South Africa

Bad Medicine

Covid ‘miracle drug’ bust triggers black market fears

The South African Police Service ( SAPS) has arrested a 43-year-old man for being in possession of Ivermectin tablets worth a market value of R100 000. Photo: SAPS

A recent arrest at King Shaka International Airport involved a man found in possession of ivermectin, a drug lauded as a ‘miracle treatment’ for Covid-19. But the drug, banned from import by the local drug regulator, has not been proven safe or effective in treating or preventing the disease. Now there are fears a black market may emerge for the medication.

A 43-year-old man was arrested at King Shaka International Airport on Monday after being found in possession of ivermectin tablets worth R100,000. 

Police said the man, who had flown in from Dubai, had 2,464 ivermectin tablets in his hand luggage. He has appeared before the Verulam Magistrates’ Court charged with possession of unregistered medicines and importing medicines without a valid permit.

Ivermectin, which is widely used to treat and control parasites in animals, has been touted by some healthcare professionals as a “miracle” treatment for Covid-19. It has gained popularity in India and Latin American countries such as Brazil and Peru.  

However, the drug is not approved for human use in South Africa, but is used to treat several tropical diseases in humans which are uncommon to the country. The South African Health Products Regulatory Authority (SAHPRA) occasionally grants Section 21 permits for the use of “topical Ivermectin” as an “unregistered product” to treat individual patients with conditions such as scabies and head lice.

The South African Police Service ( SAPS) has arrested a 43-year-old man for being in possession of Ivermectin tablets worth a market value of R100 000. Photo: SAPS

In December, the regulatory authority said any attempts to import the drug would be seen as unlawful. It said on 6 January there was no evidence to prove the safety and efficacy of ivermectin. Definitive clinical trials to support its use in treating Covid-19 are also lacking. 

Additionally, the body has not received any applications for clinical trials or to register ivermectin for the treatment or prevention of Covid-19. 

SAHPRA chairperson Professor Helen Rees said larger clinical trials of the medication are ongoing and the results are expected in the first quarter of 2021. 

It isn’t the first medication to garner attention as a possible lifeline against Covid-19. 

“If you cast your mind back, people were feeling the same way about chloroquine and studies showed it didn’t have an effect. We’ve looked at things like antiretrovirals, chloroquine, hydroxychloroquine, remdesivir – these are all existing medicines and they’ve been identified as having the potential to have an effect,” Rees told Daily Maverick

But well-designed, randomised trials are needed to prove their efficacy and conclusive data are scant. 

Lab studies have found that ivermectin can inhibit the SARS-CoV-2 virus’ ability to multiply in the body, although SAHPRA says administering standard doses of the medicine would be ineffective while high doses may result in “unacceptable toxicity” in patients.

On social media claims have been made that ivermectin has cured people of Covid-19.

Recently, the state was threatened with court action for banning the drug. The National Freedom Party (NFP) was pushing for the government to approve, procure and administer the medication to citizens. This was before the Department of Health announced it had secured a deal for vaccines set to arrive this month. The African Christian Democratic Party (ACDP) threatened similar action. 

Rees is worried that people taking an unregulated product like ivermectin are putting themselves at risk. 

The South African Police Service ( SAPS) has arrested a 43-year-old man for being in possession of Ivermectin tablets worth a market value of R100 000. Photo: SAPS

“I think the concern is that when people smuggle things in, you’re buying things that are not approved by the drug regulatory authority. You have no idea what you’re buying. There have been reports of overdosage, people being admitted to hospital with this product because there’s clearly no indication, there’s no dosage and so on.”

And the side-effects can be severe. 

SAHPRA said: “It is also important to note that while ivermectin is considered generally safe, side-effects include skin rash, nausea, vomiting, diarrhoea, stomach pain, facial or limb swelling, neurologic adverse events (dizziness, seizures, and confusion), a sudden drop in blood pressure, severe skin rash potentially requiring hospitalisation and liver injury (hepatitis). Laboratory test abnormalities include decrease in white cell count and elevated liver tests.”

And there are concerns a black market may emerge for ivermectin.  

“Everyone understands the desperation that we’re seeing – our numbers are shooting up, GPs, especially on the frontline, are diagnosing people positive and have nothing to offer them other than monitoring them,” said Rees. 

On Thursday, authorities raided Ahmed Al-Kadi, a private hospital in Durban, after receiving a tip-off that the hospital had been prescribing and dispensing the medication. No ivermectin was recovered from the hospital but authorities found proof it had been there. 

To date none of the regulatory bodies with which SAHPRA has reliance agreements has recommended ivermectin. These include the US Food and Drug Administration, the European Medicines Agency and the UK’s Medicines and Healthcare products Regulatory Agency. DM

Gallery

Comments - share your knowledge and experience

Please note you must be a Maverick Insider to comment. Sign up here or sign in if you are already an Insider.

Everybody has an opinion but not everyone has the knowledge and the experience to contribute meaningfully to a discussion. That’s what we want from our members. Help us learn with your expertise and insights on articles that we publish. We encourage different, respectful viewpoints to further our understanding of the world. View our comments policy here.

All Comments 6

  • “But well-designed, randomised trials are needed to prove their efficacy and conclusive data are scant.”

    So, why the hell are those trials are not being conducted? Surely, anything that indicates possibly efficacy should be evaluated.

  • Early results are promising in trials. 90% drop in hospitalization and death rates of people that already had it. But data for use as prophylactic is not clear at all and that is what most (ab)use is. I have had covid, but if I did get it again I would under medical supervision use this. At worst I won’t have worms. The biggest risk is the crowds self-medicating with animal supplies. What is fine for a three monthly 650kg horse dosage WILL not be good for a 90kg human! It is being prescribed in Zim right now as part of a course of treatments

  • Dr Andrew Hill of Univ of Liverpool / Unitaid is conducting an ongoing meta-analysis on the use of Ivermectin in the treatment of Covid-19. His preliminary report on 11 completed random controlled trials looks promising but no definitive conclusions can be made as all trials had small numbers of patients, some trials were not double blinded and the trials used different dosage regimens. All were done in inpatients with varying degree of severity.A further 41 trials are in progress, with 3 due to report in Jan. None of these are in South Africa. We therefore should soon know whether Invermectin definitely works in Covid-19 or not.

  • Ivermectin was a revolutionary breakthrough drug in the mid-1970’s for which a Nobel Peace Prize was awarded. In most of the rest of the world it IS registered and used for humans. The man arrested was carrying drugs that ARE registered for humans in one or more of those countries.
    Big pharma, who had a patent on Ivermectic that has since expired, can no longer make money on Ivermectin and stand to make trillions on Covid vaccines, for which they have patents. This explains why blatant lies are being spread or has Prof Rees not yet read the scientific data on trials that have been done with the results proving their efficacy – or do we have to re-invent the wheel on trials that have been carried out since April this year while tens of thousands get Covid and many die?

  • Ivermectin in a recent study has been shown to be very effective against SARS-CoV-2 in vitro (Caly, et al, Elsevier) – it severely reduces the ability of the virus to multiply in living cells. The drug is FDA approved for human use in the USA. If I were to get Covid, I would not hessitate taking it.