Do any of the members of the ANC's 1997-2002 NEC now regret the way they heckled and jeered Madiba at an NEC meeting in March 2002?
Andrew Feinstein in his book After the Party: A personal and political journey inside the ANC (Jonathan Ball Publishers, 2007), briefly describes the incident and the build up to it (pages 139-140). Mandela was seemingly being characterised at the time as a ‘meddling old man’ who was ‘out of touch.’ This was primarily in the context of HIV/AIDS and then President Mbeki’s denialism. The onslaught on Madiba was led by Peter Mokaba – who died that year.
In a Sunday Times op-ed on 19 October 2008, Mr Ngoako Ramatlhodi, exposed further details of how Madiba had been humiliated at the NEC meeting in 2002. This article seems to be no longer available on the Sunday Times website. Khaya Dlanga takes Mr Ramatlhodi to task for having remained silent during the attack on Madiba, and all the intervening years. He quotes Mr Ramatlhodi as saying that none of the senior leaders present had the courage to stand up and defend an innocent old man who was ‘being violated in the most brutal manner by junior leaders of the movement.’
The National Chairperson of the ANC at the time, who presided over the meeting, was Mr Terror Lekota.
Another mention of this incident is made by Mpumelelo Mkhabela in the DispatchOnline of May 23 2013 in an article about the Gupta’s use of Waterkloof Air Force base as their own private airport. He quotes Ramatlhodi as saying that the ANC members were ‘wild, aggressive and merciless against their former president.’
The whole incident could ironically be described as a bizarre show of ‘unity’ and ‘social cohesion.’ I think it demonstrates the danger of staying silent when clearly an injustice is in progress.
I have been wondering if any of the members of the NEC involved ever apologised to Madiba or asked for his forgiveness – either for their hostility, or for their fear and cowardice in remaining silent during the ‘onslaught.’. It is unlikely that we will ever be told.
The ANC website conveniently lists the members of the 1997-2002 NEC in the report delivered at its 51st conference. Some members resigned during that time due to re-deployment elsewhere so we cannot know if they were part of the viciousness. Mr Ramatlhodi himself had resigned in order to take up the position of Provincial Chairperson of Limpopo’s ANC and may therefore only have been present in an ‘ex-officio’ capacity. This is not clear. Others became ill or died (like Peter Mokaba). The “top six” of the ANC at the time, who were most likely present, were then President Thabo Mbeki; then Deputy President Jacob Zuma; then Secretary General Kgalema Motlanthe; then Deputy Secretary General Thenjiwe Mtintso; and then Treasurer General Mendi Msimang.
It seems that of today’s “top six” ANC officials, the Chairperson, Ms Baleka Mbete, and the Secretary General, Mr Gwede Mantashe, were not involved in that shameful NEC meeting. It is reasonable to assume that President Zuma, Mr Cyril Ramaphosa, Ms Jesse Duarte and Dr Zweli Mkhize were all present – and kept quiet.
Surprises on the list – some who may today perhaps be having regrets about their behaviour – are Mr Collins Chabane, Rev Frank Chikane, Mr Jeremy Cronin, Ms Frene Ginwala, Mr Derek Hanekom, Mr Pallo Jordan, Mr Ronnie Kasrils, Ms Brigitte Mabandla, Mr Trevor Manuel, Mr Amos Masondo, Rev Smangaliso Mkhatshwa, Ms Thandi Modise, Mr Jay Naidoo, Mr Blade Nzimande, Ms Lindiwe Sisulu, Mr Max Sisulu, Dr Nkosozana Dlamini-Zuma.
According to Khaya Dlanga, Ramatlhodi’s article elicited a response from our Minister of Justice and Constitutional Development, Mr Jeff Radebe. Dlanga states that Mr Radebe ‘savaged Lekota for having presided over that meeting and for having allowed Madiba to be treated in the manner he was.’ But as Dlanga rightly points out – Mr Radebe himself was present at the meeting and did not speak out! He is listed as an NEC member of that era. So did Mr Radebe choke up in Parliament this week, not only because of genuine grief for Madiba, but possibly also a regret at not having stood up for him at that notorious ANC March 2002 NEC meeting? DM
This column was first published by our friends at GroundUp.
Read more: Minister Trevor Manuel acknowledges his “eternal shame” for not trying to defend Madiba at this NEC meeting, and that no one else present tried to defend Madiba – though his memory gets the date wrong. See near the end of “A Madiba story” in Business Day.
Read more about community life in Khayelitsha and other Cape townships on GroundUp.
While we have your attention...
An increasingly rare commodity, quality independent journalism costs money, though not nearly as much as its absence can cost global community. No country can live and prosper without truth - that's why it matters.
Every Daily Maverick article and every Scorpio exposé are our contribution to this unshakeable mission. It is by far the most effective investment into South Africa's future.
Join our mission to become a Maverick Insider. Together we can Defend Truth.
Roy Jobson is a medical doctor specialist in clinical pharmacology. He is an Associate Professor of Pharmacology in the Faculty of Pharmacy at Rhodes University. His research over the last 8 years has focussed on misleading advertising of medicines in South Africa - with an emphasis on unregistered complementary and alternative medicines. He was appointed a Council member of the Allied Health Professions Council of South Africa, as a community representative, by the Minister of Health in 2011. He is a member of the Neil Aggett Support Group, and an associate of the Khulumani Support Group. He believes that health professionals have a moral obligation to speak out against injustice wherever they come across it.
In the final two years of his life Van Gogh averaged about three paintings per week.