Defend Truth

ISS TODAY OP-ED

Elections will reveal SA’s exposure to social media digital influence as service for manipulation

Elections will reveal SA’s exposure to social media digital influence as service for manipulation
Illustrative image: Researchers are monitoring disinformation tactics in SA, focusing on generative AI creating deepfakes and techniques creating echo chambers. (Image: Shutterstock)

Without access to social media data, ensuring voters have verifiable information rather than manipulated content is difficult.

Nationalist content and mudslinging have become part of the grammar of elections globally. The estimated 26 million South Africans using social media in the lead-up to the 29 May national vote will inevitably be exposed to this.

In such a highly contested election, information integrity is essential to ensure democratic principles prevail and votes are based on verifiable facts and opinions shaped by human minds — not machines or manipulated content.

Researchers monitoring disinformation will focus on two critical areas in the South African online landscape. First, generative artificial intelligence (AI) or synthetic media used to create deepfakes as part of disinformation campaigns. Second, techniques that create echo chambers by tricking the algorithm and limiting the feed of information we receive.

Institute for Security Studies (ISS) researchers are already observing coordinated techniques in South Africa that are similar to those used in other election settings. They include ‘follow trains’ (‘I will follow you if you follow me’-type activity to build engagement) and ‘hashjacking’. Hashjacking is when popular hashtags are hijacked — repurposed to push a particular agenda. Often, the communities that follow that hashtag are unaware of such manipulation.

Kenya’s 2022 election witnessed many of these techniques as part of what researchers identified as an active market for social media influence as a service. Cohorts of skilled influencers, often using university students as their lieutenants, worked around the clock to shape political narratives and influence information flows.

These influencers could command thousands of US dollars in service fees for manipulating and selling hashtags to political paymasters. In effect, they delivered a ready network or audience into which political messaging could be inserted.

In a South African setting, this may include geopolitical messaging given the prominence of the Ukraine-Russia and Israel-Palestine conflicts in national conversations. With advances in AI, the ability to shape messaging at scale and at speed is greatly enhanced.

Read more in Daily Maverick: Can Artificial Intelligence on steroids hijack an election?

Narratives, allegiances manipulated

Another trend identified in South Africa in a recent report by the Centre for Analytics and Behavioural Change (CABC) and Murmur was the digital equivalent of floor crossing. Analysing social networks associated with key political parties, the team observed the movement of anonymous core accounts from the African National Congress’ Radical Economic Transformation (RET) faction to the newly formed uMkhonto Wesizwe party.

The RET faction was associated with the 2017 Gupta bots controversy, which saw the use of multiple fake automated accounts to flood social media platforms with a nationalist white monopoly capital narrative.

Given the history of apparent manipulation by RET using bots, the authenticity of such accounts is questionable. The report highlights how these accounts appear to flip overnight and switch political affiliation and messaging using the hashtag of another political party. It seems to be a form of consensual hashjacking, although it’s unclear whether the motive is political or commercial.

Democracies rest on the principles of free speech and access to information. To provide verifiable information, professional journalists in traditional newsrooms adhere to basic principles of fact-checking and double sourcing.

But the growing market of influence as a service has muddied the waters. ISS researchers found that influencers in Kenya’s 2022 election could earn up to $7,000 just for generating a hashtag, and even more for amplifying certain content on a daily basis.

Researchers will only be able to fully appreciate the scale of this type of influence in South Africa after the elections. But early investigations by Daily Maverick indicate that the emerging market of influence as a service is shaping how voters receive political messaging.

Africa access to data

So why does this online manipulation matter? CABC researchers say “authentic communications and clear statements of financial gain should be equally, if not more, important than when advertising a product or a service given the potential to influence election outcomes”’ This is similar to political parties declaring their advertising spend within the context of elections.

Yet to understand how online influence supports or threatens democracies, especially those where the usual checks and balances on power are limited, researchers must be able to access data.

The ISS is one of 11 research groups in South Africa supporting a Research ICT Africa-led initiative urging the companies that own digital platforms such as X, Facebook and TikTok to enable greater research access to data.

Signatories of a statement to the platforms warn that “independent monitoring of social media is key to combating online disinformation and hate speech that can harm election integrity”. But access isn’t equal. The United States and European Union have privileged access to such data, while Africa doesn’t. The African Union is being lobbied to support calls to level the playing field.

Furthermore, the signatories say greater access for accredited researchers across Africa is needed to not only monitor content and flag hate speech, but hold platform owners accountable “by assisting them in monitoring their own performance in addressing potentially harmful content”.

Several platforms including TikTok and Google are helping South Africa’s electoral authorities and civil society identify inauthentic content and detect covert influence operations during the election. But gaining help from platforms for researchers to access their Application Programming Interface is still being negotiated. Without that, conducting research at scale is costly and restrictive.

Notwithstanding these constraints, ISS is mapping disinformation during this election period and examining the use of generative AI to manipulate information and ultimately undermine democratic norms. DM

Karen Allen, Consultant, Institute for Security Studies (ISS) Pretoria.

First published by ISS Today.

Gallery

Daily Maverick has closed comments on all elections articles for the next two weeks. While we do everything in our power to ensure deliberately false, misleading and hateful commentary does not get published on our site, it’s simply not possible for our small team to have sight of every comment. Given the political dynamics of the moment, we cannot risk malignant actors abusing our platform to manipulate and mislead others. We remain committed to providing you with a platform for dynamic conversation and exchange and trust that you understand our need for circumspection at this sensitive time for our country.

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted

A South African Hero: You

There’s a 99.7% chance that this isn’t for you. Only 0.3% of our readers have responded to this call for action.

Those 0.3% of our readers are our hidden heroes, who are fuelling our work and impacting the lives of every South African in doing so. They’re the people who contribute to keep Daily Maverick free for all, including you.

The equation is quite simple: the more members we have, the more reporting and investigations we can do, and the greater the impact on the country.

Be part of that 0.3%. Be a Maverick. Be a Maverick Insider.

Support Daily Maverick→
Payment options

MavericKids vol 3

How can a child learn to read if they don't have a book?

81% of South African children aged 10 can't read for meaning. You can help by pre-ordering a copy of MavericKids.

For every copy sold we will donate a copy to Gift of The Givers for children in need of reading support.