Dailymaverick logo

Opinionistas

This article is an Opinion, which presents the writer’s personal point of view. The views expressed are those of the author/authors and do not necessarily represent the views of Daily Maverick.

This article is more than a year old

Why don’t you just leave the bloody leaves where they fall? Is that so difficult?

This will be of no interest to you if you don’t live in a leafy suburb or next to a park. It’s about middle-class urban angst.

On a peaceful Saturday morning the suburban curse announces itself this way:

vvvvWWAAAHHHHHHHH

mmmMWMAAAAAAWAAAAHHHHH

NNNNAAAAHHHHHHHHHH

VVMMMAAAAAAAAHHHHHHHHHHH

brum brum brum brum

HYYYAYAAAAAAAHHHHHHHNNNNHHHHNNN

The sound is several houses away but at a decibel level that sets my teeth on edge. A neighbour is moving leaves off his lawn with his new petrol-driven leaf blower. 

I’m not alone in my dislike for these damned machines. Last week I got an email from a Mrs D de Suza in a ‘formerly peaceful KZN village’ asking Daily Maverick for help – any kind of help. Her life, she wrote, is becoming increasingly less peaceful due to noise from leaf blowers and weed eaters. “Insects, lizards etc are blown away by them together with the leaves. Leaves are surely not so bad? Why are they unwanted? Plastic litter lies around for years.”

The sound of blowers obviously had an effect on semi-South African tech entrepreneur who is almost as irritating as a leaf blower: Elon Musk. On X he texted: “Tesla is going to develop a quiet, electric leaf blower.” 

He means battery-operated of course so you don’t have to trail a cord behind you which literally has its limits. It wasn’t his idea, there were a few around, but if he can build a rocket to get to Mars there’s hope for a reliable, inexpensive solution to my Saturday mornings. 

However, that was in 2019 and it hasn’t happened yet. Maybe he got too busy landing booster rockets without crashing them and campaigning for Donald Trump. But I appreciate his sentiment: leaf blowers and weed eaters are awful pieces of gardening equipment. 

Let's begin with the sound. I watch council workers with blowers and their close cousin, weedeaters, attacking road verges and parks. Have you ever seen them wearing ear protection or dust masks (or face masks because weedeaters sling stones)? No? Me neither. 

Incidentally, these guys also kill vagrant grass along pavement edges with leaf-murdering Roundup without masks. Clearly, they are expendable labour. 

Extended exposure to anything above 55 decibels causes hearing damage and a leaf blower hits 100 or more. That doesn’t just go for its operator, but also the guy several houses removed. Noise pollution can cause stress, headaches, difficulty sleeping, productivity loss, higher heart attack rates…all that crappy stuff.

If you ever watch leaf chasers, you’ll notice it’s not an exact science. It’s like herding butterflies. They’re annoyingly inefficient machines. They blast into the air leaves and everything else lying around and a breeze happily puts them back where they came from. To get a decent pile to scrape into a bag takes five times the effort of using a leaf rake. 

And there’s dust, deadly particulates from traffic tyres, mould, spores, aerosolized bird shit, pesticide particles you shouldn’t invite into your lungs at any cost and insects that need leaves to produce all the nutrients that the soil needs to grow a healthy lawn and garden. 

Leaf blowers generate wind speeds of nearly 300 kilometres an hour and on a calm day the dust can take hours to settle.

Removing leaves is breaking a cycle of life that’s sustained it for millions of years. Trees soak up nutrients from mycorrhizal networks around their roots and redistribute them through fallen leaves. Along the way, this provides other essential cycles for wonderful little creatures that thrive under the fallen canopy. They love fallen leaves. Leaf blowers blast their world to smithereens.

We need to be kind to insects. Ever heard of the insect apocalypse? The planet is running out of them. A German etymological society collected 27 years of splat reports of insects hitting cars and found a reduction of 75%. Without them, we wouldn’t survive a month.

Then there’s emissions. On a basic exhaust level, the pollutants a two-stroke engine leaf blower emits into the world are hundreds of times worse than your car. These include carbon monoxide, which contributes to ground-level ozone, nitrous oxides which contribute to smog formation, hydrocarbons which can be carcinogenic and nitrous oxides, which can cause acid rain.

One study reported by the Sierra Club showed that under normal usage conditions, a leaf blower two-stroke engine emits nearly 300 times the hydrocarbons of a Ford Raptor and loads of carbon monoxide and nitrous oxides as well. 

If you drove the Raptor for several thousand kilometres, the amount of hydrocarbons emitted would be equivalent to using the two-stroke leaf blower for about half an hour of yard work. Hard to believe but the science is there.

Okay excuse my irritation, I’ve had my middle-class suburban gripe, but that idiot down the road is still blasting leaves. 

vvvvWWAAAHHHHHHHH
mmmMWMAAAAAAWAAAAHHHHH
brum brum brum brum. 

WHEN WILL IT STOP? 

Hold up messing around with rockets and elections, Elon. You’re urgently needed in the gardening tools department. DM

Comments

Bruce Gordon Nov 8, 2024, 05:28 AM

100% with you. Leaf blowers are the most pointless item of garden equipment ever invented. Watching them at work in my KZN village has convinced me that a rake is far more effective and environmentally friendly. If you actually really need to move those leaves.

Mike Lawrie Nov 8, 2024, 06:44 AM

Spot on.

virginia crawford Nov 8, 2024, 06:44 AM

Couldn't agree more. Strimming lawn around trees also ring barks and eventually kills them. Go outside and check the trees on your pavement and see the scars! Also if you want to create your own private mini-desert, then destroying top soil is a good start. A quiet rake is good for the soul.

edwardwes Nov 8, 2024, 07:36 AM

Finally, a public alarm for this environmental scourge. I see homeowners and gardeners shuffling a leaf or two for hours one end. I think of the environmental devastation to make such a machine. Screaming noise across the suburb. I am at a loss for words. .

brianwendy Nov 8, 2024, 08:01 AM

I fully agree with you. We live in the coastal town / city of Hermanus, wait until the garden service hits your neighbourhood. A raucous of note. Ps: must admit that I am also guilty when we use the weed eater to cut the lawn about once a week. My revenge against the neighbours.

Fanie Rajesh Ngabiso Nov 8, 2024, 09:29 AM

There is a special place in Hell reserved for leaf blower owners. It's right next to the mid-life crisis Harley owners.

Richard Kennard Nov 8, 2024, 04:10 PM

And the generator in lieu of the invertor come loadshedding

David Bruce Nov 8, 2024, 10:08 AM

Thanks Don! A highlight of my morning is to walk past a nearby school: big fields, many surrounding trees, & a bit of a view. You can imagine what the purchase of a leafblower by the school, which is put to work first thing in the morning, does to 'enhance' this experience.

John Cartwright Nov 8, 2024, 02:37 PM

Brooms are cheap to buy and cost zero to run, they're silent, good for the health of the user and the environment and at least as efficient.

Derek Sumption Nov 8, 2024, 02:44 PM

You're spot on, I live in Illovo (JHB) and some twat starts up his leaf blower at 6.30 every morning!! We used to wake up to the sound of birds chirping, now we get this awful bloody machine, they should be banned!

Mary Reynolds Reynolds Nov 8, 2024, 03:42 PM

Surely running a leafblower at dawn isn't legal? Can't you and other neighbours shut him or her down?

Mary Reynolds Reynolds Nov 8, 2024, 03:26 PM

Thanks. I entirely agree, except about Elon's tool: we really don't need that! Leafblowers are ridiculous and shouldn't be legal.

Johan Buys Nov 8, 2024, 05:18 PM

Many contractors switched to battery. Quiet, powerful, and free from the cycle of servicing & fueling the two stroke motor. Free tip : pick a platform and convert power tools over time so that same battery that runs blower also runs chain saw, trimmer, weed-eater, etc. Stihl is solid if $$

Johan Buys Nov 8, 2024, 05:21 PM

Mr Pinnock, 55 decibles is about the noise of a fridge. Turn down that hearing aid! (With apologies to Autograph)

Don Pinnock Nov 10, 2024, 02:04 PM

Thanks Johan. That fact was the only one I asked AI and it got it wrong. Just shows the biggest mind in the planet is fallible...

Kanu Sukha Nov 13, 2024, 03:59 AM

AI got it wrong? That's not possible! We're told it's infallible! Even deployed now in the genocide in Palestine & Lebanon also. Another FIRST in the world! Accompanied by automated mass surveillance/data collection, atomic/nuclear weapons, chemical (agent orange) .. lots to be proud of!

Kanu Sukha Nov 13, 2024, 04:08 AM

These 'advances' in the hands of the west are O.K. ... until 'others' (a pox upon them!) access or also develop their own! Then we need a UN to 'control' them! This UN after about 75+ years has 'outlived' its usefulness to the 'powerful' & in the interests of Zionism needs 'replacement'.

Lawrence Sisitka Nov 9, 2024, 05:47 AM

And what about the whole nonsense of lawns. Patches of essentially sterile grass, with all nasty weeds (wild plants) exterminated through the use of herbicides, that people waste water on to irrigate, then fuel to cut, over and over again. Ban lawns immediately! Grow vegetables :)

janetkgraham Nov 11, 2024, 02:48 PM

Hear hear (literally). My most despised implement. I hate it with a passion, and the destruction caused, albeit unintentionally, is just horrendous.

Edwin Hees Nov 9, 2024, 08:47 AM

The best sound effects I've read for years! In full agreemenht with the points made above.

David McCormick Nov 9, 2024, 09:44 AM

Hideous machine. I owned one, purchased to suck (yes they suck too) leaves off pebbles that replaced lawn on sidewalk during drought. Shrouded in a cloud of sucked-up dust and engine fumes, hated by family and neighbours. Used thrice, hung around garage for five years then placed in recycling bin.

Alan Salmon Nov 10, 2024, 10:26 AM

Don you really are being a bit precious here. I do my own gardening and I use the leaf blower to clear driveway, paths and lawn, which probably takes less than 20 minutes. Raking would take an hour or two ! And yes I do leave the leaves in all the flower beds for mulch.

t Nov 10, 2024, 02:36 PM

Hilarious. I wonder how many of those people howling about leaf-blowers own DOGS!! You know the ones. Usually small and yappy and who's owners couldn't care about their neighbours or the peace in suburbia. Barking dogs, now that's an article. Leaf blowers aint got nothing on barking dogs.

Kanu Sukha Nov 13, 2024, 04:24 AM

I 'own' a cat (from the neighborhood) which 'adopted' me .. and love dogs also ! Though I don't currently own one or more. I do 'get on well' with most of the neighbors' who do, and they provide great delight, mostly. Not a dog whisperer .. yet ! Let me guess ... you don't own a dog ?

hweyers Nov 11, 2024, 11:19 AM

Natures natural compost. My mother-in -law used to use the household vacuum cleaner. All a total waste of time. Let your gardener sweep it off your pavement and dig it into your garden.

Larry Dolley Nov 14, 2024, 08:55 AM

So darn true. I suggest that this tool be banned. The south easter agrees here in Cape Town. I suggest they be redeployed to supermarkets and malls to replace temporary warning signs that are used to dry mopped floors. It reduces injury risk to shoppers as well?