Defend Truth

Opinionista

Our unemployment and poverty trap is apartheid’s legacy that is perpetuated by our government

mm

Thamsanqa D Malinga is director at Mkabayi Management Consultants; a writer, columnist, and political commentator, as well as author of Blame Me on Apartheid and A Dream Betrayed.

Since the advent of democracy, our government, the former liberation movement, has crippled black South Africans. It started off by making frivolous promises they knew very well they couldn’t fulfil. From free houses, free electricity, free education to free this and that.

South Africa’s poverty problem is as institutionalised as it was during the legal apartheid years. In fact, South Africa is still an apartheid state. It is a state where black people continue to be perpetual serfs, and their white counterparts remain the privileged few with bread and salt easily available to them.

This is not a thumb-sucked argument, no way. It was confirmed by ANC veteran and former president Thabo Mbeki. In 1998, when he was deputy president, he said South Africa is “a country of two nations” – one white and wealthy, the other black and poor.

Emotions quickly reach a breaking point when it comes to the topic of the shortage of resources in black communities, and more often than not we have seen that it results in conflicts of black self-hate, or what some in the media have termed Afrophobia.

As such I feel duty-bound to contribute to the debate by addressing the emotions and the conflicts resulting from the jobs discourse and posit that problems of unemployment and poverty are a result of the legacy of apartheid which is perpetuated by the current government.

Held in bondage

A lack of jobs and the resultant poverty is an institutionalised problem that is entrenched in and by the state’s systems which hold black South Africans in bondage as serfs. Writing his prologue to my book, Blame Me on Apartheid, legal eagle Vuyani Ngalwana SC noted:

“Sadly, since 1994 that most evil and enduring apartheid achievement seems to be perpetrated by successive governments of what used to be a liberation movement, sacrificing the cerebral development of the black child at the altar of political expediency. It is a fact that ruling over an ignorant population is less complicated than having to account to a population that thinks and therefore can reason and therefore can make informed choices, especially when the ruling elite has nothing to offer except promises of ‘a better life for all’ which often translates to food parcels and poverty-trap social grants.”

The so-called democratic government has mentally incapacitated the unemployed, and largely black South Africans, by not empowering them.

Ngalwana was spot-on – since the advent of democracy, our government, the former liberation movement, has crippled black South Africans. It started off by making frivolous promises they knew very well they couldn’t fulfil. From free houses, free electricity, free education to free this and that.

Even with jobs, the ANC government had promised them and said they would be available here and there. These include many other sorts of lies that served as building blocks for institutionalising poverty.

To receive these free packages, people had to do one thing only: look up to the government for the manna and you shall be saved. Perhaps it is for this reason that former ANC president Jacob Zuma arrogantly declared that “the ANC will rule until Jesus comes”.

At the time he probably knew the damage his political party had done in trapping black South Africans in enduring poverty. Unfortunately, many in our communities fail to grasp this institutionalisation. Instead, when the issue of jobs is discussed some resort to saying “South Africans are lazy” – oh please! That is a lame excuse.

Read more in Daily Maverick: South Africa comes first — this country is ours and not an ANC (Pty) Ltd

The so-called democratic government has mentally incapacitated the unemployed, and largely black South Africans, by not empowering them. Instead, it has been promising them what it could not deliver for almost three decades – nor will it deliver in the four decades to come.

This is no different from the apartheid government that rendered blacks debilitated by denying them quality education. On the matter of education, I wrote in Blame Me on Apartheid that “it is not common sense that there will be investment in a black child’s education. It is not common sense that the infrastructure of a public school in Zola, Soweto, or KwaMagxaki in Port Elizabeth, is going to be the same as that of a public Hoërskool in Akasia, Pretoria simply for one reason: the education of a black child is an apartheid social paradigm.”

A true apartheid paradigm

In South Africa, where employment is offered, the requirements are made stringent for the black child through educational achievements, which are likely to be present or otherwise as a legacy of apartheid. This has been the case with the government sector as well.

The one largest provider of jobs in South Africa, a black majority-administered government, has been found wanting by encouraging young people to flood universities and yet making them mere interns only to discard them after internship programmes.

At least, on their part, they would have fulfilled the statistical requirements for reporting for budget votes and the presidential State of the Nation Address. We know. We have seen it.

Our bureaucrats get massive kudos for mentioning statistics – politically curated statistics. I guess it’s comforting to just mention what you did for the natives no matter how meaningless it is – a true apartheid paradigm.

For this reason, as I note in Blame Me on Apartheid, to this day we see young people reduced “to the legacy of Number 80, Albert Street, Johannesburg, the head office of Johannesburg’s Non-European Affairs Department (JNEAD).

“This was the nerve centre for controlling the lives of black people in Johannesburg for decades. This area was notorious for its function of carrying out the Department’s responsibility for influx control and employment. In a way, it served as a recruitment spot for all work seekers.

“So, the traffic intersections are now the modern-day Albert Street equivalent, degrading young black children from the townships and their parents because they are compelled to stand at intersections hoping that a car will stop by to pick them up and transport them to a place of employment. This further opens them up to exploitation by any potential employer seeking cheap labour.”

Read more in Daily Maverick: The South African government is just another unashamedly absent father

I therefore cannot be faulted when arguing that poverty in its current form in South Africa is institutionalised, just like how apartheid institutionalised it.

It is all in the promises and lies, the bureaucracy and systems of our democratic government, the corridors of the buildings our people visit daily – all of which have been an inheritance of that apartheid, a crime against humanity. DM

Gallery

Comments - Please in order to comment.

  • George Holmes says:

    Punt my book… punt my book… punt my book… offer any cohesive solution, what’s that?

  • Thelma Mort says:

    From the second paragraph Malinga establishes his outdated anti-white or white monopoly capital (which was debunked years ago) trope: “This is not a thumb-sucked argument, no way. It was confirmed by ANC veteran and former president Thabo Mbeki. In 1998, when he was deputy president, he said South Africa is “a country of two nations” – one white and wealthy, the other black and poor.” The fact he quotes Mbeki from 25 years ago, shows his political understanding is outdated. Anyone can see the ANC’s looting and corruption taking place has crippled the economy. There are effectively two nations now – those who milk the state and those who want to make a difference.
    Take the city of JHB whose infrastructure has been destroyed by the ANC. This could be a perfect site to create all the jobs (fixing roads, clearing pavements, sweeping up the forest city’s leaves which clog the untended gutters for starters) that Malinga points out are much needed.
    We need better analysis and quality of writing in the Daily maverick, please.

  • Thelma Mort says:

    The ANC is the poverty trap.

  • Nic Bosveld says:

    It is so easy to lie to the uneducated, isn’t it?

    The ANC does exactly that, to garner votes in mostly rural areas.

    Roll on 2024 – lets get rid of this criminal gang, which operates without a leader.

    • norman mokone says:

      Absolutely agree…the only dilemma of ousting this criminal gang is that the criminal gang rely and feed off the vote of the uneducated who happen to be the majority. To eliminate the ingnorance of the majority while this gang is still at the helm is a near impossible task, hence the need for a revolution!

  • Jon Quirk says:

    If the rest of Africa, or indeed any part of Africa, was an economic success story then there could be some level of credence to the old trope of “blame it all on apartheid”, but given that is clearly not the case, then excuses and reasons for “the African economic malaise”clearly needs to be found elsewhere, and Africa needs to look deep and long at itself and ask the probing question – why?

    Various reasons can and must be examined, not the least being the low, by any objective measurements of IQ, work ethics, societal cohesion, investment levels, all of which contribute, but most fundamentally, having done the necessary introspection, ask how can Africa change itself such that it can start to play a meaningful role in uplifting it’s peoples, their educations and change their economic fortunes.

    Their are no short cuts and exemplary leadership, as shown for example Lee Kwan Yew, in Singapore over 30 years that lifted this country out of their economic mire, is a fundamental building block in ensuring the social cohesion, common purpose and sustained objectives, in enabling this to happen.

  • Johan Buys says:

    Poverty is the fruit of the unemployment tree. In 1980 ago unemployment was 8%. We are simply not growing our economy – well, at least not growing it as fast as our population. Have a look at the key stats (gdp growth, population growth, unemployment, gdp per capita) of SA and China 1980, 1990, 2000, 2010 and 2020.

    In that time the country expanded electrification, health, education and housing to thirty million citizens – acts that of themselves should have boosted economic growth. The difference is fixed capital formation China vs SA. Investors are scared of SA because nobody believes we have an honest government or competent state machine.

  • Alan Salmon says:

    I agree with many of the points made in this article. It is true that apartheid denied black people quality education and opportunity, and that the ANC “has mentally incapacitated the unemployed, and largely black South Africans, by not empowering them.” However, it is not just quality education that is required. There are university graduates that are unemployed because this government will not reform labour laws and state financial institutions to allow businesses to be started up, and grow, to create jobs. The ANC continues to do nothing and wait for some sort of miracle in the workplace !!

  • Kanu Sukha says:

    At least the apartheid government did not lie openly about their intentions … which the ANC government (with the help of sleigh of hand!) has brazenly done since the end of the Madiba era ! His approach of ‘negotiations’ has been replaced by diktats . Sure signs of authoritarian/fascist inclinations. A tendency our constitution does not promote.

  • Fanie Rajesh Ngabiso says:

    One can only laugh.

    Please don’t judge me. Anyone sensible living in SA needs to enjoy pain at some level to survive watching intentionally blind people persist in providing this cruel joke of a ruling party with excuses to continue destroying what could be a wonderful country for all. Duh.

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted