PODCAST REVIEW

Behind the Music: From Struggle songs to opera

By Neroli Price 16 October 2020

Legendary South African singer Miriam Makeba and Hugh Masekela. (Photo by Gallo Images / Sunday Times)

This week we step into the recording booth and listen to how music is made and reverberates across time. From Miriam Makeba and Hugh Masekela’s music-making in exile to the racialised Asian fantasies contained in Puccini’s Madama Butterfly, we explore how songs bear the mark of their creators and their time.

With the hit podcast, Song Exploder, being adapted into a Netflix show, it seems like music podcasts aren’t going anywhere. Indeed, the content and form are a match made in audio heaven.

Music, like podcasts, trade in the currency of emotion and intimacy. There’s something about audio that makes us feel and imagine more than other mediums. The two episodes below trace two very different musical journeys, although both fill out the dimensionality of the notes and sketch in the history of the lyrics in a way that allows you to listen differently.

Tune in and hear the hope and heartbreak that underscored the creation of both an operatic classic and some of the most well-known anti-apartheid Struggle songs.

***

Hugh Masekela & Miriam Makeba – 1980 Lost Notes (KCRW)

Format: Single episode
Length: The recent season of Lost Notes: 1980 includes 7 episodes each roughly 30 minutes in length
Year: 2020
Listen on: Apple Podcasts, Spotify, or any other podcast app or streaming service

The newest season of KCRW’s Lost Notes: 1980 profiles powerful music stories from this single year. From Stevie Wonder’s return hit Hotter Than July to the Sugarhill Gang’s follow-up to Rapper’s Delight, it’s packed with big names whose music defined the 1980s. Among these monumental figures stand South Africa’s own Hugh Masekela and Miriam Makeba.

“She’d gone from a darling to a menace in just a few short years. And how quickly that line can be crossed for black people. For black women. A country adores you until it hears the truth about itself from your mouth. From the mouths of people who look like you.”

Charting Masekela and Makeba’s exile from apartheid South Africa in the US, their brief marriage and the music they made together, the episode is an ode to Struggle songs. Particularly those incubated in the longing created by enforced distance. Drawing on the musical archive and interweaving it with biography and personal history, the result is a rich tapestry of sound and activism. We hear archival recordings of Makeba’s address to the UN on apartheid in 1963 and her tribute to Malcolm X while performing in Guinea in 1976.

In addition to the musicians, the only other voice that we hear is that of host, poet and cultural critic, Hanif Abdurraqib. His superb writing and gentle narration create the scenes and reflections that instill the music with meaning and context. He takes us to Lesotho, just over the border from South Africa, where Masekela and Makeba perform the Welcome Home Tour in 1980: “The weekend itself was a celebration. A small fantasy of liberation peeled off from the decades of oppression. Oppression that, even during the concert, still hovered.” You can’t help but feel the words. Feel what the music meant and still means.

It’s always a pleasure to hear local histories feature on the global media stage, but particularly so when they’re told with care and respect. Abdurraqib draws a direct line from the US to South Africa, from the past to the present when he details how the CIA and FBI began following Makeba in the 1970s:

“She’d gone from a darling to a menace in just a few short years. And how quickly that line can be crossed for black people. For black women. A country adores you until it hears the truth about itself from your mouth. From the mouths of people who look like you.”

Take a listen to history and music that you think you may know and be prepared to hear it in new ways.

***

Puccini’s Madama Butterfly: When My Ship Comes In – Aria Code (WQXR & The Metropolitan Opera)

Format: Single episode
Length: 33 minutes
Year: 2019
Listen on: Apple Podcasts, Radio Public, or any other podcast app or streaming service

If ever there’s proof of the power of good storytelling, it’s the ability to take something you think you’re not interested in and make it utterly fascinating. This is what Aria Code does with opera. Focusing on a famous aria – or a piece of music written for a single voice – as the core of each episode, the show makes the history of opera come alive. A collaboration between WQXR, New York’s classical music radio station, and the Metropolitan Opera, Aria Code is the gateway drug to falling in love with opera.

This episode unpacks Puccini’s aria Un bel di vedremo from one of the most loved and hated operas of all time: Madama Butterfly. Singing the aria is Cio-Cio San, also known as Butterfly, a Japanese woman waiting for her American lover to return. Alone with their child after years of waiting, Butterfly cannot give up hope that he’ll return.

With four different guests: a soprano, a composer and conductor, a professor and a writer with her own real-life Madama Butterfly story, Grammy Award-winner and host Rhiannon Giddens considers the aria from multiple angles. At once a cautionary tale to Japanese audiences about the danger of the West and a western psychosexual fantasy of Asia and Asian women, the aria is political and deeply emotional. It touches at the uncomfortable closeness of delusion and hope. “Illusion is harder to let go of than reality.”

Perhaps the greatest feat of the episode is unfolding the story of the aria alongside a real-world counterpart. Kyoto Katayama tells the story of her parents: a Japanese woman and an American GI who was shipped out of Japan before realising he was going to be a father. This real-life Madama Butterfly adds complexity and realness to our understanding of the aria.

If you’re looking for more sonic love letters, Radio New Frame’s Charles Leonard gifts listeners with a themed mixtape every week.

Happy listening! DM/ML

Gallery

Comments - share your knowledge and experience

Please note you must be a Maverick Insider to comment. Sign up here or if you are already an Insider.

Everybody has an opinion but not everyone has the knowledge and the experience to contribute meaningfully to a discussion. That’s what we want from our members. Help us learn with your expertise and insights on articles that we publish. We encourage different, respectful viewpoints to further our understanding of the world. View our comments policy here.

All Comments 1

  • SATIRICALLY SPEAKING

    Let’s twist again, like we did last Zuma

    By Malibongwe Tyilo