South Africa


Dear Minister Pandor, SA’s foreign policy choices are a betrayal of Mandela’s solemn pledge

Dear Minister Pandor, SA’s foreign policy choices are a betrayal of Mandela’s solemn pledge
Minister of International Relations and Cooperation Naledi Pandor. (Photo: Gallo Images / Fani Mahuntsi)

In all current conflicts involving democracies versus autocracies (with Ukraine vs Russia as a prime example), South Africa is increasingly seen to be taking the side of the latter.

Dear Minister Naledi Pandor, 

I am writing to you as a former South African ambassador, in fact, the first ambassador appointed by President Nelson Mandela to serve in our new democratic dispensation, as I presented my credentials to the king of Thailand in Bangkok on 27 April 1994 — the day of our first democratic elections. 

At the start of his presidency, Mandela declared that human rights and democracy would be the cornerstone of South Africa’s foreign policy, and I was proud to represent that policy abroad. 

However, lately there seems to have been a significant shift away from this policy commitment: now we hear you and your Dirco colleagues stressing “neutrality” and “non-alignment”. You have been stating this as the basis for South Africa’s policy towards the Russia-Ukraine conflict, even with Russia being the clear aggressor in this conflict, having launched a full-on, unprovoked military attack on its independent, sovereign neighbour Ukraine.  

Archbishop Desmond Tutu used to say: If you choose “neutrality” between an oppressor and an oppressed, you are siding with the oppressor. South Africa’s policy on the Ukraine situation shows the truth of Tutu’s observation. Soon after the start of Russia’s “special military operation” in Ukraine and after Dirco hastily rolled back its initial more or less “neutral” public statement on the issue, which dared to use the term “Russian invasion”,  President Cyril Ramaphosa phoned Russian President Vladimir Putin “to get his perspective on the Ukrainian situation”. 

Neither Ramaphosa nor any of his ministers (including you, Minister Pandor) were similarly keen to get the perspective of Ukrainian President Volodymyr Zelensky, ignoring repeated appeals by Ukraine’s ambassador to South Africa to do just that. The eventual call to Zelensky, as explained by Ramaphosa himself, was much more about explaining South Africa’s stance than getting Zelensky’s perspective. This clearly shows that not even a semblance of “neutrality” was observed; instead, every effort was made to avoid any condemnation or criticism of Russia for its unprovoked attack on Ukraine. 

And now our defence minister, Thandi Modise, is in Moscow to attend and address Russia’s 10th international security conference at the invitation of her Russian counterpart, General Sergei Shoigu. This is presumably with your blessing, as the Cabinet acts as a collective and we have not noted any criticism nor condemnation of Modise’s visit by you or any of your Cabinet colleagues. 

Apart from the ethical and moral issues posed by this visit, one simple question can be asked: if Zelensky had organised a similar “security conference” in Kyiv, would Modise have accepted to attend and address such an event? You and we all know the answer. Again, so much for your “neutrality”. 

Visit Daily Maverick’s home page for more news, analysis and investigations

Moreover, Modise’s visit is taking place hardly a week after you hosted US Secretary of State Antony Blinken in Pretoria. In welcoming Blinken, you hailed “our [the US and South Africa’s] strategic partnership, which is based on common values and aspirations to build peace and prosperity for our respective peoples”, citing your appreciation for the US’s assistance in a wide range of areas, including (yes!) “capacity building for our law enforcement, defence and security agencies”. It certainly does not take a great deal of sensitivity or intelligence to see how Modise’s visit to Moscow makes a mockery of such lofty statements, and is in fact a slap in the face of the US and Blinken. 

And, by the way, Minister, if this deference to Russia in the Ukraine situation is, as many presume, somehow an expression of gratitude for Russia’s erstwhile support for the ANC’s liberation struggle, you know as well as I do that is also a false flag: it was the Soviet Union, not Russia, that supported the anti-apartheid struggle, and Ukraine was part and parcel of the Soviet Union. So any gratitude due for this support should go to both Russia and Ukraine in equal measure. This is clearly not happening. 

The reality is that the underpinning of South Africa’s current foreign policy choices seems to be a conscious ideological choice: an anti-Western bias in favour of a revolutionary “new world order”. In all current conflicts involving democracies versus autocracies (with Ukraine vs Russia as a prime example), South Africa is increasingly seen to be taking the side of the latter. This is in direct conflict with the solemn pledge by Mandela that human rights and democracy would form the cornerstone of our foreign policy — a standpoint which I as a South African diplomat proudly supported and represented.  

To be frank: South Africa’s current foreign policy choices under your direction are a betrayal of Mandela’s initial commitment, for which we used to enjoy the admiration and respect of the entire free world. Our country’s reputation as a lodestar for democracy is now fast disappearing as we are increasingly seen to be cosying up to the world’s autocratic regimes. Modise’s current Moscow visit will be widely seen as another confirmation of this trend. 

Smooth, lofty words about “common values and aspirations to build peace and prosperity”, spoken during meetings with representatives of democratic countries sound hollow and do not change this sad reality. Moreover, apart from losing our moral standing on the world stage, this policy choice is putting at risk the very foreign investment, trade, cooperation and foreign assistance for which you thanked Blinken and on which South Africa’s economic development depends.  

Choices have consequences. Our current international policy choices are bringing both shame and damage to our country. 

Yours sincerely, 

Roel H Goris DM

Roel H Goris is a former South African ambassador to Thailand. 


Comments - Please in order to comment.

  • Sam Shu says:

    Good article and morally correct but misses a key aspect. Russian funding of the bankrupt ANC.

  • Lorinda Winter says:

    Oh well said. The sad reality is that our esteemed President will most probably not even take note of this letter but will carry on cosying up to Putin. The ANC government seems hell-bent to put us on to the path of economic destruction and being, once more, one of the most despised countries in the world.

  • Dennis Bailey says:

    Yep, proudly nothing SAfrican anymore. Tx Cyril. You have been a great help.

  • Graham Ferreira says:

    Imagine if the wasted opportunity in the early 1990’s when the world couldn’t wait to invest in South Africa, when the South African passport got you into virtually any country without a visa, hadn’t been wasted by the policy of cadre deployment down to the lowest levels of government. We would not be having to get handouts from morally bankrupt countries like Russia. It is understandable that we are grateful to Russia for their assistance during the apartheid struggle. But does that mean that we must turn a blind eye to their most deplorable and morally indefensible actions? Isn’t that like turning a blind eye to your favourite uncle molesting your little cousin?

  • A S says:

    When will people realize that the idyllic martyr narrative that is told over and over about our first democratic president is nothing but empty propaganda to gain control of SA?

    There is a great Russian fable “The scorpion and the frog” that explains our government of scorpions quite well.
    We are just frogs who hope, over and over that perhaps this time, the government scorpions won’t sting us.
    You sir, are asking scorpions to honor the promise of another scorpion.

  • Bennie Morani says:

    This Mandela stuff is actually nonsense. The sad truth is that Mandela embraced tyrants, such as the mass murdering Suharto of Indonesia.

  • Beyond Fedup says:

    Brilliant article and so succinctly put. It just shows the hypocrisy, deception and treasonous that this abominable ANC that has become. So far removed from decent human values and morals that we know identify and close ranks with the most hideous and murderous regimes and thugs like the exceptionally vile and thoroughly evil Putin. What’s more, we even try and defend it by spewing mealy-mouthed platitudes about being neutral when we are anything but. SA is so ill-served and in fact positively denigrated by these revolting lying treacherous scumbags!!!

  • Malose Nyatlo says:

    The ANC has lost its soul.
    There is nothing worse than that.
    With Ramaphosa at the helm.

  • Alan Paterson says:

    The moral turpitude of the ANC is (yet again) highlighted in this excellent open letter. As South Africans we are now constantly tarred by the brush foisted upon us by the rabble that masquerades as a government. A government that has no shame. Much as we loved Mandela the statesman it was simply a faux “liberation movement” without teeth, riding in on the coattails of international opprobrium and, with hindsight, destined to fail from as far back as his first cabinet. “Our” stand on Ukraine is morally indefensible but 2024 seems a long way away in ridding us of this scourge.

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted


This article is free to read.

Sign up for free or sign in to continue reading.

Unlike our competitors, we don’t force you to pay to read the news but we do need your email address to make your experience better.

Nearly there! Create a password to finish signing up with us:

Please enter your password or get a sign in link if you’ve forgotten

Open Sesame! Thanks for signing up.

A South African Hero: You

There’s a 99.8% chance that this isn’t for you. Only 0.2% of our readers have responded to this call for action.

Those 0.2% of our readers are our hidden heroes, who are fuelling our work and impacting the lives of every South African in doing so. They’re the people who contribute to keep Daily Maverick free for all, including you.

The equation is quite simple: the more members we have, the more reporting and investigations we can do, and the greater the impact on the country.

Be part of that 0.2%. Be a Maverick. Be a Maverick Insider.

Support Daily Maverick→
Payment options