So, according to Greg Mills and Ray Hartley (“Israel, Hamas and South Africa – the Biggest Failure of All”, Daily Maverick, 19 October 2023), if a country has domestic challenges like crime that it still needs to address, it should remain silent on geopolitical developments. If we are to follow that logic, no country (big or small) in the world would ever qualify to play any role in regional or global affairs.
In the ongoing conflict between Israel and Palestine there are many aspects that are shocking, heart-breaking, indefensible and in violation of the Geneva Conventions and international humanitarian law.
But Mills and Hartley choose to be startled most by the fact that “South Africa stands ready to share its experience in mediation and conflict resolution as it has done on the continent and around the world”.
South Africa’s moral authority on conflict resolution and willingness to share its experience and make itself available to mediate between the two sides is so distasteful to the authors that they prioritise it as more concerning than the mass slaughter of innocent civilians.
History will judge harshly those who ignore the gravity of what is happening. For how long should we stand by and watch the bombing of schools, hospitals, apartment buildings and essential infrastructure, denying an entire civilian population adequate water, electricity and fuel that is needed most urgently to run hospital generators and ambulances?
What is happening to civilians – a third of them estimated to be children – are egregious war crimes and arguably some of the worst violations of international humanitarian law and the Geneva Conventions since World War 2. But what is more concerning to Mills and Hartley than those war crimes is South Africa’s willingness to assist in bringing the conflict to an end in any way possible. What type of humanity is that?
It is our collective responsibility as the international community to hold Israel, as the occupying power, accountable for its violations of the Geneva Conventions and international humanitarian law.
What should be startling to the authors is that the international community appears to have given one country a blank cheque to do whatever it wants in Gaza. A blank cheque to commit war crimes under the mantra that “Israel has a right to defend itself”.
The right to self-defence needs to be interrogated. Israel is an occupying power and the people of Palestine are occupied people. Under the laws of occupation, Israel has a duty to provide security for the people whose land they have temporarily occupied. Instead, they have not only breached this obligation but committed more crimes through the increased occupation of more Palestinian land, and the killing of Palestinians either by the Israeli security forces or through the state-sponsored violence of settler groups.
Instead of calling out these violations of international law and holding the government of Israel accountable, leaders of countries who profess to promote and respect international law support the Israeli government’s illegal declaration of war against the people of Palestine. An occupying power and army cannot declare war on people whose land they have occupied through an armed conflict which has not yet ended.
Read more in Daily Maverick: Middle East Crisis News Hub
The current siege of Gaza is in breach of international humanitarian law and the attacks on civilians are war crimes. Statements by some of the leaders of the current government of Israel since the latest conflagration began could be interpreted as intent to commit the crime of genocide.
Under the Geneva Conventions and the substantive crimes under the jurisdiction of the International Criminal Court, intention is enough to indict the leaders calling for the destruction, in whole or in part, of a recognised group or community. Those who support these actions materially, including through the supply of weapons, can be charged with aiding and abetting genocide and war crimes.
Dehumanisation
What happened to Israeli civilians in Kfar Aza and at the music festival are also unspeakable war crimes that need to be investigated.
But the devastating reality is that every day now is a Kfar Aza in Gaza, with civilians and children being buried under rubble in unrelenting bombardment of civilian homes, hospitals and schools with total disregard for the right to life of civilians in armed conflict.
The Israeli government has gone to great lengths to dehumanise Palestinians in the eyes of the world, with Defence Minister Yoav Gallant declaring that “Palestinians are human animals”.
Read more in Daily Maverick: South Africa’s offer to mediate in Israel must not be ignored — remember Northern Ireland
This is the type of dehumanisation of a people that we have fought so hard against since World War 2. Once a group is dehumanised and depicted as less than human beings, it becomes easier and more acceptable in the eyes of the perpetrators and their supporters to commit gross violations of their rights and erase them altogether. This is something that all of us need to fight against.
It is our collective responsibility as the international community to hold Israel, as the occupying power, accountable for its violations of the Geneva Conventions and international humanitarian law. Article 14 of the conventions categorically states:
“Starvation of civilians as a method of combat is prohibited. It is therefore prohibited to attack, destroy, remove or render useless for that purpose objects indispensable to the survival of the civilian population such as foodstuffs, agricultural areas for the production of foodstuffs, crops, livestock, drinking water installations and supplies and irrigation works.”
According to the Fourth Geneva Convention,
“Civilians in areas of armed conflict and occupied territories are protected by the 159 articles of the Fourth Geneva Convention. Civilians are to be protected from murder, torture, or brutality, and from discrimination on the basis of race, nationality, religion or political opinion.”
The only way forward for a sustainable solution to the cycle of violence in the Middle East is to end the occupation of Palestinian land and to negotiate the establishment of a viable Palestinian state.
Until such a state is realised, it will be difficult, if not impossible, to have sustainable peace and security for Israel, or for the wider region. DM
Alvin Botes is Deputy Minister of International Relations and Cooperation.
Become an Insider
What part of the Geneva Convention does Hamas adhere to ?
Since you ask, it’s the part where a people under foreign military occupation have the right under international law to resist that occupation using force.
Hahahahahaha
You forgot to mention the thousands of rockets sent over to Israel which save for the Iron Dome would have Israel looking as bad if not worse than Gaza. Israel has not occupied Gaza since 2005 – that is when Hamas occupied Gaza and turned the population into human shields. Israel is the only country that gets attacked for being attacked.
“You forgot to mention” — that is hilarious. There are so many things that are essential for Zionists never to mention. For instance, that under international law Israel is a hostile occupying power in the Palestinian Territories, or that its apartheid policies follow inevitably from its constitution as a Jewish state for Jews only, or that Netanyahu supported Hamas for years as a policy to prevent the formation of a Palestinian state, or that its leaders described Palestinians as “human animals” and “children of darkness”.
Israel is utterly insane. To defend it, you have to swallow the hasbara whole and ask no questions whatsoever.
Not the whole of Israel is ‘insane’ .. but the parts (people – small as it may be) cannot (will not) be heard . They have been ‘silenced’ in different ways !
“a Jewish state for Jews only”??? This is a factually incorrect statement that is deliberately misguiding people. The Jewish state is certainly not for Jews only. Israel is a democracy, no matter your rhetoric.
Is an “Islamic State” for Muslims only?
Israel is the world’s only Jewish state. Contextually the 46 countries in the world with majority Muslim populations, 23 declare Islam to be the state religion in their constitutions. The 23 countries where Islam is declared the state religion are: Afghanistan, Algeria, Bahrain, Bangladesh, Brunei, Egypt, Iran, Iraq, Jordan, Kuwait, Libya, Malaysia, Maldives, Mauritania, Morocco, Oman, Pakistan, Qatar, Saudi Arabia, Somalia, Tunisia, the United Arab Emirates, and Yemen. Currently 3 states proclaim themselves to be “Islamic Republics” — the Islamic Republics of Iran, Pakistan, and Mauritania.
In such gentrified company, only a singular state is continuously singled out for “apartheid”, which belittles the South African experience beyond description.
This is an excellent, sane piece that does not go nearly as far as it could in establishing the root cause of the catastrophe in Palestine: that Israel is constituted as a Jewish State for Jews only, which directly entails racist policies of apartheid. Absent oppression there would be no resistance. We should call not only for a ceasefire but for an end to settler violence in the Occupied Territories and a process of restitution for Palestinians to return to the lands that were stolen from them by a settler-colonialist state.
It and its sponsor … the US were the two ‘states’ that unapologetically supported the apartheid regime here, right till the end. And as long as the US has veto rights in the UN … Israel will continue ignoring all ‘negotiated settlement’ plans as it has done for almost 60 years . Its goal is the ‘occupation’ and Gaza and the West Bank . It will like our apartheid regime, find and appoint puppet ‘leaders’ of homelands as fig-leaves for their depravity … and call it ‘democracy’.
The people of Gaza voted Hamas into power. They did this with the full understanding that the stated aim of Hamas was the total annihilation of Israel and the slaughter of every single Jew. They voted for war. What’s more they have spent the aid money which nations have given to Gaza, to build rockets and tunnels. They don’t give a damn for the residents of Gaza. They are useful cannon fodder in their eyes.
Is that not more or less what ‘they’ said of the ANC during the apartheid days ? Communists and terrorists ?
You can’t ignore it, neither can you do anything about it.
For the deputy minister of supporting genocidists to talk of South Africa’s moral authority makes one wonder whether he needs to be kept in an asylum.
His ignorance of the Geneva Convention is matched only by his history of South Africa’s recent history.
Even Donald Trump could not achieve the falsehood and narcissism of “South Africa’s moral authority on conflict resolution and willingness to share its experience and make itself available to mediate between the two sides…” Had the government proposed sending VF+ members, as the successor to the NP, it might make sense. But the reality is that the ANC used 1994 to capture the state, abandon the majority of its people to poverty, hopelessness and despair and to go on a looting spree, matched only by Hamas and Putin. How on earth can a regime that sides with genocidists (al Bashir, Hamas, Hazbullah, Putin, Xi, and such), refuses to vote at UN alongside the democracies and “stands with” murderers and rapists put itself forward as a mediator?
Rather than make a fool of himself and embarrass the country, Mr Botes should resolve the conflicts between Zama zamas and the people, between gangs, between CIT attackers and banks, between public transport and hit squads and between ordinary citizens and the crooks the ANC’s destruction of the Rule of Law has spawned.
Colin I wouldn’t lose sleep worrying about the credibility of any of our government ministers, or the ruling party – either in this international relations context, or in general. Their last of their credibility, unfortunately for all of us, left the building with Madiba.