Lockdown has bought us time, Professor Karim says, as South Africa bucks the trend

Lockdown has bought us time, Professor Karim says, as South Africa bucks the trend
South African scientist, epidemiologist and Director of Centre for the Aids Programme of Research (CAPRISA), Professor Salim Abdool Karim. Photo: Dean Demos

A proactive approach to fighting community transmissions of coronavirus infections has given South Africa the edge for now in the war against the global epidemic and while lockdown appears to be working, the country has a long way to go in fighting the disease. 

South Africa is showing a unique trajectory of the coronavirus infection, with provisional data showing that government measures to slow down the infection rate are working.

This was the message from the chair of South Africa’s Covid-19 Ministerial Advisory Committee, Professor Salim Abdool Karim, during a Zoom meeting set up to explain some of the data used by the government to take decisions relating to the epidemic.

Abdool Karim reiterated that their main concern was for the two million to 2.5 million South Africans who are HIV-positive but not on antiretrovirals and especially an estimated 500,000 of them who have low CD4 counts. These counts are a measurement of a specific type of white blood cell that is indicative of a person’s immune function.

He said that due to early and proactive interventions by the government, South Africa now has a unique trajectory as community transmission had been curtailed up to now and was continuing at a much lower rate than was initially expected.

“We probably cannot escape the exponential curve [leading to a rapid increase in cases] but lockdown has bought us time. We cannot end lockdown abruptly. It will undo all we have achieved,” he added.

The Minister of Health, Dr Zweli Mkhize, who chaired the meeting, said that the pandemic behaves in the same way all over the world – it was up to communities to change their conduct and in that way influence the way the outbreak behaves.

He also announced SA’s latest figures in the pandemic: more than 83,000 tests have been completed, with 2,272 people testing positive. That is an increase of 99 cases from Sunday. 

Mkhize also announced two further deaths – a 68-year-old man in the Western Cape with underlying diabetes, hypertension and chronic renal disease, and a 57-year-old man in Gauteng.

Abdool Karrim said the data shows that in each country, once there were more than 100 cases the virus spread at a rapid rate with high numbers of new cases being recorded. He said in these instances hospitals were overwhelmed by the number of ill people seeking help.

He added that initially South Africa was on a similar upward trajectory but this took a turn on March 26 when lockdown started. 

“We began to see a decline in the number of cases. They have reached a plateau. It is very significant, because March 26 was the day lockdown started,” he said. 

He said if the trajectory of the outbreak was compared to that of the United Kingdom it is clear what a difference the lockdown made. He said for the first few weeks the number of new cases in South Africa was virtually the same as in the UK, but from March 26 the number of cases in South Africa did not continue an upward trajectory, even though those in the UK did. 

“In every one of the countries, we looked as the number of cases kept on increasing. There is not a single other country where we have seen this kind of turn,” he added.

“Our epidemic trajectory is unique.”

Abdool Karim said they had three theories about this. The first was that too few tests were done. The second was that there was not enough testing in the public sector, for patients without medical aid. 

He said while testing was restricted at first, there had been a continual increase and the number of tests in the public sector had taken off since lockdown. 

“There has to be a third explanation,” he said. “Lockdown is about reducing community transmission.”

He explained that the first wave of infections that hit the country was from travellers who brought in the virus from outside. The second wave was those who had contact with the travellers, including the medical personnel who treated them. He said what they didn’t expect was that there was not widespread community transmission.

“When the virus enters a community it spreads like wildfire,” he said. “You would expect an exponential increase in cases.” 

He said that, roughly speaking, they are not seeing that an infected person is infecting many. So far, they were seeing an infected person infecting one other person.

“That is exactly the reasons for all of our measures – handwashing, social distancing and lockdown – we want each infected person to become a dead-end [for further infections].”

He added that their biggest concern was for the three high-density hubs: Greater Johannesburg, eThekwini and Greater Cape Town.

“What we hope for is for the number of new cases steadily declining and disappearing.  This is very unlikely though. A more likely scenario is that we stem community transmission. Once we end the lockdown, and we must remember that none of us have immunity against this virus, we are all at risk. That is why as soon as the opportunity arises for this virus to spread we will see the exponential curve again.”

He said while South Africa had become the first country in the world to keep community transmission at a reasonably low level, he thought it was highly unlikely that the country would escape the exponential threat of the virus.

“Unless we have a special mojo to protect us,” he said. 

“This virus has a long period of infectiousness. It will spread really fast if people are interacting with one another. [Through lockdown] we have gained time. We have a unique component to our response: We are going out there and we are proactive – we find the cases before they are coming to the hospital.” 

Abdool Karrim added that a successful lockdown strategy had bought time for the country which will mean possible access to easier and faster testing, a vaccine and treatments.

“This coming week is critical. This is when we will see what community transmission of the virus is doing. If these passive cases [patients that seek medical help] is 90 or more on average per day we will have to continue the lockdown. If we see cases fall to between 45 and 89 then we look at active cases [those found by health workers]. If these are 1:1,000 or below then we can ease the lockdown.” 

He said by ending the lockdown too abruptly the country would run the risk of undoing the good that was done. 

“We must plan for a systematic easing – starting with transport hubs and then working our way down.” 

He added that their response to the epidemic would not end with decisions on lockdown.

“The next stage, we find the clusters of infections in our communities. I remain concerned over funerals leading to the spread of the virus. We must deal with these issues.” 

He said the next stage was to make sure that the medical response will be as good as it can be when patients start to come to hospital.

The next stage, he said, was ongoing vigilance.

This was best explained by using the metaphor of stopping small flames to prevent a raging fire. 

“You need people on the ground that are looking for fires. If we see one, we can prevent it. If we get there too late, then we have to put out a raging fire. We are going to try and stay one step ahead of the viral spread. It is a tall order. We are not going to wait for patients to come to hospital.” 

He said apart from a hospital surveillance programme he was also thinking about a monthly national surveillance day where small samples of people are tested at schools and big companies.

Mkhize said the plan was always to flatten the curve of new infections. 

“A lot of modelling is taking place to advise our actions,” he said. “We look at the impact on the economy. Many factors are being taken into account. This includes the social impact of both the outbreak and interventions such as the lockdown. There is a lot of input behind the decisions that the president announced.” DM


"Information pertaining to Covid-19, vaccines, how to control the spread of the virus and potential treatments is ever-changing. Under the South African Disaster Management Act Regulation 11(5)(c) it is prohibited to publish information through any medium with the intention to deceive people on government measures to address COVID-19. We are therefore disabling the comment section on this article in order to protect both the commenting member and ourselves from potential liability. Should you have additional information that you think we should know, please email [email protected]"

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted

We would like our readers to start paying for Daily Maverick...

…but we are not going to force you to. Over 10 million users come to us each month for the news. We have not put it behind a paywall because the truth should not be a luxury.

Instead we ask our readers who can afford to contribute, even a small amount each month, to do so.

If you appreciate it and want to see us keep going then please consider contributing whatever you can.

Support Daily Maverick→
Payment options