First Thing, Daily Maverick's flagship newsletter

Join the 230 000 South Africans who read First Thing newsletter.

Judge Parker still at work as Judge Hlophe defies presi...

South Africa


Judge Parker still at work as Judge Hlophe defies president, JSC and Office of the Chief Justice

Judge Mushtak Parker. Credit: A screen grab from the JSC confirmation hearing, courtesy of Judges Matter

Now, in apparent defiance of the JSC, the president and the Office of the Chief Justice, Western Cape Judge President John Hlophe has allowed Parker to continue to serve in the division.

On 14 October, the Judicial Service Commission (JSC) announced that it had advised President Cyril Ramaphosa to suspend Western Cape Judge Mushtak Parker pending the findings of a Judicial Conduct Tribunal into gross misconduct. Parker’s suspension was on condition that he finalised part-heard and reserved judgments, and it was to endure until the complaints were finalised by the tribunal. He was to be allocated no new matters while on suspension.

Now, in apparent defiance of the JSC, the president and the Office of the Chief Justice, Western Cape Judge President John Hlophe has allowed Parker to continue to serve in the division. 

As late as Friday 20 November, Parker was allocated by Hlophe the criminal pretrial conference roll, an action that legal experts say will open any and all of Parker’s decisions to legal challenge as they would be “incompetent in law”.

Nicole Fritz, of Freedom Under Law, said that the NGO had confirmed that Parker had been informed of his suspension.

JSC spokesperson CP Fourie, responding to a question from Daily Maverick, directed our queries to Hlophe himself or judiciary spokesperson Nathi Mncube.

Mncube in turn spun a Trumpian justification for Parker being at work on Friday, offering that “the court rolls are prepared at the beginning of term. That would have been long before the suspension was an issue.”

Mncube suggested we rather “check if he has heard any new matter since his suspension”.

We did forward evidence to Mncube of the 20 November court roll, which clearly shows Parker presided over the criminal pretrial conference roll. These are all new matters.

Parker is the only person standing between Hlophe facing a tribunal, a decision by Chief Justice Mogoeng Mogoeng which Hlophe has appealed.

Judge Hlophe appeals Chief Justice Mogoeng’s ruling with a hefty stack of counter-accusations

Parker has been accused by 10 colleagues in the division of providing conflicting versions of an alleged assault on him by Hlophe, in 2019. 

This rendering of conflicting versions may have made Parker guilty “of gross misconduct” and the tribunal will deliberate on all the evidence. 

Hlophe maintains the assault never took place and that Deputy Judge President Patricia Goliath, colluding with the chief justice, had manufactured the complaint.

He also accused Goliath and Mogoeng of trying to induce Parker to make a false statement against him.

These are deeply serious and worrying charges and an action from the chief justice and the JSC is long overdue in the case of Hlophe and Parker.

How does one explain the lack of concern or urgency with regard to both Hlophe and Parker’s contempt for the law?

Parker faces a further inquiry related to the Western Cape Bar Council complaint to the JSC that Parker had not disclosed, when he was interviewed for the Bench, that a law firm which he had helped establish had an R8-million deficit in its trust account.

Western Cape Judge implicated in misappropriation of R8m in legal firm trust funds

This matter, the JSC said, was “extremely serious” and if proven “would constitute gross misconduct on his [Parker’s] part”.

The Constitution allows for the suspension of a judge by the president on the advice of the JSC when that judge is the subject of an impeachment procedure. 

Hlophe’s apparent ignoring of the JSC and the suspension of Parker by the president, mimics the behaviour of former president Jacob Zuma and his public display of contempt for the law and the Commission of Inquiry into State Capture.

In that instance, Zuma absconded without permission and will now face a criminal charge as well as a Constitutional Court application to compel him to appear before the commission.

Zondo gets hardcore on Zuma, throws every legal lasso, including urgent approach to Constitutional Court

Hlophe has been on a fightback campaign, giving exclusive press interviews where he has accused the chief justice of South Africa as well as the deputy judge president of the Western Cape of perjury.

It is hard to think of a more grave set of circumstances that undermine the South African judiciary at a time when it will be called upon to act with independence and impartiality in the litany of cases that are about to face trial.

Is Hlophe above the law and untouchable, just like Zuma? 

It certainly appears so, as a paralysed JSC has delayed for more than a decade dealing with myriad serious complaints against him. DM


Comments - share your knowledge and experience

Please note you must be a Maverick Insider to comment. Sign up here or sign in if you are already an Insider.

Everybody has an opinion but not everyone has the knowledge and the experience to contribute meaningfully to a discussion. That’s what we want from our members. Help us learn with your expertise and insights on articles that we publish. We encourage different, respectful viewpoints to further our understanding of the world. View our comments policy here.

All Comments 6

  • An even graver set of circumstances has been scrupulously ignored for more than a decade, which is Hlope’s attempt to corrupt at least two Concourt judges. By that time it was already clear that Hlope lacked integrity but he has since been allowed to run amok with all the powers of the Chief Justice of the Western Cape. Did the JSC expect Hlope to miraculously grow a conscience in the meantime?

  • Timely reminder that judiciary is fallible and sometimes even malleable to crooked intentions. Hlope untouched = judicial compromise so why shouldn’t JZ score the same trick! Arrests are the only remedy; why such forbidden fruit?

  • Come on! We’ve all known for more than a decade that Hlophe is a dubious, duplicitous, dishonourable character. How he can be a lawyer – let alone a judge president – boggles the mind. And the saddest part of this whole sorry saga is that the JSE has allowed Hlophe to get away with his nonsense. It’s time for someone – anyone – at the JSE to start growing a backbone before we’re subjected to more of Hlophe disgraceful behaviour.

  • How is it that scum get away with so little or no consequences for a seemingly never-ending time? I pity any non-anc cadre who would attempt anything similar.

  • The only hope I cling to is that we have a strong and independent judiciary who have integrity as well as journalists with the same integrity and bravery. If our judiciary goes the same way as the corrupt politicians there IS no hope.
    The best journalists in the world will not be able to save what’s left of our country.

Please peer review 3 community comments before your comment can be posted