South Africa

NEWSFLASH

Signed & Sealed: The UAE – home of the Guptas – ratifies extradition treaty at long last

Ajay and Atul Gupta in Midrand on 4 March 2011. (Photo: Gallo Images/City Press/Muntu Vilakazi)

The ratification of the treaty comes after nearly three years of legal wrangling, political tap dancing and, at times, a rather unbecoming diplomatic tone from South Africa.

The United Arab Emirates — widely regarded as the home base of the Gupta family, including fugitive brothers Atul and Rajesh and their wives Chetali and Arti — has ratified an extradition treaty with South Africa.

Daily Maverick understands this was done recently, though indications are that South Africa is not brimming with excitement — just yet. 

The ceremonial exchange of the treaty is yet to take place. Comment from the Department of International Relations was not immediately available.

UAE Extradition Treaty

 

News of the ratification comes as South African law enforcement has managed to take one criminal case featuring the Gupta name to court.

Atul and Rajesh, along with their wives, are accused with former Transnet board member Iqbal Sharma in a R24.9-million fraud and money laundering case in the Free State

Last week, the NPA also announced it had approached Interpol for help in executing warrants of arrest for the two Gupta brothers and their wives.

This came roughly four years since the #Guptaleaks first emerged in mid-2017.

Interestingly, South Africa has not formally uttered a word about the ratification of the treaty. Instead, the UAE embassy in Pretoria released a statement announcing it on Wednesday, 9 June 2021. 

Ratification is usually the final box to tick in the drawn-out process between two countries, but the UAE has required a tremendous amount of time to make this treaty a reality.

This is especially so given the pressure around the Gupta family and how much of their business dealings in South Africa has been a daily feature of the State Capture Commission since August 2018. 

Negotiations for the treaty began in 2010 and took eight years to be signed.

South Africa took the treaty to Parliament within four months of its signing to kick-start the ratification process. 

The ratification by the UAE comes after nearly three years of legal wrangling, political tap-dancing and, at times, a rather unbecoming diplomatic tone from South Africa.

In November 2020, Justice and Corrections Minister Ronald Lamola — addressing MPs — said the UAE was not cooperating in efforts to have the Guptas extradited to South Africa to face the music over their alleged involvement in an estimated R50-billion in State Capture crimes.

While the treaty will become an effective tool in the fight against crime, some may view the UAE’s sudden resolution of outstanding issues — for a long time it included translation of the document — as a way to manage its reputation in the international community. 

The Guptas have gained significant notoriety on the international stage over the years.

The three Gupta brothers and their South African kingpin, Salim Essa, were described as members of a significant corruption network when the US Treasury, under its Global Magnitsky Act, slapped them with financial sanctions. 

Hain/Zondo

Former British MP Lord Peter Hain too criticised the UAE during his testimony at the Zondo Commission in November 2019.

“It seems to me, either the government, under the rule of Sheikh Mohammed bin Rashid Al Maktoum, is wilfully sheltering a family that has looted astronomical amounts from South African taxpayers, or the South African authorities don’t have the will or capacity to bring them to book.” 

The Guptas hurriedly packed up and left South Africa after several South African banks terminated their bank accounts in 2016 and then things really went from bad to worse.

*In October 2016 former Finance Minister Pravin Gordhan lifted the lid on a staggering R6-billion in suspicious transactions in a High Court case.

**They then brought an unsuccessful court application to force their lone banker, India’s Bank of Baroda, to retain them as clients saying they had been left commercially impotent as a result. 

*Claims that they had allegedly offered former deputy finance minister Mcebisi Jonas R600-million to work with them have also been supported by testimony at the State Capture Commission. 

The State Capture hearings into fraud and corruption in the public sector amplified the allegations against the Gupta brothers.

The Guptas refused to travel to South Africa to participate in the hearings where reams of evidence have been presented of how they allegedly had a hand in Cabinet appointments and at the Boards of state-owned companies during the tenure of former president Jacob Zuma. 

The UAE embassy’s announcement on Wednesday came nearly two months after that government ratified the treaty in April 2020.

But, this does not necessarily mean the Guptas have had a two-month headstart on the news. They will no doubt have had their lawyers in Dubai fully briefed to monitor the progress of the legal or legislative process in the UAE very closely — and systems will have long been put in place to prepare for any eventuality.

Furthermore, the exact whereabouts of the Gupta brothers and their spouses remain unknown. Except for an April 2018 cellphone video clip of Ajay Gupta that went viral, public sightings of the brothers have been rare. 

Anecdotal evidence suggests they move between Dubai, India and Russia where they allegedly operate various businesses.

More recently, their sons and son-in-law Aakash Garg (the groom of the infamous Sun City wedding) have made appearances at business events in Uzbekistan. 

It is highly possible that the Guptas continue to use the R300-million L35 mansion in Dubai’s Emerald Hills as a strategic base —  a convenient springboard to Russia and India in particular. 

While the family’s former primary residence, otherwise known as the Saxonwold compound in South Africa, has become a mini ghost town, it is unlikely that the same fate would befall L35.

Their partner Salim Essa has been seen around Dubai, at least up to late 2019. He and the brothers have been throttled by financial sanctions imposed by the US government. DM

This article was updated with additional information on Thursday, 10 June 2021.

Gallery

Comments - share your knowledge and experience

Please note you must be a Maverick Insider to comment. Sign up here or sign in if you are already an Insider.

Everybody has an opinion but not everyone has the knowledge and the experience to contribute meaningfully to a discussion. That’s what we want from our members. Help us learn with your expertise and insights on articles that we publish. We encourage different, respectful viewpoints to further our understanding of the world. View our comments policy here.

All Comments 18

  • It seems to me, either the government, under the rule of Sheikh Mohammed bin Rashid Al Maktoum, is willfully sheltering a family that has looted astronomical amounts from South African taxpayers, or the South African authorities don’t have the will or capacity to bring them to book. Or both.

    • There’s no way that the ANC wants the Guptas to be brought back to SA.
      Assuming on the off chance that they’re extradited, once they open their mouths, they’ll take the whole lot of this criminal cabal which masquerades as a govt. down the toilet with them.

    • Glyn, a sharp comment, as well as the reply by Hiram C Potts. In fact, all the comments made by others at time of writing, The sheikh has much to loose if the Guptas are indeed extradited. The Guptas provide them with enormous amounts of money, stolen from South Africa. The UAE relies on tourism (why people want to go there is beyond me. Been there twice, and it is in my opinion the worst tourist destination in the world). So until and when I see the Guptas and Essa in chain’s in South Africa, I will not trust any article of this kind, whilst well meant. Rich criminals have a way to buy themselves out of anything. For starters, how sure are anybody that they are indeed in Dubai. Even Indian media questions this (do some googling if you wish into Indian media on this subject). And Hiram’s comment is so true. The ANC can not afford to have the Gupta’s in South Africa, as they will expose the real rot in the governing party

      • Look no further than Bishkek, Kyrgtstan, where the old school Soviets will shelter, nay, shower them, for hard currency. Advance base camp is already secure.

      • OR … like in the “greatest ‘democracy’ in the world” there could be an insurrection (described by Republicans as a picnic of ‘patriots’ – quite sincerely it seems in some cases ! lol – it failed this time) inside the white house, or a coup …. and we could have another ‘government’ in its place … that does NOT recognise what the previous one agreed to !!! What a lark that would be ! Maybe I am just way too cynical . It would be like getting any of the guilty parties here pleading ‘guilty’ to the charges – which would ‘impoverish’ the legal eagles and their hefty costs ! Imagine how ‘little’ Mpofu et al would make, if they did the right thing ?

  • It’s about time! But will anything important come out of it? There seems to have been so many “ slip ups” in the whole sorry saga- only believe when the Guptas are back here and in handcuffs- remember when they were allowed to leave the country?

  • Give mr.Lamola his due. Without doubt the best Minister in Cabinet and this treaty has Dirco as a silent partner. If we could find another 10 young guns like Lamola this country might well have a future after ditching the corrupt useless dinosaurs

  • I agree with Jessica Beuidenhout’s view that the UAE is now concerned with reputational damage, despite the country being run by an autocrat. Guess they want tourists back in Dubai!

  • Why telegraph the news of the agreement before Interpol make arrests? Give them a chance to go somewhere else?

  • The Gupta family, thanks to the speedy services of Home Affairs to super rich criminals are South African citizens. Sheik Mohammed will surely consider this fact. We just want our own back, after all.

  • This article really should be about why the UAE didn’t immediately sign a the treaty and deport the Gupta’s to SA. The world needs to hold the UAE accountable for the sheltering of global grade criminals. The Gupta’s are now decamped elsewhere, likely after having heavily bribed the UAE rulers and authorities.

  • Oh, come on! With their loot they can go to the best plastic surgeons (let’s not forget the poor late M. Jackson RIP who was changed from a black man into a white woman) and obtain new nationalities and passports, and would disappear for ever.