Interview: Ebrahim Ebrahim on SA relations with North Korea
- Khadija Patel
- 26 Nov 2013 (South Africa)
KHADIJA PATEL sat down for a cup of coffee and a chat about North Korea with South Africa’s Deputy Minister of International Relations and Co-operation, Ebrahim Ebrahim.
Deputy Minister of International Relations and Co-Operation Ebrahim Ebrahim caused quite a flap recently when he visited Pyongyang. Human rights agencies pressed the South African delegation to raise human rights issues with their North Korean counterparts. Others were perplexed: is North Korea the type of company we really want to keep on the international stage?
Daily Maverick: Apart from the satisfaction of thumbing one’s nose at the West, just what does South Africa hope to gain from relations with North Korea?
Ebrahim Ebrahim: We have diplomatic relations with them like we have diplomatic relations with many other countries in the world. And of course NK has a history of supporting the liberation movement in the past. And when we have diplomatic relations with a country there are obviously visits. With NK, unfortunately we have not had any high level visits. The last visit was by Deputy Minister Aziz Pahad in 2005. And they kept inviting us, their deputy minister came to see us, and I think even the South Koreans were keen that we visit NK. And of course there’s not much trade or economic activity going on [between SA and NK] because of the long sanctions by the US, which have been re-enforced by the UN Security Council.
So economically there’s not much that goes on.
We raised the question of their nuclear programme. And we felt that our own experience was that we did away with our nuclear weapons and we saw the benefits of that. We don’t believe having nuclear weapons provides any security. We want a nuclear-free peninsula.
Of course, they came out with a long argument, that they are threatened by the United States all the time and by South Korea.
They seriously think they are going to be attacked. And the only defence they say is to have nuclear weapons. They said that Iraq and Libya would not be attacked if they had nuclear weapons because it’s a guarantee of security.
Of course we didn’t agree with them, but this is what they said.
We encouraged them to go back to the six party talks.
DM: And how did they respond?
Ebrahim: They said yes, but they kept on saying that the Americans are not honest. And they want to destroy them.
There is some progress [being made]. There was a Chinese special envoy there, encouraging them to go back to the six party talks.
Then, we also encouraged them to allow family visits between the two sides. They took note of that. And what we felt and what the other western countries, and some of the other western countries we met, said - it’s important that there is one message communicated from the international community.
Also, we wanted to see what the country is like.
DM: What was the country like?
Ebrahim: Pyongyang looked to be developing quite well. Lots and lots of building there. You can drive for miles - you’ll find skyscrapers and the like.
It seems they’ve solved the housing problem. They said to us, and we couldn’t confirm it independently, that people stay without rent. Somebody said they pay three per cent of their salary, [but] they don’t pay for water, electricity, medical care, education.
Pyongyang is a very clean place. The Egyptians are building a huge hotel there, about 114 stories, in the shape of a pyramid. I think this will be a commercial building.
There’s a lot of cultural activity going on. While we were there, there was a soccer team from Japan there. We saw some beautiful gymnastics.
They had a bumper harvest this year, but we couldn’t get a feel of the economy, of economic progress.
DM: They do have chronic food shortages. How are they coping with that?
They had a bumper harvest this year. But we met a South African working there with the UN in agricultural research. And he told us that it is a very hilly country. There are valleys which must accommodate people and farming. And the weather is very unpredictable. It’s the same with South Korea. South Korea imports 70% of its food. It’s also a very hilly country. So with [North Korea], they don’t have the money to import so much food.
Everything is state-owned, though. The hotel we stayed in is state-owned. You could see that – breakfast was not a buffet. You get a yoghurt and two slices of toast, that’s all.
But they are a poor country.
They’ve got a very good metro system, train system. Our ambassador, who accompanied us, was last there two years ago, and he said there is a tremendous difference now in the developments and the buildings going up. They are building a special dental hospital. They’ve got a big building where scientists are staying. You see the army here in big groups going to these cultural shows. Everything is done with inspiration from Kim Il Sung or Kim Yung.
They hero-worship the leader.
DM: Following this visit, is South Africa now in a position to influence North Korea on things like human rights or persuade them on nuclear disarmament?
Ebrahim: I don’t think South Africa can persuade them. I met the British ambassador there – Britain has full diplomatic relations with North Korea – and he said, ‘Look, it’s important that whoever meets them comes with the same message.’ I don’t think South Africa is in position to persuade them but the Chinese are coming there with the same message. It’s important everyone gives the same message. In that sense they should know our position.
We raised the question of human rights as well.
There are also allegations of human rights violations. Of course they denied it saying it’s all imperialist propaganda. So we approached it by saying there’s a lot of negative publicity about the human rights track record. You say that, so why don’t you allow us to come and help with human rights. We are prepared to send our Human Rights Commission there to look at the country, to see if there are labour camps or not. They took note of that but didn’t say anything positive.
But that is a thing we can pursue.
DM: So how does South Africa hope this relationship with North Korea can develop?
There’s no trade relationship, but if the six party talks succeed…
Also, they were speaking about special economic zones. They’ve got one called Kaesong, where the South Koreans are involved, so they want some kind of investments, joint-ventures, which may open up the country. [Last Thursday North Korea announced it is setting up 14 new economic development zones, including one in a north-western city that borders China in an apparent bid to attract more foreign investment.]
DM: Some South Africans may be curious to visit to North Korea. Would it be possible for South Africans?
Ebrahim: I think so. They like visitors. As I said, the Chinese are there; there are other eastern Europeans there. But it’s not a tourist thing.
We got stuck there, waiting for six days for a flight to Beijing.
They’ll allow visitors, but of course you’ll have a translator or guide with you all the time. They are very paranoid. They think genuinely that they are under threat. DM
- South Africa and North Korea: ‘With friends like these…’ in Daily Maverick
- North Korea and Israel: SA’s strange foreign policy double standard in Daily Maverick.
Photo: Deputy Minister of International Relations and Cooperation Ebrahim Ebrahim holds a news conference on Tuesday, 13 November 2012 in Pretoria on international developments. Picture: Department of International Relations, Cooperation/SAPA
Reader notice: Our comments service provider, Civil Comments, has stopped operating and will terminate services on 20th Dec 2017. As a result, we will be searching for another platform for our readers. We aim to have this done with the launch of our new site in early 2018 and apologise for the inconvenience.