Public education doesn't need fixing; it needs to be euthanised
- Paul Berkowitz
- 31 Jul 2012 01:07 (South Africa)
The parent goes up to the teacher and says, well, I am not satisfied with what you are doing, and the teacher can say, well, tough, you can't take him away, you can't remove him, you can't do what you like, so go away and stop bothering me. That can be the attitude of some teachers today – it often is. But now that the positions are being reversed and the roles are changed, I can only say tough on the teachers – let them pull their socks up and give us a better deal, and let us participate more.”
The above quote is a transcript from an interview with a parent whose child attended Newtown Primary School in Ashford, England. The school was part of an experiment with a school voucher system that paid for parents to send their children to any school of their choice. The interview is part of a TV series (and book) entitled Free To Choose, by the economists Milton and Rose Friedman.
In this particular chapter, focusing on education, the Friedmans looked at the failures in the education system and possible solutions provided by the free market. Unsurprisingly, the suggestion of a school voucher system was met with opposition and even hostility from teachers’ unions and the education bureaucracy. Parents, however, loved the idea.
Unless you’ve been living under a rock for the last six months or you work in the Department of Basic Education, you’ll know that education in South Africa is badly broken. School books aren’t delivered for half the year. Blind pupils are receiving books meant for sighted pupils. Dodgy tenders and middlemen are highly correlated with inflated costs of school supplies and non-delivery of orders.
The failure by the state to deliver quality education is exacerbated by socioeconomic problems like poverty and broken families, but these are extenuating factors and not underlying causes. The failures of state education should also not be the starting point of any analysis. To frame the problem in terms of fixing state failures assumes that the state should be at the centre of education.
If we were to describe the education market – in any country – in the normal dry economic terms, the following characteristics would apply almost universally. There’s a dominant supplier (the state) with the power to enforce market standards, including the syllabus and the minimum qualifications required for teachers. There are all sorts of barriers to entry, from copyrights on teaching materials to the abovementioned teacher qualifications.
Consumption of education is geographically specific, and a family can only realistically choose from a handful of schools, particularly a poor family. This creates effective oligopolies in almost any poor part of any country.
Teachers’ unions are typically strong, well-organised and quite good at shielding their members from market-related competition like performance-linked pay and (in a few cases) from performing at all.
If I had to tell the story of a teachers’ union that lobbied successfully for an increasing percentage of tax revenues, that shouted down attempts to hold its members responsible for minimum teaching standards, and whose members aren’t fired even if they’re found having sex on the school premises, some of you would swear blind that I must be taking SADTU’s name in vain.
Well, yes, SADTU would fit the bill. But so would the California Teachers Association. In an article entitled ‘The Worst Union In America’ the City Journal describes how the state’s teachers’ union has taken an increasing share of the state budget and blocked most education reforms, while standards have plummeted.
California is a pretty rich place. If it were an independent country, its economy would rank in the world’s top ten. The California Teachers Association ensured in 1988 that at least 40% of total state spending would go to education. Somehow, inexplicably, this flood of milk from the state’s teat did not translate into higher educational standards.
California’s education is at the bottom of the national rankings and the state’s finances are in the toilet. It has a $16bn deficit to plug and its debt rating, already the lowest of any of the states, has been given the wagging finger treatment by Standard & Poor.
SADTU itself is the fourth-largest union in South Africa by membership. All other things being equal, it should move even higher up the rankings in the future. Education is a strong growth industry in a country where over 40% of the population is aged 19 or younger. SADTU’s strength within the alliance has grown significantly, and will continue to grow.
SADTU has changed dramatically since its early days. It’s grown exponentially in the last decade and has attracted many members with its promises of sinecure and no heavy lifting. My apologies to those union members who feel their integrity is under attack. It’s true that teaching is a calling and a vocation for many people of principle. It’s also true that, human nature being what it is, the useless and otherwise unemployable will always be attracted to jobs where there is little pressure to perform and almost no risk of being fired. Like mushrooms that sprout after the rain, it’s a simple case of cause and effect, of rational behaviour reacting to available incentives.
SADTU are not the only ones to blame. They’re looking after their members’ interests, and that is exactly what is to be expected of them. Any appeals to a higher calling or the welfare of the kiddies are charming, naïve and utterly misplaced.
In the case of the missing Limpopo textbooks, it’s not even SADTU’s fault. The culprits for that educock-up include the minister of basic education, her DG, the Limpopo department of education (and its MEC) and EduSolutions. Also Hendrik Verwoerd and Bantu Education. The beauty of the problem is that it’s become so big, so ubiquitous and so endemic that everyone is to blame for the mess. If everyone is to blame, then nobody is responsible.
Even if the president were to fire his minister (after Mangaung, obviously) the rusty education bureaucracy would continue to creak along, unoiled, spreading tetanus and eye infections wherever it existed.
Luckily, the private sector and civil society are increasingly providing solutions to fix the mess of public education. Sometimes this occurs through new technology that changes the fundamentals of the market, such as providing open-source teaching resources, breaking down some of the barriers to market entry. Sometimes it takes a public interest law centre to force the government to do its job a bit better. Sometimes it takes a visionary educator to set up an independent school that delivers incredible results with few resources.
There’s little chance of educational reform being undertaken from within government. There are too many special interests to satisfy, and there’s too little political will to challenge the unions or the bureaucrats. The solutions will have to come from the private sector.
While the public education system continues to ossify, costs of bandwidth and smartphones continue to fall as the number of ICT platforms providing educational content rises. Young entrepreneurs continue to bring innovations to market in the way that subject content is provided, in training methods and in learner support systems. Low-fee schools continue to pop up in downtown skyscrapers and one-room buildings.
I made a request on Twitter a few weeks ago for links to people and businesses in the private sector that provide educational solutions. The response was immediate and overwhelming; I had to populate a spreadsheet just to keep track of the different initiatives, companies and individuals in the private education space.
I will share as many of these stories as possible with Daily Maverick readers in the weeks and months to come, in the hope that the success stories will find a greater audience and will ultimately bring benefits to more South Africans who don’t currently have that many choices. For almost a hundred years, the teacher has had a greater say in a child’s education than that child’s parents. It is a perverse market where the seller can supply an inferior product and the buyer is forced to make the purchase. It is time to restore the balance of power to the parents, and to ensure that poor South Africans are not denied the education that they deserve. DM
- December by-elections: the battle for Tlokwe in the time of Mandela
- Analysis: Third-quarter GDP growth remains weak, outlook remains lacklustre
- October by-elections: Voter consolidation in a time of budget consolidation
- The beggar-thy-neighbour outcomes of strike season
- Breaking up with Breaking Bad is so very hard to do
- Analysis: Tlokwe aside, no drama in September by-elections
- Analysis: By-elections in Tlokwe, another round of boxing and more blood-letting
- An unequal music: flaws in the Gini coefficient
- Analysis: Why the ANC will most likely keep Tlokwe
- Building houses vs. building communities
- Analysis: 2012 Q2 GDP figures
- The 2012 development indicators: solving the problem or just describing it?
- General Household Survey 2012: Arrested Development?
- August by-elections: A bad day for the ANC
- Can we afford not to privately educate our children?
- SA’s unemployment rates rise to near-record levels
- What is to be done? A song in the key of EFF sharp
- Who benefits from inflation-targeting?
- Analysis: Tlokwe, split councils and divided municipalities
- SA's price of bread and circuses
- Analysis: Tlokwe's merry-go-round
- If you register them, will they vote?
- Arrests, damn arrests and StatsSA
- GDP analysis: Bleak showing in the first quarter
- Municipal by-elections, supplement: The ANC gets punished in Carolina
- Municipal by-elections: The ANC/DA fight continues
- Analysis: Mid-year population estimates point to Census 2011 problems
- Open letter to the Joburg Mayor
- Analysis: Labour Force Survey
- SA politics, betting edition
- April by-elections: ANC's bad day at the polls
- How much education do we need?
- I bet you we can make gambling better
- Analysis: How do you solve a problem like Apartheid?
- DA draws the line in demarcation battle
- Dear guardians: Please stop 'protecting us'
- Meet your meat
- Analysis: The future of South Africa’s labour market, post-Marikana
- The mystery of the wards that do not bark
- Analysis: Municipal by-elections
- March municipal by-elections: little change to the status quo
- Analysis: Gauteng 2013/14 provincial budget
- 2013 budget analysis: Still stuck in the lean years
- 2013 budget: Help us to help you, Mr Gordhan
- Analysis: 2012 Q4 GDP figures
- Living while female is the worst crime of all
- Free State of municipal chaos and lip service delivery
- The meaning of numbers: Labour Force Survey, Q4
- Census 2011 numbers: New concerns over the results' accuracy
- Analysis: January by-elections - ANC tastes first blood
- Phillip has left the building
- Analysis: Land rights and the mining sector in 2013
- SA party financing: Show us the money
- 2013: the Year of the Citizen?
- Vertigo: The dizzying roller-coaster ride of an adult comic
- December by-elections: winning the Mangaung war and losing the battles
- Joburg: Growling with flavour
- November by-elections: heavy cloud but no rain
- Census 2011: Telling stories
- Census 2011: The (incomplete) (probably inaccurate) sum of us
- Analysis: Medium-term budget and the medium-term outlook
- Eternal sunshine of the finance minister: Budgeting and the call for a social compact
- Off the books: SAPS liability fund hidden - and growing
- In a spin: Felix Baumgartner's mission to the edge of space, and back
- On the street where you lived: What next for Schubart Park?
- Analysis: The state of municipal capacity
- Service delivery and development: Hot or not?
- The Marikana effect: A sharp drop for the ANC in September's by-elections
- The dark side of the Force
- Reserve Bank Quarterly Bulletin: Damned if you cut, damned if you raise
- Vote now, vote often
- Analysis: Zen and the art of municipal finance figures
- Analysis: Labour market dynamics in 2011
- GDP Q2 2012 - no cure for wild mood swings
- Tinkering with the great machine: how do we get the society we want?
- The eLibrary Project: Baby steps into better education
- Curiouser and curiouser: surprises in the August by-elections
- Labour Force Survey: All quiet on the employment front
- Public education doesn't need fixing; it needs to be euthanised
- Analysis: Municipal audits - what progress has been made?
- Dear Minister of Sport and Recreational Drugs…
- June by-elections: double-digit losses for ANC
- SA's Q1 GDP - those muscles are only Photoshopped
- Racism killed the Rainbow Nation
- April by-elections: the DA leaves the ANC feeling blue
- The migratory patterns of the South African human
- T20: nasty, brutish and short - and lots of fun
- Open letter to Comrade Vavi
- March by-elections: it was all (ANC) yellow
- SA's Pyrrhic victory in Test series against NZ
- NZ vs SA Third Test - Don't rain on our parade
- Manufactured outrage and the art of being under political house arrest
- Proteas batting battle is a drag on the bowling triumphs
- New BEE legislation: make it work or go to jail
- Proteas vs Black Caps – a fairer fight at Hamilton
- The market: don't take it personally
- Judge Nicholson throws book, kitchen sink at Gerald Majola
- SA vs NZ Test - a slow start to a delicate balance
- Municipal finances and budgets: money's too tight to mention
- Malemadness – what happens now?
- Budget 2012: Cosatu wins, everyone else loses
- 2012 Budget: there is no new policy under the sun
- Budget 2012: Ask not what your budget can do for you...
- By-election trainspotting just became interesting again
- February by-election: reading the parties' palms, not the voters'
- Labour Force Survey numbers: running out of hope
- Test cricket: it's never going to survive unless it gets a little crazy
- Dr. Jekyll and Mr. de Villiers: the baby-faced captain with the ruthless streak
- You have a dream, I see sex
- Devastating Dale Steyn - a mid-career retrospective
- Colour-blind spots in Cape Town and racism
- The accident-prone tourists: Sri Lanka in South Africa
- By-elections: the DA and Cope learn how to steal ANC marbles by and by
- As more survive HIV, quality of that life become central
- If you build it, they will come: sports facilities and local government
- Shared honours for a short but deep Test series
- Hot time, summer in the city: SA vs Aus 2nd Test preview
- Helen Zille and the case of the bad law
- South Africa vs. Australia, Day 2: murder on the grassy knoll
- If one-day games are cricket on steroids, T20 adds a turbo-booster
- Why inequality matters
- As season starts SA cricket suffers under admin blunders - again!
- Begging China for money, and begging the question
- To cut or not to cut, that is the Reserve Bank's question
- Population estimates and the war against HIV/Aids
- Another municipal year passes - along with wasted chances
- Youth wage subsidy: a response to comments
- DA's proposed youth wage subsidy - a mostly sane, constructive affair
- How not to strike for Dummies: Samwu edition
- Justice Mogoeng and Zapiro: political satire of character assassination
- Gwede Mantashe and the Deathly Bills
- The youth wage subsidy: a closer, not very pleasant look
- Analysis: SA municipal finances? The horror. The horror.
- Quarterly Employment Statistics: SA still far off 2008 peak
- SA municipalities: Mess, royal mess and a gigantic mess
- Analysis: What ANC decline? A different view.
- Local elections 2011: Beyond ANC and DA numbers
- Analysis: The carnage of small parties in the land of Cortinas and Carnival City
- Analysis: The new Tshwane and what the post-election picture could look like
- Analysis: Working SA's local electoral system
- Analysis: Shapley values and SA's local coalition politics
- Analysis: The nascent rise of the independent ward councillor