Defend Truth


Malema’s day of humiliation – South Africa must return to mass democratic politics


Dr Imraan Buccus is a senior research associate at the Auwal Socio-economic Research Institute and a postdoctoral fellow at Durban University of Technology.

Prior to the EFF’s self-described ‘national shutdown’, the party was dominating the media space. The intersection between Julius Malema’s threatening language, the paranoia resulting from the July 2021 riots, and the authoritarianism of the state gave Malema and his party massive attention in the media, and on social media channels too.

EFF leader Julius Malema is a master at media manipulation, and the lead-up to the “national shutdown” generated huge attention for a small party. But when the day of reckoning came, Malema and his party suffered complete humiliation.

For their “national shutdown” to be successful, the EFF would have needed to mobilise tens of thousands of people in the major cities. Instead, there were only small protests – pathetically small protests. Even in their main event – the march in Pretoria led by Malema – they could, according to media reports, after a very slow start, only draw a medium-sized crowd.

The gap between Malema’s hubris – he was even speaking of a revolution in the days before the protests – and reality was vast. He is now exposed as a politician who is very good at winning media attention, mediocre at winning votes and completely inept at organising real support on the ground. 

But the damage done to Malema and his party was not only due to the failure to mobilise on any sort of scale. The image of Malema and Carl Niehaus walking hand-in-hand in the Pretoria march would have been sickening to most South Africans. 

Malema, who once said he was willing to kill for Zuma but then turned on Zuma when it was expedient for him to do so, is now openly allied with the self-described “Radical Economic Transformation” (RET) faction of the ANC. 

Niehaus is one of the most nauseating figures in South African politics and Malema’s reputation, already battered by the EFF’s own corruption scandals, will now be in tatters. 

Most South Africans have a deep loathing of corruption. The attempts by the Zuma faction of the ANC and its hangers-on – like the now defunct Black First Land First – to spin massive state looting as “revolutionary”, cut no ice with the vast majority of South Africans. 

Malema has done himself serious, and quite probably permanent damage, by associating with the likes of Niehaus. 

Malema will remain a player in our politics because the media always amplifies his relevance, and because the decline in the support for the ANC will mean that small parties can negotiate real power for themselves in coalition arrangements, and he is a canny operator. 

But we now know for sure that Malema has no right at all to claim that he speaks for anything other than a small minority of South Africans, and that he has no capacity to mobilise on the streets at any meaningful scale. 

Visit Daily Maverick’s home page for more news, analysis and investigations

But while most South Africans will welcome Malema’s day of humiliation, the failed “national shutdown” should leave us very concerned. For a start, the highly militarised response of the state was disturbing. After Marikana, we cannot be sanguine about the sort of language used by Police Minister Bheki Cele and others in the lead-up to the EFF’s call for a national protest. 

And no democracy can accept that the army should be used to police a protest. In South Africa, we all know what happened when the army was brought onto the streets during the Covid lockdowns. It was a disaster, and the ANC’s willingness to deploy the army against protest is deeply worrying. 

The paranoia that was running out of control in the lead-up to the “national shutdown” was not only a middle-class phenomenon. Many migrant communities were deeply worried and some appealed to progressive organisations for support. This is understandable. 

The EFF flip-flops on the question of xenophobia but has taken highly xenophobic positions at times, and its allies in the RET faction of the ANC viciously attacked migrants in the lead-up to the July riots. 

But the way in which some middle-class groups armed themselves and prepared for war was also deeply disturbing. It shows an alarming decline in faith in the state, and raises the real risk of vigilante violence. There is a sense that South Africa is splitting off into antagonistic groups, some armed. 

This does not bode well for our future.

The failed “national shutdown” was also a day of disgrace for some factions of the South African left. While the larger mass-based organisations of the working class and the poor refused to support the EFF’s day of protest, some of the tiny but vociferous sectarian organisations on the outer fringes of the left offered their support to the action. 

Of course, this support was in the form of statements and not people on the ground, because these organisations have no mass base. But for the left to support a march led by Malema and Carl Niehaus walking hand-in-hand is a staggering error in political judgement. Nobody in their right mind considers the EFF or the likes of Niehaus to be on the left. Their politics is the authoritarian populism of a kleptocratic political class. 

Zwelinzima Vavi’s reputation also suffered a heavy blow as a result of his support for the EFF action. His standing has been declining for some time now. He has a history of poor political judgement and political opportunism. We must not forget that, along with Malema, he also threatened to “kill for Zuma”. Since then there have been sexual harassment scandals and xenophobic and Islamophobic statements. 

In the union movement, he is widely seen as more aligned with a group of NGOs than with worker formations. But for Vavi, putatively a man of the left, to support a day of protest led by Malema is such gross opportunism that it is difficult to see that his reputation could ever recover. 

Vavi has turned out to be as much of a political chameleon as Malema himself, having followed a similar trajectory of support for Zuma, then a turn to critique, and now a drift into an alliance with the most corrupt elements of the ANC. 

Moreover, just as Malema failed to mobilise, Vavi was also unable to bring members of Saftu-affiliated unions onto the streets. A leader with no supporters is not really a leader and the sun has probably now set on his political career.

In a way, it is almost surprising that, despite the massive media coverage leading up to the EFF day of action, it attracted such desultory support. South Africa is in such a deep economic and political crisis, made concrete to us all by mass unemployment, load shedding and Cyril Ramaphosa’s failure to lead, that it seems logical to assume that almost any sort of spark could ignite mass protest or even mass riots. 

Political experts have been warning of an Arab Spring-like event for years, and the July riots showed that nihilism and destruction can also emerge from a crisis. An unanticipated event could still spark another round of rioting, or a charismatic populist could emerge to do what Malema has failed to achieve, and put the spark to the tinder. 

We now know that Malema does not have the capacity to win mass support on the streets or to spark an insurrectionary moment. 

But this does not mean that that moment is not coming. 

If it does come, we do not know whether it would simply take the form of politically aimless looting; if it would take the form of xenophobic violence, or if it would take the form of some sort of progressive demands.

We urgently need a new political party that can inspire us around a vision for a better country, and we urgently need the sort of political force that can organise millions of people around a progressive vision for a country. 

Those of us who are old enough can remember the days when Cosatu and the UDF could organise real national shutdowns, with tens of thousands of people on the streets in cities across the country. We need to recover mass democratic politics. DM


Comments - Please in order to comment.

  • Graeme de Villiers says:

    No ‘new’ political party is going to come close to what you are dreaming for, and you know it.
    Although I will always enjoy the evisceration of Malema and his vegetable army, your article does little more than expose a bias that impartial journalism is meant to avoid. Malema and humiliation will NEVER fit in the same sentence in this country, or in his nihilistic ego.

    • Helen Swingler says:

      BTW Graeme, an opinion piece is personal comment and not ‘impartial journalism’. Readers are free to decide what they believe. Important part of freedom of expression.

  • Gavin Brown says:

    Marches and protests are so ’80’s these days. The only ones that now matter are the ones that are not announced weeks ahead and soaked in media coverage but the ones that are sparked without warning or organisation….?

  • William Dryden says:

    The only party that can put the country right is the DA, if they cannot within 4 years then the voters can vote them out, instead of voting for the ANC for the last 26 years expecting a different outcome after 26 election promises that never materialise.

  • Sydney Kaye says:

    The paranoia you mention is mainly the result of our media treating Malema like a statesman, and hanging on to his every word, instead of a big mouthed bully. But will it be the same next time or will he be asked serious questions. Will he be reminded of his humiliation or will he be reported barking it was a victory.
    And I don’t agree about the army. The show of organized strength may make people less afraid next time Malema pulls a stunt.

  • Ockert Fourie says:

    We do not need a new political party. We need people to vote firstly and secondly to vote for any other party than the ANC or EFF.
    The ANC is hell bent on destroying this country and the EFF will succeed in destroying it.

  • Gerrit Marais says:

    I cannot understand the media’s obsession with the EFF? Why would you persistently publish the utterings and goings on of these unspeakables? It is like taking the garbling of a 5 year old seriously.

  • sandy govender says:

    In terms of the government activating members of the defense force to protect key installations and citizens, I can understand why it was necessary. Hindsight is a perfect science. Therefore, now that the protest on the street was underwhelming, one can argue that those extra boots on the ground were unnecessary and possibly counterproductive. However, if one listened to the ‘Hitler’ style rhetoric spouted by Malema to supporters, plus, if everyone overestimated his support base, then our understanding of the past episodes of mayhem, would have made any reasonable governing body take every possible precaution to prevent harm to the people of South Africa and to protect businesses which remain the heart of South Africa’s tax base. Now, after the fact, we are all aware that such action by government to ensure peaceful protest, would be unnecessary. If future mobilizing of the defense force for protest action occurs, one would be justified in criticizing such a move.
    Also important is the fact that South Africans are resilient, stoic and detest violence and damage to infrastructure as it directly affects service delivery to every individual in every home. For this reason, I doubt very much that a new rabble rouser orator spouting the same pillage and burn rhetoric, would gain much support. The people want a government that is steady , increasing employment and service delivery.
    I also agree with the other commentators that a new party is not the answer.

  • José Lueje says:

    Looking at the rest of Africa, and what has happened in RSA in the last 30 odd years. I will say that we still have another 10/15 years, before politicians and their greed, totally destroy our “Beloved Country”.

  • David Forbes says:

    What I find much more worrying than anything the EFF says, thinks or does, is the failure of the media, the middle- and upper classes and big business to see or plan for what is coming. If we do not change the situation very quickly, we are heading for a revolution, and the EFF won’t be leading it. The complacency of South Africa towards the poverty and inequality in this country is astounding. Thousands of centimeters written about Malema and the EFF, but so little about the coming crisis. When it explodes, and it will, it will put July 2021 to shame.

  • David Walker says:

    No, we do not need to recover mass democratic politics. Those are only necessary when the citizenry have no voice and do not have the vote. Not to mention the danger of mass movements being hijacked for looting and criminality. We all have the vote, and so we have the government we have voted for. Unfortunately, with the exception of the Western Cape, the majority of South Africans have voted for thieves and incompetents. They have the opportunity to change that in 2024. There is no point in protesting against the government you voted into power.

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted

MavericKids vol 3

How can a child learn to read if they don't have a book?

81% of South African children aged 10 can't read for meaning. You can help by pre-ordering a copy of MavericKids.

For every copy sold we will donate a copy to Gift of The Givers for children in need of reading support.