First Thing, Daily Maverick's flagship newsletter

Join the 230 000 South Africans who read First Thing newsletter.

Maverick Citizen

LEARNING GAP OP-ED

Even before the pandemic, pupils were falling behind – how can we achieve a fundamental catch-up?

Teachers and support staff queue for the Covid-19 vaccine at Universitas Hospital in Bloemfontein on 24 June 2021. (Photo: Gallo Images / Volksblad / Mlungisi Louw)

We urgently need a framework to support pupils who have been chronically falling behind – even before the pandemic. There are international examples of how to implement this in Burundi, Liberia and Sierra Leone with accelerated learning programmes.

Learning loss. We’ve heard this term a fair number of times since the Covid-19 pandemic began. It’s commonly understood as a specific or general loss of knowledge and skills, or a reversal in academic progress because of gaps in a pupil’s education. On radio, television and in newspapers, education researchers and experts used the term to describe the impact of disrupted schooling on our country’s pupils over the past two years.

Despite the uptick in the use of the phrase in public discourse, learning losses in South Africa precede the pandemic. For thousands of pupils, school closures, absent teachers, crumbling infrastructure, extreme weather conditions, community protests and struggles to catch up to the curriculum have kept them from classes before.

In addition, six out of 10 children are considered multidimensionally poor; their socioeconomic circumstances affect their pathways through school, their ability to learn and access opportunities. This is evident when eight out of 10 children in Grade 4 cannot read for meaning in any language. They are not faring much better in maths either. A 2019 study found that roughly 41% of pupils had basic maths skills. These statistics tell us that even before the pandemic, many children had weak foundational learning.

Without the basic skills to grasp the curriculum, many pupils begin to chronically underperform for their age and grade. This is apparent in high rates of grade repetition nationally. In high school, the number of pupils repeating grades more than doubles. Among those in grades 10 to 12, about 20% are three or more years overage, having repeated grades. High repetition leads to pupils becoming overage for their class, increasing their likelihood of dropping out.

Considering the complex context detailed in the preceding paragraphs, as a country we should be looking to solutions that are bold enough to abandon pre-existing scripts. To quote education writer Valerie Strauss of The Washington Post, that which is lost cannot be found in “pre-written tests of pre-specified knowledge or pre-existing measures of pre-coronavirus notions of achievement”.

In the boldness of the author’s statement lies an invitation for public dialogue about how to change the trajectories of pupils who are chronically falling behind – pandemic or not – so that they are able to keep their grip on opportunity. In the boldness of the author’s statement lies an opportunity.

Accelerated learning programmes

In various countries, governments and civil society have turned to accelerated learning programmes (ALPs) to support overage children in different circumstances, with considerable success in meeting the needs of vulnerable groups and learning outcomes.

Read in Daily Maverick: “Read and weep – Covid lockdowns leave South Africa’s pupils far behind in maths and language

ALPs target those who are out of school or overage for their grade. Many were initiated in response to a crisis, usually a conflict, such as in Burundi, Sierra Leone and Liberia. Typically, ALPs focus on primary education; the classes are relatively small, and facilitators are community volunteers who receive training. According to Unesco, the most common rate of acceleration is for two grades of primary school to be covered by one year of an accelerated learning programme.

While accelerated learning programmes are often time-bound, they can become permanent features of an education system like in Bangladesh with the BRAC (Bangladesh Rural Advancement Committee) model. BRAC had an interesting start; it began with a functional literacy programme for adults in the mid-1970s when it became evident that without a literate population, people were not able to take advantage of income-generating activities, public health and other social services.

Different teaching methodologies set ALPs apart from other after-school programmes, weekend classes or holiday classes. For instance, here in South Africa, the practice of Teaching at the Right Level (TaRL) is at the centre of the Reading for Meaning programme, initiated by the Zero Dropout Campaign and supported by the DG Murray Trust.

Reading for Meaning focuses on a child’s learning needs rather than their age or grade to support pupils who missed key literacy and numeracy concepts early in life. The programme runs after-school sessions with Grade 5s in low-resource communities in the Eastern Cape, the Western Cape and KwaZulu-Natal by training community volunteers, known as Reader Leaders, to facilitate sessions over 16 weeks.

Partnerships are key

We can learn from these examples to develop an adaptable framework to fit the needs of our pupils. Civil society should play a leading role in partnership with communities, the basic education sector and investors. To do so, civil society organisations should have the authority to run accelerated learning programmes with the necessary checks and balances in place. In addition, they should be able to adapt their approaches based on experience of how their programmes are implemented, with flexible investment from funders.

Over the years, international comparison tests have shown that a young person learning in South Africa lags those in countries with fewer economic resources. This poor performance – and the gap between the rich and poor – will continue to widen until there is greater equity in the delivery of quality public education. DM/MC

Senzo Hlophe is Director: Strategic Operations at the DG Murray Trust (DGMT), Rahima Essop is DGMT’s Communications Director and Pumza Ndamase is the Project Lead for the Reading for Meaning programme.

Gallery

"Information pertaining to Covid-19, vaccines, how to control the spread of the virus and potential treatments is ever-changing. Under the South African Disaster Management Act Regulation 11(5)(c) it is prohibited to publish information through any medium with the intention to deceive people on government measures to address COVID-19. We are therefore disabling the comment section on this article in order to protect both the commenting member and ourselves from potential liability. Should you have additional information that you think we should know, please email [email protected]"

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted