South Africa


Coalition with DA on shaky ground after Patriotic Alliance leader Gayton McKenzie ‘insulted’

Coalition with DA on shaky ground after Patriotic Alliance leader Gayton McKenzie ‘insulted’
Patriotic Alliance leader Gayton McKenzie. (Photo: Gallo Images / Netwerk24 / Lulama Zenzile)

The Patriotic Alliance has informally told the Democratic Alliance it will withdraw from its coalitions in the province over alleged ‘insults’ about PA president Gayton McKenzie.

There is trouble between the Democratic Alliance (DA) and the Patriotic Alliance (PA) coalition in the Western Cape over comments made by DA interim provincial leader Tertuis Simmers about the PA president, Gayton McKenzie, and his mayoral chain. 

The PA has informally told the DA it will withdraw from its coalitions in the province over the alleged “insults”. The PA’s deputy president, Kenny Kunene, confirmed this to Daily Maverick on Thursday. 

“We are not going to allow anyone to insult us any more,” said Kunene during a telephone call. 

The party announced it would remove itself from coalitions with the DA in two Western Cape municipalities — Knysna and Matzikama — following alleged insults by Simmers. News24 reported that Simmers is alleged to have described McKenzie’s appointment as mayor of the Central Karoo District Municipality as “political thuggery”.  

In April, McKenzie was elected as a councillor of the Laingsburg municipality after the party’s councillor Mitchell Smith resigned from his position. At the same council sitting where McKenzie was inaugurated as a councillor, he was elected as the municipality’s representative on the district council. 

On 11 April, McKenzie was elected unopposed as mayor of the Central Karoo District Municipality in his first council sitting.

Read in Daily Maverick: Central Karoo mayor Gayton McKenzie calls illegal immigrants a ‘stain’ and warns of ‘citizen’s arrests’

Kunene said Simmers’ comments were not only an insult to McKenzie and the PA, but also to those in the Central Karoo who voted for the party. Kunene pointed out that during the council sitting — at which Kunene was present — DA councillors agreed to McKenzie’s nomination and election as mayor as they did not field a candidate of their own. Kunene said Simmers’ comments “insulted a democratic process”. 

Who is behind South Africa’s xenophobic nationalism?

Kunene also questioned how a political “junior” could be allowed to insult a party president. According to Kunene, the DA has yet to reprimand Simmers or distance itself from the comments, despite the PA talking informally to the DA about it. 

Following a meeting with the PA’s National Executive Committee, the party decided to withdraw from the coalition in the province, Kunene confirmed to Daily Maverick

Kunene said the party had informally told the DA of its plans to leave the coalition, but it had not done so formally yet. 

Daily Maverick has sought comment from Helen Zille, the DA’s Federal Council chair and point person for coalitions, who had not responded by the time of publication. When Daily Maverick receives a comment, it will be included. 

In March, Daily Maverick reported the PA was slowly starting to work with the DA in municipalities such as Knysna, where it voted with the party to nominate a representative to the municipality’s disciplinary committee. However, in council it emerged the candidate was allegedly the husband of a PA councillor in the neighbouring Bitou municipality as well as a spokesperson for the party. Then PA councillor Waleed Grootboom was appointed as Knysna mayoral committee member for community services.

However, on Thursday afternoon, the municipality confirmed that Grootboom had resigned from the DA-led mayoral committee. Confirming the news via a statement on the municipality’s social media channels, Mayor Levael Davis said: “I would like to thank Cllr Grootboom for his positive contributions to the mayoral committee and for serving the greater Knysna people with passion.”

Despite Grootboom’s resignation from the mayoral committee, he remains a municipal councillor.

Kunene confirmed to Daily Maverick the coalition between the two parties remained in place in Johannesburg and Ekurhuleni. DM


Comments - Please in order to comment.

  • anton kleinschmidt says:

    How does any of this infantile bickering help the people. Who cares about the fragile egos of the politicians concerned. Who cares about the opposition which somehow thinks that dishing out insults equates to political maturity. In fact who cares about politicians, apart than other politicians.

    None of this is about good governance. It is exclusively about the fact that there is no maturity or intellectual depth within political structures.

    Increasingly we see politicians milling squealsome in the muck just below the bottom rung of the ladder that represents civil society. In South Africa. In the USA. In the United Kingdom. Why do we tolerate this?

    Dare I remind ALL politicians that your job is to ensure good governance. To place people first. To stop behaving like small children. To actually EARN the salary that the people pay you.

    • Glyn Morgan says:

      Great stuff! Except….. The muck-racking is being done by McKenzie and his PA as well as News24 and Daily Maverick. What the DA’s Simmers said is robust political yacker. If the PA cannot take that, shame.

    • Pet Bug says:

      Good response!
      McKenzie‘s very thin skin is showing – par for the course for politicians of course. But grow up!

      The writers of our constitution consulted with Germany. Theirs bans communist and fascist parties, and crucially, requires a 5% hurdle of votes to be eligible for seats in any local, state or federal assembly.
      One must ask why this was not adopted here… ?
      This is the reason for the political and social stability in the Germany.

      Surely in 1994 we would’ve chosen this middle ground, aware of the dangers of both the left and right wingers.
      Lost opportunity.
      Every single voice does not need to be in decision making forums. If they are so convinced of there magnificence, these party’s must adjust their views to reach 5% to actually be accountable.
      Now it’s just like herding cats with narcissistic tendencies.

  • Lorinda Winter says:

    Gayton Mackenzie seems to be where he is for one thing and one thing only, strutting around while being followed by the media. Has he ever done a day’s work in his life or is he just there to play to the masses? His feelings seem to be hurt, shame, but what about service delivery and helping those in dire need. Scoring political points does not help Beauford- West, does it?

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted

We would like our readers to start paying for Daily Maverick...

…but we are not going to force you to. Over 10 million users come to us each month for the news. We have not put it behind a paywall because the truth should not be a luxury.

Instead we ask our readers who can afford to contribute, even a small amount each month, to do so.

If you appreciate it and want to see us keep going then please consider contributing whatever you can.

Support Daily Maverick→
Payment options