First Thing, Daily Maverick's flagship newsletter

Join the 230 000 South Africans who read First Thing newsletter.

‘Phala Phala is fast becoming your Nkandla,’ Steenh...

South Africa


‘Phala Phala is fast becoming your Nkandla,’ Steenhuisen tells Ramaphosa in disrupted debate

President Cyril Ramaphosa addresses the National Assembly Plenary Sitting at the Good Hope Chamber at Parliament. The EFF disrupted Ramaphosa’s speech numerous times, wanting clarity on the issue of millions of dollars allegedly stolen from his home in 2020. 09 June 2022. Photo: Shelley Christians

After an hour of EFF MPs’ interjections, when all were muted online or physically removed from the House, President Cyril Ramaphosa delivered what essentially was a State of the Nation 2.0.

That disruptions hit President Cyril Ramaphosa’s Presidency Budget Vote on Thursday wasn’t really a surprise – EFF leader Julius Malema had warned of this a day earlier. A hint had also emerged during Tuesday’s Parliament Budget Vote debate

In 2014, the call was: “Pay back the money”, for then president Jacob Zuma to do as the Public Protector said – to repay money spent on so-called security upgrades of the cattle kraal, chicken run, amphitheatre and swimming pool at his Nkandla homestead. 

On Thursday it was: “We will not listen to a money launderer and a criminal”, in relation to the February 2020 theft of forex stuffed into sofa cushions on the President’s Phala Phala farm in Limpopo. 

The interruptions were rowdy, raucous and persistent.  

Anthony Matumba from the EFF is thrown out of the National Assembly Plenary Sitting at the Good Hope Chamber in Parliament on 09 June 2022. (Photo: Shelley Christians)
The EFF’s Anthony Matumba reacts during the National Assembly Plenary Sitting at the Good Hope Chamber in Parliament on 9 June 2022. (Photo: Shelley Christians)

These scenes in the House could have been avoided had the President  come clean about the circumstances surrounding the forex and the theft, said DA leader John Steenhuisen. 

“Phala Phala is fast becoming your Nkandla,” he said, pointing also to the “blurring of the line between Mr Ramaphosa, the head of state, and Mr Ramaphosa, the businessman”.  

“Do you recall the shame of Nkandla and the arrogance of your predecessor? Do you remember the embarrassment of the fire pool video and all the shameless defending done by the members in these ANC benches? Do you remember the scathing rebuke our Parliament received for failing to hold the president accountable?” the DA leader asked. 

Steenhuisen pointed out that while the police budget had been slashed, the allocation for the Presidential Protection Service had been boosted. 

“We are told these precious police resources have been put to work serving the private business interests of the President – conducting secret cross-border investigations, interrogations and cover-ups. 

“I’m sure you’ll agree, Mr President, South Africans have a right to know if you are using your VIP Protection Unit as a private debt collection agency.” 

What the saga has shown clearly is that the Presidency, which has no parliamentary committee to account to, cannot police itself. 

If, as Ramaphosa said, it was all above board, then “stuffing millions into couches, hiding the robbery from the police and paying the robbers hundreds of thousands of rand to not say a word”, were not the actions of a man with nothing on his conscience. 

“These are the things we see in Mafia movies about cartels and syndicates and gangsters,” said Steenhuisen, later adding that no one in South Africa wanted “a two-bit mob boss with houses stuffed full of dirty cash for a president”, but someone who put personal ambition second to the country’s needs. 

“The presidency is not yours. It belongs to the Republic of South Africa. When you drag the presidency into the gutter, you drag our country down too. South Africans don’t want this and they don’t deserve this.” 

Predictably, the ANC came out in support of the President, who stayed silent on the saga, preferring to recount his administration’s track record, works in progress and social compacting.  

But Ramaphosa coordinated with his deputy, David “DD” Mabuza, on the line that South Africans were not interested in political squabbles, with a ministerial chorus line of everyone joining to rebuild and renew. 

“What people of South Africa want above all is to see the quality of life improving. They do not care about the political squabbles, about the competition between political parties, rivalries, plots and intrigue,” Ramaphosa said. 

Mabuza echoed this: “South Africans are disinterested in our political disputes, divisions, and slogans.” 

An EFF member of Parliament is thrown out of the National Assembly Plenary Sitting at the Good Hope Chamber in Parliament on 9 June 2022. (Photo: Shelley Christians)
An EFF member disrupts proceedings during the National Assembly Plenary Sitting at the Good Hope Chamber in Parliament on 9 June 2022. (Photo: Shelley Christians)

Speaking on the farm forex saga was left to Minister in the Presidency Mondli Gungubele, who reiterated that his boss was not facing any charges and had pledged to cooperate with all investigations. 

The minister seemed to take umbrage that no one was concerned about Ramaphosa’s security – the President was at an African Union summit in Addis Ababa at the time of the theft at his farm – or about the President being a victim of crime. 

Earlier, ANC Chief Whip Pemmy Majodina took the same line. “At the moment there are no charges and we are happy the President has committed to support the work of the law enforcement agencies.” 

The broad sweep of deflection had emerged hours before Ramaphosa stepped to the podium in Parliament’s Good Hope Chamber for the Presidency Budget Vote debate. 

At Parliament, National Assembly Speaker Nosiviwe Mapisa-Nqakula told the Thursday programming committee she was still considering requests for a parliamentary inquiry into the forex theft saga from the United Democratic Movement (UDM) and African Transformation Movement (ATM). 

Majodina bluntly said: “That is not within the rules anywhere… allegations on a case that is not with us. On what basis should we act?” 

The Cabinet had decided to await the outcome of investigations by law enforcement and financial institutions after being briefed by Ramaphosa, according to Gungubele in a televised briefing in which he answered journalists’ questions about Wednesday’s Cabinet meeting. The official statement was silent on this. 

“The approach is, let’s leave it to all those institutions until we are clarified what the outcome is going to be, then we can cross that bridge when we reach it…” 

And the ANC’s Luthuli House agreed, saying Ramaphosa stepping down was not an option yet. 

“When you are indicted, in other words, you are appearing in the court of law, that is the only time a member will step aside. When matters are raised in the public domain… without failure, expeditiously, you must appear before the Integrity Commission. And our President has done so,” ANC National Executive Committee member and Deputy Water and Sanitation Minister David Mahlobo told eNCA after a policy discussion document briefing. 

Across party and state, ranks are being closed around Ramaphosa. This should not be a surprise. Ramaphosa is a vote-catcher – various public opinion polls put his popularity well above that of the ANC. The 2024 elections are loading.  

On Thursday, Ramaphosa, in a rare moment, was blunt about centralising powers in his office since his term began in February 2018. 

What we have sought to do over the past four years is to locate the Presidency at the centre of an integrated government. From this centre, we have been leading the drive to reconstruct the nation’s economy in a manner that is inclusive and that leaves no one behind.” 

But Ramaphosa also said that various reform initiatives his Presidency was pursuing, including in investment, infrastructure, employment, climate change, jobs and red tape reduction, were supportive and collaborative. 

“Ultimately, it is departments and not the Presidency that implement policy,” said the President. 

That’s a fudging which, like the blurring of the lines between Ramaphosa the President and Ramaphosa the farmer, as he self-describes, is set to come back to haunt him. 

Perhaps to deflect the controversy, the Presidency announced that Ramaphosa had suspended with immediate effect Public Protector Busisiwe Mkhwebane amid the parliamentary impeachment inquiry. 

On Friday, Ramaphosa will have the final say, in his reply to the Presidency Budget Vote. DM



Comments - share your knowledge and experience

Please note you must be a Maverick Insider to comment. Sign up here or sign in if you are already an Insider.

Everybody has an opinion but not everyone has the knowledge and the experience to contribute meaningfully to a discussion. That’s what we want from our members. Help us learn with your expertise and insights on articles that we publish. We encourage different, respectful viewpoints to further our understanding of the world. View our comments policy here.

All Comments 3

  • Deflect, deflect, deflect. We are taken as a nation of Phala-Phala-***** wits. Just wait, inexplicably delayed/ unpaid social grants will miraculously get unplugged. If you can’t win our minds, bribe the asses.

  • “What we have sought to do over the past four years is to locate the Presidency at the centre of an integrated government. From this centre, we have been leading the drive to reconstruct the nation’s economy in a manner that is inclusive and that leaves no one behind.”
    Imagine what a field day the next president (elias or DD or little zuma?) will have with all this power which the anc has just taken without any serious objection from the rest of parliament. The anc must rule at any cost, is the only objective. Of that I am convinced.

  • This whole thing is a mess. if the President did these things he must pay the price. But no our politicians must grab on this one issue provided by a source whose own reputation is questionable and ignore what are the real issues in this country. let the investigation follow its course and DA you have just fallen into the trap of following the same path as idiot politicians of other parties who know no better with this piece of rubbish.

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted