Maverick Life


Netflix psychiatrist Phil Stutz says 85% of early therapy gains are down to lifestyle changes. Is he right?

Netflix psychiatrist Phil Stutz says 85% of early therapy gains are down to lifestyle changes. Is he right?
Jonah Hill and his therapist Phil Stutz, as pictured in 'Stutz' on Netflix. Image: Stutz / Netflix / Supplied

Changing your eating, exercising, socialising and engagement with nature can help treat depression. Now mental health professionals have some guidelines to shape treatment around lifestyle therapies.

Jonah Hill’s Netflix documentary, Stutz, is an insightful journey into the mind of his therapist, renowned psychiatrist Phil Stutz. Hill delves into Stutz’ model of care, creatively using visual depictions of key concepts and “tools” drawn by Stutz himself.

This model is founded upon one’s relationship with their physical body. When he’s discussing the importance of health behaviours like exercise, diet and sleep, Stutz estimates 85% of the initial gains to someone with mental health concerns commencing therapy can come from focusing on these “lifestyle” factors. Surprised, Hill says in the film:

“When I was a kid, exercise and diet was framed to me in like, ‘there’s something wrong with how you look’. But never once was exercise or diet propositioned to me in terms of mental health. I just wish that was presented to people differently. Because for me, that caused a lot of problems.”

So, is Stutz right?

What does the latest evidence tell us?

While the 85% figure is debatable, there is now good evidence therapies targeting lifestyle factors can be a critical part of treating psychiatric conditions such as depression. A recent meta-analysis (which brings together results from different research studies) shows exercise may be as powerful as anti-depressant medication for depression.

Our own research shows a modified Mediterranean diet can substantially improve symptoms and functioning of people living with moderate to severe depression. The mental health benefits of these interventions occur independent of weight loss, can be used in combination with medications (such as antidepressants or antipsychotics) and are cost-effective because of societal gains such as increased workplace productivity.

And the benefits of these approaches can be experienced relatively quickly, with effects evident in as little as three weeks. Lifestyle changes can reduce the risk of common conditions such as heart disease and diabetes, which contribute to the 20-year life expectancy gap for those experiencing mental illness. The strength of the evidence means it has now been cited in key policy documentsadvocacy and clinical practice guidelines in Europe and the United Kingdom. (…)

Despite all of this, this approach has not been comprehensively taken up by mainstream mental health-care providers.

Supporting clinicians

The use of lifestyle therapies is a reasonably new area to psychiatry compared to other treatments such as antidepressant medication or talk therapy with psychologists. Our randomised control trial showing diet can be a treatment strategy for depression mentioned previously was the first of its kind and was only completed in 2017. There are various barriers to its translation in mental health care: training, funding, access and variability in quality given the historical absence of guidelines.

In October, we published the first international guidelines that can be used across any clinical setting – from general practices, to specialist mental health care and by dietitians – in any country. They cover nine established and emerging lifestyle “pillars” to support whole-of-person care. These are:

  1. physical activity and exercise – improving aerobic and resistance training, yoga, reducing sedentary behaviors
  2. relaxation techniques – such as guided breathing exercises
  3. engaging (or re-engaging) with employment or volunteering
  4. getting enough sleep
  5. mindfulness-based therapies and stress management (including coping skills)
  6. healthy diet that includes intake of a wide variety of plant-based whole foods and minimises highly processed foods
  7. quitting smoking
  8. improving social connections
  9. interaction with nature – in green spaces such as forests and parks, and blue spaces like the ocean or creeks and rivers.

Clinicians can shape their approach in four key ways:

  • increase lifestyle and social assessments. Our guidelines contain a list of recommended tools to capture changes in a patient’s health behaviours across the course of therapy as well as social screening tools to help understand their socioeconomic backdrop (such as stable housing, access to resources)
  • get input from allied health professionals (such as dietitians or exercise physiologists), patients’ support networks including other health professionals, community, family, carers and peers. It’s important to know, for example, how someone’s household or neighbourhood may shape their ability to give up smoking
  • identify behavioural change strategies. Each individual will have a different mindset in terms of their openness to changing their behaviours. Clinicians can use the guidelines to identify the best strategies for different individuals
  • help reduce stigma and/or assumptions that lifestyle is a choice. Instead, understand and explain to patients how individual, social and commercial factors can play a role and make it harder for them to make changes. This can make it feel less like a personal responsibility or fault and help navigate realistic changes.

Still more to understand

While these guidelines and resources are an important first step, there are key questions in this field that remain unanswered. These include how to best personalise treatments using a person’s unique physiology, genetics, demographics, background and individual preferences.

We need to examine how this approach compares to gold-standard care such as psychotherapy, especially for more severe depression. We are currently testing this question and recruiting participants for a national trial. It is important to note medication and other therapies can play an important role in mental health treatment. Medications should not be ceased or changed without consulting a medical professional. We have also created a course for health professionals who want additional support.

For now, our guidelines provide a way for health professionals to begin addressing Jonah Hill’s point – that lifestyle factors should be presented to people as critical to their mental health. DM/ML 

This story was first published in The Conversation.

Adrienne O’Neil is a Professor & Co-Director of the Food & Mood Centre at Deakin University. Sam Manger is a Senior lecturer at James Cook University. Wolfgang Marx is a Senior research fellow at Deakin University.

Visit Daily Maverick’s home page for more news, analysis and investigations



Comments - Please in order to comment.

  • Sean KALISKI says:

    So, genetics, stress, personality style, trauma etc are not really important? If only humans were ever so simple that facile panaceas could be prescribed for all. Most depressed people get better without interventions (which is why placebos are often also effective). As a psychiatrist I have anecdotally encountered fitness and health fanatics who also get depressed. The problem with most research is that the number of factors that separately or combination potentially be culprits is so vast that studies would have to follow hundreds of thousands of subjects. Clearly this would be almost impossible to do. Therefore most studies trumpet their results based on too few subjects. The Gordian knot for psychiatry.

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted

We would like our readers to start paying for Daily Maverick...

…but we are not going to force you to. Over 10 million users come to us each month for the news. We have not put it behind a paywall because the truth should not be a luxury.

Instead we ask our readers who can afford to contribute, even a small amount each month, to do so.

If you appreciate it and want to see us keep going then please consider contributing whatever you can.

Support Daily Maverick→
Payment options