Dailymaverick logo

Opinionistas

This article is an Opinion, which presents the writer’s personal point of view. The views expressed are those of the author/authors and do not necessarily represent the views of Daily Maverick.

This article is more than a year old

Can intellect, dedication and integrity trump ignorance, indifference and deceit – even in SA politics?

As in all democracies, South Africa has both good and bad politicians. For the past 20 years or so, the majority of our electorate have consistently chosen bad politicians to govern our nation.

There are a number of reasons for their ill-advised choices which possibly include traditionalism, racism, African nationalism, personal incentives or just the plain naivety of believing false electoral promises. Whatever the reason, it has had a devastating impact on the socioeconomic circumstances of our country and has led to the near destruction of the country’s once valuable infrastructure designed to service the basic needs of our people.

It is high time therefore for the electorate to urgently reflect on and re-examine what kind of politicians the country needs to reverse its decline and fulfil its undoubted potential to deliver a better life for all its citizens.

A political career should be practised with decorum, transparency, prudence and propriety and an adequate degree of humility and compassion.

A political career should be seen as a vocation. A calling to public service inspired by a personal desire to project and apply ideologies, values, principles and policies that optimally benefit the nation’s socioeconomic well-being. 

In South Africa that requires a commitment to our constitutional imperatives of freedom of the individual, the rule of law and the provision of a state of human dignity to all citizens – that is to say, acceptable and progressive levels of security, employment, housing, education, healthcare and basic services such as energy supply, water and sanitation and public transport. It also demands the acceptance, and implementation, of accountability and consequences for incompetence, misdemeanour and failures including criminal or civil charges, dismissal or other forms of appropriate sanction.

A political career should be practised with decorum, transparency, prudence and propriety and an adequate degree of humility and compassion. It can be practised independently or within an established political party. The above describes the nature of a good politician.

The overwhelming majority belong to political establishments that lack the intellect, dedication and integrity to competently extract our nation from its rapid decline to a failed state.

In stark contrast, a political career should not be seen as an opportunity to boost one’s ego and satisfy a craving for publicity. Nor should it be used as a means to promote one’s societal status or to enhance personal financial ambitions. At the very worst, it should not provide the moment for corrupt looting of state coffers and taxpayers’ money for party or personal financial gain. It also should not be an avenue to promote and facilitate dubious international and domestic business dealings with governments, organisations, companies or individuals who promise financial or other forms of personal or party rewards in return for preferential treatment. More often than not these kinds of shady dealings and transactions are shrouded in secrecy, lack the necessary transparency and are hidden from public scrutiny

A bad politician persists in trying to deflect the nation’s attention away from government failures and uses deceit, half truths and lies to fraudulently boast to a naive electorate about their so-called progress and achievements.

In South Africa we have politicians, at all levels of government, who fall into both good and bad categories, but tragically the overwhelming majority belong to political establishments that lack the intellect, dedication and integrity to competently extract our nation from its rapid decline to a failed state, who reject accountability and responsibility for failure and who prefer to practise their political careers with a high degree of arrogance, indifference, deceit and in a state of wilful ignorance. They disdain the rule of law and no matter how grievous their felony, crime or incompetence, believe that they are immune from the consequences that under the same circumstances would befall ordinary citizens.

Read more in Daily Maverick: Shaky coalitions do not inspire confidence but may be the only route forward

As South Africans we are privileged to live in a constitutional democracy which confers upon us the right to vote for our political representatives regularly. However, that right to vote also demands of us to use it responsibly, diligently and in the best interest of all citizens, not just a selected elite, their accomplices and their appointed cadres who only have their own self-serving interests at heart

At the risk of stating the obvious, the electorate should throw out the failed current crop of bad politicians and replace them with good ones. Sadly, the obvious does not seem that obvious to a large proportion of our voting public and consequently our future political and socioeconomic landscape remains precariously uncertain. DM

Comments (6)

brucedanckwerts Dec 21, 2023, 06:20 AM

This article provokes me to reply not to the article, but to Daily Maverick. I have said it before and I will continue to say it until you change. In a planet threatened not ONLY by Climate Change but by other constraints there is NO place for a print edition of a newspaper, such as DM168. Close it down and use the resources saved to make DM available in a cell-phone friendly format in all the major languages of South Africa. This article is important, but it is preaching to the converted - it needs to be read, in their own language, by the electorate . . . . and the sooner the better. With elections next year, we don't have much time to educate the electorate on the hollow promises of the corrupt politicians in our midst. Bruce Danckwerts, CHOMA, Zambia

Marie Venn Venn Dec 21, 2023, 06:45 AM

Brilliant idea, Bruce. Agreed. DM urgently needs to reach far and wide on a daily basis.

Skinyela Dec 21, 2023, 09:57 PM

"within an established political party." Problem is, with our political parties, that they are largely viewed as either black or white. Even though they don't organise themselves along racial lines, well at least on paper, because their constitutions explicitly say that membership is open to members of all population groups. My second point is that we expected our democracy to mature very quickly, which is unreasonable and has never happened anywhere.

roelf.pretorius Dec 24, 2023, 03:48 PM

Oh I think that that stereotype is fast disappearing. For instance, just look at the support the ActionSA is getting from all communities of all sides, and they don't make the mistake of applying it. And my information from most young activists is that race is not an important issue in SA any more, in spite of the big political parties trying to make it an issue. The new political parties are all focusing on solutions, and all of them emphasize that solutions can't be based on race. So I would think that we just have to be patient; SA is maturing in this regard.

frances hardie Dec 22, 2023, 08:46 PM

?

roelf.pretorius Dec 24, 2023, 03:44 PM

Maybe you don't know it, but DM is available on the internet, in fact it is by means of that that I am able to reply to you. I don't know how it is in Zambia, but unfortunately many South Africans don't have the ability to access the internet, so to reach them a printed version is also needed.

James Harrison Dec 21, 2023, 09:28 AM

The question in the headline has not been answered. Can good trump evil in South African politics? It is a question that bothers me a lot, and I was hoping for some new insights. What is needed is well defined in the article, but what are the prospects for the electorate making appropriate decisions? My children, who face an uncertain future in this country, would particularly like to know.

Sydney Kaye Dec 21, 2023, 04:22 PM

I think it wasnt answered because the answer is too obvious and there is no point in stating the obvious. NO. But is that a surprise when the same disease is present in most so called democracies. You can't tell refugees from the ANC in the Eastern Cape, now living in the Western Cape, that voting for the ANC they just ran from makes no sense, anymore than you can tell a Maga that voting for Trump ,who cuts taxes for the very rich and wants to reduce the little national medical they have, is against their own interests, or tell the residents in Northern England that voting for Brexit wasn't too smart when the car companies you work for will close down because they can't sell to Euirope Morover I don't even see the point in the should-be article which is as you say preaching to the converted.

roelf.pretorius Dec 24, 2023, 03:50 PM

This article is probably the most relevant and actual that I have seen for a long time in ANY newspaper. David has put the finger on the main illness in SA politics. Read my further comments on how to change it further down in the column.

David Gant Dec 22, 2023, 05:46 PM

The solution in my opinion is contained in the highlighted article "Shaky coalitions..." which predates the current article.

roelf.pretorius Dec 24, 2023, 04:03 PM

Maybe the answer to the question involved is not seen obviously because of what was NOT said in the article. Whether good or evil triumph in SA to an extent depends on us South Africans ourselves. But it is not as simple as voting a government or politicians in or out - our electoral system does not allow us to vote the corrupt out because they are present in all political parties and we can only vote for political parties, not for who represent those political parties in parliament. So those of us with the resources have to step up and set in motion an avalanche of ConCourt challenges to the current (also the new) electoral system to force the government and ruling party to change it to allow constituencies. But it also can't be single-seat constituencies because in such system the political parties still decide who represent them. No, it must be multi-seat constituencies so voters who still want to support the same political party can vote the bad individuals out and replace them with good ones IN THE SAME POLITICAL PARTY. Those in the seats are not going to allow that without a fight, therefore those with adequate resources (I would think that quit a few million bucks will probably be needed) have to step up outside of the electoral process, to change the system for good. The answer is thus that it depends on us, both as voters and in the courts. I am willing to involve myself in this but I don't have the resources. My email address is roelf.pretorius@absamail.co.za.

Kanu Sukha Dec 21, 2023, 05:39 PM

Pertinent in many respects ... but also a display of a number of sanctimonius presumptions and prejudices of the author also, with little regard for what happened prior to 'democracy' and how that impacted on the situation .. when he enjoyed 'heaven on earth' here, just like the cadres are doing now. I still have an English/Afrikaans dictionary from my days in school in the early sixties, which translates gentleman as witman !

roelf.pretorius Dec 24, 2023, 04:09 PM

From you post it rather looks as if YOU are the one with misplace presumptions and prejudices. David has hit the nail on the head regarding the root cause of our problems in SA, as well as where the solution lies. By the way, if you dislike the outdated dictionary so much, why are you keeping it? Is it not maybe because one of the prejudices you are still harbouring is that of race? If not, why do you still have it? I was also in school in the 1960's, and I have shed all those prejudices! So why can't you?

District Six Dec 21, 2023, 09:21 PM

We have so much analysis of South Africa. We are drowning in analysis. Please stop. We get the issues. What we lack are clear, implemenable, measurable, solutions-oriented, political goals. EFF, stop telling us that Ramaphosa is our problem. DA, stop telling us what we already know, and maybe stop hopping about like a yappy chihuahua. You sound ridiculous. We are also drowning in political parties. All of them giving us more - and utterly useless - analysis. Also, stop suggesting that poor, black people are "dumb" because they don't exercise their vote the way you want them to. It's the height of arrogance to assume poor people are ignorant. Having a democratic, secret vote means something, as in no one can tell another person whom to vote for. Just stop that.

Kanu Sukha Dec 22, 2023, 11:21 AM

Your second last sentence confirms my observation of the author's own blind-spots or prejudices or presumptions.

David Gant Dec 22, 2023, 06:07 PM

No such suggestions or assumptions are made in the article. We need a different type of politician to govern our country. Whatever colour, creed or class. When reality stares you in th face, it is better to recognise it and confront it. Wilful ignorance is just another form of deceit and denial.

f v Dec 22, 2023, 01:06 PM

Yes To Bruce Danckwerts.

roelf.pretorius Dec 24, 2023, 03:33 PM

David, you are hitting the nail on the head - and I don't know if you know it, but President Ramaphosa not long ago echoed these same sentiments in a public speech. But unfortunately we can't vote the bad individuals that exist in each political party out and the good in, because we can't vote for or against the individuals; we are confined to voting for the political parties. That effectively takes these decisions out of the hands of the voters, and relies on the same grassroots members of which, as you say, the overwhelming majority "lack the intellect, dedication and integrity" to do this. So the only way to achieve this is to establish the variable multi-seat constituency system that the Electoral Task Team of dr. Van Zyl Slabbert envisaged 20 years ago, so the VOTERS can decide who represent EVEN the political parties in the legislative bodies. And the bad politicians are using the political parties' power to resist this; even going so far as to violate the Constitution and their oaths of office to not have to be subject to the voters decision about their suitability for office, for obvious reasons. Thus millions of rands of money is needed to force the government to change their ways through the ConCourt. I would like to do this but I don't have that kind of money. Would you be willing to support such an avalanche of ConCourt challenges? If you do, or anyone else, please email me at roelf.pretorius@absamail.co.za.