Dailymaverick logo

Opinionistas

This article is an Opinion, which presents the writer’s personal point of view. The views expressed are those of the author/authors and do not necessarily represent the views of Daily Maverick.

This article is more than a year old

I reject the racial construct ‘coloured’ and its stranglehold on people’s lives

I was given an exciting birthday present this year: a DNA test. The result would scientifically and definitively tell me who I am, where I come from, and whether or not I – classified as ‘coloured’ under apartheid and still today – am an African, as indigenous as fynbos.

With a hard rain falling, and a raging wind forcing trees on the roadside to wave madly at me, I entered Franschhoek, the town that prides and sells itself on its French Huguenot roots, looking for a store to buy some provisions. I was on my way to Greyton for the weekend.

I stopped in front of Heritage Square and walked into Woolworths. I bought what I needed and walked back to my car to continue my journey to the Overberg.  

The moniker, Heritage Square, spoke directly to the just-received answers to my own search into my heritage and ancestry. For as long as I can remember, I have been wondering, who am I? What am I? Who exactly are my ancestors?

Different groups of invaders have between them spread a convenient lie that the indigenous people disappeared without a trace. They might have left behind names like Keiskamma, their clicks in the isiXhosa language, rock paintings, biltong, and remnants of ancient fish traps along the coastline, but they were gone, having left the Earth without leaving any descendants.

This myth and distortion made it easier for the various political regimes that ruled over South Africa to legally create a new group of people in the country: the so-called coloured people.

According to this convenient narrative, this group was the result of sexual relations between indigenous women – females shipped in chains to the Cape as slaves – and non-indigenous men.

As is the case when the conquerors narrate history, not much is said about these sexual encounters: were they willing or through rape – the inevitable punishment that invaders have since time immemorial inflicted on the women of the conquered to humiliate them and their men and to prove that they were their new and superior masters?

As is the practice internationally, those who take land by force usually imprint their identity on it. In the case of South Africa, white settlers claimed that they had brought civilisation, even, as in the case of my forebears, if that so-called civilisation included deadly chicken pox, and also mirrored to the indigenous people that they were inferior – in fact, barely more than animals.

This caused self-rejection, even self-hatred, and stealthily encouraged a desire to be anything but who we were.

This condition was given extra teeth during apartheid when people like me were despised and mocked by segregation laws. My family and I were kicked out of our home in District 6 and cruelly dumped on the Cape Flats.

Read more: Coloureds are Africans: We are the indigenous people of South Africa

After the first two democratic presidencies, our condition was further exacerbated by an ANC-led government that relentlessly advanced a policy of Africanisation. 

Today, millions of people like me are not regarded as African and are daily on the receiving end of dehumanising discrimination, in racial classification legislation and practice.

I never dreamed that apartheid would rise over South Africa again. I had seen up close the evil that it brings. 

In post-apartheid South Africa, we should have bolted the door to keep out the divisions, racial tension and league table that ranked groups in terms of rights, privileges and freedom.

We did not.

When I made my way through childhood and suffered the indignity of forced removals, I learned that apartheid had created a hierarchy. In so-called coloured communities, it was considered an advantage to have a European surname, an alleged European ancestor, and light skin or straight hair instead of kroes (crinkly) hair.

Looking in from the outside, it might have appeared to other black groups that the “coloured” identity was one to be envied. But it was not. I should know; I’ve lived it. It was simply a piece of evil National Party propaganda of divide and rule suiting their self-preservation purposes.

These days, when I hear the refrain “it’s our time”, I cynically add, “Yes, to justify stealing the land of my forefathers and to punish us for what you believe, that coloureds had a better time under apartheid.”     

Yeah, right. I was born into a group with an almost predictable future. That future included pervasive poverty that assaulted human dignity, dropping out of school, degrading and poorly paid jobs such as being messenger boys, tea girls, domestic servants, and, of course, a stint in prison for various crimes.

In May, the month of my birth, I was given an exciting birthday present: a DNA test. My DNA would be scientifically and comprehensively probed and the result would tell me who I am, where I come from, and whether I, despite what the ANC government may believe and pontificate, am an African, as indigenous as fynbos.

As I carefully followed the instructions and took the swabs required, I informed the laboratory doing the test that it could send a courier service to collect the sealed specimens.

Then it was time to wait for the outcome which was due to be delivered in about six weeks. It was a long time to spend not thinking about what the DNA results would show. After about five weeks, my curiosity got the better of me and I sent off an email to inquire when I could expect my results.

The reply was that it would be in a matter of days. In the following days, I checked my email burning with nervous anticipation. Finally, the results were there waiting to be opened, read and digested. It was a big moment, one of the biggest and most important ones of my life.

I read the report slowly. Not wanting to miss anything. Wanting to take in every word.

According to my DNA results, the main root in my bloodline is grounded in the KhoeSan (another name for KhoiSan), which, according to the report, “is the oldest population worldwide and has ties in southern Africa for centuries. The KhoeSan population are made up of Khoekhoe populations who were agropastoralists and the San who were historically hunter-gatherers. These populations were the first to meet the Europeans as they arrived at the southern tip of South Africa in the 15th and 17th centuries”.

So, there it was. The indigenous people are in my DNA and probably in those of millions of people like me. The report also said that in my veins flowed contributions from East and West Africa, central Europe and Asia. However, the KhoeSan is the main contributor.

There was a surprise, one that literally took my breath away, in the report. 

According to the DNA result, my maternal bloodline showed that I have the same ancient female ancestor as Nelson Mandela and Desmond Tutu. So, if these iconic South Africans are African, what does that make me? An African, nothing less; an African indigenous to South Africa.

I was shocked because I have known an environment where apartheid was so successful in burning the word “coloured” into our identity that some who have taken on this definition would be happy to be anything other than black and African.

Some have also lauded their slave ancestry but kept quiet about possible African links. As a journalist, I have also heard people in Mitchells Plain calling Mandela the despicable K-word.

As I absorbed the DNA information, some thoughts came to me: there should be an application made to the Constitutional Court to define what an African is and to declare that the descendants of the indigenous people living in South Africa are indeed the first Africans that lived here. Without such a decision, the government will not change its position and we are doomed to be forever defined as “coloured”, exactly like the apartheid masters labelled us.

As the descendants of the first indigenous Africans who lived in South Africa, we, the so-called coloured people, should accept our African identity and strenuously resist the temptation to counter our country’s relentless Africanisation by retreating into “coloured” nationalism.

Such a withdrawal, understandable as it is, is divisive and ultimately a belated victory for apartheid-style group identity.

I long for a real and not a pseudo-united country where all people born here, or who are naturalised South Africans, are free, equal and not condemned to a life filled with the pain of exclusion and identity denial.

If we don’t do this, then apartheid, whether through its new post-1994 African converts or the initial white architects of this despicable system, has won.

And we, the descendants of the indigenous people, will continue to live in denial of who we really are, without a true identity, drifting aimlessly, not belonging anywhere and being excluded everywhere. Just go look at the Cape Flats. If you dare.

As I sit writing here in Greyton, my ancestral village Genadendal – the Moravian mission station where my KhoiSan forebears exchanged their nomadic lifestyle and chose Christianity and survival – lies just down the road. I now have it in black and white: as an African, I belong here as much as the Riviersonderend Mountains behind Genadendal, the Karoo, or the ancient Keiskamma River.

I reject the racial construct “coloured” and its stranglehold on people’s lives. Sadly, some have even embraced it enthusiastically as an identity marker.

We should see it for what it is: a stronghold of the apartheid heresy that has remained standing, defiantly. It should be abolished. DM

Comments

Fanie Rajesh Ngabiso Sep 29, 2024, 10:12 PM

"I long for a real and not a pseudo-united country where all people born here, or who are naturalised South Africans, are free, equal and not condemned to a life filled with the pain of exclusion and identity denial." If we want national progress, this longing is essential for everyone.

Michael Britton Sep 30, 2024, 12:43 AM

At the International Jazz Fest in May, bassist and composer Benjamin Jephta performed tracks from his new album, called Born Coloured, Not Born Free. Jeptha, born in 1994, is a member of the born-free generation. Between compositions, he dissects and interrogates his "born coloured" experience.

Skinyela Sep 30, 2024, 07:20 AM

Shouldn't we reject all racial classifications and adopt a common identity, that of being South African?

Malcolm McManus Sep 30, 2024, 07:52 AM

I back that for sure. I am lilly white and am first and foremost South African. I have known nothing else. I will die being South African and embrace all South African cultures. I have no need for a DNA test to prove I am South African. What positive life improvement will a DNA test bring.

Josie Rowe-Setz Sep 30, 2024, 07:54 AM

Such a great article. Wish more of us felt like this, acted like this. Thank you

Malcolm McManus Sep 30, 2024, 08:25 AM

Since you've got this far, why stop there. Your name doesn't appear to fit your new found freedom or narrative. Its legal to change it. Nobody is stopping you.

adamskyle90 Sep 30, 2024, 08:52 AM

That little sense of identity that people do have, you want to abolish and chuck them into nihilistic freefall? Haibo.

Trenton Carr Sep 30, 2024, 09:17 AM

Why do you allow other people to define your Africaness? And how has that negativity effected your ability to be yourself today? I'm as white as the driven snow and as African as you can get, I belong to this continent, not groups of people in it, and I don't rely on black and white to tell me so.

T'Plana Hath Sep 30, 2024, 10:17 AM

Great article with an important message. "[M]y maternal bloodline shows I have the same ancient female ancestor as Nelson Mandela and Desmond Tutu." Not to burst your bubble, but you will find that ALL humans alive today have that common female ancestor - Mitochondrial Eve. We're all related!

alastairmgf Sep 30, 2024, 10:22 AM

That’s exactly what I thought when reading the article. Well said.

Malcolm McManus Sep 30, 2024, 10:47 AM

Yep, just that some people will go to great lengths to choose their relatives, even if its not possible, judging by this article. By implication, tells a deeper story.

Indeed Jhb Oct 1, 2024, 12:11 AM

Yep agreed, name dropping soo yesterday

Peter Oosthuizen Sep 30, 2024, 11:14 AM

Well done - the Bushmen (their name) in Nieu-Bethesda have taken back their identity and proudly display their heritage at the Bushman Heritage Museum. The people of the town are proud of who they are. I fully support the other, so called "coloured," communities to do the same.

Malcolm McManus Sep 30, 2024, 11:39 AM

I think most people in coloured communities celebrate their heritage. And so they should. Be proud. Don't be like Americans and see colour as a centuries old disadvantage.

Roke Wood Sep 30, 2024, 12:19 PM

A DNA test? great. My family settled in South Africa 200 years ago. Im a patriot and South African. one is entitled to have a DNA test to test their lineage or history. However, IMO we as citizens of SA should move past specific demographics and embrace our africaness, be proud to be South African.

ashleyhaywood4 Oct 7, 2024, 02:03 PM

Yes, except for a lot of us who are not white, our history has been stripped from us. It is an odd feeling not knowing where you truly come from but knowing that the ancestors of white South Africans have deliberately and carefully crafted that history (slave trade) and destroyed it (slavery).

Walter Spatula Sep 30, 2024, 12:44 PM

I am an African. It's mildly interesting, but of no consequence to me, who the "first Africans" were.

Pieter van de Venter Sep 30, 2024, 01:04 PM

Unfortunately to achieved this "impossible" dream, we have to get rid of the ANC and the EFF that keep on driving the race card. Neither will ever allow all of us to be citizens of the land.

Peter Dexter Sep 30, 2024, 01:06 PM

Great article Dennis. Please listen to Des Latham's - History of South Africa. The victors edit written history, meaning most of what we learned is rubbish. Too much blood has been spilt and mixed over the last 400 years: There was never any sense in classifying race, and it must stop now.

Beverley Roos-Muller Sep 30, 2024, 01:37 PM

Thanks for sharing this, Dennis. (Disappointed in finding my DNA is 100% Irish, bit of W. Scottish, not even one exotic ancestor!) Yet my heart lies at Africa's foot. Those who scoff at 'the race card' have no personal concept of the power of 'race', not only under apartheid but still, today.

Kanu Sukha Sep 30, 2024, 03:20 PM

Being 'exotic' might be nice .. but imagine how intoxicating (or is it awe-inspiring?) it would be to discover that you are part of 'God's Chosen People ' (reference - Gideon Levy)!

ashton Sep 30, 2024, 02:10 PM

I think it is easy for us to underestimate the pain and semi-conscious questions of identity that come from that kind of in-between identity that he describes as a Coloured in South Africa. Instead of criticising his experience, I prefer reading it slowly, and using it to help me understand that.

Brett Redelinghuys Sep 30, 2024, 02:11 PM

Dennis your points are 100% correct. We are African and the difference in hue, language, upbringing etc are all factors out of our control. We do need an honest decision, as to what is African. I am 9th gen, my boys 10th. If not African then what?

Kanu Sukha Sep 30, 2024, 02:48 PM

Fascinating ! Do you know if there is a 'test' for what ML King called 'character' - that is what I am really interested in finding out ? Not sure if I can get anyone to 'gift' that to me ? Sections fully describe what is happening in the Middle East right now .. genocide repeating itself.

Don Pinnock Sep 30, 2024, 02:50 PM

In a book I wrote some time back, Rainmaker (now sadly out of print) I outlined the powerful links contemporary people have to the ancient indigenous populations and the ridiculousness of the term Coloured. I also showed why there was resistance to that identity. Worth a read if you can get a copy.

Human Being Sep 30, 2024, 03:29 PM

There is no such thing as racism. We are all one race - the Human Race. Everyone's blood is red. We may have different ethnicities but one group is no better or worse than another. We are all equal in God's sight since we were made in the image of God. Finish + Klaar.

superjase Sep 30, 2024, 04:09 PM

1/2 what makes a person an african? being born here? having had one's parents also born here? grandparents? how many generations of african-born ancestors? having zero (1st generation) non-african ancesors mixed into the african-born ones?

Johan Buys Sep 30, 2024, 06:47 PM

We have many quirks. One of them is race as an adjective. Black South Africans. Nobody talks about Black Zambians or Black Zimbabweans NEARLY as much. When will we just be South Africans? Not in my lifetime, sadly. It is ACTUALLY about wealth & privilege, not race?

Indeed Jhb Oct 1, 2024, 12:04 AM

Read Mbeki's speach 'I am an African'. Unless you are black you can never be one. Yet soccer player John Barnes can be 'Brittish', Obama 'American' Despite being 11th generation I am still not African because I am 'white'. So Dennis wake up and smell the roses you are not special.

berniemkiewiet Oct 1, 2024, 05:20 AM

Good morning Dennis, I advocated this for the past 50 years, often to much ridicule from family, friends and colleagues. But I continued and had my novel, Life's Soiled Red Earth, published last year, which your book review editor rejected at that time. Thanks, I will share this everywhere.

David Bristow Oct 1, 2024, 06:54 AM

In reality it's much more complicated. Starting with the San, who might argue that the Khoe stole their heritage. It often strikes me that if you lined up all the racial "types" on any street in Cape Town you would have a continuum of just about every human DNA type.

frankvdv Oct 1, 2024, 11:25 AM

Hi Dennis, it is pleasant to see your writings again. A well written and balanced article, inspiring in fact

Maria Zinsser Oct 1, 2024, 12:16 PM

Thanks Dennis! I too was thrilled to find out that "my ma se ma se ma"* 8 great-grandmothers removed, we are offspring from Maria Evert or Zwarte Maria, a slave child from Guinea, in addition to the Visagie, Spangenberg, Theron, Taillefer, Van der Merwe admixture. *Diana Ferrus

Nkunku S Oct 1, 2024, 12:00 PM

Brah you have issues

Peter Southey Oct 1, 2024, 05:54 PM

On the day I admire the sanity of Dennis's article, DM also informs me of the insanity of the 20 000 new race inspectors we will be paying for. How ironic.

User Oct 17, 2024, 06:12 PM

You are never what you claim to be, you will always BE what others think you are. Have PEACE my brother.

Jennifer D Nov 22, 2024, 07:46 PM

We are all Africans - my family have been here since the early 1800s and I have lived in Europe and America and this is my home. We need to embrace our country and our fellow countrymen and stop this terrible segregation and division. I never thought it would continue post apartheid.