Defend Truth

RIGHT OF REPLY

Dirco and the Ukraine war — The Department of Whataboutism

Dirco and the Ukraine war — The Department of Whataboutism
International Relations and Cooperation spokesperson Clayson Monyela. (Photo: Flickr / GCIS)

Using ‘whataboutism’ is a sloppy way to argue. It would be more useful if the department’s Clayson Monyela addressed the substance of the argument.

Department of international relations spokesperson Clayson Monyela’s rebuttal “Why is the Brenthurst Foundation obsessed with Ukraine — what about Palestine, Yemen, Libya, Western Sahara?” of our article last week — “Naledi Pandor: The Minister of Utter Incomprehensibility and Obstruction” — is a sad attempt to defend the indefensible.

One might equally ask: “Why is Clayson Monyela obsessed with the Brenthurst Foundation — what about the ANC Youth League’s partisan support for Russia’s illegitimate referendums in occupied parts of Ukraine?” 

The images of these ANC stalwarts waving Russian flags and grinning gormlessly in the violently occupied territories are surely the greatest diplomatic embarrassment South Africa has suffered in recent times, but Monyela and his boss, Naledi Pandor, have nothing to say about it.

Two can play whataboutism. Why is Ethiopia — a country where the Brenthurst Foundation has worked and where our chairman, President Olusegun Obasanjo, is the AU’s Special Envoy — not on Monyela’s laundry list of important causes?

A visit to our website would reveal that the Brenthurst Foundation has been “obsessed” with Ethiopia — visiting the frontlines in Tigray and assisting with efforts at mediation.

What about Somaliland? It’s one of Africa’s foremost democracies with five successive democratic elections and changes of government not recognised by South Africa, which appears “obsessed” with recognising Western Sahara. A solution to that dispute is being managed by multilateral organisations such as the UN, and Monyela and the minister always defer to multilateralism. Except they don’t in this case, choosing instead to shout from the sidelines.

We have worked in Ethiopia, Somaliland, Zanzibar, Zambia and Lesotho, among other places, over the past year, but this work is not interesting to Monyela because it doesn’t chime nicely with his tired old “Western imperialism” narrative.

We have also written a book on policy in South Africa, “Better Choices”, and one on the spectacular failure of Western aid to move the dial, “Expensive Poverty”, while being “obsessed” with Ukraine.

Using whataboutism is a sloppy way to argue. Much more useful is to address the substance of the argument. Monyela’s argument is weak in three respects:

First, while he is correct in deducing that the minister’s statement to the 77th UN General Assembly sparked our article, it was not the bit he assumed: that the world should “treat all conflicts across the globe with equal indignation, no matter what the colour or creed of the people affected”. We have no beef with that: if only the South African government actually matched such rhetoric with actions. 

Rather, it was this special phrase uttered by Minister Pandor that got our attention: Having listened to leader after leader speak on Ukraine, Pandor’s suggestion that the biggest global challenges were not the rule of international law or the risk of nuclear war caused by the Russian invasion on 24 February, but rather “poverty, inequality, joblessness and…” take a deep breath, “… a feeling of being entirely ignored and excluded”.

It’s the last bit that sticks. It’s the tone of a whiny, ignored teenager and its effect is to dilute South Africa’s influence by underscoring that it — and Dirco for that matter — is not being heard. Why is this? The reason no one listens to Dirco, Clayson, is that it is the absent father of southern Africa. 

When elections are rigged and stolen, when economies collapse under the weight of looting, when governments become narco-states, they remain schtum and with their hands in their pockets (and hopefully not, like much of the rest of government, in someone else’s pockets).

Coupled with South Africa’s recently quite hopeless economic performance — the lights are again out as we pen this reply — the consequence is that South Africa’s international voice is diminished. 

People have tuned out and are turned off.

Perhaps there is one hand clapping in Russia and another in North Korea. But for the democratic world which values sovereignty, raging on about inequality and Cuba’s role in the liberation struggle is not a convincing argument that we are in the trenches fighting for accountable democracy.

Second, Monyela then makes the leap in writing that, “Like some in the Western world [presumably with a childish conspiratorial nudge and wink], Mills and Hartley have prioritised the conflict in Ukraine above every other conflict and gross violation of human rights occurring elsewhere on the globe. One wonders whether the lives that are being lost in conflicts such as in Palestine or Yemen don’t matter.”

Again, that is not what we said at all. The reason we have recently prioritised the conflict in Ukraine in our research is because that conflict threatens world peace and food security in Africa, and reflects back on us in terms of our support (or not, in the SA government’s case) on critical issues of international law, democracy, human rights and territorial sovereignty.

As for the “Western World” slur, why does Monyela ignore the fact that 27 African countries voted to condemn the invasion of Ukraine at the UN, while 17 abstained and one voted with Russia? What about Nigeria, Egypt and Kenya, the other three points of Africa’s economic diamond? They have condemned the invasion.

Are we to believe they are all vassals of the West?

Visit Daily Maverick’s home page for more news, analysis and investigations

On the subject of malign foreign powers, why does Monyela have nothing to say about the presence of the Wagner mercenary group in the Sahel and elsewhere, supporting coups and executing Africans who get in the way?

Of course the lives lost in other conflicts in the Middle East matter. So do those lost in Zimbabwe, Eastern DRC, CAR, Mozambique, Ethiopia, Eritrea and Sudan. None of these, which share the absence of social peace and security, made Monyela’s laundry list. This points to a constant failure by the ANC. Its default is to externalise conflict. Yet when its friends violate human rights or rig elections, it is silent and even argues that they should not be sanctioned.

In the land of Dirco, it seems the one-eyed writer is king.

And third, in playing the man and not the ball, Monyela again forgets to do his homework. He accuses one of us (Mills) of having served as an adviser to the ISAF commander in Afghanistan in 2006 — this is apparently proof that we were now furthering another global agenda in criticising the foreign policy of the country in which we were born and to which we pay our taxes (and his salary).

It was not one tour, but four, Clayson, as a trip to our website (www.thebrenthurstfoundation.org) might have informed you, excluding the time spent in assisting President Ashraf Ghani in the palace in 2021 shortly before Kabul fell.

Monyela should read “The Ledger” (authored by Mills), which is globally recognised as the most complete, scouring critique of the failings of the Western intervention in Afghanistan.

Of course, to make such criticisms with credibility, you had to be there to observe and learn about the limits of external powers, no matter how powerful they are. It also offered the opportunity to roll up one’s sleeves and assist those less fortunate; something that probably comes as a shock to some South African bureaucrats, who don’t like the feel of the streets.

It also afforded the occasion to assist refugees from Afghanistan when Kabul fell, and it is with some pride we can report that, together with an Australian-American colleague, we managed to extract nearly 1,700 people in the two weeks between Ghani fleeing and Kabul falling to the Taliban.

He also writes that taking John Steenhuisen to Ukraine was a demonstration of bias. The leader of the opposition asked, and we agreed. So, too, did Bobi Wine and Zitto Kabwe, two prominent opposition leaders from Uganda and Tanzania. It was a trip that had political and practical outcomes. In Ukraine, Bobi recorded two solidarity songs with local artists. It showed that Africa was a participant in international affairs and had a voice, and was not always just a spectator yelling at the referee about the unfairness of the rules.

Human rights — humanity itself — is indivisible, a quality which all three visitors have shown in going the extra mile to find out for themselves what is going on in Ukraine.

The point here is that we are free to take whomever we wish to Ukraine or anywhere else we are free to travel to. The difference with government, is that we actually go, and don’t do it by remote control and through exhibiting our own prejudice.

We argued that at the core of South Africa’s Constitution is the directive to build an inclusive, socially just society. The Constitution makes it clear that these noble objectives will not be achieved unless we have an open, accountable and transparent democracy.

Democracy is our core value, the fulcrum around which all others orbit. It should be defended and promoted at home and abroad.

While Monyela fixates on Dirco’s bread-and-butter serving of Cuba, Palestine, Western Sahara, Libya (the invasion of which was incidentally supported by the South African government) and Yemen, we believe that Ukraine must be top of mind.

Monyela’s Russian friends are threatening nuclear war, Africa’s food supplies are at risk, a global recession driven by an energy disaster looms. 

Ukraine, a sovereign democracy subjected to colonial invasion by a dangerous autocracy, says a lot about international law and human rights — and especially of the direction in which those countries which have not defended these attributes are heading. South Africa’s fiddly fiddlestix approach to this epochal conflict is frankly embarrassing.

We should be talking about Cuba. Why are we funding this undemocratic autocracy? Because it once supported the Struggle? The critical faculties of the ANC, which Monyela defends, are warped beyond salvage.

Similarly, there is another error routinely committed by Monyela and his colleagues — defending the invasion of Ukraine on the grounds that the West defended the invasion of Iraq. To remind you, Clayson, of the kindergarten rule of diplomacy: two wrongs don’t make a right. If you really believe the invasion of Iraq was wrong out of principle, you ought to be equally indignant at the invasion of Ukraine.

A final word of advice: Do your homework, visit Ukraine, walk in the shoes of the people whose rights you blithely dismiss. And listen to the voices of your seniors in Africa who don’t share your biases. DM 

Mills and Hartley are with The Brenthurst Foundation. www.thebrenthurstfoundation.org

Gallery

Comments - Please in order to comment.

  • jeyezed says:

    Messes Mills and Hartley have provided far more attention to Mr Monyela than he deserves, by treating him with respect and sensible response at a level far above that displayed by his writing.

  • Rudd van Deventer says:

    Thanks, it needs to be said.

  • Libby De Villiers says:

    Dear mr Monyela,
    Could you, please, write us a little something about the wonderful work the African Union and African states are doing in Ethiopia and Somalia. And then maybe how we are supporting our Zimbabwean and Congolese brothers and sisters.
    And perhaps you could also follow up with another informative article about the opposition parties in Russia and how free and fair elections have been conducted there over the last few years.

  • John Pearse says:

    Great response with lots of totally relevant content. Time to rid this beautiful country of the sick warped views of the ANC and concentrate on feeding our people, finding them employment and teaching them the real values of this world

  • Colin Louw says:

    Mr Monyela is a total box. He is simply a poorly programmed phonograph (I did mean an old fashioned gramophone) spewing out the old old contents of a worn out record written by Stalin apologists a century ago. Dirco is not part of a democratic SA Government at all but simply a meaningless tail hanging on to the ANC. A decade ago I actually was dumb enough to think Pandor actually was a ray of hope.

  • Malcolm McManus says:

    I am no supporter of Russia or its invasion. I do however think that if we were to take historical steps in both the shoes of Western and Eastern Ukranians over the past decade or so, you would have conflicting views on who they would prefer ruling them. There have been many human rights abuses in the East of Ukraine over the years. The only sure way to find out would be through a free and fair referendum as proposed by Elon Musk. The same Elon Musk who has supported Ukraine throughout this crisis. He has faced both approval and criticism. No other options have been put on the table that could avoid further loss of life in a war that is far from over. Even though it may look like Ukraine has the upper hand, things can change quickly.

    • Johan Buys says:

      Malcolm, the eastern Ukranians that hanker for mother russia are free to flee there on the back of a retreating russian army truck. Ukraine had a referendum with a 90% turnout that voted 90% to be independent. By your logic if most people in Orania want a little apartheid state, they should have it. We would have a patchwork of 5,000 states globally if local voting counted like that.

  • Beyond Fedup says:

    Well said and a huge slap in the face of what I can only describe this fool in foreign affairs as a complete and utter idiot, so typical of most of our incompetents and intellectually challenged in high position in our pathetic and useless government. They are simply too thick to understand the whole picture and blindly stick to the very little that they know and what has been drummed into them. I cannot wait for the day when this obnoxious, hugely not fit for purpose and monstrously corrupt ANC that it has become is consigned to the sewerage where they belong!

  • Angus Auchterlonie says:

    You’ll have to forgive Dirco – their single shared brain cell was offline because of loadshedding!

  • Douglas Ian Scott says:

    Well said, thank you Greg Mills and Ray Hartley.

  • Hans Wendt says:

    Wow, what an article. Also loved the heading. The ANC and people like Clayson should really take a look at themselves and be embarrassed at what garbage they spew out. Do they really think the rest of the democratic countries around the world take them and their destructive thoughts and policies seriously. You guys are awesome. Keep up this amazing work.

  • Dennis Bailey says:

    Nice. No doubt the idiot will be back with a rebuttal. DIRCO is an embarrassment to any thinking SAfrican. Expected more from Pandor, but hey, the ANC doesn’t fail to disappoint.

  • Aslam Dasoo says:

    This is really rich from the authors. If they are to be believed, this is the most egregious invasion in modern history and nothing short of regime change in Russia will be sufficient punishment. I don’t recall such demands for regime change in the US because of its savage invasion of Iraq that cost over a million lives.
    To be sure, Russia’s invasion of Ukraine is rightly condemned as a breach of international law and must be resisted. The world must work for peace in Ukraine, but the banshee wail of those willing to fight Russia to the last Ukrainian makes that very difficult.
    And parading the trenchantly homophobic entertainer cum politician Bobi Wine in Ukraine as representing African solidarity against Russia is just cringeworthy. Might you have taken the view of gay people in Ukraine about his visit?This is not whataboutism. When you demand that Russia be condemned, will you condemn the US when it next invades another country, which its petroleum addiction and armaments industry practically guarantees?
    Casting assistance to a US lackey, Ghani, as a benevolence impresses no one. It is the height of hypocrisy. It whitewashes what was no less an illegal invasion of Afghanistan and Iraq that wiped out over a million people during the unspeakable brutality of the US invasion. Assisting Ghani validates that invasion.
    I hold no brief for an inchoate SA foreign policy, but your elevated equine perch doesn’t prevent your partisan western slip from showing, either.

  • Clive Van Der Spuy says:

    From the ANC website on 6.10.2022 doc dated 1.4.2003 [I added the brackets]

    wwwDOTanc1912DOTorgDOTza/stop-the-war_a/
    South Africans unite against the War in Iraq (Ukrain).
    The American (Russian) government continues to pursue its criminal war of aggression against the people of Iraq (Ukrain). As the civilian death toll rises, South Africans . . . are increasingly outraged by the horrors of this imperialist war.
    In solidarity with the people of Iraq (Ukrain), the Stop the War campaign invites the media to join South Africans . . . in the following main events over the coming week:
    THURSDAY 3 APRIL
    MASS PRAYERS FOR PEACE will be led by the Women`s Interdenominational Prayer League (Manyanos) between 12h00 – 14h00 at the Beyer`s Naude Square (Library Gardens). People of all faiths, especially women are welcome to come and pray in solidarity with the people of Iraq (Ukrain). For further information call Masechaba on 083 710 3542.
    The US (Russian) EMBASSY IN PRETORIA will be the venue for a protest meeting between 7PM – 9pm on the evening of Thursday 3 April. Activists and people of faith from all communities will be joined by Smuts Ngonyama (Pule Mabe) and other leadership of the tripartite alliance and the mass democratic movement to pledge solidarity with the People of Iraq (Ukrain) outside the embassy of the aggressor state. Join in this poignant candle-lit event, which combines prayers with political songs and speeches, choirs and poetry for the people of Iraq (Ukrain).

  • Alan Paterson says:

    The pedigree of Mills and Hartley shows through, as always, in their prompt rebuttal of this windbag. Some honest self-reflection by Monyela would appear in order but I don’t think this is in the hymn book of the ANC. Like others, I had some hope for Pandor but her reputation is now irreversibly damaged. Only Creecy is hanging on. I wonder how she sleeps at night. However what is still not explained is how the ANC babies were funded to gloat about Putin’s “referendum”. Likely not the Brenthurst Foundation!

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted

X

This article is free to read.

Sign up for free or sign in to continue reading.

Unlike our competitors, we don’t force you to pay to read the news but we do need your email address to make your experience better.


Nearly there! Create a password to finish signing up with us:

Please enter your password or get a sign in link if you’ve forgotten

Open Sesame! Thanks for signing up.

We would like our readers to start paying for Daily Maverick...

…but we are not going to force you to. Over 10 million users come to us each month for the news. We have not put it behind a paywall because the truth should not be a luxury.

Instead we ask our readers who can afford to contribute, even a small amount each month, to do so.

If you appreciate it and want to see us keep going then please consider contributing whatever you can.

Support Daily Maverick→
Payment options

Become a Maverick Insider

This could have been a paywall

On another site this would have been a paywall. Maverick Insider keeps our content free for all.

Become an Insider