Dailymaverick logo

Politics

This article is more than a year old

INTERNATIONAL RELATIONS

Was he snubbed? Ramaphosa fails to crack the nod for G7 summit in Japan

President Cyril Ramaphosa was all geared up and ready to go to the G7 summit in Japan next month, as he has attended every G7 summit since becoming President in 2018. Only, this time the invitation did not arrive.
Was he snubbed? Ramaphosa fails to crack the nod for G7 summit in Japan Japanese Prime Minister Fumio Kishida. (Photo: EPA-EFE / Radek Pietruszka) | President Cyril Ramaphosa. (Photo: Waldo Swiegers / Bloomberg via Getty Images

Unlike Canada, France, the UK and Germany, which had hosted President Cyril Ramaphosa as an honoured guest at their G7 summits in 2018, 2019, 2021 and 2022, respectively, Japan did not invite him to next month’s G7 summit in Hiroshima.

Though some diplomats are trying to explain that this year’s summit is different because the other G7 hosts are countries more interested in Africa, while Japan is more focused on its own Asian region, clearly something is amiss in South African-Japanese relations.

It may have something to do with the fact that South Africa declined to attend Japan’s own big Ticad summit with African leaders in Tunisia last year. South Africa had raised concerns about Morocco’s participation at Ticad in line with its stance to support the Sahrawi people in their long-running territorial dispute with Morocco over the ownership of Western Sahara. When South Africa received no response from Japan about its complaint, South Africa decided not to attend the summit as a means of protest, sources told Daily Maverick

But could it also be related to South Africa’s failure to condemn Russia’s invasion of Ukraine, which has increasingly irked Western and like-minded countries?

Read more in Daily Maverick: Dangerous liaisons: SA’s Russian roulette jeopardises trade agreements with US and other Western nations

Certainly, Tokyo’s decision not to invite a South African president to a G7 summit for the first time in many years has taken the South African government by surprise.

The President’s team was certainly under the impression that he would be invited to the summit and had pencilled the event into Ramaphosa’s busy schedule. The Presidency went as far as inviting journalists to cover the summit. However, last week the chief of staff in the Presidency dropped a bomb when he informed the communications team that Ramaphosa had not been invited after all.  

That is when they discovered that Tokyo had decided instead to invite only Azali Assoumani, who is the chairperson of the African Union and the president of Comoros, to represent Africa.

People close to Ramaphosa have told Daily Maverick that he is undeterred by the latest developments and is determined to stay in the country and work on domestic problems which include the power crisis.  

International Relations Minister Naledi Pandor also seemed surprised. She said on Wednesday that Japan’s decision not to invite South Africa to the G7 summit was “unusual.” She was speaking following a meeting with Norway’s minister of foreign affairs, Anniken Huitfeldt.

“What I am aware of is that there was a meeting of [G7] ministers but the summit has not happened as yet, so I do not know whether President Ramaphosa will be attending the summit. With respect to the ministers’ meeting, South Africa was not invited.

“Japan chose to invite the African Union chair, so a minister from Comoros came to the meeting. This was rather unusual as South Africa is always invited to G7 meetings, but of course, the host chooses what they do, we cannot force ourselves on them,” said Pandor.

Presidency spokesperson Vincent Magwenya said: “The President is not feeling snubbed. The host made a decision to reconfigure Africa’s participation to have the AU chair as the main participant from Africa. It is the host’s prerogative, [one] that the President respects.” 

The Japanese embassy in SA explained to Daily Maverick that Ramaphosa had not been invited because: “Countries selected for outreach are those beyond G7, centred in the Global South, playing an active and significant role in global peace, stability and economic order or those who are showing a strong motivation to do so.

“Adding to this, as G7 is held in Asia, the focus was also put on to the Indo-Pacific region.” DM

Comments

Bee Man Apr 20, 2023, 02:29 PM

Well done, Japan. Our government and Cyril in particular have done little to deserve a seat at this illustrious table.

R S Apr 20, 2023, 02:41 PM

Considering the actions of the ANC, it's unsurprising that the world has finally realised that the party of Mandela no longer exists and don't want anything to do with them.

Kanu Sukha Apr 20, 2023, 08:42 PM

Exactly ... but what has he been doing about our energy crises ... other than appointing a delinquent or is it irrelevant minister of electricity who bounced in and out of 5 or 6 power stations in ONE day (under the noses of none other than the EFF of all things !) ... and proudly (more like irresponsibly) announces that the 'problems' are purely 'technical' .... and have nothing to do with 'corruption/sabotage' !! If that is the case ... why has the problem not been solved ? Instead it has gotten worse ! Disgraceful ... and shameless.

Grenville Wilson Apr 20, 2023, 04:25 PM

What value could SA represented by CR add in any event?

tonysturges Apr 20, 2023, 04:26 PM

The government had already penciled the event in and went as far as inviting journalists. He is 'said' to be undiscouraged and is determined to work on domestic issues – oh please, the ignominy has to be embarrassing! Further proof of this country’s irrelevance in global politics and its relegation into the diplomatic backwaters!

Jane Crankshaw Apr 20, 2023, 05:17 PM

We are what we have become….just another “ s…hole. African country” to coin a phrase first uttered by US President, Trump! Didn’t take long, but there it is!

Trevor Forbes Apr 20, 2023, 07:00 PM

Hopefully, Cyril and Naledi will reflect on South Africa's trade balance and the extreme economic risk they are clearly running with their so called neutral stance on the Ukraine war and Russia. In 2021, South Africa exported more than twice as much to America and her allies (for this read most of G7) than Russia and her axis (including China and India). South Africa ran a positive trade balance of $21.6 billion with America and her allies and a $3.6 billion negative balance (deficit) with Russia and her axis. Maybe the government should be very worried about the potential economic impact from this clear warning from the G7. The ANC's stance on Russia, Ukraine and China could come with a significant economic cost just when South Africa needs all the 'good' friends it can muster to resolve it's significant economic problems. After all the trade stats don't lie. America and her allies create jobs in South Africa through a trade surplus but Russia and her axis export South African jobs, via a trade deficit, - mainly to China!

virginia crawford Apr 21, 2023, 08:16 AM

Many obvious reasons but possibly to avoid the cringing when CR claims all is well and please invest, load shedding is not a problem etc. It must be incredibly embarrassing having to listen to this and difficult to keep a straight face.

Hilary Morris Apr 21, 2023, 08:53 AM

As always, the most depressing part of everything that is falling apart in SA is the absolute certainty that nothing constructive can or will be done by this bunch of clowns masquerading as a government. Ramaphosa seems to exist in a fantasy bubble, and it becomes increasingly embarrassing to watch him flounder his way through any nonsense speech he makes. He even starts to look like a zombie. Lost and confused.

Rory Short Apr 21, 2023, 07:47 PM

When a country is governed by a criminal syndicate it is not surprising when the gang boss is not invited to a meeting of non-gangsters.

Andrew Blaine Apr 25, 2023, 01:49 PM

It appears that the distrust of government endemic in South Africa has become international? With the ongoing vacillation and talking in circles will inevitably miff the western powers. Should they lose patience then South Africa and North Korea will become partners in poverty