South Africa

MARITIME DRILL FALLOUT

Ukrainians in Cape Town sail yacht close to Russian frigate to protest against naval exercise

Ukrainians in Cape Town sail yacht close to Russian frigate to protest against naval exercise
Ukranian Viktoriia Kordiumova waves posters at the Russian frigate Admiral Gorshkov, which is berthed in Cape Town harbour, 14 February 2023. (Photo Supplied)

The protesters called on Pretoria to cancel the naval drill with Russia and instead spend the money on helping flood victims and on diesel for Eskom.

Ukrainians in South Africa and their sympathisers on Tuesday continued their rolling protests against South Africa’s planned war games with Russia when they sailed close to the Russian frigate Admiral Gorshkov in the Cape Town harbour to brandish posters of protest.

They called on Pretoria to cancel its maritime Exercise Mosi II with Russia and China and instead use the resources of the South African National Defence Force to help the victims of the current floods in parts of the country.

There was an appropriate symbolism about a small yacht full of Ukrainian protesters confronting the hypersonic missile-bearing frigate.

The protesters carried posters demanding “Keep Russian wars away from our shores” and “No Russian Missiles” as the crew of the frigate lined the ship’s railings to watch. Some of the crew used binoculars to inspect the protesters.

Harbour police in a dinghy kept close to the yacht but did not interfere with the protest. Dzvinka Kachur, a representative of the Ukrainian Association of South Africa, told Daily Maverick that the organisation had received permission from the port authority to sail in the harbour.

“Our aim was not to attack the ship. Our intentions are peaceful. We wanted to send the message that we do not welcome this extension of the Russian aggression against Ukraine into the Southern Ocean,” said Kachur, who was one of eight protesters on the yacht.

The Admiral Gorshkov slipped into Cape Town harbour on Monday morning after sailing down through the Atlantic where it conducted its own manoeuvres, including firing its 130mm cannons at a floating target, in preparation for Exercise Mosi II, the 10-day joint maritime drill with South Africa and China which is due to start off the KwaZulu-Natal coast on Friday.

The South African Police Service kept close to a yacht as it passed the Russian frigate Admiral Gorshkov, which is berthed in Cape Town harbour, 14 February 2023. (Photo Supplied)

Ukranians Viktoriia Kordiumova and Dzvinka Kachur show their anger at the Russian frigate Admiral Gorshkov, which is berthed in Cape Town harbour, 14 February 2023. (Photo Supplied)

Crew members onboard the Russian frigate Admiral Gorshkov, which is berthed in Cape Town harbour, 14 February 2023. (Photo Supplied)


Visit Daily Maverick’s home page for more news, analysis and investigations


Further protests planned

The Ukrainian Association of South Africa and other NGOs issued a statement saying they would hold another protest against Exercise Mosi II in front of the Russian consulate-general in Cape Town on Friday and then again at Umhlanga, north of Durban on Saturday.

“It is most unfortunate that South Africa has chosen to invite the Russian Federation to participate in war games off the South African coast between Durban and Richards Bay, at a time when Russia is engaging in the invasion of the sovereign state of Ukraine,” the statement said.

“The naval exercise not only falls on the first anniversary of the invasion of Ukraine on 24th of February 2022, but it also falls over the day commemorating the sinking of the troopship SS Mendi on the 21st of February 1917, during World War I, ‘The War to End all Wars’.

“These war games signify the end of South Africa’s ‘neutrality’ in what is essentially unprovoked and unjust military aggression in violation of the UN Charter, with global implications.”

Read more in Daily Maverick:

Cape Town mayor says ‘voetsek’ to docked Russian frigate Admiral Gorshkov

Controversial Russian frigate sails into Cape Town harbour ahead of contentious war games

So far, Extinction Rebellion Cape Town, Kai Tikquoa Conservancy (George) and The Green Connection have also signed the statement and others are expected to also do so.

The signatories said they were concerned that by welcoming “Russian military aggression into the previously peaceful waters of the Southern Ocean”, South Africa had increased the risk of further confrontations with other trading partners, jeopardising its already precarious economy. 

“The Russian invasion has already impacted on our fragile economy by escalating the cost of wheat, sunflower oil and fuel costs, thus increasing our cost of living and impacting on the poor of our country.”

The statement added that South Africa was jeopardising its high moral ground as a country firmly opposed to the use of nuclear weapons by associating militarily with Russia, which had threatened to fire nuclear weapons in the war against Ukraine.

“Our concern is that these visiting vessels may be armed with nuclear weapons. The South African government must ensure that no nuclear weapons are brought into South African waters,” the statement said.

It said that South Africa was being used by Russia for propaganda, especially through the information that Moscow was putting out that a hypersonic Zircon missile — which the Admiral Gorschkov carries — would be tested during Exercise Mosi II.

“Such propaganda, even if it is a lie, benefits Russia by distracting media from losses and atrocities of the Russian army, but damages the relationship between South Africa and its key trade partners. We stand the risk of economic sanctions being imposed on South Africa as a result of our support for Russia, which will result in further economic hardship for our country.”

The signatories said the military exercise could affect the marine environment. With the poor state of the economy, the government should be keeping defence costs to a minimum, and rather spend the money on diesel fuel for Eskom to reduce rolling blackouts.

“We therefore call upon the South African government to call off the naval exercise, to condemn the Russian invasion of Ukraine and to use the South African Defence Force resources allocated for this exercise to disaster relief desperately needed as a result of the recent floods in South Africa.” DM

Gallery

Comments - Please in order to comment.

  • Pagani Paganini says:

    Will it not be useful for these so-called ‘Ukrainians in South Africa and their sympathisers” should rather go back to Ukraine and fight in the frontline rather than holidaying in sunny Cape Town eating cavalier and expensive wine? Symbolisms are of no use.

  • Diana Penny says:

    Cyril Ramaphosa owes us a personal explanation as to why the SA government are allowing Russia to do this when the majority of South Africans are against the invasion of Ukraine by Russia.

  • adrianpillingsubscribe says:

    There are always three sides to a story. In this case Ukraine, Russia and the truth. I welcome ships from all nations. We are a BRICS country and therefore have relations with Russia.
    Neither Ukraine nor Russia are innocent parties in this conflict. Do not blindly believe the western press. Do research before protesting. The truth will surprise most people if they care to look for it.

    Welcome all ships to SA.

  • Andrew C says:

    @pagani How on earth do you know the status of the Ukranians in Cape Town? Maybe they have lived here for a long time. Maybe they fled Ukraine to save their lives along with many others. I very much doubt they are eating caviar or drinking expensive wine. A very unpleasant and thoughtless comment.

  • Pagani Paganini says:

    @Andrew C, And I don’t question their status in Cape Town. Not even in the country for that matter. I question the pointless symbolism of protesting seating in a yacht when the war is going on in Ukraine. One would have expected them to go and fight on the frontline if they want to see change. But make no mistake the military drills in KZN coast will take place, come rain or shine. And of course Cape Town is sunny with lots of wine.

  • Paddy Ross says:

    Are you the same person as Adrian Pilling?

  • R S says:

    @Pagani, perhaps the Russian warship should similarly return to Europe considering the absolute beating the Russians are taking from a country a fraction of their size.

  • R S says:

    @Adrian, the truth is that the first actual shot was fired by the Russians the moment they rolled their troops over the Ukrainian border to try and claim Ukraine by force.

  • Robert de Rooy says:

    If it was not for “the western press” Zuma’s corruption, the Guptas’ corruption, and all other corruption would never have been exposed. Anyone attacking the “conspiracy” of the “western press” or the “mainstream media” is serving the interest the corrupt.

  • David Walker says:

    Mr Paganini, it would be more useful for the Russian frigate to go back to the Black Sea (hopefully to be sunk by Ukrainian forces), rather than enjoy our sunshine and hospitality. We should not be supporting the war-mongers and mass murderers in the Kremlin.

  • Ian Gwilt says:

    I think the truth is pretty clear for anyone who has eyes to see
    Do you think that Sky and CNN have mocked up the scenes of devastation, The NGO groups that have documented atrocities.
    O and the space landings were filmed in the desert

  • Johann Olivier says:

    There can be little doubt that Paganini and adrianpillings are Russian trolls/bots. Responding to them gives them bandwidth. I would challenge DM to verify their provenance. This sudden appearance on these pages tells me that they’re related to the visit of their criminal navy. Review Paganini’s use of English. Clearly weird. “Cavalier”? A South African would say chowing on snoek and sipping wine (or Klippies and Coke).

  • Pagani Paganini says:

    @ Johann Olivier Lol! Oh dear Johann, I’m certainly as South African by birth as you are presumably. I just happen to hold a different view but that shouldn’t make me some sort of foreigner. I neither support Russia nor Ukraine. To be clear what is happening in Ukraine is awful and urge the parties involved to resolve their differences through negotiations and peaceful means.

    What is mind-boggling is Western hypocrisy. People are already talking about illegal war and all of the sudden even international Criminal Court is on the bandwagon to press for war crimes charges. The occupation of Iraq was illegal and not a single person was charged for the murder of more a million Iraqis. ICC’ was nowhere to be seen.

    Wars have been going on in this continent for years and again no one from the west is talking about. Way in Tigray region is a classic example and we never get to hear UN Security Council saying a word about them. Russia/Ukraine war is European war and let Europeans deal with it.

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted

X

This article is free to read.

Sign up for free or sign in to continue reading.

Unlike our competitors, we don’t force you to pay to read the news but we do need your email address to make your experience better.


Nearly there! Create a password to finish signing up with us:

Please enter your password or get a sign in link if you’ve forgotten

Open Sesame! Thanks for signing up.

We would like our readers to start paying for Daily Maverick...

…but we are not going to force you to. Over 10 million users come to us each month for the news. We have not put it behind a paywall because the truth should not be a luxury.

Instead we ask our readers who can afford to contribute, even a small amount each month, to do so.

If you appreciate it and want to see us keep going then please consider contributing whatever you can.

Support Daily Maverick→
Payment options

Premier Debate: Gauten Edition Banner

Gauteng! Brace yourselves for The Premier Debate!

How will elected officials deal with Gauteng’s myriad problems of crime, unemployment, water supply, infrastructure collapse and potentially working in a coalition?

Come find out at the inaugural Daily Maverick Debate where Stephen Grootes will hold no punches in putting the hard questions to Gauteng’s premier candidates, on 9 May 2024 at The Forum at The Campus, Bryanston.