Defend Truth


Ramaphosa address: Nation needs a message that goes beyond Thuma Mina!


Judith February is executive officer: Freedom Under Law.

On Thursday evening President Ramaphosa will deliver the annual State of the Nation Address and face a cynical country weary of corruption and outrageous allegations of State Capture, which have been a steady if unpleasant daily diet for us all.

In an ideal world, the Opening of Parliament, or SONA, as it is now known in popular parlance, would be a low-key affair. Roads would not be barricaded to shut down the centre of town. Policemen and -women would be out in the suburbs and townships protecting us all from crime instead of flooding the streets of Cape Town CBD, enforcing rules in petty displays of power.

Ordinary citizens would not flee the city early to escape the circus. Our favourite bookstore and coffee shop would not have to shut up shop early either, losing sales because no one is able to enter their premises. In an ideal world, life would continue at its usual pace despite the fact that the president and MPs were coming to town.

There would also not be military trucks and soldiers dotted along Philip Kgosana Drive doing little, looking as bored as they probably are. Security for SONA has long since become a completely paranoid, over-the-top enterprise.

So much for the People’s Parliament where the people are absent as the president arrives to empty streets. In an ideal world too, no one would feel the need to comment breathlessly and with vacuity on dresses and hats. But perhaps this year we will all be searching for the Louis Vuitton handbag and what it contains. There is probably more than one.

But this is not the ideal world. No doubt Thursday evening will be no different — dresses, red carpet, hats and security causing irritation to citizens who simply wish to get on with their lives without a further reminder of the presence of politicians, most of whom have not covered themselves in glory.

Given the inevitability of the above, we can still try to focus on the substance of the event.

It’s hard to think that a year ago we were furiously speculating when the State of the Nation Address (SONA) would take place and who would deliver it? At that point, Jacob Zuma was still hanging on to the Presidency for dear life. A lot can happen — and has happened — in a year.

On Thursday evening President Ramaphosa will deliver the annual SONA and face a country weary of corruption and outrageous allegations of State Capture, which have been a steady if unpleasant daily diet for us all. He will face citizens not only weary but cynical too. Will Ramaphosa’s ANC, so deeply divided and corrupt, be able to fulfil the promise of 2018 when the president exhorted us to seek the better angels of our nature in the rallying cry, “Thuma mina!”, we ask ourselves?

The 2019 elections will make this session of Parliament a short one. MPs will start campaigning as early as 29 March. The President will doubtless make the usual promises. The ANC manifesto, after all, traverses well-worn territory — seeking to ensure job creation, better health care and education and dealing decisively with crime, among other things.

In addition, the manifesto makes grand promises about ending State Capture. Given what we are hearing at the Zondo commission, this will be an uphill battle. If even half of the allegations made by former Bosasa COO Angelo Agrizzi are true, it indicates that corruption is brazenly endemic within ministries and departments.

Ramaphosa’s own position is precarious as he attempts to lead a clean-up of government within an ANC which is deeply divided and after Nasrec, where his support came in the form of a tenuous majority.

Yet despite it all, the president can come to Parliament claiming some gains in trying to clean up the state. He has made important inroads. There is no doubt that the Zuma years were indeed “wasted years” as Ramaphosa recently claimed at Davos, and that we are better off with a Ramaphosa presidency.

In his address to the ANC faithful at the launch of its manifesto recently, Ramaphosa admitted:

We accept that mistakes have been made and in some critical areas progress has stalled.” That might be an understatement, but in the past year, we have seen a Cabinet reshuffle, even though imperfect, which saw the departure of deeply problematic ministers such as Lynne Brown, Des van Rooyen, David Mahlobo and Faith Muthambi.

We have also seen the departure of Siyabonga Gama at Transnet, Anoj Singh at Eskom, Berning Ntlemeza at the Hawks, Dudu Miyeni at SAA and Lucky Montana at Prasa — and of course Shaun Abrahams as the NDPP. All welcome departures — and there are also a string of commissions or inquiries investigating wrongdoing at SARS, the PIC and the NPA.

The question, of course, is whether any prosecutions will happen as a result of what is being revealed? Our new National Director of Public Prosecutions Shamila Batohi will have her work cut out for her, but hers is a good appointment and Ramaphosa can be pleased with the outcome of that process.

In Galeshewe this past weekend, Ramaphosa said of his party and corruption:

We truly want to change our ways.” Yet sitting in the audience on Thursday evening will be those who strut about on the public stage simply denying all corruption allegations levelled against them. They do so utterly without shame.

Ramaphosa’s call for “the truth to set us free” will thus also have to mean that justice is done and perpetrators are brought to book. Batohi will be instrumental in the search for justice citizens seek as stories of politicians on the take increase.

On the legislative front Parliament will be focused on passing a Constitutional Amendment Bill dealing with land expropriation without compensation. The National Assembly established an ad hoc committee to initiate and introduce a constitutional amendment and report back to the House by 31 March 2019. This deadline will be tight and one wonders whether it will be met or whether ANC MPs will seek to kick the contentious land issue into touch?

Given that polling data indicates that land is low on the agenda of most South Africans, the ANC manifesto itself seems to relegate the issue. Ramaphosa will need to be nuanced on the land issue and deal with the populism that the EFF, for instance, has championed on land.

The EFF, for its part, has threatened to disrupt Ramaphosa’s address if he does not provide a full explanation regarding the R500,000 his campaign at Nasrec received from Bosasa, via his son Andile. The president has been proactive in referring the matter to the Public Protector. The EFF’s currency is in disruption far more than it is an interest in governance. During the Zuma years, this took hold with their repeated cries of “Pay back the money!” The EFF will probably find that it resonates somewhat differently in the case of President Ramaphosa.

In the bigger scheme of things, however, Ramaphosa will have to show that decisiveness on corruption, especially on how to deal with what citizens hear coming out of the myriad commissions of inquiry that are running concurrently. Related to this, ordinary crime is soaring and all surveys indicate that this is a key concern for South Africans. Ramaphosa will need to go beyond platitudes when it comes to dealing with crime.

There is never anything slow about any South African political year and 2019 will prove to be no different. For those of us watching, it will be an opportunity for the president to be clear about his vision for our country, especially on the economy and job creation. That vision will have to be matched with the details of precisely how implementation will take place — we have to move beyond platitudes and set out the bold choices needed to kick-start the economy.

With our high unemployment rates — a 52% youth unemployment rate — and burgeoning inequality, the economic vision must be one of inclusive, sustainable growth.

How we achieve this will require novel thinking about youth unemployment programmes such as the expansion of the YES programme, investing in education and dealing with errant teachers and principals, cleaning up corruption within the state and creating effective partnerships across government, business and labour which move beyond the R1.2-trillion investment drive and activates jobs.

State-owned enterprises are key to a sustainable economy. Given the condition most of them are in, Ramaphosa will need to spell out how he will methodically deal with corruption, but also get them back on track. Eskom is a crucial cog in the economic wheel and the country urgently needs to know how Minister of Public Enterprises Pravin Gordhan will deal with the challenges these SOEs face and how we will increase our reliance on alternative sources of energy.

There is much to be done. We do not have the luxury of divisive politics.

The President’s job on Thursday will be to forget about the ANC and speak to us all as citizens and spell out a vision which goes beyond “Thuma mina!” and which provides a practical plan of action for the crucial year ahead — even as he may feel the Brutus-like knife edging towards his back from people within his own party. DM


Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted

MavericKids vol 3

How can a child learn to read if they don't have a book?

81% of South African children aged 10 can't read for meaning. You can help by pre-ordering a copy of MavericKids.

For every copy sold we will donate a copy to Gift of The Givers for children in need of reading support.