Dailymaverick logo

South Africa

PEOPLE OF THE YEAR RUNNERS-UP

Lawyers in ICJ case make SA feel immensely proud – and so does our President

In a year that saw South Africa’s legal eagles soar to new heights at the International Court of Justice, arguing against Israel's Gaza actions with the finesse of a courtroom matador, President Cyril Ramaphosa played the reluctant ringmaster, juggling political chaos and economic woes while trying to keep the circus from burning down.
Lawyers in ICJ case make SA feel immensely proud – and so does our President President Cyril Ramaphosa. (Photo: Gallo Images / Brenton Geach)

Legal team at ICJ

This year, the South African team at the International Court of Justice (ICJ) showcased exceptional courage and unparalleled legal expertise on the global stage. Tackling one of the most contentious cases in modern history, they argued that Israel’s military actions in Gaza after 7 October 2023 violated the Genocide Convention. It was a case that demanded not only meticulous legal ingenuity, but also immense moral conviction, and the team delivered on both fronts.

Their arguments culminated in a groundbreaking court ruling that mandated Israel to take measures to protect Gaza’s population. This landmark decision underscored the enduring importance of international law while reaffirming South Africa’s unwavering commitment to justice and human rights. The team’s performance was nothing short of transformative, catapulting South Africa to the forefront of global legal discourse and showcasing the brilliance of our legal minds.

Behind this remarkable achievement was a team of dedicated professionals who worked tirelessly to ensure their case was meticulously presented. Their collaboration, determination and shared vision for justice created a synergy that resonated far beyond the courtroom. Each team member brought unique expertise to the table, collectively forging a path that left a lasting impression on international law.

They may not have been crowned Person of the Year, but their 28% share of the public vote reflects the immense respect and admiration for their work. Their contributions this year stand as a beacon of hope and a testament to the power of collective effort. The South African ICJ team have not only made history, but have also inspired a nation by proving that our voices can shape global narratives. Their legacy will endure as one of the defining achievements of 2024.

President Cyril Ramaphosa

With 12% of the votes, President Cyril Ramaphosa’s inclusion as a runner-up for Person of the Year reflects the weighty and complex role he has played during a challenging period in South Africa’s history. Leading a nation beset by political uncertainty, economic turmoil and social unrest, Ramaphosa faced a year of extraordinary trials that tested the limits of leadership.

Throughout 2024, he navigated the ANC's electoral setbacks, addressed corruption scandals and worked to stabilise an economy teetering on the edge. Adding to these challenges were the negotiations for creating a government of national unity (GNU), during which he played a central role in leading the ANC, as well as navigating subsequent disputes between its parties. This coalition, vital for economic growth, the fight against corruption, the professionalisation of the civil service and job creation, simply would not exist without Ramaphosa at the helm.

Under his leadership, initiatives aimed at tackling unemployment and fostering foreign investment began to take shape, signalling a path forward for South Africa’s recovery. His ability to stand firm amid criticism and divisive public opinion underscores a resilience that has been pivotal in maintaining stability during uncertain times.

Ramaphosa’s leadership this year exemplifies the often overlooked qualities of persistence and resolve. Although public opinion remains divided, his impact on the nation is undeniable. He has held the fort during one of South Africa’s most challenging years, embodying the essence of leadership by showing up, taking responsibility and striving for progress even when the odds are stacked against him. DM

Comments (10)

sksimplified@gmail.com Dec 23, 2024, 05:36 AM

Good analysis.

gabrielagoldberg1 Dec 24, 2024, 08:53 AM

I agree wholeheartedly and it's a relief to read something with the focus on what is positive and there is a lot to be thankful for living in SouthAfrica.

David Kramer Dec 23, 2024, 09:33 AM

2020/01/27: I wrote to Minister Pandor and cited a recent ruling by the ICJ on the plight of the Rohingya of Burma(Myanmar). The ruling stated that Rohingya are at risk of genocide. I asked SA to support the legal action. I have repeated the letter every year since but I have never received a reply.

Kevan O'Donnell Dec 25, 2024, 11:44 AM

Your silliness for expecting a reply.

dexmoodley@gmail.com Dec 23, 2024, 09:37 AM

On ICJ agree totally , but on the Prez. the bar has to be really low for him to even be on the list. History will judge if what is being put in place is sustainable and shows fruit.

abuchand2@gmail.com Dec 25, 2024, 08:29 PM

What ever! South Africa made History. The Legacy of Mr Nelson Mandela Lives!

Clifford Smith Dec 23, 2024, 10:04 AM

Even though R97m of taxpayers money was exhausted on this theatrical display Shérie's "courageous experts" failed to secure even a simple ruling that Israel was even guilty of war crimes. They failed to table sufficient evidence to galvanize the court into declaring a crime was being committed.

dexmoodley@gmail.com Dec 23, 2024, 04:23 PM

This hearing was only to decide if there was prima facie evidence for the court to take on the case. Court agreed with SA 's arguments and rejected Israel's argument that was no case for court to proceed with the case and should be rejected by court. I think one charge the even Israel judge agreed

Muishond X Dec 23, 2024, 10:06 AM

What a load of codswollop. Cyril is the Corrupt Executive Officer of this cesspit called cANCer. He is weak and cannot root out corruption as he is corrupt. As for the lawyers, they should have rather focused on Sudan, Syria and Ukraine, where the genocides happen/ed. What is wrong with this DM

Derek Taylor Dec 23, 2024, 10:39 AM

This indicates a warped value system at GM as well as the country. I am reconsidering my contribution, sadly. Spending millions on a court case, sponsored by Iran but ignoring the Ukraine, Sudan etc smell of prejudice. Tragically, to my own loss, because there are also good investigations in DM

Fernando Moreira Dec 23, 2024, 11:42 AM

I'm South African , it doesnt make me feel proud ! Courageous legal team ????? Pretty quiet on Rusia , Sudan, China UNRWA etc etc etc

greg.rascher@sasol.com Dec 23, 2024, 02:11 PM

The governments misuse of public money to fight the case at the ICJ is nothing to be proud of.

Kevan O'Donnell Dec 25, 2024, 11:42 AM

I wonder how much of the leather couch money changed hands for this gook to get published?

Mr. Fair Dec 29, 2024, 02:10 PM

We'e neighbours. I run my business badly. You call me out. Another neighbour injures, disappears, or kills over 100 thousand. Mostly women and children. I, your bad boss neighbour, has evidence to bring the worse neighbour to justice. Do you dismiss my case because I treat my employees badly?