Maverick Citizen

HEALTHCARE CRISIS

Chris Hani Baragwanath runs out of life-saving Adrenaline after health department switches suppliers

After doctors reported that the last vial of Adrenaline at Chris Hani Baragwanath hospital was used up this week, the supplier, Pharma-Q, blamed load shedding for its failure to meet its contractual obligations.

An about-turn to downgrade a long-standing supplier of Adrenaline™ to Gauteng’s public hospitals in favour of a relatively unknown company has left the province’s key hospitals running critically low on the life-saving drug and raised more red flags of tender processes.

On Monday, 14 August, the last ampoule of Adrenaline was used up at Chris Hani Baragwanath Academic Hospital (CHBAH), according to doctors. 

But frustrated staff have been raising the alarms of dwindling stocks from as far back as 8 May, with, they say, no intervention, no contingencies, no communication of a strategy forward, and outright blocks to activate emergency procurement processes as the stock-out crisis worsens. 

Adrenaline injections are used as a first-line drug in cardiac arrest cases for resuscitation. It’s also used as a medical treatment for life-threatening emergencies.

As of 1 June 2023, the hospital had ordered 54,960 units based on consumption, but had only received 18,270 units, meaning only a third of their order had been filled. The hospital uses between 8,000 and 12,000 units of Adrenaline a month.

A letter widely circulated this week set out the damning outline of multiple failings that led to this looming medical disaster. The letter, written by Dr Jacqui Brown, chairperson of the pharmacy and therapeutics committee at Chris Hani Baragwanath is dated 13 August 2023. It’s addressed to the hospital CEO, the acting CEO of the medical supplies depot and the head of the National Department of Health’s Affordable Medicines Directorate.

Brown writes that continued shortages have led to rationing of Adrenaline in the hospital as doctors and pharmacists have tried to reserve stock for the Intensive Care Unit. The hospital has also had to resort to alternative drugs, including noradrenalin, a more costly drug.

She stressed in her letter that noradrenalin is only approved for use in ICUs and coronary care units because of its “significant side effects”. Brown added that stocks of this drug too, had in the meantime, also become “depleted”.

“Despite all our efforts, we are still struggling to keep up with demand,” she wrote.

Switching suppliers

Her letter also referred to communication the hospital received from the medical supplies depot (MSD) that pointed to the crisis emanating from a change in Adrenaline suppliers. The current supplier is a company called Pharma-Q, which has failed to meet its contractual obligation.

It’s emerged that Adrenaline had previously been supplied, without glitches, according to Brown, by Germany-based multinational Fresenius, but its contract had been reduced to just 10% of their usual supply.

The 90% supplier bid went to Pharma-Q, a company based in Industria West in Johannesburg. Its active directors are listed as Kaamil Adam, Hussein Akbar Kalla, Nazir Adbul Kalla, Anthony Lesch and Anand Mehta, Dheerajmal Bastimal Siroya and Dilip Surana. It lists its “product base” as eye and ear drops as well as creams and ointments.

baragwanath adrenaline

Adrenaline vials (Photo: iStock)

Brown said efforts by the hospital to invoke the government’s “buy-out” procedures, essentially a way to allow for procurement under extraordinary circumstances, for Chris Hani Baragwanath had been blocked. This emerged when Fresenius representatives informed the hospital that it had been instructed to not give quotes to individual hospitals, ostensibly to ensure that stock is diverted only to the MSD.

Other special circumstances procurement, including what’s called a Section 21 application, requires an out-of-stock letter from Pharma-Q, which hasn’t been forthcoming, and authorisation from the South African Health Products Regulatory Authority (Sahpra).

But Brown pointed out that Sahpra gives these approvals only if the medicines in question are not available in South Africa. This is not the case with Adrenaline, which is available here.

“Solutions: enforce the contractual obligations and if these companies are unable to supply, approach companies that are manufacturing adrenalin [sic] in the country to increase production,” Brown wrote.

‘No patients compromised’

Motalatale Modiba, head of communication for the Gauteng Department of Health (GDoH) confirmed the Adrenaline shortages at Chris Hani Baragwanath Academic Hospital, “together with other health facilities in the province”, but said no patients had been compromised.

He acknowledged that Pharma-Q had not met its contractual obligations and said the company had blamed load shedding for not meeting its manufacturing output.

“Pharma-Q is struggling to cope with the demand, and is only supplying limited quantities … they say they have made provision for alternative power supply,” Modiba said.

Even though Bara used up its last ampoule of Adrenaline on 14 August, Modiba said that the “majority of our facilities have one-month stockholding, instead of the usual two months”.

He said the MSD had received 20,000 vials of Adrenaline, 5,000 of which were issued to CHBAH. He said that as of 15 August, the hospital had received a total of 9,000 vials.

Modiba directed the question of consequences and penalties for a breach of contract by Pharma-Q to the National Department of Health. But the communications department at the department directed Daily Maverick’s questions back to its provincial communications counterpart.

Exactly how Pharma-Q will be brought to account is still unanswered.

Continued crisis

The latest crisis at Bara has come to light among a growing culture of intimidation, harassment and victimisation of those who raise the alarm. In recent months, Bara has faced crises including a shortage of food for patients, interruption of waste removal services and a lack of maintenance leading to burst pipes flooding theatres. It is also without a permanent CEO.

Read more in Daily Maverick: Bara Hospital cancels surgeries after infrastructure department contractors fail to fix flood damage

Responding to questions on how the GDoH intends to make workplaces safe and protect those who speak out and raise the alarm, Modiba said: “Doctors are civil servants and are expected to comply with public services provisions. It would be incorrect to threaten workers [for] flagging issues that affect patient care, especially if those are raised in the correct platforms.”

The Progressive Health Forum (PHF), a network of doctors, health academics and health activists, said downplaying the intimidation of doctors who are speaking out and choosing to take a stand is an outrage.

PHF spokesperson Dr Aslam Dasoo said: “Clinical staff face continued harassment by departmental officials and are threatened and intimidated for raising issues even through official channels.”

He said the latest crisis at CHBAH signalled “astounding dysfunction of the GDoH.

“Reports that key academic hospitals are running dangerously low of stocks of Adrenaline is a new low for the GDoH. No hospital worthy of the name anywhere in the world is deprived of this essential drug.” Daily Maverick did send this story to Pharma-Q and will add any further or additional comment should it be forthcoming. DM

UPDATE: Pharma-Q has responded to Daily Maverick’s questions after the publication of our article on Tuesday detailing months of dwindling stocks of Adrenaline at Chris Hani Baragwanath Academic Hospital in Johannesburg.  

The pharmaceutical manufacturing company Pharma-Q insists that the crisis of a shortage of Adrenaline from its failure to manufacture and supply it to Gauteng’s hospitals “lasted only 24 hours”. It deems the crisis over after it delivered “a full order of stock to Chris Hani Baragwanath [Academic] Hospital (CHBAH) by 9am, 16 August”.

This is despite a confirmed province-wide shortage of Adrenaline in Gauteng’s key public facilities for months, and staff at Chris Hani Baragwanath raising concerns of a looming disaster as far back as 8 May.

Chris Hani Baragwanath reported that it used its last ampoule of Adrenaline on 14 August. Leading up to that, the hospital had to ration stocks and use less suitable alternatives as a last-resort option for months.

Pharma-Q sticks to load shedding as its reason for failing to meet its contractual agreements to deliver Adrenaline. It says it only had backup power for “certain parts of its factory and only for a limited number of hours”. It says it began to be affected by load shedding in March and was unable to “manufacture a sterile batch in continuity for 6.5 hours straight”. 

However, it only approached the City of Johannesburg to enter into a “load curtailment agreement” in May and two generators it procured will only be installed in November.

It says when its contract to supply Adrenaline in 2021 was agreed on, “power cuts were not a daily reality”. The company has held several contracts with the National Department of Health since 2001. The contract for supplying 7.52 million ampoules of Adrenaline is worth R27-million. The national department oversees centrally facilitated contracts, so-called transversal contracts. 

During the height of load shedding, Pharma-Q imported batches of Adrenaline from India, where one of its shareholders, Micro Labs Group Ltd is based. It says that since 10 June, when its “load shedding curtailment” agreement with the City of Johannesburg came into effect, it has been able to “manufacture product consistently without any power interruptions”. 

By Pharma-Q’s own acounting, it has still taken more than two months to make a full delivery of Adrenaline to Chris Hani Baragwanath Academic Hospital. DM 

Gallery

Comments - Please in order to comment.

  • Ben Harper says:

    Is anyone really surprised? What was/is the kickback for awarding that contract?

  • Andrew W says:

    This crisis is self made, and with so many contributing factors. Multiply the cultural issues (bureaucrats vs health professionals), Ebi Patel’s monumentally stupid industrial policies and incompetence from the national and local state, and you have a perfectly formed NHI storm of epic proportions

  • Iam Fedup says:

    Why do we know, deep down in our gut, that all of this is related to the thievery and incompetence of the ANC, and in all likelihood that bribes have been paid? Of course, the insidious BEE policies have contributed to this also. My fellow citizens, people are literally dying every day while politicians dither and argue, and the ANC/EFF gangsters will still be voted in. None are so blind as those who are not willing to see.

    • Johann Olivier says:

      Oh … they see. They see. They see rand (to steal) & don’t give a damn about human lives that are impacted. This is the South African governmental modus vivendi. (And, sadly, many corporations are ‘learning’ & gradually making it their modus operandi.)

  • Louis Sweidan says:

    Fortunately the NHI will solve all these problems when the State starts manuafacturing product and continue buying from crony BBBEE companies. In the meantime GDoH members will frequent their private hospital as they are not reliant on public hospital. Viva ANC our saviours

  • Andrew Sjoberg says:

    Another failed BBBEE appointment of a provider that threatens the lives of our citizens. Where does it end?

  • Dhasagan Pillay says:

    This sounds like an exciting opportunity for the Auditor-General’s office to do something. I would normally be excited for a department like the Ministry of Planning and Measurement in the Presidency, but they’re very busy enumerating Elon Musk’s personal contribution to Apartheid at present. Cynical coping mechanisms aside though, it would be amazing for the AG to become involved in such debacles, because there is now opportunity for sanctions that would hopefully stimulate action by accountable parties.

  • Janine Stephen says:

    Please could a reporter request a visit to Pharma-Q to be shown this factory and how load-shedding is affecting manufacturing. This is appalling.

  • nico.boshoff says:

    But don’t worry – this will never happen under the NHI.

  • Grenville Wilson says:

    I Googled this info, “Pharma-Q Shareholders? Micro Labs Group Ltd is an India-based pharmaceutical company with 30 years business existence. Probably owned by the Gupta’s!

  • Bradley Welcome says:

    “Doctors are civil servants and are expected to comply with public services provisions. It would be incorrect to threaten workers [for] flagging issues that affect patient care, especially if those are raised in the correct platforms”. Yet again ineffectual policy is quoted to substantiate non-existent processes.
    Yet again the citizenry is expected to hold on to a concept without realisation.

  • Cachunk Cachunk says:

    Does anyone else get the feeling that things are now rapidly spiralling out of control? Our ‘government’ is just too stupid, too incompetent and too complicit to do anything about it!

  • Hilary Morris says:

    Roll on the much vaunted NHI. Then no one will be safe in any hospital. I won’t swear aloud, but temptation is strong. Just WTF? Really? No one held to account – ever. The only people who seem to give a damn are the poor overworked, bullied doctors. What a f……. fine government Gauteng has! And this (may they sink) ANC tries to destabilise the Western Cape. Dear God!

  • Patrick O'Shea says:

    So they swap big pharma for little pharmacy. The words “lifestyle audits” come to mind. Anyone affected by the shortages should be considering a class action.

    • Johann Olivier says:

      I would agree, Mr. O’Shea … except the courts seem helpless in the face of governmental intransigence. They literally seem to pay no attention to court decisions or orders. The courts make findings and nothing happens!

  • Hermann Funk says:

    In China, of which our government is a great admirer, corruption could lead of being put against a wall and shot.

  • Johan Buys says:

    29 years ago a doctor revived me after anaphylactic reaction to a different treatment caused totally unexpected heart failure. This is not a drug for the wealthy elite : it is basics in a trauma unit and I’d imagine in ambulances.

  • jessicacastelyn says:

    Who is fact checking these articles?

    From a WhatsApp message from a doctor who works at Bara:

    ‘So we are not all out. Just essentially become a schedule drug so not freely available.’

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted

X

This article is free to read.

Sign up for free or sign in to continue reading.

Unlike our competitors, we don’t force you to pay to read the news but we do need your email address to make your experience better.


Nearly there! Create a password to finish signing up with us:

Please enter your password or get a sign in link if you’ve forgotten

Open Sesame! Thanks for signing up.

Daily Maverick The Gathering 2024 banner

Daily Maverick has secured an esteemed speaker line-up...

to help make sense of Elections 2024.

Trevor Manuel, Prof Thuli Madonsela and Minister Ronald Lamola are among the latest panellists confirmed for Daily Maverick The Gathering Twenty Twenty-Four.

Join us, on Thurs 14 March 2024 at CTICC Cape Town or online wherever you are, for an event that will put the election in perspective.

Make your taxes work for you

Donate to Daily Maverick’s non-profit arm, the Scorpio Investigative Unit, by 29 February 2024 and you’ll qualify for a tax break.

We issue Section 18A tax certificates for all donations made to Daily Maverick. These can be presented to SARS for tax relief.

Make your donation today

Support Daily Maverick→
Payment options

Otsile Nkadimeng - photo by Thom Pierce

A new community Actionist every week.

Meet the South Africans making a difference. Get Maverick Citizen in your inbox.