodge a new application for approval. If its request for extra time was granted, “the process will continue as per the conditions of approval”.

The department said that, in response to allegations from The Green Connection, it had also received further representations from Karpowership’s consultants.

After perusing the records and “interrogating” submissions from Green Connection, “no evidence could be found that supported the allegations”, the department stated.

Regarding Richards Bay harbour, DFFE spokesperson Peter Mbelengwa said his department had also received an extra-time request from Karpowership to “address challenges identified with the public review of the [environmental impact assessment] report and to ensure that all identified interested and affected parties have an opportunity to review and comment on the report”.

This request for extra time had been granted on 3 May, giving Triplo4 another month to submit a final report to the department.

The situation regarding the rejected Coega harbour application is less clear.

On 7 April, Karpowership attorney Adam Gunn wrote to DFFE Minister Barbara Creecy requesting condonation of extra time to appeal against the department’s decision to refuse permission for the Coega power ship plan.

Stiff opposition expected

Gunn’s letter does not disclose the basis of Karpowership’s appeal. Behind the scenes, however, the Turkish company and Transnet appear to be in discussions over a possible new site for power ships in Coega.

Nevertheless, Karpowership and the DFFE are expected to encounter further stiff legal and public opposition from several quarters.

The Green Connection spokesperson, Liz McDaid, told Our Burning Planet that the group was waiting for official clarity from Creecy’s department, but remained “confident” that the Karpowership plan for Saldanha had been withdrawn.

The Green Connection was also consulting with its legal team on how to take the issue forward.

“We believe this is an open-and-shut case. We are not accepting the department’s decision to dismiss our objections,” she said.

In its official complaint to the department, The Green Connection alleged that Karpowership consultants had sought to “fraudulently present other persons’ comments and views as those of small-scale fishers” during a public consultation meeting in Saldanha Bay.

“All of the attendees at the meeting titled ‘small-scale fisheries engagement’ on 3 October 2022 clearly identified themselves as being directors, owners or officials in the aquaculture industry on the attendance register, with the exception of one person who comes from the commercial pelagic sector.

“None of them are small-scale fishers or interim relief fishers permitted to fish in the Saldanha Bay or Langebaan area. Yet the consultants got them to fill in statements confirming that they were small-scale fishers. Even these participants themselves indicated on the form that they signed that they were actually from the aquaculture sector/pelagic commercial sector. 

“It is difficult to understand why these persons were involved in a focus group that claimed to represent the small-scale sector when they were actually not in a position to do this,” The Green Connection stated in its complaint to DFFE.

Karpowership, for its part, on Thursday reiterated its determination to pursue its plans, stating in response to questions: “South Africa remains central to our operations, and we are committed to contributing towards an energy solution that enables inclusive economic growth.” DM/OBP

For tickets to Daily Maverick’s The Gathering Earth Edition, click here.

Absa OBP

Comments - Please in order to comment.

  • Jane Crankshaw says:

    In a civilised country run by competent people this would be unbelievable but here? …anything is possible no matter how outrageous, stupid and corrupt!

  • Johan Buys says:

    How does the public have key questions answered? Or, is there a whistleblower with a sense of Justice?

    What are the availability fees per year for the ships? In Lebanon and Pakistan it turned out that availability fees for Karpowership for only three years was enough to buy and build the equivalent gas power capacity onshore.

    Who are the actual beneficial owners of the 49% local partner? actual = looking through trusts and nominees.

    A 1GW gas power station’s capex is less than R20 billion and ship turnkey with short lead times.

    We now have viable onshore gas in the free state. It is certain that liquifying gas overseas, shipping it here and reconverting it for use in the power ships will cost probably double what direct use of domestic gas would cost.

    Per 2023 study the LCOE of gas should be around R1.10/kWh. That is all-in cost over lifetime of plant, decommissioning included. What will Karpowerships cost SA taxpayers at current gas prices and including the 18h a day availability fees of the ships?

    • A Green says:

      A news24 article posted on 31 Jan 2022 stated the agreement was R218bn for 1220 MW over a 20-year period. My calculation must be incorrect compared to your stated R1.10/kWh!

  • Lorinda Winter says:

    Wasn’t that the original ‘long’ plan of our ANC corrupt cadres in the government? Bring Eskom to its knees, make South Africans desperate and hey presto back is this ludicrous, ridiculous, unaffordable plan to save the day! The trough eaters will be gorging themselves, the ANC will win in 2024 and the taxpayer will pay and pay and pay! Brilliant!

  • Soil Merchant says:

    I see they had to use Fake Concrete Geese in order to show some form of “wildlife” still around the power-ship …

  • Epsilon Indi says:

    Why is it that bunny hugging groups like the Green Connection always base their attacks on false “facts” ? Is it because they can’t get their way unless they lie ? Personal experience with a well known international green organisation leads me to believe that many of these organisations will do ANYTHING to get their way whether that way is based on science or not.

  • Sam Shu says:

    Higher and higher levels of blackouts? New ministers? And this thing comes back to life as an emergency? 🤔

  • Miles Japhet says:

    Follow the money

  • Gerrie Pretorius says:

    So the anc plan is still for bc to roll over for gm and allow the 20year emergency feeding trough.

  • Gordon Bentley says:

    “Mr Fokol Electricity”, has a wife who, apparently has major share holding in Karpower Ships. That’s second prize. First prize is of course, maintain the status-quo Eskom with the crooked use of coal so that all comrades and cartels can continue feeding at the trough. Both alternatives are acceptable to Mr Fokol Electricity, with back-handers but unacceptable to the taxpayer who will carry the costs either way.

    It would be far better to start obtaining cleaner energy from South African sources – natural gas, driving turbines, in the interim and green energy – wind/solar and Hydrogen (brown – from coal big Co2 – emissions, grey & blue – some Co2 removed = less Co2, and green from wind-driven electricity using electrolysis of sea water = Nil Co2) in the future.
    Hydrogen is quite expensive but other countries are already beginning production of hydrogen. Why can’t we?

    Let’s not pull a previous-presidents action on SA and ignore our dire situation. Lets do something.

  • William Stucke says:

    Despite the obvious corruption behind the Karpowership proposals, and the obscenely high R/kWh rate, I’d be prepared to accept this as lower cost to the economy than additional stages of LoadShitting – FOR A VERY LIMITED TIME.

    So, yes to a 6-month contract, with the possibility of an extension. NO WAY to a 20-year contract. Calling a 20-year contract an “emergency” is an obscenity.

  • William Dryden says:

    Mantashe is determined to get the Karpowership deal off the ground, I wonder why??

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted

MavericKids vol 3

How can a child learn to read if they don't have a book?

81% of South African children aged 10 can't read for meaning. You can help by pre-ordering a copy of MavericKids.

For every copy sold we will donate a copy to Gift of The Givers for children in need of reading support.

A South African Hero: You

There’s a 99.8% chance that this isn’t for you. Only 0.2% of our readers have responded to this call for action.

Those 0.2% of our readers are our hidden heroes, who are fuelling our work and impacting the lives of every South African in doing so. They’re the people who contribute to keep Daily Maverick free for all, including you.

The equation is quite simple: the more members we have, the more reporting and investigations we can do, and the greater the impact on the country.

Be part of that 0.2%. Be a Maverick. Be a Maverick Insider.

Support Daily Maverick→
Payment options