Dailymaverick logo

Politics

ANALYSIS

No load shedding, running trains... Who knew South Africa could fix things

It has been obvious since June 2024 that the current national government coalition would endure if voters believed it was improving their lives. Now, there is some evidence that, in certain areas, life is improving for many (but probably not most) people. And, it is often in areas where the ANC has dramatically changed policies that were once foundational to the governing political party's core beliefs.
No load shedding, running trains... Who knew South Africa could fix things Illustrative image | Minister of Higher Education Buti Manamela. (Photo: Frennie Shivambu / Gallo Images) | Minister of Transportation Barbara Creecy. (Photo: Gallo Images / OJ Koloti) | ANC flag. (Photo: Gallo Images / Brenton Geach) | Transnet logo. (Photo: Leila Dougan) | Eskom power station. (Photo: Waldo Swiegers / Bloomberg via Getty Images)

So dire is the state of so many of our towns and cities, it is easy to forget just how much has changed in South Africa in the past two years or so.

Load shedding, which was strangling our economy, has disappeared - along with the fear of it.

Eskom has now rolled out what looks like a cogent plan to deal with load reduction.

Transnet appears to be making significant progress in improving its railway service for the mines on which so much of our economy still depends. On Wednesday, 29 October 2025, Kumba Iron Ore reported: “Total sales increased by 7% … reflecting improved rail performance.” Other mines have reported a similar picture.

On Sunday, Transport Minister Barbara Creecy confirmed that she was asking the private sector to play a much bigger role in our railway system. These plans even include requests for information about rapid rail links between our major cities.

Last week, Higher Education Minister Buti Manamela announced that the government was going to start a process to recognise private universities for the first time. These institutions would be able to confer qualifications that could be called “degrees”. 

This should mean that, over time, the pressure on state-owned institutions will finally start to ease, as the private higher education sector is likely to start growing even more strongly.

Five years ago, getting a driver’s licence card in Gauteng was a nightmare for almost everyone. Now the driving licence testing centre in Waterfall in Gauteng has a rating of 4.47 (out of a possible five) on Hellopeter.

Meanwhile, other processes of reform continue.

Read more: The GNU has failed the only test that matters: growing the economy and delivering jobs

The South African Revenue Service confirmed on Wednesday it had taken in more money than previously expected for the first six months of the fiscal year. 

Our police service, known by millions of people to have corrupt leaders, is currently going through a process that has the potential to lead to real reform.

And while the National Prosecuting Authority and our criminal justice system have been much maligned over the past few years, people such as Ace Magashule are fighting off charges, while an allegedly dangerous criminal, who has previously entertained a former police minister at breakfast, Vusimuzi “Cat” Matlala, is currently in jail.

To look at these and other examples is surely to see progress. Importantly, that is progress that should, potentially soon, lead people to see that their lives are improving.

Unfortunately, much of this “progress” is obscured. For millions of people, perhaps most of our people, they see no change at all.

They might appreciate having no load shedding, but can’t afford much electricity anyway.

Trains carrying coal and iron ore mean nothing to their lives if they finished school at 14 and a driver’s licence is something they only aspire to.

All of that said, the fundamental changes to our economy through the big reforms around electricity and transport should, over time, lead to an uptick in economic growth.

With more electricity and a more efficient transport system, more companies should invest in growth.

For the moment, that investment seems hard to see. While this is hugely contested, it actually appears companies are holding on to capital rather than investing. 

ANC’s only choice

There is another aspect of these changes that may prove to be critical for our future.

In the past, it has often appeared that some aspects of government policy were almost set in stone. This was because the ANC simply refused to make these changes. And, at the time, the ANC appeared to have a solid lock on power.

Now, that is no longer the case and, instead, the ANC is often the party implementing these changes. Key to all of this is the fact that the private sector is much more involved in services previously controlled only by the government.

The ANC, while formally saying it wanted a “mixed economy” in South Africa, generally seemed to prefer a bigger role for the government. As a result, efforts to reduce the role of the government, either through the privatisation of state-owned enterprises or other means, were often hugely controversial.

Until last year’s elections, some in the ANC appeared determined to actually increase the state’s role in our society. For example, the party campaigned on the introduction of National Health Insurance, which would severely curtail the role of the private sector in our healthcare system.

Eleven years ago, Dr Aaron Motsoaledi, then and now the minister of health, said proudly that he would never allow private institutions to train doctors. 

His rationale was not based on the obvious shortage of doctors, but that “only the children of rich families will be able to become doctors”. As was pointed out at the time, this was all about the people who would become doctors, with no thought given to the patients who could now be treated because more people would have been trained to be doctors.

It is the ANC that has allowed the private sector to generate and sell electricity, and to play a role in Eskom.

Creecy, who is now unveiling major changes in our railway system, is also from the ANC.

And Manamela, who is now opening space for private universities, comes not just from the ANC, but from the SACP. One wonders what one of his predecessors, Blade Nzimande, might think about all of this.

The reason the ANC is making these changes is obvious; it’s tried using the state, but through its own policy mistakes and the incompetence of many of its deployees it has come to realise there may be only one option left.

At the same time, ideology may have become an expensive luxury. So pressing are the needs of voters, the party has no other choice.

All of this is an important aspect of what will hopefully become a more competitive and accountable democracy.

Many people in the ANC have realised, finally, that if it wants to have any hope in elections, it has to show that it can implement policy that will improve people’s lives.

This new ideological ambiguity might well lead to better policy - and make it easier for parties with different histories to work with each other in the national coalition in the longer run. DM

Comments

Karl Sittlinger Oct 29, 2025, 10:02 PM

Hard to take this as serious analysis. The author praises the ANC while taxpayers continue bailing out Eskom with billions of rand, and the rail system remains a shadow of its former capacity after years of ongoing collapse, insane corruption, and high levels of violence, including whistleblower deaths, caused by ANC policies. Real recovery is nowhere near. Much of what little progress exists is likely only because the DA is forcing transparency the ANC would never have chosen.

Francois Smith Oct 30, 2025, 06:57 AM

I guess Groottes is implying that a journey of a thousand miles has started with a few steps. The irony of the message is that the ANC is subtly acknowledging that it cannot govern or manage this huge and complex economy. Let us hope that the 14 year old who aspires to have a driver's license punishes the ANC at his first election by voting AGAINST them. The fact that load sheddinng is declining, does not make a smelter in Newcastle to open again.

Karl Sittlinger Oct 30, 2025, 08:27 AM

Well said, Francois. I’d just add that we’re still far from anything resembling normal, so praise right now feels misplaced. Giving the ANC credit too soon risks killing momentum for real progress — they could easily rest on unearned laurels, as they have so often before. And if the ANC keeps getting away with lying to that 14-year-old without consequence, can we really expect them to vote differently one day?

Willem.ivo Oct 30, 2025, 04:06 PM

The fact that government under the ANC has been able to make improvements -evidence of a productive mindset, at least among some- is a break in the decades-long trend of neglect and corruption. As such it is noteworthy. Yes, a few steps forward, hopefully on an upward trajectory. Let's hope Grootes' analysis is correct and democracy is still working. Who knows, despite everything, some sense is prevailing. I'm taking it with both hands.

Marco Savio Oct 30, 2025, 07:25 AM

Agree with this comment. We have heard this all too often ahead of elections only to see it all slide further backwards. Real advancement will come with real changes in our institutions that lead to significant jail sentences for those that are guilty. With the ‘cancer’ removed national healing can take place and the state of the nation will be seen to improve, not just the echo of false narratives once again misleading the people as to the true state of affairs.

Justin Vickers Oct 30, 2025, 05:36 AM

Stephen, are you delusional? Stockholm syndrome? We don’t need to praise the ANC for 1/10 performances. Having electricity is not an achievement. Nor is anything else you’ve listed here. Get a grip.

Graeme Oct 30, 2025, 02:31 PM

Spot on!

Zonker Zoggs Oct 30, 2025, 05:57 AM

I’m not convinced. The inquiry into the SAPS leadership is just another striking illustration of how high the rot goes. I don’t believe Eskom has sorted its problems out either. If the chaotic, corrupt state of affairs described by Andre DR has somehow magically been resolved, I would be astonished. I would guess they are simply sweating the grids hardware instead of doing necessary maintenance. I would love to be wrong though

Mike Meyer Oct 30, 2025, 08:32 AM

Agreed. Changing "loadshedding"to "Load Reduction" doesn't change anything except to make it impossible to plan around random, unannounced power outages.

Samantha Yeowart Oct 30, 2025, 05:57 AM

Thank you Stephen! Glimmers of hope make a cheerful start to the day.

Michele Rivarola Oct 30, 2025, 07:40 AM

Is the author of this unbelievably biased piece employed by the majority party? It is quite baffling how statements are based on propaganda and not on facts: take ESKOM fir example the EAF has not improved at all in fact it is lower in 2025, the only reason there is no load shedding is because many private individuals have invested their own money in self generation it has nothing to do with the GNU. DM check your facts pls before reporting propaganda just like some other channels do

Mike Schroeder Oct 30, 2025, 09:59 AM

Personally, I'm not surprised by this "opinion piece". Grootes has always been a flag-bearer for the ANC, and will continue to do so

Cobble Dickery Oct 30, 2025, 07:56 AM

It's the ANC that got us into this state in the first place. The author is wrong. You don't praise people for fixing something they broke. You fire them firstly and then get more competent people to fix things. The author is doing what the ANC does. Rewards criminals, incompetents etc and promotes them. Besides, Eskom is still NOT fixed. It's prices and wages are too high, and the number of employees is also too high. Only when these are 'fixed' can it be said Eskom is fixed.

Patterson Alan John Oct 30, 2025, 08:12 AM

One swallow, does not make a summer! And what if someone shoots that swallow? There will be no summer! South Africa needs to attract a lot more swallows Stephen, before there is a glimmer of hope for a summer.

Glyn Morgan Oct 30, 2025, 08:17 AM

Has the size of our bloated government, all those dozens of incompetent ministers and deputies, been reduced? Nah! No change there.

Hans Rehder Oct 30, 2025, 08:24 AM

This piece has all the makings of superficiality, bias, and even paid propaganda. But let's read the message clearly. The changes mentioned are real. Ascibing success to one source is probably incorrect, but still partially right. The gist of this article is that we are actually experiencing a moment when the important can take centre-stage, rather than the urgent. We are experiencing less crisis management, and have greater opportunity for agency. As such, well done, Stephen!

Oct 30, 2025, 08:25 AM

Misguided viewpoints this time Stephen. The ANC wrecking ball is far from inertia. This is amply borne out by what is being unearthed in the Madlanga Commission and the ad hoc committee on Mkhwenazi's allegations. South Africa is being saved by the private sector, and not by any insane stretch of the imagination by parliament's 32 ministers and 43 deputy ministers. Idle fat cats drawing huge salaries and perks while poverty and joblessness reigns supreme.

Oct 30, 2025, 08:54 AM

SG is clearly desperate to make a case using whatever scraps he can find to prop up this rotten ANC in the media. He needs to spend more time in the real reality of daily South African life in the townships and informal settlements and less harking back to his student activism days. His attempts to make a case for the NHI on the money show last night were in similar vein - even while one hears daily about the Tembisa hospital violations which Nicholas Crisp seems to ignore.

snake.greenwood Oct 30, 2025, 09:14 AM

It's sad the ANC require the almost total collapse of the electrical, railway & transport grids, along with losing voters + being shown up by the folk they've been forced to share government positions with, to begin to change their tune (and ideology?). Also sad that, as pointed out, corporations are hogging cash because I'm sure that they don't trust that, if the ANC can spin this as inspired by them & get a full mandate next election, they won't go right back to their old tricks.

Confucious Says Oct 30, 2025, 09:35 AM

How can DM print this rubbish??? What trains?? 2 per week is not success. It can still take weeks to get a train from Jhb- Dbn depending on cable theft! TRUCKS STILL MOVE THE MAJORITY! What electricity? We are 1 unplanned maintenance surprise from loadshedding? Every city outside the W Cape is in decay! Unemployment is increasing? Where does the author get his stories from???

Graeme Oct 30, 2025, 02:34 PM

The author is clearly delusional.

megapode Oct 30, 2025, 09:53 AM

The Minister for electricity has been a star performer, and has an understated style which is a welcome difference from many of our leaders. DHA was not even mentioned. There's a department which is getting its act together. I recently renewed my passport and got the new ID card (and I'm an immigrant) in a very hassle free process. There's still much to do, but things CAN be turned around.

Karl Sittlinger Oct 30, 2025, 01:11 PM

But the again the DHA is a DA led ministry.

megapode Oct 31, 2025, 09:22 AM

It is. And on Minister Schreiber's watch it has improved. My point is that there is light at the end of the tunnel, that good leaders can still turn things round.

Just another Comment Oct 30, 2025, 11:51 AM

Please Steven. Stop praising the mediocrity that is the ANC. It has done nothing good of its own accord. It always has to be pushed backs to the wall before they even start to consider change. BBEEE proves it. They're merely a liberation movement that did a good job of ending apartheid and should never have been allowed to be a political party. Those are different sides of the coin. But it suited their pockets to be a bad government. And they'll never be a good government. Ever!

David Walker Oct 30, 2025, 12:21 PM

Um, perhaps you haven't noticed Stephen, but Cape Town has been doing maintenance, upgrading and 'fixing things' very effectively for decades now?

Brett Redelinghuys Oct 30, 2025, 12:48 PM

Steven, pls, pls read Rizo comic further down in paper for more honest, shorter version of "what's really happening in our country".

D'Esprit Dan Oct 30, 2025, 01:27 PM

Some obvious positives, but not nearly far enough down the line to get excited. Only once we've got rid of Mantashe, who is strangling the mining industry, Manamela and his corrupt-crony-SETAS, ditched almost every ANC Mayor and town council and put competence and honesty above party fealty, will we be able to truly grow and thrive: none of this is possible with the ANC in, or anywhere near, power.

D Dog Oct 30, 2025, 04:36 PM

We shouldn't comment on Stephen's garbage. DM is just encouraged to post more of it because it drives "engagement".

Mike Lawrie Oct 30, 2025, 08:19 PM

SG needs to revist the town where he studied and then write a revised article based on what he sees with his own eyes, bumps into with his car, and reports on what the citizens and business folk have to say. The ANC have wrecked what used to be a lovely functioning city.

Stewart Currie Oct 31, 2025, 08:58 AM

Can I be the only one who comments that SG is right. Since the GNU has come into existence things have improved. That's not to say the ANC has totally changed. There are still many old ANC comrades that believe in doing the same old things and hope for a different outcome. To turn a big ship like SA around will take a lot of change but I see the first chinks of like and the curtain is lifted.

Bonzo Gibbon Oct 31, 2025, 11:20 AM

In the London Times this morning there was a story about polls in SA showing that most people would prefer to be ruled by a military dictatorship. I'm sure the fat old generals would do an even worse job! The real problem is that in election after election sheople continue to vote for a corrupt and incompetent party. Turkeys voting for Christmas.

Bonzo Gibbon Oct 31, 2025, 11:20 AM

In the London Times this morning there was a story about polls in SA showing that most people would prefer to be ruled by a military dictatorship. I'm sure the fat old generals would do an even worse job! The real problem is that in election after election sheople continue to vote for a corrupt and incompetent party. Turkeys voting for Christmas.