Defend Truth


Seize the moment: Ramaphosa must give Cabinet dead wood the axe


Wayne Duvenage is a businessman and entrepreneur turned civil activist. Following former positions as CEO of AVIS and President of SA Vehicle Renting and Leasing Association, Duvenage has headed the Organisation Undoing Tax Abuse since its inception in 2012.

Millions of South Africans are breathing a sigh of relief as order is restored and looted supplies are replenished. However, it is the unpacking by socio-political analysts that we need to dissect and heed, as we expose the underlying issues of why South Africa was forced to dodge a seriously damaging bullet.

As we celebrate the nationalism and camaraderie portrayed through community action across all sectors of society to protect property, lives and livelihoods, followed by the inspirational acts of the clean-up, one gets a sense of the depth of the humanity and ubuntu that binds us as a nation. However, one also gets a sense that many may not have grasped the depth of the danger we were, and may still be, in.

In a country with the highest rate of inequality in the world (and growing), coupled with a ruling party both politically divided and steeped in a conflicted anti-corruption journey, the gravity of the past week’s crisis is attracting significant discussion and realisation of how precariously close we came to losing control of law and order.

Aside from our witness of an ineffective state intelligence agency, along with a police force largely unfit to manage the chaos and a lethargic army that struggled to get into position, one shudders to think of what might have been had the drivers and instigators of this anarchy been better organised, bigger in numbers and smarter in their execution of whatever plan it was they had. One cringes to think of might have been, had citizens and communities not taken up the role of the state by providing necessary protection to property and lives.

Now more than ever, the adage by Churchill rings so true for us: “Never let a good crisis go to waste”. This is not the time to breathe a sigh of relief and believe that our worries are over. We must unpack the real burning issues. And here I don’t mean the obvious matters of attending to the ineptitude of the State Security Agency and its weak intelligence capabilities, or the lack of discipline and training of our police and defence forces. The real work of getting down to reversing our levels of inequality, unemployment and poverty requires substantial attention if we are serious about removing the threat of more and larger incidents of unrest and violence in the future.

Unfortunately, we have lost two decades in which to develop a highly educated, vibrant and entrepreneurial environment of employment opportunities, due to the ruling party lacking the moral courage to place South Africa’s people ahead of the party and self-enriching interests.

The recent crisis presents us with an opportunity for a critical thinking approach from the top, one that will begin a new journey to construct a competent state. One that will give meaningful attention to our desperate and dysfunctional systems of education, health, safety, water, energy, industry and so on.

Our president’s biggest dilemma has an opportunity to be dismantled. While Cyril Ramaphosa’s journey to lead the country was made possible by many compromised cadres who helped him “across the line” at Nasrec in December 2017, his opportunity to break the shackles of indebtedness has arrived. Far too many of his Cabinet posts are filled by people out of their depth, implicated in acts of corruption, or well past their sell-by dates. Most are suffering the long-term effects of a visionary bypass and keep South Africa trapped in a quagmire of inefficiency and administrative bungling that fails to unlock even a fraction of the prosperity we are capable of.

Seriously, what does Gwede Mantashe really know about the minerals and energy sector? Similarly, what does Fikile Mbalula know about the complex transport industry? Sure, they have advisers who may know a lot, but it’s the Cabinet ministers’ responsibility to challenge their advisers and drive the innovative vision and future of these ministries. If not, we sit with expensive and shockingly poor decisions like e-tolling, Russian nuclear deals and powerships, to mention but a few.

Others such as the bumbling Blade Nzimande and our Minister of Communications, Stella Ndabeni-Abrahams, have done much to disenchant the industries they preside over. Worst of all is our deputy president, the enigmatic David Mabuza, who has largely been MIA and has developed an amazing skill of skipping the country for “medical treatment” every time the courts need answers about his gross abuse of power while he was the premier of Mpumalanga.

Ministers have come and gone in the critical area of education, each one unable to arrest the declining pass rates and the issue of a largely unemployable youth sector. There is a similar mess in the Ministry of Health, where the current management of the pandemic and the decade-long inability to introduce a workable universal healthcare system has been atrocious.

And as for Police Minister Bheki Cele, well let’s just wait and see if he will pass the sanity test of opening his filing cabinet to tear up his plan that seeks to stop citizens from applying for gun licences for reasons of self-defence. With last week’s crisis providing all the empirical evidence and a statistically sound sample of what citizens have been arguing for, will the penny drop?

The adage by the late civil rights activist Tyree Scott is extremely apt for the president today: “You can’t leave those who created the problem in charge of finding a solution.”

The time for a Cabinet shake-up is overdue and with the past few week’s events as a backdrop, the president’s conundrum of a passing-out parade for the fickle crew could not be better timed. A well-crafted discussion to convince them of a need for a well-deserved break or retirement to enjoy the trappings of their extraordinary wealth has arrived. I imagine many of them will breathe a sigh of relief and seize the opportunity. DM


Comments - Please in order to comment.

  • Trevor Pope says:

    Unfortunately the president will be fishing in a very shallow pool for replacements. Finding honest, competent candidates who are not ideologically hidebound will be a tall order.

  • Andrew Gunn says:

    Wishful thinking, he doesn’t seem to realise the majority of South Africans will support him.

  • Rob Glenister says:

    Nice thoughts that will not be implemented. How many times has someone suggested that Ramaphosa should seize the moment? Countless. How many times has he done so? You cannot count up to zero.

  • Bryan Shepstone says:

    Hear, hear! Let’s hope they president reads the Daily Maverick…

  • Chris Green says:

    If ever there was a reason NOT to hand in your weapons (licensed or otherwise) last week was it !!! Just be smart about where you retain it and when you need to bring it to bear.

  • Carol Green says:

    Thank you Wayne, but very slim pickings in the ANC NEC. And Cyril seems genetically incapable of “seizing the moment”. Cry our beloved country.

  • Gordon Pascoe says:

    The problem is our president is simply unable to see the “dead wood” in the first place so how can we expect him to get rid of it? Ask yourself, if for argument sake your company was one of 64 in the world and it ranked the lowest when it came to education and number 62 out of 64 in the World Competitiveness Ranking, wouldn’t this alone be a wake up call? Wouldn’t you stop all the talking and take steps to actually do something about your ranking? That’s what I mean when I say he is unable to see the “dead wood”.


    Firstly the BEE BILLIONAIRE has to abolish the positions of Deputy Minister. There isnt a cabinet minister that shouldn’t be booted out – so the Cabinet should be immediately dissolved and a complete team of honest and intelligent persons be appointed-irrespective of their political background. HA HA. JUST DREAMING. Will awake tomorrow to the same-old, same-old.

  • Peter Dexter says:

    Great Article Wayne. I agree with your sentiments completely, but believe the appointment of ALL public office bearers should be subject to appropriate competence, integrity and accountability standards. This is the ONLY way to improve service delivery, make South Africa more competitive, and thus reduce poverty and inequality. It really is that simple!

  • Denny Moffatt says:

    He won’t do it. A man who cannot plan and doesn’t act.
    We need a complete restructuring, reconsidering the roles of provincial, regional and LG. Not to mention reducing the cabinet.
    This is an opportunity for CR but he will not seize the moment.
    Sad really…. ANC political representatives all feed back a portion of their income to the party, which hopefully will reduce. So they may also have to look at their own top heavy structure.

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted