Boks’ performance against Wallabies not worthy of the Springbok jersey, says coach Jacques Nienaber

Boks’ performance against Wallabies not worthy of the Springbok jersey, says coach Jacques Nienaber
The Wallabies pose with the Mandela Plate during the Rugby Championship match between the Australian Wallabies and the South Africa Springboks at Suncorp Stadium on 18 September 2021 in Brisbane, Australia. (Photo: Albert Perez / Getty Images)

The Wallabies claimed the Nelson Mandela Plate after beating the Springboks in Brisbane on Saturday.

Australia 30 (15) South Africa 17 (12)

The Springboks might be world champions, but their reputation is in tatters after a second defeat against Australia in the space of six days. Bok coach Jacques Nienaber described it as a performance not worthy of the jersey – and it’s difficult to disagree. 

Last week the Boks lost with the final kick of the match, but in Brisbane on Saturday, the last rites came much earlier when Wallaby wing Marika Koroibete scythed in for his second try 12 minutes from time. 

It bookended a match in which Australia dominated the first and last quarters to raise serious questions about how the Boks go forward from here. 

Koroibete’s second strike was Australia’s fourth try of the match and took them into a 30-17 lead, which remained the score until the end. It was the first time since October 2018, against the All Blacks, that the Springboks conceded more than two tries in a match. 

The territory-based, kicking and smothering game the Boks have employed successfully in recent years is only effective when all the parts are functioning in union. In Brisbane, the Boks’ defence was as weak as it’s been in years, and everything else fell apart from there. 

And now the All Blacks loom for the 100th meeting between the sides in Townsville next week. The Boks arrived in Australia with five wins from six games in 2021 and as the number one team in the world. That record now stands at five wins in eight, with their hardest fixtures to come. 

The world champions will also drop to number two in the world rankings when they are updated on Monday after the All Blacks beat Argentina 36-13 in the day’s later game at the Suncorp Stadium. It all regressed quickly in two weeks. 

The Boks face an uphill battle to salvage something from the Rugby Championship, which they could mathematically still win, but that is clutching at straws. Beating the All Blacks next week seems a fanciful notion after two inept displays against Australia. It won’t happen if the Boks play like they did in Brisbane. 

Although South Africa’s set piece was strong enough, they had no imagination and flair on attack despite moving the ball in hand more than they have all season. 

The Boks carried 87 times to the Wallabies 63, but only beat five defenders. The Wallabies beat 19 defenders with their carries and made more metres with fewer attacks. Cheslin Kolbe’s ability to conjure up magic has been sorely missed in the past two weeks. 

Bok scrumhalf Faf de Klerk struggled with both his decision-making and execution, and there were simply far too many tackles missed – 19 in all. It was a shambolic performance, which the stats only partly reveal. 

The Wallabies in effect shut down the Boks’ rolling maul and were brutally effective in defence, completing 96% of their attempted tackles. By contrast, both the Wallabies’ first two tries in the opening quarter, scored by centre Len Ikitau, were direct results of missed tackles by the Boks. 

Australia, despite their struggles at set piece, were much more clinical on attack and breached the Bok line with effective surges that will leave Nienaber pondering his options. 

For a second week running, it was a strangely flaccid display from the Boks. Under Nienaber, they are famously clinical in their analysis and review everything unemotionally. But maybe that is exactly what is lacking. They are too robotic. 

“We were truly beaten in every department. We made too many errors and it’s something we have to figure out quickly, but I can’t put my finger on it,” Nienaber said after the match. 

“You get tested differently (by southern hemisphere teams) against sides like this. And it’s been a massive challenge for us. 

“It was not a performance worthy of the Springbok jersey. Our one-on-one defence was poor. It’s definitely not the worst performance of the year; it’s probably the worst performance since 2018 when we lost to Argentina in Mendoza. 

“It was not a great performance. In what areas? I think everything. Our exit game wasn’t up to standard and was inconsistent … it wasn’t a great performance. 

“We were truly beaten in every department. We got hands down beaten in everything. Defence, kicking game, attack … we just made too many errors.” 

The reality is that Australia, after three heavy losses against the All Blacks where they tried to go toe to toe with New Zealand, played the percentages against the Boks. 

They kicked for territory, and kept the flamboyance to a minimum, yet were good enough to score tries when they created chances. They are definitely improving under coach Dave Rennie while the Boks have taken a few steps back. 

Bok skipper Siya Kolisi blamed the players for the defeat and it was hard to disagree. The game plan is well established and has shown to be effective. But if players constantly make mistakes by knocking-on, missing tackles and conceding penalties, there is little the coaching staff can do in a match. 

“It’s just mistakes,” said Kolisi after the match. “We’re training very well together, but every single guy is making a mistake. 

“We maul well, and then we’re not consistent afterwards and, at the next maul, we stuff it up. Our exit plays were poor. 

“Defence is our thing, and we love that physicality and it didn’t work for us. We’re going to have to look at ourselves, and we have to be better next weekend. We have to pull tighter. 

“I thought on the field, we were well prepared. We, as the players, didn’t enforce what we planned, so it was 100% us. The preparation was good, and we just didn’t deliver it on the day. As players, we have to take responsibility for that.”


Australia – Tries: Len Ikitau (2), Marika Koroibete (2). Conversions: Quade Cooper (2). Penalties: Cooper (2).

 South Africa – Try: Lukhanyo Am. Penalties: Handré Pollard (4). DM


Comments - Please in order to comment.

  • Charles Parr says:

    It certainly was a poor performance by the Boks and I wondered whether living in a bio-bubble was getting to them. It doesn’t bode well for the toughest games against the All Blacks.

  • Memphis Belle says:

    Sloppy defence, missed tackles and self inflicted errors are all signs of an arrogant/complacent coach and team who think they are untouchable.

    The starting point is an absolutely zero tolerance towards penalties and missed tackles no matter who.

    • Paddy Ross says:

      As a non-South African lover of good quality rugby, I hope that the last two weekends will have weakened the arrogance of the Boks and the giant ego of Erasmus and that the Boks will come out of this doldrum a much better rugby team.

  • gavin0549 says:

    Saturday 18 September: SA versus Australia 17/30

    1 SA Coaching staff continue to be exposed at an International level. ‘Voices’ in the rugby world regarding the ‘Boring Boks’ seem to have instigated some change in tactics. Maybe the Zoom meetings can be blamed, because nobody appeared to have any clue of what the ‘game plan’ was!? Confused with ‘change’!?
    2 ‘pin-up’ Captain continues to uninspire. After-match excuses demonstrate his inability to ‘describe the reality’ of the situation
    3 Pollard returns to kicking more consistently but is a culprit, with the rest of the squad, of pathetic first-time tackling
    4 ‘Faf’ needs to be disciplined for his selfish arrogance!
    5 Duane does the basics but is mostly ‘missing in action’ – lacking match fitness
    6 Willie le Roux, only a mother could love this!?
    7 I would go to war with Quagga any day, rather than the majority of the 2019 ‘primadonnas’!
    8 In the last 10 minutes Australia conspired to hand the game to the Boks, but poor execution prevailed to rob the stupid Boks! Guilty on all counts.

  • Coen Gous says:

    Jacques Nienaber, are you worthy of being the coach? Clearly, the mastermind behind the boks at the RWC 2019, and the series victory over the Lions, was Rassie Erasmus, even as a water boy. The poster man Captain is unable to even vaguely resemble Erasmus in motivation, strategy, execution and leadership. Neither is Nienaber. Now, as so many times with previous bok coaches, this individually brilliant players will slip because there is not the cohesion, play for each other, approach. The performance over the last 2 weeks against a mediocre Wallaby team was awful. Don’t blame the players, blame the coach and captain.

  • Dragon Slayer says:

    South Africa’s strategy on defence – smash them and hope they make a mistake. On attack … same as on defence.

  • Jon Quirk says:

    Picking a number 7, only marginally more mobile than a telegraph pole was the first major mistake; the second is the lack of conditioning which makes the Boks a side who can only only compete for half a game, even allowing for the loading of the bomb squad to carry them through the last 30 minutes, results in the falling off tackles and gaping defensive holes. 4 tries against the Aussies may result in many more against the All Blacks.

    • Charles Parr says:

      I can’t understand why Marcell Coetzee was left behind. They said that he wasn’t match fit but I think he’s fitter than most of the team and he’s a great flank which would leave the locks to do what they do best. In any event, I’m sure that there are enough flanks on tour so why not give them a chance.

  • Johan Buys says:

    One suspects that there is a pay dispute going on in the background; so disinterested was the performance.

  • Just Me says:

    The Boks were poor in virtually all facets of the game. They seem to be stuck in the wrong style of play and lacking intensity. Not just not worth of the jersey, but not worthy of their pay.

  • Derek Alberts says:

    As paid professionals, they played like clueless amateurs … eish!! Maybe the All Blacks will reignite the passion, just maybe …

  • gavin0549 says:

    The reason they did not take Marcell Coetzee, was because the flight was already fully reserved for ’43’ other players, excluding other ‘management’, easily taking the number to 60 plus! Not more than 30 are likely to play in the four matches? Expensive ‘water boys’ or carrying ‘tackle bags’ having a free holiday for four weeks, learning not how to play in the 2023 World Cup. Was not aware SARFU was so cash flush!?

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted


This article is free to read.

Sign up for free or sign in to continue reading.

Unlike our competitors, we don’t force you to pay to read the news but we do need your email address to make your experience better.

Nearly there! Create a password to finish signing up with us:

Please enter your password or get a sign in link if you’ve forgotten

Open Sesame! Thanks for signing up.

MavericKids vol 3

How can a child learn to read if they don't have a book?

81% of South African children aged 10 can't read for meaning. You can help by pre-ordering a copy of MavericKids.

For every copy sold we will donate a copy to Gift of The Givers for children in need of reading support.

A South African Hero: You

There’s a 99.8% chance that this isn’t for you. Only 0.2% of our readers have responded to this call for action.

Those 0.2% of our readers are our hidden heroes, who are fuelling our work and impacting the lives of every South African in doing so. They’re the people who contribute to keep Daily Maverick free for all, including you.

The equation is quite simple: the more members we have, the more reporting and investigations we can do, and the greater the impact on the country.

Be part of that 0.2%. Be a Maverick. Be a Maverick Insider.

Support Daily Maverick→
Payment options