Business Maverick

BUSINESS REFLECTION

After the Bell: Like Johnny Cash, Pravin Gordhan walked the line

After the Bell: Like Johnny Cash, Pravin Gordhan walked the line
Public Enterprises Minister Pravin Gordhan. (Photo: Waldo Swiegers / Bloomberg via Getty Images)

For sheer endurance, dexterity and intellectual heft, Gordhan has no comparator in SA’s democratic period.

It’s hard to think of a sadder and more triumphant singer than Johnny Cash. He was a country singer long before the category established itself but gradually became an icon across genres, ending his career singing a set of searing pop songs against a sparse background in his famously deep and croaky voice. 

For sheer visceral emotional exposure, it’s hard to get more personal than his cover of the Nine Inch Nails song, Hurt

Yet he wasn’t always a figure of empathy and was often something of a contradiction, even at one point singing a lighthearted novelty song, A Boy Named Sue (he hated the song). 

He was both a voice for the ordinary man and, famously, a highlight of his career was singing to the inmates of Folsom Prison. He was also personally haunted, leading to a very pop star-ish drug addiction. 

Like so many famous people, he was a contradiction, but unlike many famous people, he cleaved towards an ordinary life. 

There’s a scene in the movie about his life that starred Joaquin Phoenix as Cash and Reese Witherspoon as June Carter, in which she gets infuriated at the band’s disorganisation before a concert. As she turned on her heel and marched out, she spat out at the band (if I remember correctly), “You know your problem is … you don’t walk the line.”

And that pronouncement became the chorus line of Cash’s most famous and bestselling song, I Walk the Line. The song is about responsibility and duty and shouldering the burden, however heavy it might be. 

In fact, the movie did not portray the real origin of the song. Cash wrote it after meeting and falling in love with June Carter, but he was also married and seemingly trying to convince himself to stay on the path. 

“Because you’re mine, I walk the line.” It’s both a love song and a curse.

If there is any politician who reminds me of Johnny Cash – his career, his contradictions, his triumphant sadness – it’s Pravin Gordhan, who intends to hang up his gloves after an extraordinary career as an activist and a politician.

It must be said – and it’s unfortunate – that he leaves politics at a personal and political low point. 

His last function as public enterprises minister has arguably been a disaster. Eskom is producing less electricity every year; SAA remains insolvent; Transnet has just fired the CEO, whose appointment he oversaw; the SA Post Office is bankrupt and so is the Land Bank. It just goes on and on. 

It’s a wall-to-wall catastrophe.

How much of this is Gordhan’s fault is debatable. He had a reputation as a meddler and as someone who didn’t consider the CEOs of public enterprises any different from one of his deputies in the ministry. They were, as far as he was concerned, under the jurisdiction of the political system and therefore subject to its requirements.

Consequently, the CEOs of public enterprises, under his watch, were constrained from doing anything as outrageous as right-sizing the staff complement, heaven forbid, which could anger government union supporters. 

In his book Truth to Power, former Eskom CEO André de Ruyter said Gordhan supported what he called an “activist board”. This was essentially “a peculiar governance construct” called an “engaged board” based on an old Harvard Business Review article.  

What that meant in practice was that instructions were given by board members directly to people several levels below the executives – without informing line managers. 

The board required reams of information and wanted to get involved in outage management and issues of plant management without really knowing much about either. 

Gordhan was, in his later years as a politician, understandably torn by his long-standing belief in communism and the requirements of the modern era. 

It’s never been clear whether or not he was in favour of public sector involvement in state-owned enterprises. And that’s despite President Cyril Ramaphosa repeatedly stating that this was the new policy of the government.  

He certainly wasn’t a supporter when the SA Communist Party, Gordhan included, decided to throw in its lot with Jacob Zuma and forcibly remove the more modernist and irritatingly successful government of Thabo Mbeki, of which he was then part. 

He came, as we all know, to rue that moment when he was fired by Zuma, not once but twice, essentially for not doing the bidding of the Guptas, we later learnt. 

Gordhan became famous for instructing others to “join the dots” but, you know, the weird thing was that he never did so himself, or at least not in a way that would have caused a major breach. He remained a dutiful, diligent, disciplined member of the party, taking on new functions with vigour and staying in the fight. 

And what a fight it was. 

SA has many people to thank for the fact that the State Capture effort largely failed, but one of its major impediments was Gordhan, whose decision not to walk away, to play his cards carefully and deliberately, and to stick it out for the long game, was an important factor in limiting the damage. 

Among the important skills Gordhan commanded (and I remember this from way back during the UDF days when I was a student activist and Gordhan was a UDF organiser in Durban) were subtlety and organisation. He’s always been a plotter by nature and sometimes by function, notably during the infamous Operation Vula.

And those skills were most evident during his inestimable spell as SA Revenue Service (SARS) commissioner. His dedication and functional literacy came to prominence at SARS. 

SA suddenly became one of the first countries in the world to permit e-filing, for example. 

SARS was transparently and sensibly run for decades, eventually becoming a crucial impediment that had to be overturned by the Radical Economic Transformation faction – and it was. 

But under Gordhan’s leadership, year after year, SARS produced more tax for the government than budgeted. Sometimes so much so, that it was virtually an embarrassment to a government for whom social spending was such an important policy principle. 

His years as finance minister were – I don’t know how best to put it – peculiar. He seemed both at home and at odds with the job. 

In his interactions with business, he would often castigate company owners by pointedly asking them what they had done to promote democracy, address poverty, correct society’s evils and so on. It never seemed to occur to him that business success is rooted in being excellent at what it does rather than being good at what he wanted it to do, which was to be a kind of ANC government proxy and support system. 

There was a palpable cultural difference. But there was also no lack of respect, so business, rather meekly, in my opinion, rolled with his tax increases, his low-key hostility and his ideological chastisement of wealth.

Yet for sheer endurance, dexterity and intellectual heft, he has no comparator in SA’s democratic period. 

He might have been torn at points, but when all is said and done, he walked the line. Respect. DM

Gallery

Comments - Please in order to comment.

  • Geoff Coles says:

    Gordhan should have retired more or less a decade back, with an unsullied reputation.

  • Jay Vyas says:

    I have lost all respect or admiration for this COMMIE CADRE many many years ago!

    A TRUE PATRIOT WILL ALWAYS PUT THE COUNTRY & THE PEOPLE BEFORE HIS PARTY ( In his case both his Outdated Ideology SACP and Corrupted ANC)
    In spite of his differences or fall-outs with Zuma & his RET Acolytes, this same Gordhan, has ALWAYS VOTED with the ANC in all those (Zuma 9 lives votes of no confidence) – Including on the NKANDLA FIASCO!

    Furthermore the same Gordhan, also VOTED WITH the ANC to protect the ‘Serial Rama Phala Phala Sofa’ FIASCO! More shocking is that the same Gordhan, knowing very well the Financial Processes of FICA, Exchange Controls, SARS and the Reserve Bank chose to NOT SPEAK OUT or OBJECT to this LAUNDERING FIASCO!

    Will he ever have the decency or conscience like that of the Late Bishop Tutu or the Late Ahmed Kathrada to PUBLICALLY CALL OUT AND CHASTISE THIS ROUGE CORRUPT ANC?
    Do not hold your breath, as he and the Cronies in the ANC are still desperate to fob-off DUDU MYENI’S DESTROYED SAA, in some clandestine deal – so that the ENTITLED ANC Comrades & Cadres could still fly around at the Taxpayer’s Cost!

    HE HAS AN OPPORTUNITY TO STILL OPEN HIS MOUTH AND CONSCIENCE – THE ANC HAS DESTROYED A WHOLE GENERATION’S FUTURE – HE KNOWS IT!

    I Rest My Case!

    • Gerrie Pretorius says:

      You said it all. Thanks! This commi was probably one of the worst, if not THE worst parliamentarian SA ever had.

    • James McMichael says:

      Yup, a loyal party hack to the core who was never able to understand that “other people’s money” is finite and never abandoned his dismal support from calamitous Communism. A real “apparatachic” only and what a pity that he didn’t decide to remain a professional pharmacist.

  • Middle aged Mike says:

    The only good commie is . . . . one who has no more power than a member of their SRC. It infuriates me that someone with a starring role in the absolute basket case we’ve become economically can be regarded as any sort of hero. Not stealing like your colleagues while sticking dogmatically to a patently failed ideology are not the qualifying criteria a hero badge. His biggest achievement post democracy was in making SARS efficient and that had it’s own downside as it provided more gravy for his fellow party members to slurp.

  • Charles Butcher says:

    He was also “all by myself”so as to not atract attention

  • Njandini Njandini says:

    Gordhan is as bad as the rest. Yes, there is a few good things he did at SARS, but as a Minister of Public Enterprises, he performed extremely bad. The worst ever. He destroyed the SOEs. Its a pity, he is exiting active politics as a wounded and certified failure. To maintain his allegedly clean political sheet, he could have exited soon after the Zuma administration. Unfortunately, greed and obstinacy consigned him from blunder to blunder as though led by blind fate.

  • Alan Schley says:

    What a magnificent comparison. I learnt a lot about the man I did not know. I being quite ignorant of politics.

  • Anil Maharaj says:

    This guy probably thinks that he served the country well. He did not! Instead, he was part of the problem

  • Colin Braude says:

    “ANC connected so protected” became a thing while Gordhan was SARS Commissioner.
    His role in SOE’s as Minister of Bailouts has been an 100% disaster, with his clash with then Eskom CEO de Ruyter over crime and “privatisation” of SAA highlights.

  • Trenton Carr says:

    “state capture largely failed”?

    Really!? Have you looked around.
    They make a GDP disappear and everyone is in the dwang and trying to run away.

    He screwed the pooch and we suffer.

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted

X

This article is free to read.

Sign up for free or sign in to continue reading.

Unlike our competitors, we don’t force you to pay to read the news but we do need your email address to make your experience better.


Nearly there! Create a password to finish signing up with us:

Please enter your password or get a sign in link if you’ve forgotten

Open Sesame! Thanks for signing up.

We would like our readers to start paying for Daily Maverick...

…but we are not going to force you to. Over 10 million users come to us each month for the news. We have not put it behind a paywall because the truth should not be a luxury.

Instead we ask our readers who can afford to contribute, even a small amount each month, to do so.

If you appreciate it and want to see us keep going then please consider contributing whatever you can.

Support Daily Maverick→
Payment options

Daily Maverick Elections Toolbox

Feeling powerless in politics?

Equip yourself with the tools you need for an informed decision this election. Get the Elections Toolbox with shareable party manifesto guide.