Defend Truth


Allowing local governments to impose an alcohol sales tax would boost municipal revenues


Chris Pappas is the mayor of uMngeni Local Municipality.

As South Africa grapples with the fiscal dilemma of the ongoing challenge to generate sufficient revenue to meet the growing demands of urban development, social services and infrastructure improvements, one potential solution stands out: granting local authorities the authority to impose an alcohol sales tax.

Municipalities across South Africa play a vital role in the lives of their residents. They are responsible for an array of services ranging from waste management and road maintenance to electricity provision and law enforcement. However, their financial resources often fall short of meeting these obligations, leading to a frustrating cycle of limited funds and stalled development initiatives.

In addition to this, many municipalities have very limited ability to generate income through conventional means such as property tax or electricity sales. In this context, the notion of introducing a localised alcohol sales tax offers a ray of hope.

Allowing local governments to impose an alcohol sales tax would create a new stream of income.

The revenue generated from this tax could be earmarked specifically for local projects such as upgrading public infrastructure, expanding recreational facilities and enhancing public transportation systems.

This newfound financial flexibility could stimulate economic growth and improve the overall quality of life for residents.

Implementing an alcohol sales tax at the local level can also serve as a gentle nudge toward responsible drinking.

Higher prices could deter excessive consumption and reduce the burden on healthcare systems caused by alcohol-related illnesses. 

By discouraging harmful drinking habits, local governments can work towards cultivating healthier communities.

In addition to the potential deterrent, local authorities would have more resources to deal with the consequences of excessive alcohol consumption. These include littering, public urination and drunk driving.

Alcohol abuse often contributes to various social issues including crime and domestic violence. Revenue generated from the alcohol sales tax could be channelled into initiatives aimed at substance abuse prevention, treatment and rehabilitation programmes. This holistic approach would not only alleviate the strain on law enforcement, but also contribute to a safer and more cohesive society.

Granting local governments the authority to impose an alcohol sales tax aligns with the principles of decentralisation and local autonomy. It empowers municipalities to tailor policies to their unique needs and preferences, fostering a sense of ownership among residents. Moreover, it encourages innovative approaches to revenue generation and service delivery, ultimately promoting a more efficient and responsive governance structure.

Allowing local governments in South Africa to impose an alcohol sales tax represents a prudent step toward addressing their revenue challenges while simultaneously promoting responsible drinking and tackling alcohol-related social issues.

By providing municipalities with a new income source, this approach can stimulate economic growth, enhance public services and create a safer and more vibrant community for all residents.

As the nation looks to empower its local governments, the implementation of an alcohol sales tax emerges as a promising solution that deserves serious consideration. DM


Comments - Please in order to comment.

  • dylan smith says:

    Hi Chris love your work. A few issues with this idea. Kzn liquor authority is almost entirely disfunctional, would the municipalities then administer their local outlets? What about the knock on effect of inflation on the hospitality industry, some areas almost entirely rely on this revenue. How would it not become another conduit for corruption and who would oversee and determine such taxes. Would it not be better to propose a sliding scale rates system that allows all south Africans to contribute to their basic services. It’s my understanding that municipal income streams rely on very small percentages to lubricate their budgets. How to educate local constituents that municipalities were formed through collective collection for the greater good seems more reasonable. Of course in theory it sounds good but may be a bitter pill to swallow.

  • Iain Robertson says:

    Some issues here before we get to the meat of the proposal.

    1. As with ciggies and booze during lockdown, it will promote a parallel contraband market.
    2. Most municipalities are dysfunctional already, so let’s fix what is broken before applying a futher layer of bureaucracy to administer the tax, including making sure it is used for the noble purposes proposed.
    3. Municipalities have applied large rates increases to cover increases in electricity and other infrastructure costs. There will be a large pushback against this proposal. Durban’s rates boycotts are an example.

    A fine idea perhaps, but as we have seen unworkable in practice.

  • antonio66 says:

    Easy, add more taxes. We’re already paying our fair share of taxes and getting very little in return – look at the backlog of maintenance in all spheres of local & national government. The taxes collected should rather be deployed effectively, instead of being wasted on over inflated government and municipal contracts and corruption.

    Driving on the roads during the day, I see many delivery drivers pulling off the road and relieving themselves in plain sight – I see very few drunks doing the same.

    Maybe the grime, filth and public urinating has more to do with us as a nation – increasing taxes will not solve this.

  • Donald Knight says:

    The uMngeni Municipality is already charging excessive property rates!

  • Mayibuye Magwaza says:

    This is an interesting idea, since it’s clear that local government needs more revenue and the current solutions aren’t hacking it. The challenge I see here is how to levy it in an easy and cost-effective manner. I also want to ask, are alcohol taxes (and prices) going to be different from municipality to municipality, or is this going to be a blanket levy that goes straight to the local municipality? If e.g. I buy alcohol in Durban wholesale and sell it at my bottlestore in Howick, where does the tax get paid and at how much?

  • Anthony Kearley says:

    Bad idea, sorry. Alcohol in particular is already heavily taxed by national government through sin taxes, VAT etc. When you impose yet another tax on the same product, already overtaxed, you unintentionally create a black market and the criminal cartels which will arise attached thereto. Sales taxes should be broader based at a low rate across multiple products to prevent this. Also, local governments are not set up to police the distortions they would create, such as cross-jurisdictional smuggling within SA borders. Finally, the question has to be asked, if you need more revenue, why not simply levy a slightly higher municipal rate as a more efficient way of raising revenue, no extra collection cost because municipalities are already setup for that. How can a new tax, which has to be policed, be better than that?

  • William Dryden says:

    If the government ministers and their cohorts didn’t loot so much and reduced their exorbitant salaries, there would be enough money in the kitty to provide the services required, but no it’s easier just to bring in another tax, again unconstitutional and theft in broad daylight. When will it all end with these thieves.?

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted