South Africa


Prasa chair Leonard Ramatlakane gets the facts wrong

Chair of the Prasa board, Leonard Ramatlakane, stated that corruption buster Martha Ngoye sat on the Bid Adjudication Committee that approved the infamous oversized locomotives deal. But a report by Werksmans Attorneys shows this is almost certainly false. (Archive photo: Ashraf Hendricks)

He has relied on a dodgy document to try to link a corruption fighter to the infamous oversized locomotives deal.

First published in GroundUp.

The chair of the Passenger Rail Agency of South Africa (Prasa) board, Leonard Ramatlakane, has tried to use a discredited document to explain the sacking of corruption fighter Martha Ngoye at the weekend.

Ngoye was the head of the legal team at Prasa and had helped save the company billions of rands from looters. She was fired over the weekend. Ramatlakane did not answer GroundUp’s questions about the reasons for her dismissal given in a press statement on Saturday.

But in a new press statement on 3 February, he produced a new smear: that Ngoye was a member of Prasa’s Bid Adjudication Committee which recommended the appointment of Swifambo. Swifambo was the company responsible for the purchase of locomotives too big to fit on South Africa’s tracks, one of the more laughable and expensive bits of corruption in the state capture saga.

It turns out to be nonsense that Ngoye approved this deal. In fact, her actions as head of Prasa’s legal team helped Prasa win three court cases against Swifambo which has saved billions of rands and should lead to the recovery of more.

Ngoye was indeed one of several members of the Bid Adjudication Committee in 2012. The minutes of a Bid Adjudication Committee meeting of 11 July 2012 seems to show that it recommended the Swifambo deal. This would seem to confirm Ramatlakane’s version of events.

But the authenticity of these minutes is questionable, as a report by Werksmans Attorneys in 2019 found:

  • The report and the included minutes are unsigned.
  • The minutes state that the Committee met on 12 July 2012 — a day after the date of the minutes themselves.
  • The date at the bottom of the report is 23 June, which coincidentally is the same day that another committee — the Bid Evaluation Committee — met. Ngoye did not sit on this committee.
  • The Bid Adjudication Committee report itself is almost an exact copy of a Bid Evaluation Committee’s report and, in fact, is labelled as such at the foot of every page.

The Werksmans investigators record that when they consulted the members of the Bid Adjudication (not Evaluation) Committee about these irregularities, they were told that the Bid Adjudication Committee had never met to consider these bids. In light of this evidence, the investigators regard the authenticity of the documents as “questionable”.

This Werksmans investigation was commissioned by the interim board at the time. Ramatlakane must be aware of the findings. And yet he still chose to use a questionable document to further smear someone who has saved Prasa billions. DM




Comments - share your knowledge and experience

Please note you must be a Maverick Insider to comment. Sign up here or sign in if you are already an Insider.

Everybody has an opinion but not everyone has the knowledge and the experience to contribute meaningfully to a discussion. That’s what we want from our members. Help us learn with your expertise and insights on articles that we publish. We encourage different, respectful viewpoints to further our understanding of the world. View our comments policy here.

All Comments 5

  • This anc “stalwart” must have a nefarious agenda, like most in the anc as history has proven. Why dismiss an anti-corruption fighter and who has saved billions??? Is this not another typical cadre deployment where loyalty above all counts? What qualifications and experience has this individual got to be in such a position? SA has suffered grievously through grand-scale and a feeding-frenzy of corruption, gross ineptitude and outright stupid cadre deployment!!

  • If this is true, and I never doubt that Groundup deal in truth, then Leonard Ramatlakane should be FIRED! But I’m not holding my breath. Question is, what is the motive???
    Is Ngoye getting in the way of some who need to feed at the tough?

  • The most obvious that I can see is that Ngoye is honest and that is a threat to most of the ANC Cadre appointments including Ramatlakane who is not (honest)
    Honesty for these people is extremely rare!! This has been the biggest problem in this government, DISHONESTY in everything they do, it actually borders on evil. There are too few honest people around to make
    this Democracy and business work!