That race card ain't no trump card
- Alex Eliseev
- 03 Dec 2012 01:41 (South Africa)
I was covering a story at the High Court in Pretoria when a colleague of mine popped in during a lunch break and relayed a most unusual drama that had just played out in the building. One of the country’s most respected prosecutors – a man who has won international awards for taking on untouchable villains – had found himself the target of a racial outburst from a translator in another trial.
The story went that, during a break in proceedings, this prosecutor had asked the translator to stop laughing at the testimony being heard and to have a little more professionalism. Admittedly, the testimony was probably amusing, but as an officer of the court, the prosecutor reminded the translator, he should show more restraint. What followed included an explosion of anger and a tsunami of racial accusations. The prosecutor happens to be white while the translator (who took offense at being reprimanded in public) is black. Eventually, in front of everyone, the prosecutor turned around and walked away, while the translator cooled down. It was an ugly scene, but one which is not that uncommon in South Africa.
I thought about this quite a lot. I know and respect the prosecutor and know that his only possible mistake was to confront the issue in court instead of stepping into a quiet corridor or a back room. I don’t know the translator but his outburst – which involved yelling the K-word – seemed to be a complete over-reaction and a cheap way to avoid the real issue: his behaviour in court.
On Friday, I held in my hand a scathing judgment from the Supreme Court of Appeal in the matter of Rivonia Primary School and the Gauteng Education department.
I’ll get to the heart of the ruling in a moment, but this is the line that really jumped out at me: “ Instead of treating this matter as an ordinary dispute relating to the application of the school’s admission policy the department opprobriously invoked the ugly spectre of race to obfuscate its unlawful conduct”. In other words: The Department played the race card.
I couldn’t help thinking of the court translator as I read this. If this is happening everywhere from a tiny spat in a courtroom to a multi-million rand battle involving the government, we need to start thinking seriously about how to put an end to it.
Consider any recent big new story in South Africa. Chances are someone played the race card. The Spear? Nkandla? Pretty much anything Julius Malema says? I read a fascinating story in Time this week called “Africa Rising”, which spoke about the continent becoming a superpower (through the growth of Ghana, Nigeria and Kenya, as well as the shifting dynamics of the world’s natural resources). A few minutes after tweeting the highlights of this story, I was told that the article was nothing more than “nonsensical imperialist rhetoric”. My Twitter rules of engagement are pretty clear and I didn’t enter into a debate. I doubt the author of the accusation had read the article or taken the time to analyse the economic data. Whether Africa is rising or being re-colonised would never have been debated properly with that kind of an attitude. You can’t pull the trigger and then talk.
In the Rivonia case, what happened was that a black woman wanted to enrol her grade one daughter at the school for the 2011 academic year. She was late in applying and landed up on a waiting list. The school refused to admit her, the mother (believed to be politically connected) ran to the Department, yanked out the race card, took some officials with her and saw to it that her daughter was marched into a classroom.
I’m cutting a long story short here, but the principal was disciplined for insubordination and the Department claimed that some schools were not prepared to stretch their limits to accommodate children-in-need.
The Supreme Court of Appeal, however, found the Department had no right to intervene and acted in a “high-handed” and “unlawful” manner.
It said Rivonia Primary had transformed dramatically from the bad old days and now has a roughly 50/50 split between white and black students. One can argue that this doesn’t represent the country as a whole, but then one has to consider the school’s feeding area.
But all that aside, the court ruled the school and the area had nothing to do with the case because this “might have occurred at any public school that had a waiting list for admission of learners”.
The court took into account that Rivonia Primary’s governing body had raised millions of rands to upgrade the school and take in more pupils, and that it had the right to govern itself.
The Department argues that it has the responsibility to make sure every child in the province has a place to learn and that this right trumps a school’s desire to give a quality education.
The SCA didn’t take lightly the fact that the girl in this case had already been placed in a private school as plan B, and spoke about how her mother “continued to put pressure on officials of the department”. As a final zinger, it added: “Although the sanctions imposed on Ms Drysdale (principal) are not before us, I am confident the department is sufficiently gracious to withdraw these sanctions in the light of this judgment”.
In essence, the judgment finds that a principal, while representing the Department, must abide by the rules of the governing body. And that if the Department accepts the governing body’s admission policy, it can’t then go and flout it a few months later. It is a victory for the autonomy of public schools across South Africa.
The Department says it’s studying the judgment and hasn’t decided whether to turn to the Constitutional Court. It probably will. And that battle will be absolutely fascinating: the right of a school to give quality education versus the rights of every child to have an education, against a backdrop of “state-run education that can be among the worst in the world” (a quote from that same Time article). Watch this space; you won’t be disappointed.
The other great lesson here is that the Department bought into the mother’s claim that she was being discriminated against based on her race. That this was a white school that was hell-bent to keep her daughter out. The Department then used this argument to “obfuscate its unlawful conduct” (forgive me, I just can’t get enough of this quote).
No one in their right mind would ever argue that race is not an issue in contemporary South Africa. We need to keep talking about it and, in cases that warrant it, take action. But the lesson we should all learn from this judgment is that not every foul needs the race card. Sometimes it’s better to deal with the real problem instead. We all know what happens if we cry wolf too many times. DM
- Analysis: In the wake of Chinese adventure, a reminder of freedoms we take for granted
- Analysis: Police’s ‘clenched fist’ strikes blow against fellow human beings
- The real brutality of Nkandla
- The new e-tolling dispensation – too little, too late
- Op-Ed: Curro School scandal – when Government does its job well
- Op-Ed: South Africa, a country of misdirected anger
- Op-Ed: Xenophobia, the darkest déjà vu of them all
- Fake affidavit(s) and unhappy communities: Sanral's brand new scandal
- Op-Ed: No 'dark sarcasm' in the classroom
- NPA vs SAPS: Justice is down and out
- Analysis: The SAPS need more than prayer – they need a leader
- TB Joshua and the Nigerian tragedy that shook SA into gear
- TB Joshua: When stupidity rules
- When it comes to policing, accountability is what matters
- Op-Ed: Everybody, CALM DOWN!
- Joshua Broomberg, a schoolboy defending our most fundamental right
- The Accusation Game 2.0: Prince Mokotedi vs NPA
- With Prince Mokotedi's departure from NPA, many questions will remain unanswered
- Popcorn ballet: Easy to digest, delicious to swallow
- We are but dandelions against the wind
- Madonsela, the Defence Review, and SA’s cries for leadership
- On the Nkandla campaign trail: The ANC’s continuing mission down Denial Avenue
- The ANC's Judgement Day gone wrong
- As Oscar looms, Ketani DNA expert gives his verdict on SA justice system
- A cold case, a sizzling battle: Betty Ketani murder trial, week one
- His name is Louca, and he could be a game-changer
- Analysis: Bonfires of discontent, in horrifying numbers
- Limpopo's fierytale: the people vs. the police, Armageddon style
- Joburg's latest mystery: A rocket-head of possibilities
- Analysis: e-tolls' first act of sabotage, a sign of deep discontent
- Analysis: Never forget Jan Rivombo
- Nkandla government report: Controlling the (scandal) creep
- Wanted: A time machine. Mission: Re-do Nelson Mandela memorial
- Nkandla leak: one step closer to the truth
- Jo'burg Ballet: A gorgeous 'The Nutcracker'; an antidote to e-tolls and Krejcir
- Police vs. Krejcir: Could this be the final battle?
- Blue Light Brigade: The president’s bullies assault journalist
- McBride as head of Ipid? WHAT WERE THEY THINKING?!
- Crime intelligence: Ngcobo joins Mdluli on sidelines
- Analysis: Joburg, Gotham City without Batman
- SA schools' safety: Festering scandals, emerging lessons
- Nazir Alli: The man whose bells are e-tolling
- SA government: excellence, unforgiven
- Riah Phiyega’s disaster-filled journey, far from over
- Gemballa case: Key witness' memory U-turn
- Krejcir assassination attempt: The stuff of movies, Bond movies
- The magic of (de)construction: Unveiling the biggest losers
- Goodman Nono and the darkness of our system's soul
- Away from the squabbling family, graciousness and love for Madiba
- The things that Obama can teach us
- A day in the life of a soul-searching country: Will good eventually prevail?
- E-tolls: Final countdown? Or not so... final... countdown?
- Mvula Trust scandal: Minister Baloyi changes tack
- Mvula trust, minister Baloyi and the basic question of trust
- The Phiyega Problem
- Oscar: The day our newsroom went quiet
- Humphrey Mmemezi: An embodiment of all that Mamphela Ramphele loathes
- Mvula Trust: The inconvenient questions
- Exclusive: Water Affairs Deputy Minister, her friends and the R30-million tender
- Get OUTA here: Sanral's win, everyone else's loss
- That race card ain't no trump card
- Gauteng's e-tolling volcano
- FIVE MINUTES: South Africa, 27 September
- E-tolls: the lawyers slug it out
- Humphrey Mmemezi rides into the sunset, for now
- Higgs boson and the loss of our collective compass
- Death of a (textbook) salesman: Motshekga blames the supplier
- Reporter's notebook: Chaos and pain in Marlboro Gardens
- Ketani murder: ex-wife steps out
- Outa's Wayne Duvenage, out of Avis
- Humphrey Mmemezi: Have you any shame, sir?
- Betty Ketani: A murder less experienced
- Zuma squeezes the oxygen from General Cele's job
- The week we learned to listen. And prepare for new battles.
- Crime: Cold case files, South Johannesburg, chapter 1
- The realpolitik of SKA
- PaintingGate: the Gallery strikes back
- Analysis: Painting debate will test our democracy
- Unchain my art
- Gauteng's Highway to Hell, revisited
- Extra! Extra! Coming soon to a court near you: The Richard Mdluli Show
- Maldonado's triumph unites polarised Venezuela
- Defiance 2.0: Malema's back, alive & kicking
- Nazir Alli: E-tolling scandal's first victim
- That sinking feeling: Khoza 2.0 unleashes a storm of... silence
- Analysis: Which model will the police follow - Marc Ishlove's or Richard Mdluli's?
- E-tolling: Judge Prinsloo and hope for South Africa
- E-tolls: The puppet-masters drop their masks
- E-tolls: Judge's admission of urgency Outa hurt Sanral
- Reporter's notebook: Sanral's raging bronco vs Outa's angry rider
- Chuck Colson, Nixon's 'master of dirty tricks', has left the building
- Analysis: Malema's organised demise
- Lights go off on SA electric car project
- Radovan Krejcir is just a symptom
- E-Tolls: A dogfight on the cards
- A fissioning of poetry with imaginative adventures in humanness
- E-tags: The silence before the storm?
- The Princess of Bergplaas
- The Future Eaters... effectively beyond parody
- Malema suspension: ANCYL chess game continues
- His back to the wall, Malema's down to primal instincts - fight or flight
- SKA goes into referee's optional extra time
- The 'Monster', his men and the twists and turns of the Modimolle trial
- African financial ministers back Nigerian for World Bank job
- ZANEWS: Weekly Digest – S4 Episode 27
- ZANEWS: The Misfortune Teller (Part 2) Feat. The DA Team
- ZANEWS: The Misfortune Teller (Part 1)
- ZANEWS: Old School
- ZANEWS: Show me the Money!
- ZANEWS: Juju in Memoriam
- ZANEWS: Tokyo Adrift
- ZANEWS: Coming To America
- ZANEWS: Touchy-feely Boers
- ZANEWS: Weekly Digest # 25
- ZANEWS: Hail to the Chief
- ZANEWS: The Devil Wears Gaga
- ZANEWS: Lindiwe's African Dream
- ZANEWS: The Constitution and Other Fairytales
- ZANEWS: Star Wars Ep. VII – A No Hope
- ZANEWS: Sex, Drugs & Boerie Roll
- ZANEWS: Juju's in the panic room
- ZANEWS: Amazing Zooma
- ZANEWS: Buns in the oven
- ZANEWS: Eye Spy
- ZANEWS: Sirious?!?
- ZANEWS: Flushed Away?
- ZANEWS Weekly Digest
- ZANEWS: Dubul' ibhunu e Gabbana
- ZANEWS: Life after PDV
- ZANEWS: The Donald is angry
- An advice to a monster
- Ster: Return to Art for the Sake of Art
- Missing. One Maverick writer. Might be in Fifth Dimension.
- The SA economy's Cosatu migraine
- France finally arrive at Rugby World Cup
- Libyan War's forgotten sufferers
- Only 12 years after Dubya, another Texan wants to be president
- The 2010 World Cup: Was it all worth it?
- Analysis: Twitter, a @realpoliticalpowerplayerSA
- SKA's little Mozambican brother, still an embryo
- Lewis Pugh: Frack off, Shell!
- The Square Kilometre Array, a project The Karoo deserves
- Press Council hearings in Cape Town - speaking to empty chairs, again
- The Chinese Sphinx: How China reports on Egypt
- Nightmare at Baragwanath refuses to end
- Reporter's notebook: A most curious vigil
- Justice slowed by toxicology reports is justice denied
- Gauteng's mean streets offer police a reality check
- 'Fela! The Musical' comes to South Africa - well, kinda...
- 63rd Cannes: The Bang Bang Club, the movie - where art doesn't imitate life
- 63rd Cannes: Applause, emotion and Life Above All
- 63rd Cannes: Winnie, the movie, Winnie, the dilemma
- 63rd Cannes: Judging the jurors
- Cannes it all come together?
- ZANews Friday: Thabo Mbeki is the obvious choice for Bafana Bafana
- ZANews: Zuma, De Villiers, and Percy Montgomery's hair
- ZANews: Hellen Zille and national security
- ZANews debuts, politicians Shaik in their boots