South Africa


Right to die: patients would be vulnerable to unscrupulous doctors and relatives, judge hears

Right to die: patients would be vulnerable to unscrupulous doctors and relatives, judge hears
The Health Professions Council of South Africa is opposing an application to legalise euthanasia. (Photo: Armin Kübelbeck, CC-BY-SA via Wikimedia Commons)

Health Professions Council’s lawyer argues that a legal option available to people is to starve themselves to death.

First published in GroundUp.

Legalising euthanasia would leave patients vulnerable to collusion between unscrupulous doctors and family members, the Health Professions Council of South Africa has said. The Council is opposing an application by Cape Town resident Diethard Harck and his doctor, Dr Suzanne Walter, a palliative care specialist, to change the common law on euthanasia.

Harck and Walter want to decriminalise both physician-assisted suicide (PAS – where the doctor prescribes and the patient self-administers) and physician-assisted euthanasia (PAE – where the doctor administers any medicine to end life). Harck has motor neuron disease and Walter has multiple myeloma. Their evidence is being taken on commission before retired Judge Neels Claassen in case they are too ill, or have died when the case is heard later this year.

The Health Professions Council strongly opposes the legalisation of euthanasia and medically assisted suicide, the Council’s advocate Adrian D’Oliveira told the commission. The Council also believes that there are already lawful options in place for people who wish to terminate their lives because they are suffering from terminal illnesses.

In his cross-examination of Harck on Wednesday, much of it grounded in the realities of South Africa, he said many poor people suffering from terminal illnesses might feel obliged to take a lethal dose so that they did not become a burden.

“You could imagine a home where there are not sufficient beds for everybody and where food is insufficient,” the advocate said. “They would internalise the pressure to die. It would not be a free choice and the law would not protect them.”

The Health Professions Council also believed that “in reality” there would be situations where family members and doctors would abuse the system and cause the deaths of people for money or inheritance, he said. D’Oliveira said no checks and balances could stop abuse by unscrupulous doctors acting in collusion with unscrupulous family members.

“There is also a more distasteful scenario, where an individual is forced to end their life through PAS or PAE. It will be undetectable. All of this, unfortunately, would occur in a society like ours, if the power of euthanasia and assisted suicide is conferred and given by law,” he said.

Another issue for consideration was the general lack of trust in doctors which would worsen if doctors were allowed to assist people to die.

He said should the court, or Parliament, ultimately allow euthanasia, the council’s stance was that it should be done by “properly trained’ people, but not medical doctors.

Harck insisted that “the primary power behind the decision is the patient who suffers, not the doctor” and that checks and balances would stop any abuse.

D’Oliveira referred to two online documents which detailed how people who wanted to end their lives could do so legally.

One option would be to refuse food and water. Another, “for those who can afford it”, would be to travel to a country such as Switzerland where euthanasia was legal. There was also information on the use of certain drugs and inert gases to end life.

Earlier, D’Oliveira said it was also legally permissible for a palliative care doctor to put a suffering patient into sedation “like being under anaesthetic”.

During re-examination, Advocate Claire De Witt, for Harck, said deep, terminal sedation was not available to all patients and had to be clinically indicated when the signs of death were present. If not, the doctor could be guilty of “over-servicing”.

Harck said, “This is extremely unsettling to know. That makes me feel disempowered and angry.

“Light sedation would not address my fears and my desire. What would be the purpose if I want to die?

“It would cause me extended life and suffering.” DM



Comments - Please in order to comment.

  • Rodney Weidemann says:

    So we can legally put an animal down if it’s suffering too much, but now lawyers (those paragons of virtue) are arguing that we should not have the right to decide to put OURSELVES down if we are suffering the same? That is utterly ridiculous – there are ALWAYS ways to implement checks & balances!!

    • Annalene Sadie says:

      How ironic that the Health Professionals Council cannot trust their members to act in the best interest of their patients!

  • Johan Buys says:

    Surely the situation in a case of a good Living Will is much clearer? We need a process, nobody is asking for widely available lethal injections.

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted


This article is free to read.

Sign up for free or sign in to continue reading.

Unlike our competitors, we don’t force you to pay to read the news but we do need your email address to make your experience better.

Nearly there! Create a password to finish signing up with us:

Please enter your password or get a sign in link if you’ve forgotten

Open Sesame! Thanks for signing up.

We would like our readers to start paying for Daily Maverick...

…but we are not going to force you to. Over 10 million users come to us each month for the news. We have not put it behind a paywall because the truth should not be a luxury.

Instead we ask our readers who can afford to contribute, even a small amount each month, to do so.

If you appreciate it and want to see us keep going then please consider contributing whatever you can.

Support Daily Maverick→
Payment options

Daily Maverick Elections Toolbox

Feeling powerless in politics?

Equip yourself with the tools you need for an informed decision this election. Get the Elections Toolbox with shareable party manifesto guide.