Our Burning Planet


Anger after trapped national park honey badger shot for catching pigeons

Anger after trapped national park honey badger shot for catching pigeons
A honey badger. (Photo: Supplied)

Underestimating the fury of a trapped ratel led to a killing at the West Coast National Park that should never have happened.

On the face of it, the issue was uncomplicated. Some racing pigeons were nabbed by a honey badger so it was trapped and shot. On closer investigation, however, the questions begin stacking up.

The honey badger (commonly known as a ratel) was a resident of the West Coast National Park. The pigeons belonged to Glen Johnson who is staying with his aunt and was given permission by the park a year ago to keep. But the local Churchhaven Homeowners Association (CHA) warned him it wasn’t a good idea because the area contained predators almost assured of being interested in fluttering, caged birds.

As far as can be pieced together from several often conflicting sources, the story unfolded like this… 

Three honey badgers came sniffing around. Johnson reinforced his cote, but almost nothing stops a determined ratel so one got in and he lost some birds.

The correct procedure would have been to inform the CHA, but instead, he called up park ranger William Brink, who, without informing his superior, senior ranger Pierre Nel, came over with a trap.

The correct procedure would have been to ask permission. If he had, says Nel, he would have been informed that the route to follow was to tell Johnson to remove his pigeons because a ranger’s primary responsibility was towards the park’s animals and not to a resident’s pigeons.

David Slingsby of the CHA agreed:

“If  Mr Johnson contacted us, we’d have said, sorry, there’s no catching of any badger. You have to sort out your birds because they and not the badger are the issue.”

The trap caught the honey badger and, being the creature it was, things rapidly went pear-shaped. The animal attacked the trap with extraordinary force. Even lions, it has been noted, are afraid of honey badgers. The trap, being made for lesser creatures, was in danger of coming apart as the furious creature lashed and clawed against its confinement.

Johnson and Brink tried to shore it up with bricks and rocks. Cape Nature, when contacted, told them to throw a blanket over the trap to try to calm it down. Any thought of removing the cage seemed out of the question because of the state of the cage and because anyone touching it was liable to lose their fingers.

At this point, the spectre of the badger escaping and turning on its captors occurred to the pair and Johnson, described as “a very forceful man”, demanded that it be shot. He said it was a threat to his family and his children, for which he would hold SANParks liable.

At some point, the police were called and the story gets murky. One version is that a policeman shot the badger. Another version, purportedly corroborated by a resident, is that the policeman refused to fire his 9mm service pistol in a built-up area, so Brink grabbed the weapon and shot the animal. Neither version has been confirmed and inquiries are ongoing.

Are there consequences? The CHA is furious and may be considering charging Johnson under the Animal Cruelty Act. Cape Nature and the SPCA have asked for and been given a report and are considering the options.

Pierre Nel is doing a manful job trying to manage the situation, but admits things went badly wrong and that Brink is on the carpet.

“The long and short of it is the men were scared of being mauled so they shot the animal. Johnson should have first informed the CHA but went directly to Brink. He set the trap without informing his superiors.

“It’s unheard of for Parks to prioritise someone’s private pigeons over animals we’re expected to protect. It’s not the right thing. The actions weren’t best practice.

“Brink and Johnson should not have communicated with each other. Johnson should have gone to the homeowners and Brink should have come to us and said we got a problem. In no circumstances should Brink have engaged directly with the landowner. If he’d acted correctly there would have never been a trap set.

“We’ll deal with it internally through our disciplinary process and we need to sort out Johnson’s pigeons. This time it’s a honey badger, next time it will be a caracal, then an African wild cat, then another badger and we’ll be back to square one. This can’t happen again,” said Nel.

The Homeowners Association wants the pigeons gone. “We’re highly unhappy about this,” said Slingsby.

“Our chairman is going to write to Johnson saying his right to keep pigeons has been rescinded and if there are any pigeons left, he must get rid of them. And I think his cote is also an illegal building.”

Of course, none of this will be of any use to the dead honey badger, but it might make things safer for what remains of its family in the future. DM/OBP

Absa OBP

Comments - Please in order to comment.

  • Marianne McKay says:

    People like Johnson should not be staying in a National Park.
    He should be in nice, safe, built-up, brick and concrete-covered suburbia with all the lights on behind a big electric fence with his birds in their little house.
    Get him back where he belongs. Keep him and his kind out of wilderness areas.

  • Timothy Van Blerck says:

    Pigeons are flying rats – the honey badger was performing a public service RIP

  • Glyn Morgan says:

    Get rid of those pigeons! Get rid of Johnson!

  • Diane Cameron says:

    This is a tragedy, the person who is meant to protect wild animals has failed in his duty. He needs to find a new job as he certainly has not done what he was paid to do. Johnson should never have been allowed to keep pigeons in Nature reserve either, what were they thinking ….

  • Stuart Woodhead says:

    Both Johnson and Cape Nature are to blame. It is disgusting that such an incredibly beautiful and clever wild animal should have been shot to satisfy some wealthy persons desire to keep pigeons in a nature reserve.
    Get the pigeons and Johnson out of there. Johnson should be ashamed of himself!!

  • Neesa Moodley says:

    Save the badgers, lose the pigeons. The resident should find alternative accommodation for his pigeons off the nature reserve and feel free to join them if he is upset about it.

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted

[%% img-description %%]

The Spy Bill: An autocratic roadmap to State Capture 2.0

Join Heidi Swart in conversation with Anton Harber and Marianne Merten as they discuss a concerning push to pass a controversial “Spy Bill” into law by May 2024. Tues 5 Dec at 12pm, live, online and free of charge.

A South African Hero: You

There’s a 99.8% chance that this isn’t for you. Only 0.2% of our readers have responded to this call for action.

Those 0.2% of our readers are our hidden heroes, who are fuelling our work and impacting the lives of every South African in doing so. They’re the people who contribute to keep Daily Maverick free for all, including you.

The equation is quite simple: the more members we have, the more reporting and investigations we can do, and the greater the impact on the country.

Be part of that 0.2%. Be a Maverick. Be a Maverick Insider.

Support Daily Maverick→
Payment options