Defend Truth

GROUNDUP

Development halted – Court hears how women were beaten with knobkieries in battle over Wild Coast land

Development halted – Court hears how women were beaten with knobkieries in battle over Wild Coast land
A court has ruled that no development can take place in Sigidi village in the Eastern Cape without community consent. (Archive photo: Daniel Steyn)

Amadiba Crisis Committee secures interim interdict against development.

The Amadiba Crisis Committee (ACC), has secured an interim interdict against community member Nero Dlamini, stopping him from excavating a site — possibly for a hotel — in an Eastern Cape conservation site without authority.

The committee said that members of Dlamini’s family beat several women with knobkieries when they tried to protect the land “with their bodies”. They said he also said he would not “listen to women” and that “no woman could prevent him from his work”.

The dispute is believed to have its roots in the bid by the South African National Roads Agency (Sanral) to build a new toll road through the Wild Coast.

Dlamini only opposed the urgency of the application, which came before Makhanda high court Judge Justin Laing on 9 May. Dlamini claimed Chief Lunga Baleni had given it the stamp of approval. Baleni also approved the Xolobeni Mining Project that was stopped by the courts in 2018.

Read more in Daily Maverick: Battle to stop 22km long mine on Wild Coast

But Judge Laing issued the interdict, giving Dlamini until 6 June to make submissions why it should not be made final.

In terms of the order, Nero Dlamini and Vuyisile Dlamini are interdicted from building on any land in Sigidi Village, Mbizana, within one kilometre of the sea or tidal river, without getting the required consent from the community and a permit in terms of the Transkei Decree 9 of 1992.

In her affidavit, Nonhle Mbuthuma Forslund, spokesperson for the ACC, said the community had defended “our land” for generations, in the face of colonialism, apartheid, and a multinational mining company, through recognised customary law property rights.

On 22 April this year, a tractor-loader backhoe had begun to dig up a pristine site, overlooking the Mzamba Estuary, apparently at the behest of Nero Dlamini, she said.

“When challenged, he did not stop tearing up our land. Instead, he claimed that no woman — not even the iNkosana (headwoman) of Umgungundlovu, would prevent him from doing his work.”

Coastal conservation

Forslund said the coastal conservation area, established by the Transkei Decree, was no mere formality: “it protects our pristine, diverse and unique coastline”.

Attempts to reason with Dlamini — who is the headmaster of a local school — came to nought, she said. After women resorted to “using their bodies” to protect the land, the digging resumed on 3 May, this time led by Vuyisile Dlamini.

Forslund said land not specifically allocated to individuals is owned and used by the community through collective rights defined by customary law.

There was an “absolute prohibition” on intensive or commercial land use without specific authorisation, and consensus was especially crucial for decisions with potential for conflict or division.

Nero Dlamini, she said, had not been allocated any rights to the site. As a member of the community, he was entitled to be allocated a residential site through the same process as any community member, but not the site in question because it was used for grazing and was in the conservation area.

Knobkieries

According to Forslund’s affidavit, when first confronted by a group of women in April, Dlamini had told them to “go home and wash the dirt off”, telling them they were “uneducated”.

His relatives then arrived with knobkieries, according to Forslund. They beat several of the women. When the women asked where his Permission to Occupy certificate was, they were told this was a “men’s issue”.

Some elders heard their screams and came with their own knobkieries and spears.

Forslund said things calmed down. That evening seven women struck by the knobkierie, including herself, were treated at a local hospital.

After laying criminal charges, the investigating officer contacted Nero Dlamini who said that he had “bought the land” from his brother.

Forslund said from the extent of the land that was cleared, “it is more consistent with an intent to develop a business than a mere home”.

The committee’s lawyers immediately wrote a ‘cease and desist’ letter to Dlamini. They also wrote to the Provincial Department of Economic Development and Environmental Affairs and Tourism, which is responsible for enforcing Decree 9, seeking its intervention.

Men’s only meeting

Then on 1 May, iNkosi Lunga Baleni called a “men’s only” meeting“, and it became clear that he was not attempting to mediate the conflict but was there in support of Nero Dlamini,” Forslund wrote.

“iNkosi Baleni declared in the meeting that Mr Nero Dlamini must continue building inside the coastal conservation area … showing his rejection of Decree 9, the law that protects the Wild Coast … and promoting conflict.”

The clearing activities then resumed on 3 May.

The community believed representatives of the provincial department were on their way, but they did not arrive, Forslund wrote. However, Zeka Mnyamane, a former director of the mining company who is now employed by Sanral to promote the toll road, arrived and was allowed into the fenced area.

By then 50 members of the community had gathered outside the fence. Baleni was called but said he could not come as his wife was sick and refused to commit to a date when he could come to the area.

The community insisted that the clearing of the site was illegal and eventually, the tractor stopped work.

Forslund said the community was concerned that if Nero Dlamini was allowed to violate customary law with impunity, others might feel they could also claim land.

“This is not a remote concern … the land was stolen to make way for the Wild Coast Sun Resort and Casino and many outsiders have flooded in to ‘buy’ land adjacent to it with payments of a mere R10,000 …”

“We have some of the most pristine valuable land in all of South Africa. Many outsiders would jump at the chance to claim some for themselves.”

Dlamini in his affidavit said that he only received the court papers the day before the hearing. He only responded to dealing with the case being brought on an urgent basis. DM

First published by GroundUp.

Gallery
Absa OBP

Comments - Please in order to comment.

  • jcdville stormers says:

    And where is our useless goverment and their lapdog ,Anc woman’s League?Ruing the dollars they lost

  • Ryckard Blake says:

    Am I the only reader who does not know where in the Transkei Sigidi Village is ? According to Google Maps, Sigidi and Mbizana are more than 100km inland from the Wild Coast.
    Give us a point on a map, DM, rather than a pic of unspoiled land with the ocean just beyond.

    • Rudi Hillermann says:

      Having worked in KZN rural areas:
      1. Search for school/clinic/Hosp names – these institutions names are ‘never’ repeated, whereas area names are OFTEN repeated.
      2. Search for all the names which are used in an article – time-consuming, but in the absence of the use of ‘location GPS’ by journalists it will often assist in locating the area under discussion (eg ‘Mzamba Estuary’)

  • Marina Hall says:

    Having recently completed a hike along the Wild Coast and experienced the unspoiled natural beauty and splendour of the area, our local guides mentioned the internal struggles of the communities…some do not want the mines or roads to disrupt their largely peaceful way of life…they fear that the crime that plagues cities will reach them whereas others are keen to bring “progress” to the area.

    The ungraded unimaginably rough access road undoubtedly helps to preserve their inaccessibility and ultimately their way of life.

    Many of the local guides were incredibly knowledgeable but some had had no formal training and were self taught by reading Newman’s Birds and the Sappi Tree books. They care deeply about the preservation of this area.

    The communities have demarcated areas which allows employment opportunities through tourism to be spread among the various communities to avoid one group having a monopoly.

    The Wild Coast is truly a natural treasure that ought to be preserved for future generations. Let the community members decide what’s best for them as they have done a sterling job of protecting this area to date!

    • Gazeley Walker says:

      Am I reading correctly – a school principal is funding and building tis development? With what money – who is he fronting for? And how can an educated school principal, someone who is highly educated be so disparaging and disrespectful to the local woman folk? What is he teaching the young children in his care – that woman don’t count for anything and are there to be disrespected?
      I know the Eastern Cape coast, it is beautiful and everything possible should be done to halt this “opportunistic land invader. DM, maybe an investigation into who is really funding this venture will be be extremely interesting and enlightening, because a school headmaster on his own is unlikely to have the knowledge and finance to undertake such a project.

    • andrew farrer says:

      to b honest, i did a hike there a few years ago Further south than this area – Morgans bay), and what may once have pristine, beautiful . .. now pretty much fcuked up! Absolutley no birds. Why? because no fish. Why? because local population take flat coal shovels and scrape every living thing off the rocks, leaving nothing to grow to reproduce nor for the fish to feed on. And if that wasn’t bad enough, they sift the sand from tidal pools taking every living thing out. Won’t catch me back there in a hurry!

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted

A South African Hero: You

There’s a 99.7% chance that this isn’t for you. Only 0.3% of our readers have responded to this call for action.

Those 0.3% of our readers are our hidden heroes, who are fuelling our work and impacting the lives of every South African in doing so. They’re the people who contribute to keep Daily Maverick free for all, including you.

The equation is quite simple: the more members we have, the more reporting and investigations we can do, and the greater the impact on the country.

Be part of that 0.3%. Be a Maverick. Be a Maverick Insider.

Support Daily Maverick→
Payment options

MavericKids vol 3

How can a child learn to read if they don't have a book?

81% of South African children aged 10 can't read for meaning. You can help by pre-ordering a copy of MavericKids.

For every copy sold we will donate a copy to Gift of The Givers for children in need of reading support.