First Thing, Daily Maverick's flagship newsletter

Join the 230 000 South Africans who read First Thing newsletter.

‘Where is the intelligence?’: Top cops grilled in P...

South Africa


‘Where is the intelligence?’: Top cops grilled in Parliament

(Photo: Leila Dougan)

The Crime Intelligence division of the South African Police Service came under the spotlight in Parliament on Wednesday. The questions directed at cop bosses boiled down to this — what is happening with Crime Intelligence and where exactly are the officers meant to be preemptively cracking down on threats

Parliament’s portfolio committee on police was on Wednesday ready to hear from the country’s top cops about a turnaround strategy for their forensic laboratories which have become bogged down in backlogs.

However, the SA Police Service (SAPS) only submitted its report on this the day before — it was meant to do so seven days in advance — and that important aspect of the briefing could not proceed.

Instead, the committee focused on interrogating the quarterly crime statistics covering the period from the start of January to the end of March 2022. These stats were released last week.

During question-and-answer sessions about issues relating to the statistics and underlying factors that could be driving crime, queries about the country’s critical Crime Intelligence unit surfaced.

Serious issues affecting the SAPS and the country were also raised.

These included an escalation in racial tensions, social unrest and protests. Also, there seemed to be no progress in patching up the beleaguered Central Firearm Register. And there did not seem to be any clarity about the role of Crime Intelligence.

Beyond the roller coaster ride — whither South Africa?

Gunshots at funerals

“Do we still have (police) intelligence? If we do have intelligence in our regions… I think they must be disbanded because they are not doing anything,” said the EFF’s Henry Andries Shembeni. 

Referring to guns being fired at funerals, Shembeni said when there were “bereavements” in certain areas, gunshots were heard “like crackers… from morning to sunset”.

Shembeni said no intelligence-driven operations were held so that those behind these shootings could be arrested.

National Police Commissioner Fannie Masemola assured Shembeni that Crime Intelligence was operational. 

In the Western Cape, he said, a pilot project was being run, with Crime Intelligence officers deployed to certain “contact crime” police stations.

“It’s something that is new… It’s not decentralisation. They’ll still report within their line functions. But we want them to be responsible for a station,” Masemola said.

He said the pilot project could be extended nationally to stations based in areas with high levels of crime. Masemola also said SAPS was dealing with firearms being discharged at funerals.

He said SAPS had “observed… it’s a new tendency”.

Masemola recalled a case stemming from North West where a father had complained that “police overshadowed the funeral of his son”. This, Masemola said, happened because officers had intelligence on what was going to transpire there.

In KwaZulu-Natal, 30 people from Gauteng were arrested for firing their weapons at a funeral.

“Those that come with firearms, we deal with them,” Masemola said.

If police were not aware of incidents beforehand, they dealt with these retroactively and ensured individuals were held to account.


Portfolio committee chairperson Tina Joemat-Pettersson pointed out that Crime Intelligence had more than eight vacancies.

“We’ve consistently asked [about this],” she said, “but we’ve not seen any movement on this… I’m again concerned about Crime Intelligence. We’re going to make a lot of noise about Crime Intelligence.”

The unit was mired in controversy when its national head, Peter Jacobs, was suspended in late 2020 over allegations relating to personal protective equipment procurement irregularities.

In March 2021, Jacobs — who claimed there was evidence that cops, including Crime Intelligence colleagues, had abused the secret service account — was told he could return to work, but as head of the police Inspectorate.

Lieutenant-General Yolisa Mokgabudi was subsequently appointed acting Crime Intelligence head, only to resign in 2021.

In May, the police portfolio committee again brought up Crime Intelligence issues in Parliament.

“The committee expressed significant concern about the ongoing instability in the Crime Intelligence Division which remains without a Divisional Commissioner,” minutes of that meeting said.

Vacant posts and concerns over investigations

Masemola on Wednesday said that submissions relating to panels had been made about the filling of the Crime Intelligence posts. He said Police Minister Bheki Cele, who was not present at Wednesday’s meeting, had to peruse the submissions. 

It was expected that this process — and the filling of vacancies — would be completed within the month.

Joemat-Pettersson was critical about other aspects of Crime Intelligence, pointing out that SAPS was not briefing the police portfolio committee on important issues, including transnational crime and the status of investigations into Eskom — News24 previously reported that sabotage was suspected at the troubled power utility.

Joemat-Pettersson said the previous national police commissioner, Khehla Sitole, had received no Crime Intelligence reports ahead of the attempted insurrection of July 2021 that devastated parts of KwaZulu-Natal and Gauteng.

The background 

President Cyril Ramaphosa previously said that those behind the unrest had wanted to “cripple the economy” and “severely weaken or even dislodge the democratic state”.

An expert panel set up to investigate the riots released a report that found: “Government’s initial handling of the July 2021 events was inept, police operational planning was poor, there was poor coordination between the state security and intelligence services, and police are not always embedded in the communities they serve.”

During his State of the Nation Address in February, Ramaphosa vowed to make major changes in SA’s security structures. He said critical vacancies, including in Crime Intelligence, would be filled.

That same month, it was announced that Sitole would be stepping down as national police commissioner “in the best interests of the country”.

During Wednesday’s police portfolio committee meeting, no mention was made of the elephant in the room — former spy boss Arthur Fraser’s lodging of a criminal complaint against Ramaphosa last week in relation to a 2020 burglary at the president’s Limpopo farm. DM




Comments - share your knowledge and experience

Please note you must be a Maverick Insider to comment. Sign up here or sign in if you are already an Insider.

Everybody has an opinion but not everyone has the knowledge and the experience to contribute meaningfully to a discussion. That’s what we want from our members. Help us learn with your expertise and insights on articles that we publish. We encourage different, respectful viewpoints to further our understanding of the world. View our comments policy here.

All Comments 1

  • To put it bluntly, crime intelligence has been compromised!!!Parallel SSA,Parallel everywhere.Who is the good guys, who is the RET sleepers, aligned to Zuma.The rot he created with Jiba , Mrwebi , Shaun the sheep,Ace Magashule,Arthur Fraser,Mduli , etc. it runs deep.Strategic positions filled by people with agendas,let’s not forget grabber Sitole!!! To get the good guys running things again is going to take time ,and no amount of indignation by Joe mat Paterson and others will make it happen quicker.Masomela and Co is gonna have there work cut out.Hope that Zuma and his lackey Malema don’t embark on destroying more infrastructure hospitals ,Harbour etc.The country is in a sorry state, and it’s going a helluvaceffort to safe this country and its citizens.Parliament is just like Razmataz Fix f*k*l Mbulela all talk and no action.Time to roll up those sleeves and start working,and forget about the fat cat salaries. Without discipline and good training and screening the police will not improve in a million years.Presently SAPS hold more meetings than they catch criminals.Rule of law must start applying. At present everybody is more interested eating from the trough(which incidentally is tax payers money, not that they care)

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted