The legacy of Meles Zenawi: What might have been
- Kevin Bloom
- 23 Aug 2012 11:03 (South Africa)
In February this year, a few days after I’d written a news article for this website under the header “The AU summit: A rare ring of truth”, Janice Winter, a journalist with an Oxford degree in international development, decided to set me straight by penning a rebuttal entitled “Meles Zenawi: Where the truth lies”. Foolishly, I fired back the same week with a rebuttal to her rebuttal, cleverly (or so I thought) calling it “The Ethiopia of Ms Winter’s discontent”.
Now that Meles has passed—he died on Monday in a Brussels hospital at the age of 57—it’s only right that I come clean. And my confession is this: while I was aware back then that in highlighting the Ethiopian prime minister’s positive attributes I’d be under-emphasising his dark side, I had just returned from a trip to the country during which I’d conducted interviews and research on his economic policies (for a forthcoming book on China’s influence in Africa), and my impressions had been such that I considered the angle justified in a column of necessarily compromised length.
Beyond that, I felt my decision was buttressed by Joseph Stiglitz’s much-cited 2007 op-ed in the New York Times, wherein the Nobel-winning economist had applauded Ethiopia’s annual growth rate of 10%, attributing the remarkable incline to Meles alone. Although Stiglitz did refer in his piece to the “controversial” elections of 2005, conceding that Meles had jailed opposition members and journalists who’d demonstrated against the government, he went on to note that shortly after the incident 30 opposition members had been given amnesty and released.
Stiglitz also wrote the following: “Meles’s overthrow of Mengistu not only ended the Red Terror, but also centuries of domination by the Amharas. Power was devolved toward the regions, and a most unusual constitutional provision, giving regions rights to withdraw, ensured that the centre would not abuse its powers.”
Of course, as the weeks of follow-up research would show me, it had always been highly unlikely that this constitutional provision would be tested via a referendum—and indeed, not only did Meles die without putting the clause into practice, he routinely and defiantly abused the powers of “the centre”.
During his lifetime, in his speeches and papers, Meles may have praised the tenets of democracy and inclusive governance—he may have even called his economic model “democratic developmentalism”—but it was obvious from his actions that the man was not a democrat. Undeniably, his standard response to journalists who were critical of his regime was to imprison them, and his economy, although it had been somewhat liberalised, was anything but open. After all, to do big business in Meles’s Ethiopia, connections to his office were crucial, and foreign investors were shut out of most key sectors, including banking.
The most damning stain on Meles’s legacy, however, will remain the extent of his crackdown on those election demonstrations in 2005—a crackdown that Siglitz neglected to fully acknowledge in his New York Times piece. To be clear about the scale of it: at least 193 people were killed, thousands were arrested, and scores of opposition activists and journalists were detained without trial on spurious charges of treason.
As the editorial board of the Washington Post observed after the prime minister’s death this week: “Mr. Meles’s desire to protect his political ‘system’ grew more and more repressive. Under the guise of national security, the parliament passed legislation between 2007 and 2009 to stifle dissent. According to Amnesty International, an anti-terrorism law ‘effectively criminalises freedom of expression.’ The State Department’s 2011 human rights report notes that the government arrested more than 100 people between March and September, including opposition political figures, activists, journalists, and bloggers.”
So, as a journalist who’s supposed to believe in media freedom—and who knew, prior to visiting Ethiopia, that Meles had more journalists in prison than any African head of state—what was it that impressed me about the prime minister? How could I, according to Ms Winter and a number of incensed Ethiopian journalists-in-exile, have gotten him so wrong?
On one level, it has to be reiterated that Meles, despite his authoritarian bent, did do much good for his country. His intellectual force was legendary, and, according to the writer and Africanist Alex de Waal (currently executive director of the World Peace Foundation) and the Ethiopian diplomat Abdul Mohammed (chief of staff for the African Union High Level Implementation Panel on Sudan), in his very first press conference as prime minister he declared that he would consider his government a success if Ethiopians were able to eat three meals a day.
“All his national policies were framed around the conquest of poverty,” the duo wrote on Wednesday. “Unconvinced by the prescriptions of the IMF and the World Bank, he held back on accepting international loans until his conditions were met... Throughout the next two decades, he was uniquely ready to engage in sustained debate with policy makers, diplomats and scholars from around the world.”
It was this commitment to the vision of Ethiopian and African development, a vision manifest in his 10% growth rate (as ratified by the IMF itself), that I witnessed first-hand during Meles’s speech at the inauguration of the new African Union headquarters in January. What intrigued me most were his scathing references, throughout the speech, to The Economist magazine. Known to be high on his reading list—Meles had both an MBA and a master’s degree in economics—he blamed the magazine for espousing the same market fundamentalist principles that had once crippled the economies of Africa.
First, citing the infamous “Hopeless Continent” cover line that ran in The Economist in 2000, Meles attributed the lost decades of the late twentieth century to failed African leaderships and the misdirected interventionist measures of the West. “We were given medicines,” he said, “that were worse than the disease.” Then, building up to the “Africa Rising” theme that ran in the magazine in 2011, he spoke of an unprecedented investment surge and “access to new powers of finance and growth.”
As was typical of Meles, the speech was profound and engaging, a rousing monologue peppered with his trademark dry wit, and its message was as strong as it was unambiguous: Africa, for the first time in almost 50 years, was beginning to make its own decisions.
But given the presence behind him on the stage of China’s senior political adviser Jia Qinglin—and taking into account the $200 million Chinese donation that had just paid for these new AU headquarters—there was an even more significant cover line to mark the hypothesis, and it was by a quirk of fate the one that appeared in The Economist of that very week. “The rise of state capitalism,” the magazine declared, from the front page of its 21 January 2012 edition.
The corresponding text, which argued that China no longer viewed state-directed companies as a means to the end of liberal capitalism but rather as an end in themselves, noted that a growing number of developing nations were beginning to agree with the policymakers in Beijing. What the report didn’t note was that Ethiopia, with an economy growing even faster than China’s, had long been one of them.
In February 2012, the opening of a $600-million cement factory underlined in a profound way Meles’s partiality to the Chinese model of growth through infrastructural spend. Located 70 km northwest of Addis Ababa, the factory has a yearly capacity of 2.5 million metric tons and is funded by, amongst others, Saudi Arabian/Ethiopian billionaire Sheikh Mohammed al-Amoudi, the European Investment Bank, the African Development Bank, the Development Bank of Ethiopia, and the International Finance Corporation. Built by China National Building Materials Co., the project is an archetypal Meles initiative—a meeting of West and East in a context that is distinctly African.
And this brings up the second reason that I couldn’t help but admire the man. Often referred to as Africa’s wiliest head of state, Meles became an adept at playing the West off against China. The former needed him as a stabilising force in a region routinely rendered volatile by Somalia and Sudan, and the latter saw in him a likeminded “strong man”—a supreme leader of an effective one-party state (in the 2010 elections, Meles’s party, the EPRDF, took 99.6% of the vote)—with whom they could do some very good business.
The $4 billion that Meles received in development aid each year was a direct result of this political nous, and was linked, many said, to his country being constantly named as the fastest-growing non-oil economy on the continent. Question was, did his brand of donor-driven industrial development translate into disposable income for ordinary Ethiopians?
With a population of 85 million and a projected national income of $38.5 billion, Ethiopia is still one of the poorest countries in the world. Rampant inflation was always going to be the principal side-effect of Meles’s infrastructure projects—it had been running for a while at around 50%, although in March 2012 dropped to a nine-month low of 32.5%. In Addis Ababa, while the populace can now commute on highways built by Chinese contractors with Chinese loans, the bulk still live in tin shantytowns, and the cost of living leaves little prospect for upward mobility.
Perhaps understandably, Ethiopia’s many political exiles cited such statistics to pop the myth of Meles’s genius. And yet, within the country, there existed a genuine respect for the leader—if not exactly “love”. On Tuesday, I was moved by a posting on Facebook of a young man named Hallelujah Lulie, who, when I spoke to him in his office at the Institute for Security Studies in Addis, had been eloquent and forthright on the subject of Meles’s autocratic methods.
“Meles is no more,” wrote Hallelujah, “but the radical transformation he made to the state, citizenship and polity will continue to define the political and public life of the nation for decades to come. He was a visionary and competent leader who stood up against injustice as a young man, unfortunately his democracy and justice project failed. He and his government made some stubborn decisions with lasting consequences. Meles was no democrat, but he surely raised the bar for the top post. Though imposed, the economic vision he had for the nation changed the country and has [the] power to transform the nation. I can’t hide my sadness and shock.”
A photograph a few lines above the post showed Meles in deep conversation, in the main hall of the new AU headquarters in January, with none other than Thabo Mbeki. Hallelujah’s caption? “This was the last time I saw Meles, conversing with his dear friend of [the] same calibre…”
Another case, unfortunately, of what might have been. DM
- Rest in peace, Madiba. Thank you for everything.
- Revealed: America's new greatest writer was Ayn Rand's lover
- We were wrong! But happily, Israeli elections haven't gone to the right
- Israeli elections: The bizarre payoffs of Bibi's 'illegal settlement' record
- The Church of Scientology's week from hell
- Let's make Oxfam famous for its epic stupidity, not charity
- The return of Sir Ranulph: A winter traverse of Antarctica
- Hollywood, Newtown, and Obama's showdown with the gun lobby
- China in Africa: A narrative glance from a bullet train
- The KPMG report and the confirmed indestructibility of the Mandela legacy
- Poetic Justice: Fifty Shades author named ‘Publishing Person of the Year’
- Ms Clinton and Mr Lieberman: Next US president 'hearts' Israel’s Putin?
- Kim Jong-un 'Sexiest Man Alive': Is the joke on China or the West?
- How Richard Goldstone saved thousands of lives in Operation Pillar of Defence
- Goodbye, Transgression: Philip Roth retires his literary libido
- Attack on Gaza: Not another Bibi election ploy
- The 'butterfly effect' and the crisis at the BBC
- Early Israeli elections a failsafe Netanyahu ploy
- The EU's Nobel Peace Prize: Backslappers unite!
- Found in translation: Mo Yan wins literature Nobel
- Chinese security threat or US insecurity? Congress attacks Huawei
- Clint and cute animals: Warner Brothers at 90
- Apple, China, and the mounting violence of the profit margin
- Zuma and Xi: Uncanny similarities, vast differences
- View from China: Anti-Japanese sentiment spills onto the streets
- View from Beijing: The Bo Xilai affair and the looming leadership changeover
- Attack on Iran: Israeli opinion shaped by US casino mogul
- Julian Assange and Joseph Heller: A match made in prison
- The legacy of Meles Zenawi: What might have been
- Facebook's vicious cycle - the price of playing by Wall Street's rules
- Hypocrisy and context: SA, Israel and the growing BDS movement
- Death of a humorist: The beautiful pessimism of David Rakoff
- Marilyn Monroe and the invention of 'sex'
- Paulo Coelho, Amanda Hocking, and social media's great publishing lie
- Legacy Wars Redux: Jan Smuts vs Dullah Omar
- Only in America: The tragic inevitability of the Aurora massacre
- Bullets Over Tel Aviv: Why Woody Allen shouldn't shoot in Israel
- Standoff in South China Sea: US and People's Republic test the waters
- Ernest Borgnine, beloved actor 'with a face for radio', dies at 95
- Springsteen in Paris: An intimate night with The Boss
- Mohamed Morsi and the likely end of the Camp David Accords
- The Endgame: Assange running low on support - and options
- Gitta Sereny: Death of a journalistic iconoclast
- Danny Boyle's Olympic vision: The £27-million nervous breakdown
- When a hero is cheated: Why Pacquiao's loss is boxing's tragedy
- The Diamond Jubilee: What would Shakespeare say?
- Facing extradition, Julian Assange chooses his master
- IPO lawsuit: Remember when Facebook was the biggest thing on the planet?
- Covering Israel's immigration laws: When anti-Zionism becomes anti-Semitism
- Capital punishment and the US's mounting shame
- Marilyn Monroe: Graydon Carter's blunting edge
- Making the monsters bearable: Maurice Sendak dies at 83
- Elon Musk: On the brink of re-inventing space travel
- The Scream: An existential steal at $120 million
- File destruction 101: How to whitewash the colonial legacy of 'cool Britannia'
- Time's 100 Most Influential People in the World: A heartbreaking list of staggering genius
- Robert Caro on Lyndon Johnson: One book, half a lifetime
- Israel and Gunther Grass: A knee-jerk reaction to a really terrible poem
- Peter Beinart: The Jewish world's most divisive intellectual
- Rage: It's all the rage right now
- At last, Ziggy Stardust gets a seat next to Lord Byron
- View from the Eastern DRC: A day and a night in Goma
- But wait... what if this isn't the End of the West?
- War in the Middle East: Aipac has spoken, again
- Putin wins – but who did he beat and what does it mean?
- An Israeli attack on Iran: 'if' moves closer to 'when'
- The end of state capitalism in China?
- No accident: The death of Marie Colvin
- Consider the Human: David Foster Wallace at 50
- A nuclear Iran: Netanyahu's 'Churchill moment' looms dangerously close
- Return of Die Antwoord: The endearingly soft side of Zef
- The sad sameness of another JFK love affair
- The Ethiopia of Ms Winter's discontent
- Dickens at 200: The man who made Christmas and influenced Karl Marx
- Glencore and Xstrata: Former Witsies create mining's most feared mega-merger
- Facebook IPO: The hype and the value
- The AU Summit: A rare ring of truth
- Un-Davos 2012: The World Economic Forum that isn't
- The story of the shelving of SOPA/PIPA - not so simple
- Kodak bankruptcy - the end of the funky yellow box
- James Joyce: Free at last
- Piers Morgan's first year - what the ratings (and others) say
- How to gear up for Facebook's IPO, or, Zuckerberg's 'insane' vacation
- Stop presses: Why Rupert Murdoch may have joined Twitter
- A century later, Amundsen claims more than just South Pole
- Putin loses his iron grip
- Pearl Harbour: 70 years later, the conspiracy theory still endures
- Tiger finally wins, but it's hardly a 'comeback'
- The Frankenburger: Why 'cultured meat' is humanity's destiny
- Bad Sex - The soft heart of the South African male
- The Rolling Stones at 50: Who's planning next year's party?
- Michael Bloomberg's unsatiated ambition - a cautionary tale
- Time travel: The upshot of faster-than-light
- Occupied no more: where next for 'the movement'?
- Local government's electricity tariff hikes - an economic perspective
- Billy 'safe bet' Crystal back to host Oscars
- Carlos the Jackal returns... to court
- Analysis: Yet more proof of the demise of the American male
- Unforgiven - the aftermath of Ruth and Andrew Madoff's 60 Minutes confessional
- After Unesco welcomes Palestine, a new conflict front may be open
- Coming soon to the Senate: pay $500,000 for house plus free US visa
- Beavis and Butt-head returns: Why the US needs all the 'stupid' it can get
- Largest cell phone study yet - the contents of this box do not cause cancer
- Analysis: If Amazon ruled book publishing, too...
- Revolution rumbles as Occupy Wall Street goes global
- Largest insider trading case ever: Rajaratnam gets 11 years
- Big-shot intellectuals lend (yet more) weight to Occupy Wall Street
- War of the populisms: Occupy Wall Street vs. the Tea Party
- Nobel week: medicine prizewinner dies before announcement; literature speculation heats up
- View from New Orleans: America's cultural jewel post-Katrina
- Assange the (would-be) Censor: Uncensored
- Palestine's UN bid: If Abbas isn't bluffing, history is about to be made
- Analysis: Why Democrats fear losing the Jewish vote
- View from Middle America: Why US literature has failed 9/11
- View from Middle America: Iowa may be losing that loving feeling, Mr President
- Booker 2011: Julian Barnes's year, surely
- Confirmed: The end of the paperback era
- View from Middle America: Dissent in the Michele Bachmann heartland
- Jorge Luis Borges: Google's shrewdest doodle yet
- Australia edges ahead of SA in oldest fossil showdown
- World markets: An idiot’s guide to keeping calm
- The problem with defining addiction as a 'brain disease'
- The Christian fundamentalist heritage of Bachmann and Perry - a crash course
- The Dow Jones Industrial Average: An instructive history
- China’s two-punch combo: First the US debt crisis, now the launch of an aircraft carrier
- Debt crisis result: Congress and Republicans bad, Obama (sort of) good
- A literary milestone: Discovery of first travel narrative published in South Africa
- US debt deal: A middle finger to first commandment of economics
- US national default: The funny side
- Writers without Borders: Death of a bookstore chain
- Freud, cocaine, and the 'talking cure' - a theory
- The inner life of the tabloid journalist
- Murdoch's US troubles begin as FBI probe 9/11 hacking allegations
- News Corp implosion: Rot extends to Sun, Sunday Times, and Wall Street Journal
- Alan Rusbridger: Return of the editor as hero
- Decline and fall of the Murdoch Empire?
- The Milly Dowler saga: UK chokes on its own tabloid culture
- Graham Chapman: Not dead, just pining for the fjords
- Beyond populism: Michele Bachmann and the politics of Armageddon
- Who’s the fool? China's soft-diplomacy on Libya highlights Western media bias
- Weiner resignation: A tragicomic tale of media frenzies, hypocritical politics, and penis pictures
- Judgment Day aftermath: Camping suffers stroke, believer prosecuted in Malawi
- Anthony Weiner: Heh-heh, you said 'penis'
- Caster Semenya: Victories not erasing history, but victories nonetheless
- V.S. Naipaul and the art of the literary insult
- The enormously anxious influence of Harold Bloom
- As Judgment Day fails to dawn, it's no time for cheap shots
- Dylan at 70: Still one step ahead of the persecutor within
- Life, the universe, and Douglas Adams - ten years later
- Countdown to Judgment Day - global cult stays firm as weeks turn into days
- The torture and the glory: secrets of the navy Seals who terminated Osama bin Laden
- Holocaust Day, Israel and bin Laden: The fear and the paradox
- Glencore: One of the world's most secretive firms goes public
- Chasing the Bang Bang: Hollywood's conflict with combat photography
- On meeting Prince Charles
- 'What would you do?' - Bradley Manning's back in the headlines
- 'You're an idiot, babe' - Dowd misfires on Dylan's China tour
- Liberté unravelled: Sarkozy's burqa ban stumbles into being
- Cobain remembered: Like Hendrix, but not entirely
- Goldstone's 'regret': Why Israel and world Jewry should revere him
- David Foster Wallace: A morality tale from the grave
- Bob Glenister's message: 'If the population doesn't rise, it means nothing'
- The new Chinese economic theme: Happiness!
- Hillary Rodham Clinton: A story that’s unlikely to get its rightful ending
- Confirmed: the super rich are unbearably miserable - and yes, we need to cry for them
- Internet kills the PR star: The all-new DIY churnalism detector
- Maybe get a blister on your thumb: SA guitarist to front for Dire Straits
- England's pain: As told by a Saffer with an Irish passport
- The cult of Sachin: A tale of a cricket fan and a secret TV in Jaipur
- Why Mel Gibson matters
- Jaipur, Rajasthan: A lesson in chaos, beauty and confusion
- Analysis: What the Egyptian revolution means for Israel
- Church of Scientology slammed in massive New Yorker exposé
- Analysis: Chinese foreign minister's Zim visit brings more questions than answers
- AOL gobbles up Huffington Post for $315 million, leaving many puzzled
- Plagiarism's Mr Universe: Editor of US Men's Health
- Comcast NBC Universal: what is the behemoth good for?
- Ricky Gervais: Biting hard on the hand that feeds
- The ‘Gin Craze’ and UK drinking laws: Wills and Kate change history
- Analysis: Mbeki's 'two nations' hits the US
- Youth festival fiasco: What would you do with R69 million?
- Mark Madoff's suicide: No point asking why
- Shanghai kids the world's smartest
- Remembering John Lennon: Three decades later, superlatives still apply
- Rubber toys and electronic cigars: China product fair blitzes Africa
- Has Andrew Jennings killed England's 2018 World Cup hopes? Not likely.
- Masters of the Universe start spending again: Could the financial crisis be over?
- It's finally out there: China wants to replace America
- Top Gear tries, again, to make it in America
- Monarchy in the UK: Johnny Rotten's about-face in The Sun
- Anglo American's PR campaign: not quite the full story
- Publishing industry sea-change, brought to you by James Frey
- Person of the Year: Time to get it right
- Houellebecq wins Prix Goncourt? Whatever.
- Should the dream ever sour: Dubya's bookie thing
- The Cleopatra revival: Egypt's last pharaoh still dazzles and confounds
- Google Maps causes international incident, again
- China vs. America: Does it even matter in the long-term?
- Idiocracy: a chronicle of our future
- I'm (almost) a believer: Neil Diamond selling out in SA
- Life gets even better for Google employees
- Heroin, books and blues: Keef's memoir is out
- Analysis, Part II: Why China needs Africa more
- Drugs and bad dates: 2012 'Doomsday' industry teeters
- Analysis, Part I: Does Africa need China?
- Maybe, just maybe, Vavi has a point about Walmart...
- Can the world's ageing population benefit Africa?
- Does South Africa have hipsters?
- 'Foundation' trouble: What Thabo Mbeki is up against
- Booker 2010: Galgut fails, but who said the novel’s dead?
- Israel's 'loyalty pledge' for non-Jews: What would Hitchens say?
- Have you read anything by Mario Vargas Llosa?
- The Nobel Prize in Literature: A controversial and contested pedigree
- Revisiting Wall Street: Michael Lewis succeeds where Oliver Stone fails
- It’s Ryder Cup war, and General Monty wants revenge
- Planet with ‘100% chance’ of alien life discovered, life on Earth mostly unmoved
- The life of kings: David Simon, the 'genius' grant and journalism
- The 'sellout' debate: Madiba, Dylan and the modern-day saint
- The Roma: Still Europe's most unwanted people
- Zuckerberg fights Hollywood smear with New Yorker profile and $100 million charity cheque
- Franzen to appear on Oprah: What's changed?
- Gold Reef City sues Carte Blanche for R47 million: Whose side are you on?
- Why the Booker isn't golf
- Alice Walker: The respectfully humiliating non-interview
- Madonna before Madonna: The woman who introduced Miles to Hendrix finally speaks
- When democracy becomes populism: Palin, Malema and the rise of the unread
- The verdict is finally in: Language informs the way we think
- Grocott's Mail: Small-town paper, big-time rep
- Freedom's reign begins: In defence of Franzen and 'high art'
- Facebook, the great alibi
- Medical marijuana: Obama kinda chilled about it
- Selebi trial: Flint’s testimony adds little to State’s case, but provides fascinating background