South Africa

Letter to the Editor: UCT group reply

By Daily Maverick 18 January 2017

The undersigned argue that UCT progressive alumni’s support for a restorative justice approach is based on a sober analysis of social justice related violence reduction opportunities.

We would like to thank Prof Philip Lloyd, DG Scott, Andrew Kenny, Maciej Soltynski and AP Berrisford for illustrating, in the focus of their letter, precisely how difficult it is to look “beneath the surface” of manifest behaviour in which protesters all over the world engage, especially in the presence and visible face of power and authority which has been wielded over them, unquestioned, for more than a century.

The “trio” whom they refer to volunteered to represent the thoughts of a larger group of alumni who have, for the past two years, shared their ongoing concerns about occurrences at UCT as well as providing such advice and facilitation within their means as current and former academics, employees, professionals and post-graduate students.

Our letter, for instance, based as it was on experiences of exclusion, alienation and discrimination during the sojourns of many of us at UCT, produced in an iterative process and distilled to that which Lloyd et al refer, reflects the thrust of our constructive interventions, eg at the UCT Cape Town Alumni Chapter.

In our previous letter to Daily Maverick we extended an invitation to other alumni – who may hold a different view based on their life experiences – to join us in supporting the possibility of a peaceful, constructive resolution of trans-historical injustices. The students and executive are attempting, via a restorative justice approach, to do exactly that. It is an intervention such as this inclusive, reflective and honest process which we unstintingly advocate and support.

We repeat that invitation here, and hope you will join us in our support of this brave attempt to go “beneath the surface” of protest action, to face its trans-historic roots. Renewed alumni interest is part of the positive spin-offs of radical flank effects.

This is not about us and our different perspectives. It is about our common future in this society, of which the students are an integral part.

We are sure you agree that protests around the world send a message. The onus is on societies to decode it and to respond to the deeper need. Once we extend the progressive flank to support all efforts that deal honestly and decisively with trans-historical causes, the need for radical tactics will fall away. DM


Yvette Abrahams
Glenn Allies

Karen Daniels
Linda Diedericks

Carnita Ernest

Edwina Goliath

Adam Haupt
Clinton Herring
Sarah Henkeman

Jonathan Hoffenberg

Lorna Houston
June Knight
Robert Kriger
Stephen Langtry
Valmont Layne

Mary-Ann Naidoo

Ncedisa Nkonyeni
Nadira Omarjee

Melvin Rautenbach
Peter Schaupp
Marion Stevens
Ezelle Theunissen
Caz Thomas
Vicki Trowler

Hylton White

Gallery

SCORPIO 168

Department of Health suspends dodgy R82m Covid-19 communications contract

By Pieter-Louis Myburgh for Scorpio