Dailymaverick logo

Business Maverick

MINERAL RESOURCES

Mantashe pulls back on BEE proposals for mining exploration

Exploration is an extremely risky business, and BEE ownership rules on the activity would be a major obstacle to the deployment of capital on this front.
Mantashe pulls back on BEE proposals for mining exploration Minister of Mineral and Petroleum Resources Gwede Mantashe. (Photo: Brenton Geach)

Mineral and Petroleum Resources Minister Gwede Mantashe has changed clauses in the draft Mineral Resources Development Bill (MRDP) that would have imposed BEE requirements on previously exempt exploration companies and projects in the mining space.

The BEE requirements on the high-risk exploration arm of the mining sector provoked backlash from the mining industry, and Mantashe made comments last month that suggested he was not aware that the draft Bill contained such provisions — but if it did, he would correct them.

“Now, and in the future, there’s no provision for BEE on exploration,” Mantashe said in late May during a media briefing at the conclusion of the AGM for the Minerals Council SA.

Read more: Industry sees red after Mantashe says no BEE for mining exploration, contradicting draft bill

Earlier this week, Mantashe issued an erratum notice to correct the draft and remove the BEE requirements for exploration and prospecting.

“The granting of such rights will further the objects referred to in section 2(d) and comply with the broad-based socio-economic empowerment prescribed elements,” was in the original wording regarding prospecting, but that has now been removed.

South Africa’s share of global exploration spend has collapsed from around 5% two decades ago to less than 1% in the face of a range of challenges, including massive applications backlogs that the Department of Mineral and Petroleum Resources hopes to address soon with a new mining cadastre.

Read more: Explainer - a mining cadastre and public transparency

Exploration is an extremely risky business, and BEE ownership rules on the activity would be a major obstacle to the deployment of capital on this front.

“The Minerals Council South Africa notes the gazetting of ... corrections to the Draft Mineral Resources Development Bill,” said the council, the main mining industry body, in a terse statement.

“The Minerals Council continues to review the Bill amending the Mineral and Petroleum Resources Development Act and we will submit our perspectives within the scheduled timeline of 13 August 2025.”

Overall, the industry is not happy with the Bill, which once again moves the goalposts at a time when investors are crying for certainty in a sector that remains crucial for South Africa’s low-growth and high-unemployment economy.

One bone of contention is embedding the Mining Charter into the legal framework, which could again unleash the “once empowered, always empowered” debate, which the industry has already won in court.

“Once empowered, always empowered” means that once a company meets a threshold for black ownership, it does not have to keep topping up endlessly if black shareholders sell their stakes.

“The Bill in its current form does not encourage or sustain the growth and investment that the mining industry needs to realise its full potential to create employment, stimulate the economy and fulfil its social mandate,” said the Minerals Council. DM

Comments (7)

Michele Rivarola Jun 12, 2025, 07:13 AM

Time for GW to either retire willfully or to be pushed out. Ancient politicians should not be permitted to make decisions about the future, they have no future only the past.

Dragon Slayer Jun 12, 2025, 08:04 AM

The reality is that BEE, with the best of intentions, and unless based on competency equivalence, is either pure patronage for the politically connected or a business expense carrying passengers at high cost in positions where they can do as little damage as possible. All of which provide little or no added value but add costs that are passed on to struggling consumers and/or making new businesses hopelessly uncompetitive and vulnerable to dumping.

Rae Earl Jun 12, 2025, 09:02 AM

Ah ha! Is the ANC finally waking up to the realisation that BBBEE is bad for business? Is it also belatedly waking up to the fact that what's bad for business is also a killer when it comes to growth and job creation. For a has-been like Gwede Mantashe to realise this years past his sell-by date shows exactly what that legislation has achieved for SA. Nothing but riches for fat cats amid growing unemployment, poverty, and misery.

Tim Spring Jun 12, 2025, 09:43 AM

"The BEE requirements on the high-risk exploration arm of the mining sector provoked backlash from the mining industry, and Mantashe made comments last month that suggested he was not aware that the draft Bill contained such provisions — but if it did, he would correct them." The fact that the minister in charge of minerals and mining did not know what was in this bill is astonishing, in a bad way.

D'Esprit Dan Jun 12, 2025, 10:28 AM

100%. His supporters say that being an ex-coalminer, he's 'an industry man'. I'm a frequent flyer, but you wouldn't make me a pilot or put me in charge of an airline based on that. Building a mine is a hugely complex and risky business, from start to finish, with investors shunning unfriendly jurisdictions, something Mantashe is completely unable to grasp, despite the mountains of evidence produced, year in and year out. What a tragedy that Cyril needs him as his backbone in the ANC!

D'Esprit Dan Jun 12, 2025, 10:22 AM

Gwede Mantashe will go down in history as the single most destructive minister in post-apartheid South Africa: he has completely wrecked the mining industry, as well as the power sector, when he had it in his clutches; the two bedrocks of South Africa's economy. Pity we can't issue an erratum and have him removed from office. Permanently.

Rae Earl Jun 12, 2025, 11:16 AM

Ramaphosa and Mantashe (while looking after each other's backs - as always), will descend into SA history as mutual destroyers of wealth and fast growth.

Rod MacLeod Jun 12, 2025, 06:34 PM

This move by Mantashe is not so magnanimous. Much better to keep the cadres out of the risky side of mining - and then shoe-horn them in for a zero cost risk free equity carry when the prospecting has yielded a viable asset under the guise of BBBEE.

D'Esprit Dan Jun 15, 2025, 08:00 AM

100%. When countries like DR-Congo attract more exploration and development than we do, you'd imagine a Minister who actually gives a damn about his portfolio would take a serious look at what he's doing wrong. Zambia did, reformed it's investment code and tax laws, and hey presto! the dollars flowed - billions of them. Mantashe is so far out of his depth it's embarrassing.